11 ms·
BeOS almost made Apple a different company (2015)
- eesmith 9y agoI borrowed someone's BeBox for a couple of days to write my one and only BeOS program. It was fun. Why is NeXT written "NeXt" in this piece? I don't think I've ever seen it written that way. Other OSes that "almost made Apple an entirely different company" were Taligent and Copland, for varying levels of "almost".
- f00_ 9y agono mention of the alto either :0 From Masters of Doom, Carmack programmed Doom on a NeXT machine would like to get my hands on one
- dheera 9y ago> Why is NeXT written "NeXt" in this piece? It's hard to remember this kind of weird random capitalization. When I read "iPhone", I remember "i, phone, two words with only the second word capitalized". When I read "mRNA", I remember "mrna, all caps except for the first letter". When I read it I read "NeXT", I read, "next with random capitalization". Now when I write back, the first 2 are deterministic; the third is probabilistic.
- grzm 9y agoTrue. However, one would expect the copyeditors at Wired to have gotten this right.
- subru 9y agoOld school leet speak used lowercases for vowels
- et2o 9y agoRNA naming scheme is consistent in biology: tRNA, miRNA, lncRNA, siRNA, etc. Applies to DNA as well (cDNA) etc. Not sure how this scheme was chosen.
- copperx 9y agoWhenever you capitalize a company or product name "properly," you're bending the knee to their marketing department. That weird capitalization may be aesthetically pleasing for their logo but has no place in English. Writing "Apple's Iphone and Ios" may look weird, but it's technically correct. Proper nouns have only their first letter capitalized.
- whyenot 9y ago> Proper nouns have only their first letter capitalized. Are you familiar with McIntosh apples? ;)
- ghaff 9y agoMc and Mac prefixes are mostly outliers :-) At least in the case of the apples they're named for a person. The computer industry really jumped into case sensitive naming with both feet. I'm sure NeXT wasn't the first such example but they were one of the earlier ones when it started to become the norm.
- eesmith 9y agoThe comment was to point out that copperx's blanket statement was insufficiently nuanced for even daily use of written English - a lot of people got to McDonald's for food, and the signs are nearly ubiquitous. I don't know how to judge "when it started to become the norm." It seems too easy to set the line semi-arbitrarily to the time you want. A Mac users in the 1980s, before NeXT, would know about MacPaint and other Mac* software. The Mac 2D graphics used QuickDraw, which in turn was "was grounded in the Apple Lisa's LisaGraf" (quoting Wikipedia). MicroPro International Corporation developed WordStar staring in June 1979. Again quoting Wikipedia, "By May 1983 BYTE magazine called WordStar "without a doubt the best-known and probably the most widely used personal computer word-processing program"." There's AutoCAD. And in the 1970s and 1980s ComputerLand was a large retail computer store, with "about 800 stores by 1985." (Microsoft, btw, was originally "Micro-Soft".) While it may have been popular in the computer industry, I don't know enough about other fields. I pointed out in another thread the DryIce Corporation started in the 1920s, producing frozen carbon dioxide. Edit: I realized I do know of earlier naming schemes which used mixed-capitalization. Before Micro-Soft was "Traf-O-Data", which followed a mid-20th century practice that includes Bridge-O-Rama (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bridge-O-Rama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bridge-O-Rama ) Bowl-O-Rama (http://www.bctv.org/opinion/bowl-o-rama-was-more-than-a-bowling-alley-it/article_40e79484-250b-11e7-8e1e-373158834e18.html http://www.bctv.org/opinion/bowl-o-rama-was-more-than-a-bowl... ), etc.
- GlenTheMachine 9y agoOf course, if they bought Be and not NeXT (which is consistently mis-capitalized), they wouldn't have gotten Jobs back. Apple very nearly went under before Jobs brought it back from the brink; had BeOS become the next MacOS, there may not have been a next MacOS.
- bluedino 9y agoRight, without Jobs there's no iPod or iPhone to run BSD
- CharlesW 9y ago> Of course, if they bought Be and not NeXT […], they wouldn't have gotten Jobs back. Yep. That's an Apple fan's Darkest Timeline, no doubt. Having been in Apple developer relations at the time, my perspective is that the specific OS choice was irrelevant to Apple's future success. By all accounts, BeOS would've also been a fine technology platform for Apple's future. Carbon apparently worked fine on it. And Mac OS X was far from a sure thing, for some time — if early public releases were uninspiring, early developer releases were actively demoralizing. And yet somehow, we had to make developers believe. The only way that could work is if we believed. And Steve Jobs made us believe. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_(API) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_(API)
- KernelPanic0 9y agoAt the time I hoped that Apple would buy the Amiga company and fix AmigaOS to run Classic Mac stuff and merge both systems into PowerPC systems and then later on use Intel X86 chips. Amiga still exists but it is very expensive, AmigaOS has evolved a lot and AROS is like an open source AmigaOS 3.X that can be ported to other platforms. Apple can still buy out Amiga and the license to AmigaOS and make high end PowerPC workstations and servers out of them and install BSD or Linux on them. The Amiga One was better running Linux than AmigaOS, so just make an Amiga API WINE like software that runs AmigaOS apps in Linux. Then make Intel based versions to save money. Just think Apple could use HaikuOS, MacOS, AmigaOS, AROS, Linux, etc on their Mac line using Intel chips, and contribute to their development to take on Microsoft and Windows. Yet Apple could make a deal with Valve to port SteamOS to their older Intel Macs to make use of them for playing games on them, etc. Give them PowerMac specs as well to make a PowerPC version of SteamOS.
- disordinary 9y agoI still have a BeOS 4.5 disk lying around somewhere. Was a great OS at the time.
- KernelPanic0 9y agoSomewhere on the Internet Archive is a series of BeOS ISO images, but I refuse to link to it. HaikuOS is a good OS to try and use BeOS API calls to make it work like BeOS.
- adamnemecek 9y agoDo you know how to get it running on vmware/virtualbox? I spent like two afternoons once trying to get them run but could get past the booting stage and just kinda gave up.
- sien 9y agoThis may have been in the past but it's straightforward now. I tried it out maybe 6 months ago and had no issues. Just followed whatever guide I could find online.
- feelin_googley 9y agoTrivia: And what open source OS was the Sidekick? I am one of those idiots who still believe Apple is a hardware company and as with all hardware companies, software is an afterthought. When they ditched OS9 for BSD this reinforced my belief. I honestly believe without BSD there would be no NeXTSTEP/OSX/iOS/macOS/watchOS/tvOS, etc. This article suggests they could have used BeOS. But, they did not. My hope has always been that Apple would optionally sell hardware without a pre-installed BSD/Mach-derived OS, allowing users to install their own choice of OS. For example, a fully open source BSD with a BSD kernel. That would be my choice but other users might choose differently. I am not interested so much in the graphics capabilities of Apple HW. I am after the form factor.
- KernelPanic0 9y agoBeOS would not be able to run Classic MacOS PowerPC/68K apps. They'd have to use some sort of emulator if Apple went with Be. Be did have the BeBox that had a Geekport that Apple could have used to better expand Macs for. There was this ARDI Exeuctor software that could run 68K Classic MacOS stuff in Linux, Windows, NextOS, and I think they were porting it to BeOS. NextOS was a much better choice due to the OpenStep librarie shared with HP, Sun, Oracle, and others. It was forked as GNUStep and ported to Linux and other operating systems. Apple has always been a hardware company that has the software integrated to the hardware. It is because they bundle both together than it works better than PCs running Windows from everyone and their brother making PC Clones. Even with the Hackintosh stuff not all drivers work and some Hackintoshes don't have things that a Mac does like OS updates, etc. BeOS was made into a multimedia OS to challenge AmigaOS that already was a multimedia OS with Video Toaster and other stuff. BSD aka NextOS was more of a workstation/server OS and clearly the better choice.
- Reason077 9y ago"BeOS would not be able to run Classic MacOS PowerPC/68K apps. They'd have to use some sort of emulator if Apple went with Be." That is exactly how Mac OS X ran classic MacOS apps in the early days. It was called "classic environment" or "blue box". It was removed after OS X 10.4, as by that point most "classic" apps had been updated to the Carbon API and recompiled as native OS X apps.
- hoodoof 9y agoI was really taken with BeOS at the time but NextStep was a much better operating system given that it was built on top of Unix and in addition was just beautifully engineered. The evidence of the excellence of its architecture is how easily it converted between CPUs and how easily it was changed to become iOS.
- acdha 9y agoThat depends on which aspects you compare: it took OS X until ~2010 and pervasive SSDs to become anywhere close to the non-blocking user experience the BeOS I/O scheduler delivered on mid-to-late-90s hardware, and BeFS's indexed metadata is what Spotlight wants to be when it grows up. On the other hand, networking lagged far behind and while you could get into arguments about respective API quality there's no question NextStep was more comprehensive.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoSo I ran both. I still do not feel that OSX is anywhere as fast and responsive as BeOS. Check out the latest Haiku build. Still so much more responsive.
- Eric_WVGG 9y agoBack in the days when iOS was new, Android was fledgling and WebOS was flailing, I wondered why the owners of BeOS at the time weren't working on a mobile OS based on BeOS. Obviously the touch stuff would have taken some work, but the underpinnings ought to be at least as good as OS X and probably superior to Android out the gate.
- chipotle_coyote 9y agoIronically, that's kinda what happened to BeOS--the assets were bought by Palm, right around the time Palm was splitting into two companies. PalmSource, the OS company, developed "Palm OS Cobalt," which was intended to be the next-generation Palm operating system, built on BeOS. While they completed Cobalt, the now-separate Palm hardware company didn't use it. Also, according to Jean-Louis Gassée, an Apple engineer tried to buy BeOS from Palm for the then-unnamed smartphone project, as a third candidate between Fadell's vision of a souped-up Pixo--the iPod OS--and Forstall's vision of a cut-down OS X. Palm turned the engineer down. (Gassée didn't name the engineer, but it's hard not to suspect it was Dominic Giampaolo, who created BeFS and went on to create Apple's Spotlight and then, unsurprisingly, work on APFS.)
- rodgerd 9y agoOn a tangent, it's perhaps symptomatic of how unfocused Apple was for much of the 90s that they already had "the OS of the future" in the form of A/UX 3. Which was a full SysV Unix implementation with a Mac OS compatibility layer. You got a *ix implementation of the Finder as your GUI, which could also run native System 7 binaries as well as Unix applications. Of course, it was killed for OS 8 (if you worked for Apple or a reseller at the time you'll know how hopelessly over-optimistic that was - if you didn't, it was supposed to be a brand new microkernel, running a multi-user OS written from the ground up as a Mac OS workalike, plus a server for running System 7 apps. There was even talk of being able to run a Windows environment. Needless to say, the MacOS 8 that actually shipped was not that plan) and Taligent/Pink. Then they bought NeXT and got... a BSD Unix running the NeXTStep userland and an MacOS Classic compatibility later.
- GlenTheMachine 9y ago...and Steve Jobs.
- gattilorenz 9y agoYeah, A/UX is incredible, feels like "OS X before OS X". What I love most is the GUI for (some) terminal programs: http://toastytech.com/guis/auxcmdo-ls.png http://toastytech.com/guis/auxcmdo-ls.png
- pjmlp 9y agoAlthough it wasn't without its own set of issues. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX
- 95014_refugee 9y ago"But it's hard not to wonder what the past couple decades of tech history would have looked like if Apple had gone the other way." No, it's not. Plus, working for Sakoman? No thanks.
- microcolonel 9y agoHaving played DooM shareware on loop in awe on BeOS as a youngun (well past the system's prime) in a household with a functioning IBM PC 5150 (won in a grocery sweepstakes) still being used for practical work in 2004 or thereabouts, it tickles my mind to think of what it would be like for Apple to be the BeOS distributor Compaq was never up to being. It ran, as I would later learn to appreciate, really well on a Pentium II (at 400MHz?). BeOS on a P2 beat the pants off Windows XP on a 2GHz Athlon 64.
- hoodoof 9y agoQNX would have been a better choice than BeOS.
- fractallyte 9y agoAh, the good ol' days - when there was actually some diversity in operating systems and platforms!
- pjmlp 9y agoNow with Windows re-introduction of a UNIX like personality, it seems we are heading into an UNIX mono-culture. Which I find quite bad, as it hinders OS research, specially in regards to safer OS architectures.
- myrandomcomment 9y agoI ran BeOS and NeXTStep on my PC back around this time. BeOS was impressive and I do not think anyone has come close to it's speed even today. The filesystem was amazing. That being said, I loved NeXTStep and was happy to see it live on. I wish the OS X version was more NeXT then Mac, i.e., I want my menus and shelf like NeXT. I think however that Steve was a larger key to Apples success then the OS. Apple would have been dead without him.
- danieldk 9y agoThe filesystem was amazing. Interesting tidbit: Dominic Giampaolo, who was one of the main developers of BeFS is now engineer on the APFS team [1]. [1] http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/ http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/
- amelius 9y agoHe wrote a book about BeFS. I wonder if he'd be allowed to do the same at Apple. (Somehow, I doubt it.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GuiA 9y agoWell, he might not get to write a book, but he gets to design a brand new filesystem currently used by hundreds of millions, soon to be billions, of devices. Everything in life has tradeoffs :)
- fermigier 9y agohttp://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf http://www.nobius.org/~dbg/practical-file-system-design.pdf if you are interested. It's obviously dated (1998) but still an entertaining, and insightful, read.
- rvense 9y agoMy favourite tech "what if?" is the open-sourcing of all of BeOS in 2000, which I have heard was talked about internally. The main parts of the GUI, the file manager and "dock", were actually released under an MIT-like license near the end of the company. This would have meant a stable, easy-to-install graphical OS available back when KDE and GNOME were still at version 1 or 2.
- ghaff 9y ago2000 was probably too late. Linux was already being widely used for Internet infrastructure and IBM was in the process of embracing it. There were opportunities for the operating system space to play out differently--which in turn could have changed a lot of industry dynamics--but those scenarios are things like: 1.) BSD coalescing earlier and somehow avoiding the legal issues with AT&T. (And I'm not sure to what degree this would have changed the final outcome with BSD substituted for Linux.) 2.) Sun open sourcing Solaris earlier in a surprise move against Windows NT. (Hard to see this happening.)
- jacobush 9y agoWith a significant following of rabid Amiga fans. Not sure about the net gain of that, though. :-)
- memsom 9y agoOpen-sourcing would have left massive holes in the OS. A lot of code under the hood was licensed. Remove all that and at best you'd probably have a kernel and not much of the UI, networking, graphics subsystem, media kit etc. The OS didn't have a full screen command line past the kernel debugger. So, yeah, not very useful. I'm going to be honest - it was probably not worth it to employ someone to trawl through the code to clean it up. Given the Be Inc business model failed and both PalmSource and ACCESS seems to have faded in to obscurity - I get the feeling no one was going to pay for that.
- wmil 9y agoIt would have been interesting to see what Apple would have done with BeOS's ABI problem. Be used GCC's 2.9x C++ ABI, which wasn't stable and was changed in 3.0. Would Apple have forked GCC? Or re-worked the design of Be avoid the issue?
- badsectoracula 9y agoProbably what Haiku does: provide two sets of libraries, one with the 2.9x ABI for older programs and binary compatibility with BeOS apps and one with the 4.xx ABI for newer programs. I think the old one is actually a shim for the new one (it isn't a full build, all it does is forwards the calls) but i'm not 100% sure.
- memsom 9y agoBeOS for PowerPC didn't use GCC. It used the Metrowerks Compilers (mwcc etc). One of the reasons is because the BeOS used PEF exe format. As Apple wouldn't open that up, hardly any comilers support that format - which kills gcc on the BeOS PPC platform. This is why you're unlikely to ever see Haiku on a BeBox or any Haiku support for legacy BeOS PPC apps. I hacked together a MWOB decompiler back in the day and re-implemented it as a fun little project last year. It's on my GitHub [1] is anyone cares. I will some day get an assembler working and outputting MWOB files. Probably. There's some other BeOS stuff kicking about, including an input driver for using gesture based writing [2]. I was writing this for BeIA, as at the time I has one of the Dt300 web pads running BeIA 1.0. There was a crappy UI toolkit wrapper we were using for Free Pascal too [3]. The latter included "fdb", which was a cool little BMessage based debugger tool. I wrote is as a throw away, bit some one once told me it was their daily driver at one point for debugging apps on end user machines. [1] https://github.com/memsom/mwobdec https://github.com/memsom/mwobdec [2] https://github.com/memsom/ratcowsoftopensource/tree/master/BeOS/strokeit_src https://github.com/memsom/ratcowsoftopensource/tree/master/B... [3] https://github.com/memsom/ratcowsoftopensource/tree/master/delphi/begui https://github.com/memsom/ratcowsoftopensource/tree/master/d...
- memsom 9y agoClarification: BeOS PPC uses PEF (because that was the main format MW supported, there was a lot of Apple knowledge in the building and there wasn't a better exe format for PowerPC at the time.) The offshoot of this is that some of the software from PR will run on R5.03. (preview release, for some reason the first 2 public releases were called PR(1) and PR2, with AA (advanced access) being almost PR1, but not quite baked.) One of the things I managed to get working was the MW Java - it was horribly out of date, but it was pretty cool to mess about with. Intel used PE for R3, then ELF from R4 onwards. So R3 Intel software is not compatible with any other release. No idea what the Hobbit BeBoxen used. BeIA used ELF or CELF, the latter being a customised ELF exe format with compression of symbols and stuff like that to reduce on disk size.
- win_ini 9y agoTo this day - many API calls on iOS reference "NS" as a prefix. That's from "NextStep" Acronyms take on their own life sometimes.
- bonaldi 9y agoThe original NeXTSTEP prefix was "NX"; NS came about after OpenStep, the joint project with Sun — hence Next/Sun as the prefix. http://www.cocoabuilder.com/archive/cocoa/136618-what-does-ns-means.html http://www.cocoabuilder.com/archive/cocoa/136618-what-does-n...
- _pmf_ 9y agoRecommended reading on BeOS: https://www.haiku-os.org/legacy-docs/benewsletter/index.html https://www.haiku-os.org/legacy-docs/benewsletter/index.html Archived newsletters for BeOS developers.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoI run NeXTStep on a color cube (in the end) and BeOS on a developer BeBox. Although I did love NeXTStep - especially compared to all the other unix systems we were running, including some SGIs - I always loved BeOS more. It was responsive and the file system was magic back then. And the two LED strips for the two processors showed off :-)
- wazoox 9y agoIn some sort of late private joke about crossing self-references, apparently the new iPhone 8 "gesture button" sort of copy the Palm Pré interface...
- molestrangler 9y agoI built a Dual CPU Pentium PC PC to run BeOS, I still have the original SKU box and polo-shirt somewhere. An excellent experiment in building a new OS from scratch. BeFS was a wonderful experience, it showed what could be achieved if you were not held back by legacy code. Back in the real world, Apple made the correct choice in not buying BeOS.
- appleflaxen 9y ago> Back in the real world, Apple made the correct choice in not buying BeOS. how come, given the positive review you are giving it?
- k__ 9y agoI wonder how it became Zeta OS, which was sold over some shady TV channels here in Germany.
- memsom 9y agoHow? Wikipedia tells the story [0]. But here is my take. After Be Inc stopped making BeOS[1], some guy (no names, google yT, he was the CEO) tried to license the Personal version of R5.03 to allow it to be repackaged. After Be Inc folded, this guy tried to get his "yellow Tab" company going for a while. It would stop and start. No one believed it would happen. Then they released a product based on the BETA R5.1 release. Everyone was a bit confused. Was it legal? This went on for some years. They made about 4 or 5 betas, then a 1.0 release, then a 1.1 and 1.2. There was a BETA for 1.5 too.All along, people were shouting "this is not legal." They made a load of changes that implied they had source code access. A few notable community developers were involved. At least one ex-Be employee was also involved. So, 2007, the proverbial brown stuff hit the fan. Firstly, ACCESS come out and say "we do not believe YellowTab has a legitimate license. Moreover, we have been trying to give them notice of this for many years"[2]. Then, JLG (former CEO of Be Inc) basically comes out in public saying "we never licensed anything to yellowtab". There was a complete breakdown of the timeline of events on OS News[4]. It was like getting a big box of popcorn and watching the biggest BeOS conspiracy theory since the Focus Shift unravel. It was compelling. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnussoft_ZETA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnussoft_ZETA [1] Focust shift. They stopped the desktop in favour of Internet Appliances. [2] http://www.osnews.com/story/17623/Access_Completely_Unaware_of_Legitimate_Zeta_License http://www.osnews.com/story/17623/Access_Completely_Unaware_... [3] http://www.osnews.com/story/17664/JLG_No_Agreement_Between_YellowTAB_Palmsource http://www.osnews.com/story/17664/JLG_No_Agreement_Between_Y... [4] http://www.osnews.com/story/17628/Timeline_of_Zeta_Developments http://www.osnews.com/story/17628/Timeline_of_Zeta_Developme...
- k__ 9y agoHey, thanks :) I didn't know this came crashing down so hard. To me it was just another strange TV-shopping software product that nobody wanted and so it didn't sell. I was 16 and Windows was all I knew at that time.
- jlebrech 9y agowhat BeOS was missing is one killer-app (video/audio production) for users of windows to dual boot into.