3 ms·
Great article. Another thing to consider before you build Uber for X: there will come a time, perhaps in the next couple of years, when people stop tolerating
by ilaksh 9y ago
Great article.
Another thing to consider before you build Uber for X: there will come a time, perhaps in the next couple of years, when people stop tolerating having monopoly technology companies as intermediaries for everything. Or they will tolerate some business involvement when it really is a deep value add, but there will be much more competition and the types of fees being charged will have to be much more reasonable.
The reason these companies become so huge so fast is of course because what they are mainly doing is managing basic logistics and information flow (payment being part of that).
The reason we need these companies, or think we need them, is because we do not yet have practical and popular decentralized systems that can replace them. Most people are not aware of the existence of decentralized platforms that could possibly replace the centralized servers and banks.
But these decentralized platforms do exist and more innovations happen every day. Popular examples are Bitcoin and Ethereum but that barely scratches the surface of what is actually already a large ecosystem of peer-based systems with many types of capabilities.
And I know that it will be really hard to convince most people that these services could exist without centralized servers or payment intermediaries. But maybe look into places like reddit.com/r/rad_decentralization or r/Ethereum to start to get an idea.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoHas that ever happened before in the history of mankind with something significant?
- ilaksh 9y agoWell, have any two parties ever switched from transferring money via bank to sending each other Bitcoin in the history of mankind? Have any people switched from using Skype to using a p2p webrtc video chat service in the history of mankind? Have any people switched from using a proprietary network service like Prodigy to using the internet in the history of mankind?
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoNot in any significant numbers. Skype is still the king of video chat, most people (all who aren't in tech) have never heard of bitcoin.
- fragmede 9y agoOil. Well, not oil itself, since we're still heavily dependent on oil right now. (Solar and alternatives are shaping up very quickly though!) At the turn of the 20th's century, the oil tycoons like John D. Rockefeller controlled significant percentage of the US GDP. (Google/Apple/Facebook/Snap's billions are a pittance in comparison next to the US' GDP of $18.6 trillion). Those oil fortunes were achieved via a wide variety of anti-competitive business practices, and those practices are illegal today because the oil tycoons' business practices stopped being tolerated, and US antitrust law largely originates from this era.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoCompanies still control and distribute oil, even if it isn't monopolistic today, it definitely is not decentralized.
- hathawsh 9y agoThat's my gut reaction to all new cloud services. It has been my gut reaction for over 20 years, in fact. I once thought a lot about building a Dropbox-like service, but I eventually decided it would fail because decentralized services would take over instead. Then Dropbox came along... and did not fail. Against all my intuition, today, it's probably more popular than ever. I've come to realize my intuition about cloud services is wrong because I consistently underestimate how much people struggle with technology. Dropbox became popular because it solved a problem in a way that was simple for anyone with a computer or mobile device. The same story applies to nearly all consumer-focused cloud services. If decentralized services are ever going to take the place of cloud services, they need to be at least as easy to use and helpful to common computer users. Personally, I can't think of even one decentralized service that matches a cloud service in ease of use. That could change with the evolution of the Internet, but I sure don't see that change happening now. I want to be wrong, because I think decentralized is technically superior.