15 ms·
No Man’s Sky One Year Later
- etchalon 9y agoCounter opinion: https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/18/16164520/no-mans-sky-one-year-later-ps4-pc https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/18/16164520/no-mans-sky-one-...
- alexc05 9y agoHonestly - I loved the first iteration and have jumped in to play it again this time round. I love it still (again). It's changed a lot. It's upgraded again there is a tonne of stuff to do, lots to see and explore and plenty of "hooks" to give you the excuse to see them. NMS gets a lot of hate and I don't think it's deserved but hey if the author doesn't want to play it, then it's no skin off my nose. They can do what they want.
- zzalpha 9y agoSo what's your personal take on the posted article? The post article would suggest NMS is being pulled in a lot of different directions... it has a single player quest, but it's not a great quest-based game. It has sandbox elements, but no obvious gameplay loop to make the sandbox compelling. It doesn't speak to the multiplayer elements, and I don't have personal experience with them, so I don't know how well they fit. The Verge seems a fair bit more charitable regarding the changes, while acknowledging that the game is still flawed. They seem to like the additional quest components, and feel the overall engine improvements have been well done. But it still doesn't seem to address the core issue this article is focused on, which is that they feel NMS is a jack of all trades but a master of none. So what's your take?
- etchalon 9y agoI was a fan of what was released initially, and thought the uproar was completely ludicrous. But I also didn't pay insanely close attention to the hype machine. When my more "invested" friends pointed out all the things the developer said would be there, that weren't, I thought, "Well, it'll probably come later." And behold, now some are. Maybe more will come. As a game, I probably lost 40-60 hours playing the initial release of the game. I treated it as a weird independent/art house game which was more about an experiment than about a crystalized game loop experience. It was fun, and interesting, and what systems were present were pleasant enough. Having played with the update, all of the updates are great and worth revisiting. It definitely changes the feel of the game. It's not a "great" game, but what it is is great. You can fly around a universe and see things literally no one has ever seen before, including the developers. There are some mechanics to make exploring easier, some things which make you more powerful, and a loose, cryptic plot. It's easily worth the 60 bucks, which is all you can ask of it.
- ssully 9y agoAs someone who actually followed the development from the day it was announced at the VGAs, I also found the uproar to be ludicrous and the claims of the developer lying to be overblown. I think it also might be that I am pretty aware that games/most projects in any field are never going to be what is said when first announced. I used to feverishly follow game developments when I was a kid and became intimately aware that features promised at announcement don't always make it to the end and that I also impose a lot of my own desires onto the project that never had any reality of coming true. Finally I will say I found NMS to be a pretty boring game, but one that is incredibly beautiful. The sense of planetary scale in the game is unmatched IMO and I think that Hello Games or a developer with similar tech can make something truly special with that.
- EpicEng 9y ago>NMS gets a lot of hate and I don't think it's deserved Should we just ignore all of the hype and promises made by the developer/publisher which were never delivered on? That's where the hate comes from. They promised something much more than what they delivered. Yes, they've made improvements, and that's great, but it still doesn't contain some of the biggest features promised while the game was still in dev. The marketing of this game was very deceptive, and they deserve what they got for that. Besides... most find the game pretty boring.
- yflu 9y agoThey did what most "lean startups" did. They made an MVP, and iterated from there. The only difference is that their target audience were gamers who hivemind way more than most other markets.
- devrandomguy 9y agoA lean startup, done right, plans the MVP and promises only that, as a first iteration. Then, if necessary, they can pivot in a new direction with another MVP v2, or use the credibility from the execution of their first, viable, release, to raise support for a major expansion or three.
- LeoNatan25 9y agoClearly they did not create a “minimum viable” product if their customers were so unhappy with the end result. As a startup, they failed completely at determining what that “minimum viable” was.
- dageshi 9y ago>Should we just ignore all of the hype and promises made by the developer/publisher which were never delivered on? That's where the hate comes from. They promised something much more than what they delivered. The people who pre-ordered should've waited till the reviews came out and then bought? I have rarely seen a level of delusion from a fan base than the one around NMS, they collectively hyped themselves to a level of frenzy before the game came out that could only lead to disappointment.
- grabcocque 9y agoBecause they've focused on a different set of priorities from the ones he wants, thus they're incompetent and sadistic? Ok.
- zzalpha 9y agoActually, his most basic, underlying thesis is that it's impossible to determine what their priorities are. To the author, the game is incoherent. If you cleave to that view, then it's impossible to understand why the developers changed what they changed. His example of Dark Souls is a perfect one. He acknowledges that, while the game isn't his thing, he can at least intellectually grok why Dark Souls is a good game, and how it has been optimized and refined for the specific play style they aimed at. The author claims the same can't be said for No Man's Sky. So, no, it's not that it's a different set of priorities. It's that it appears to be an incomprehensible set of priorities. And that's a real problem, if you believe in the thesis (which, I assume, will be explored in subsequent installments).
- kronosEnvy 9y ago"Actually, his most basic, underlying thesis is that it's impossible to determine what their priorities are" - zzalpha (someone who read the article)
- dexwiz 9y agoOpen world games are notoriously disappointing. "What is this game supposed to be?" is a great question. Are you trying to explore? collect resources and upgrade grind? build things? combat (ground or space)? By being all these things, they became nothing. All encompassing space games (for example EVE) take years to build, usually in the form of updates after release. As for the UI. It looks like its designed so the PC and consoles have similar UIs. Also they are inspired by context menus, which sacrifice UX for flexibility. (Pretend the inventory is a file system).
- newforice 9y agoOpen world games are great for me. I can't stand it when a game locks me into a pattern.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoTotally agree. Elder Scrolls and Fallout and Ultima are some of the best games ever.
- zzalpha 9y agoSure, but every open world game includes a gameplay loop of some kind. Virtually every open world game has the same basic loop: collect, craft/buy/sell, build. After that, it's just a question of how you motivate players to go through the loop: quests (Elder Scrolls), randomly generated threats (Minecraft, Terraria), multiplayer PC threats (WoW, EVE), etc. Sounds like this author feels NMS fails to justify itself in this way.
- majewsky 9y ago> randomly generated threats (Minecraft, Terraria) Maybe that's just me, but Minecraft is totally not about randomly generated threats. Sure, you have a certain set of milestones related to combat (e.g. loot a nether fortress, defeat the Ender dragon), but 99% of what motivates me about Minecraft is building stuff.
- 9y ago
- aaron-lebo 9y agoUgh NMS. Didn't get superhyped but bought it at launch, listened to that soundtrack by 65daysofstatic for a few weeks, played the game for about 30 minutes. It was just so boring. They had the tech to make universes but made the core gameplay so boring you didn't care. How is that possible? The game is now what it could have been, but it makes me uncomfortable even enjoying the game because I remember the dev lying on the day of release about multiplayer. That breaks some kind of contract between producer and consumer. Oh, and the FOV on the PS4 version is horrific, interesting way of extending a consoles lifespan. I think NMS is a glimpse of the future, but hopefully someone else will take their formula mainstream.
- Nursie 9y ago>> The game is now what it could have been Do you mean that like "it's got as far as they can reasonably take it, it could never have been more than that" or "it has fulfilled everything that it was ever supposed to be"? Because the former is a little tautological but likely correct, and I'd be surprised if it's really the latter.
- newforice 9y agoI think all games should focus on one platform, the PC platform. Consoles drain developer's time and attention from making the actual game. And don't get me started on knuckle-dragging VR.
- dexwiz 9y agoIt looks like PS4 [1] sales almost doubled Steam Sales [2]. There were probably a large amount of non Steam PC sales, but Steam being one of the largest distribution platforms, I imagine its a large portion of total PC sales. [1] http://www.vgchartz.com/game/84663/no-mans-sky/ http://www.vgchartz.com/game/84663/no-mans-sky/ [2] http://steamspy.com/app/275850 http://steamspy.com/app/275850
- cwyers 9y agoThe consoles are much easier to develop for -- debugging GPU problems across hundreds of GPUs by three manufacturers is so much harder than doing so on a single (or two, if you count the two major consoles) GPU type. They also make a larger share of the revenue than PC games do. They don't drain attention, they put attention where the most revenue for the least work is. And from a user point of view, PC gaming just got exhausting for me. Driver updates, keeping up with GPU upgrades... or I can plunk down some money on a box that Mostly Just Works. Yes, there's parts of console gaming that annoy me. I dislike having to have a PS4 and an Xbox One, which are like 80-90% of the same damn hardware, to play all the games I want. This goes doubly because the PS4 has marginally better hardware (minus the controller, which is improved from previous generations but not as comfortable as the Xbox controller) and the Xbox has outrageously better software, so I'm missing out on something no matter which console I'm using and I can't crossplay with friends on a different console. But those annoyances are small potatoes given how much time I've sunk into getting PC games to run optimally.
- lawless123 9y agoThe UI is clunky and impossible to efficiently use. Compare the galaxy map to the one in Elite Dangerous in which it is far easier to control the camera. They meant well but they might be better restarting
- m-p-3 9y agoUpdate 1.35 is improving that, you might want to check it out.
- arielweisberg 9y agoA lot of NMS problems go away if you mod and cheat your way to game balance... Play it your way.
- hacker_9 9y agoThis product was really always about trying to push the limits of procedural generation technology. It failed as a game if you ask the gamers, but exceeded expectations if you ask the developers (lucky devils are now millionaires). This 30 second clip pretty much sums up how great their marketing was: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KxRp8jeliQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KxRp8jeliQ
- zerohm 9y agoIn the lead up, when they were touting 6.84 * 10^23 planets or whatever, my thought was, how is that fun? If it will take all of humanity 10,000 years to see your entire game, what good does that do players now?
- crispyambulance 9y agoI found the gameplay at release enjoyable as a chill-out experience, much more my speed than first-person twitch-fests. I didn't mind that it was hyped far beyond what they delivered, its a game after-all. Maybe millennial gamers have more expectations than people who grew up on atari game cartridges? Haven't played it for months, but my expectations for any game is merely few dozen sessions of play maybe ~100 hours of play total. What more do you want out of a $50 game? People are too harsh.
- wutwutwutwut 9y agoWut. The company lied about the product. Isn't that fraud? And you say people were too harsh?
- LeoNatan25 9y agoDamn millennials are too harsh, expecting developers to be honest! It’s just a game after all! /s It’s because of such ridiculous attitude and low expectation that the gaming industry is at the state that it is—terrible.
- crispyambulance 9y agoWell, it is "just a game"... an innovative, highly creative game with some really interesting features. I suspect the real creative talent behind the game got used and pressured by product-manager types to ship far before it was ready because of all the money and promises involved. Throwing a fit because of "honesty" in game pre-marketing is sort of like asking for your money back because a movie didn't fulfill the expectations set by the trailer. Yeah, good luck with that at the multiplex, but also keep in mind that many people got their money back for the game. And anyways, cautious folks who expect absolute honesty from their game vendors, would do better to wait for the 3rd party reviews before jumping in headfirst with their 50 bucks.
- LeoNatan25 9y agoThis is not really a game—more like a tech demo. This was the problem outlined in the article and many, many gamers. > And anyways, cautious folks who expect absolute honesty from their game vendors, would do better to wait for the 3rd party reviews before jumping in headfirst with their 50 bucks. 100% agree, but the two are not really related. People should be cautious, but developers and publishers should not lie.
- HugoDaniel 9y agoI love the soundtrack. Many lines of code were written to it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRI-o9JDfCI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RRI-o9JDfCI
- Nursie 9y agoI found with NMS that I couldn't really see a game in it. The planets were lovely, the creatures fascinating, but other than grind fuel and occasionally get eaten by something, there wasn't much gameplay. With the later addition of base-building I was able to ... build a base. W00t. Lovely tech, pretty planets and stuff... not much compelling to actually do.
- pram 9y agoMuch like Zombocom, the only limit is yourself.
- rxhernandez 9y ago> Lovely x, y and z... not much compelling to actually do. This is pokemon go in a nutshell yet it seemed to work for niantic.
- dcolgan 9y agoAs a former amateur Twitch.tv streamer, I've always been fascinated by the rise and fall of internet personalities, and some of the biggest personalities seem to be game developers that found themselves in the spotlight. Someone made this very in-depth video about the fall from grace of Phil Fish, the creator of Fez: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmTUW-owa2w It seems to me that the combo of high pressure and a guy with a combative personality combined with internet anonymity to create a really messy situation that drove him out of the business. I've also followed Narscissa (formerly Cosmo) Wright's fallout in the speedrun community after coming out as transgender. Once one of the most popular streamers on Twitch, I'd imagine transitioning is hard enough, but transitioning in front of a studio audience of anonymous gamers would be next level. And so the same seems to be with Sean Murray and No Man's Sky. Inexperience plus overpromising and really high expectations created the current situation. I don't think any of these people are malicious and I don't really know how I would have advised them to do things differently. Edmund McMillen, the creator of Super Meat Boy and other indie games once said in a podcast interview that he hates showing people what he's making before it is done for this very reason. Edit: I know the circumstances of these people are not identical, I'm just calling for more understanding and empathy instead of assuming the worst in everyone.
- LeoNatan25 9y agoWait, let’s not conflate the cases you describe, where the trolling may have been and probably was malicious, with the case of No Man’s Land, where lead director flat out lied about the content of the game, and people who couldn’t control their hype fell for it and late raged. In the latter case, any professional shaming—which is the only shaming of Murray I’ve seen—is justified.
- slg 9y ago>In the latter case, any professional shaming—which is the only shaming of Murray I’ve seen—is justified. Why? The guy obviously wasn't trying to make a bad game. He was just inexperienced, got in over his head, and failed to deliver the product he wanted to build on the timeline he promised. I would have assumed if any community understands that failure isn't an unusual result in the face of ambitious goals it would be the HN crowd. Meanwhile since the game's release he has continued to work on that product to get it closer to everyone's initial expectations. I understand being disappointed by the whole thing, but the vitriol directed his way was somewhat disturbing.
- Bartweiss 9y ago> No Man’s Sky inhabits this frustrating space alongside games like the nu Deus Ex games, the original X-Com, or the Mass Effect series. It offers something you just can’t get anywhere else, but it does so in a deeply flawed and annoying way. This really resonated with me. I have a whole pile of Steam games which have fascinating, unique traits, but are 'objectively' bad in that they failed to deliver a solid story, or interface, or mechanics, or all of the above. - Artemis: Spaceship Bridge Simulator comes to mind; it's a great exploration of cooperative multiplayer design and the possibilities opened up by incomplete information. But it's also clunky and acutely underdeveloped in terms of game modes, balance, and AI. If you want a good game, you'd better dive deep into modding. - Tharsis also counts; deeply strategic play in a constrained setting, undermined by strategy-destroying levels of randomness. - Even AAA stuff like Civilization does this to me. Why is Civ great? Because nothing else is Civ. Why is Civ terrible? Because the balance is underwhelming and the AI is catastrophically bad. - Hell, for years Minecraft was like this. The opening comment about "imagine if Minecraft had been clunky and unintuitive at release" made me laugh, because it was. Deep Survival play has been almost dependent on mods for much of the games history, but the underlying insight was too good to pass up. So... it's an interesting insight, and it also prompts a question. Why don't more of these intriguing flops prompt more polished attempts?
- Karunamon 9y agoIt offers something you just can’t get anywhere else, but it does so in a deeply flawed and annoying way. This just described Elite Dangerous for me. Multiplayer MMO Descent:Freespace scratches a deeply satisfying itch that I've had since I was a kid, but that game's flaws are absolutely maddening. Is there a word to describe the maddening annoyance at something being so close, yet so far away, for objectively silly reasons?
- quirkot 9y ago> Is there a word to describe the maddening annoyance at something being so close, yet so far away, for objectively silly reasons? They call that the uncanny valley
- 9y ago
- EngineerBetter 9y agoNot a particularly well-researched post. Sony did not publish the game, they provided marketing budget. This means that they were not in creative control.
- avar 9y agoFurthermore, they could be forgiven for making statements saying e.g multiplayer was included a year out since it was an aspirational goal, but they were lying to the bitter end right up to release, either explicitly or by omission.
- shepardrtc 9y agoI followed the game for years before buying it on launch and being completely and utterly disappointed. Every single time they spoke about the game and showed videos, they promised a fleshed out universe with real consequences for your actions. They promised factions that had goals and would act independent of you. They promised a deep system of crafting. They promised multiplayer. What they didn't mention was that they had scrapped all those ideas a long time before and had turned the game into a grind-fest while they tried to hack things in there. The play-throughs they showed were hand-made areas with automated entities, but they never mentioned that. There was a promise of multiplayer, but it never happened. And probably worst of all, they never mentioned that it wasn't truly open-world, it was all essentially "levels" with little freedom to fly around and explore. They never mentioned that it turned into an almost on-rails flying game when you got close to the surface. You couldn't crash, you couldn't maneuver, you couldn't land on your own. Flying around was made even worse because you run out of fuel every few minutes because of the forced autopilot landings/takeoffs. That's not open world, that's a half-assed game with training wheels permanently glued on. The whole "Not Evil, Just Bungling" that the author says simply isn't the case. But I'm not saying they're evil. They definitely wanted to make the game they were promising. They had a passion for it. But they knew well ahead of time that it wasn't happening and they kept up the charade. I'm not disappointed about losing out on my money, I'm disappointed that I lost out on the game they promised.
- KirinDave 9y agoI was just on vacation and played a bunch. They should have done an early access thing, because it's actually a quite fun game now and it was somewhat oversold at launch.
- tw1010 9y agoLooking at this from a totally different angle, I find the fact that we collectively have such a high standard for games to be such a positive signal that life today is moving along swimmingly. The fact that this is what bothers us (rather than a depression or a big war) is wonderful. (Or maybe I've just been reading too many history books recently.)
- georgeecollins 9y agoAs a game designer this resonated with me: " it’s easy to say “yes” because you already wanted to have X and you’ve already thought about how you’d go about making it happen. People love you, your work is valuable, and you don’t want to say no. " Along the way in my career I heard something that I remind myself to help me with this problem: "Promises are like babies, fun to make but hard to keep. "
- dschuetz 9y agoHaving read this article the only remaining real flaw in this game is - Sony. I'm sorry that I didn't know that it was actually Sony behind the publishing which backfired into the face of Jean Murray, and not Sony. Damn.
- dkersten 9y agoI tried No Mans Sky a year ago and it was so utterly shallow and boring. Lots of breadth and zero depth. I tried the "foundations" update at some point, built a little base and... it felt empty and pointless and still utterly shallow. The game might have been "ok", or at least, I'd have been less harsh, if it didn't have a AAA price tag (and if Hello Games had been honest). I did not try the next update, and while its added a lot of the originally promised features, from what I've heard and seen on youtube, it still looked shallow and lacking depth and substance. So I've given up hope that these 19 quintillion planets will ever be interesting enough for me to bother playing it again. Also, regardless of whether they eventually pull of what was promised, it doesn't change the fact that Sean Murray mislead or even outright lied to everybody and that leaves an extremely bitter taste. I for one will never buy anything that Sean Murray touches or has anything to do with. So in many ways, the damage is done.
- the_af 9y ago> No Man’s Sky inhabits this frustrating space alongside games like the nu Deus Ex games, the original X-Com, or the Mass Effect series. It offers something you just can’t get anywhere else, but it does so in a deeply flawed and annoying way. X-Com flawed and annoying? Them's fighting words! The game is a masterpiece. It didn't feel frustrating back then; it felt like it belonged in my top 5 most engaging and enjoyable games, and I know this is a widely shared opinion in gamers my age. edit: well, one of the commenters from TFA agrees with me: > The original x-com was “deeply flawed and annoying”? I mean if that’s your opinion, cool, but surely you realize that most people consider it a classic and using it as an example of a failed game is only going to confuse us.
- jerf 9y agoX-Com shipped with a broken difficulty selector, so that all games were played on "Easy" regardless of your setting. The gameplay could be slow and ponderous at the best of times, and at the worst of times (chasing down the one last alien) could be quite maddeningly slow, literally at times 10-30 minutes of nothing. (Then the last alien gets the drop on you and your dude dies.) Some of the mechanics are pretty opaque in the era before "I'll just read a complete disassembly of the game engine on GameFAQs." Some of that is probably a part of the love for the game, but by most modern standards that's a flaw in a game. (Having to discover mechanics is not intrinsically a flaw, but making them somewhat undiscoverable kinda is.) I'm not sure I'd defend the "deeply" part of "deeply flawed", because IMHO it still belongs in a different category than some of those other games; it came much closer to doing what it set out to do deliberately, it did not just accidentally back into being a good game despite itself. However, I will defend that X-Com was somewhat flawed. The very fact that they could ship the difficulty selector broken, because nobody noticed, because the difference was not big enough to be noticeable, is a pretty decently sized problem on its own; that affects everything from top to bottom right there.
- the_af 9y agoBecause X-Com was widely considered a masterpiece by the standards of its day (unfair to compare it to today's games, and anyway that wasn't the point of TFA) it's extremely confusing to list it as an example of a flawed or frustrating game. You already mentioned the pace: that was one of its strong points, not a weakness. I -- and most of its fans, I'd guess -- liked the game because of its deliberately slow pace, not in spite of it. Why, I remember about 15-20 years ago I debated with someone about real-time vs turn-based games, and why I preferred the latter, and used X-Com as an example!. Like you also mentioned, I don't think most people realized about the "Easy" setting bug back then (I certainly didn't!). "Easy" was difficult enough anyway, so I think this criticism doesn't apply. We're not talking about bugs here (which happen in every game), but about "flawed" gameplay, and how you experienced the game back when you played it. Nobody complained about the broken difficulty setting, so this couldn't cause a frustrating experience. To me, picking X-Com as an example of a flawed game is like picking a movie everyone considers a classic masterpiece and declaring it flawed because there is a scene which is somewhat out of focus: it's an act of snobbery.