5 ms·
The job no one wants: young people won't work in logging
- whipoodle 9y ago> “Logging is difficult, dirty, dangerous, and declining.” > Death or injury “can come from trees falling in the wrong direction, or hitting another tree and falling back on someone”, he said. Stupid millennials, how could they resist a dangerous job that is also in decline?!
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments here?
- tmh79 9y agomaybe the industry should pay young people more for their labor...
- ghostbrainalpha 9y ago$18 dollars an hour for arguably the most dangerous job in the country. That doesn't seem like a great deal to you?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- autotune 9y agoHow about: underwater welder, fisherman, skydiving instructor, firefighter, electrician, policeman, astronaut, or sanitation engineer?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pseudalopex 9y agoMost of those jobs have much lower fatality rates than logging. (Fishing is about the same, and I don't think the Bureau of Labor Statistics distinguishes underwater welders from other divers.)
- whataretensors 9y agoLower worker supply because the job sucks? Increase wages. Capitalism!
- Boxbot 9y ago> Now, fellers can earn as little as $18 an hour. So they get paid a little more than someone serving burgers in California but have to deal with much more remote, skilled, difficult, dangerous work. I'm getting really tired of articles posing this sort of thing as a "labor shortage".
- cglace 9y agoThey would have a significantly lower cost of living. So they should be able to save much more.
- dclowd9901 9y agoLower cost of living _and_ lower quality of life. People, believe it or not, are actually weighing that in their job hunting equation these days.
- SwellJoe 9y agoAlso, their likelihood of dying young is among the highest in the developed world, so they may not need to save at all! What a deal.
- cglace 9y agoI never said it was a good deal. Just that cost of living is lower. No need to snark.
- SwellJoe 9y agoMy snark is directed upstream, at the folks who believe paying $18/hour for one of the most deadly jobs in the country is reasonable while also having the gall to complain about not being able to hire enough people to do it. You were just in the line of fire; it wasn't intentional.
- antisthenes 9y agoOregon iirc, isn't a particularly cheap state. Even then, you're still making less in absolute terms, which reduces your mobility and long-term ability to move to another state if/when your logging job disappears. At $18/hr, it's hard to argue that any of those risks are built into the compensation. That is approx. ~37,000/yr for the most dangerous job in the country, apparently. If one is inclined towards the trades, it's not hard to see why they would pick something other than logging.
- anonacct37 9y agoThis sounds like yet another market problem being blamed on "millennials". If you pay enough I'd imagine some people would take the job. If you can't pay enough, then I guess the market is speaking to you about the long term outlook for logging.
- intothev01d 9y agoI don't blame people for not flocking to an extremely dangerous and grueling job only to be underpaid. There's plenty of other options. I get tired of older generations somehow trying to guilt trip us into continuing in their line of work when in reality those jobs weren't very good to begin with. Work smarter not harder. Maybe they never heard of that.
- hardlianotion 9y agoIt's not an "older generation" thing. It is a "shitty employers try to have their cake and eat it" thing.
- dclowd9901 9y agoThey got greedy during the downturn and don't want to give up the sweet milking of the labor supply. I wonder how we recovered from this after The Great Depression...
- georgeecollins 9y agoUnions
- cowsandmilk 9y agohalf the article is basically about working smarter. new machinery that can do the work of 8 men and is much safer than the old manual methods... And the crews using these machines do attract young people. It sounds like the young people joining the industry are just decided to join crews that have greater safety and the latest technology, which means their jobs are less likely to disappear as the technology spreads; in fact, they'll be those with the most experience with new methods rather than those with the least experience with old methods.
- antisthenes 9y agoThis actually looks like my ideal job, if only it pays a decent wage and you do everything with the machines.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- anotherbrownguy 9y agoSeems like a lot of these workplace injuries can be reduced by making the machines remotely operated. If the workers can be far enough to not be hit by the falling logs or trees, it would be no more dangerous than just another minimum wage job.
- mikestew 9y agoKind of what I was wondering when I read the article: why does the operator need to sit in the cab? OTOH, it could be that "we just got these new machines to be usable with a human operator. We're working on it, give us time and we'll get to remote operation in the next few iterations."
- ph0rque 9y agoHere you go: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luygMuoFnXs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luygMuoFnXs Ironic video description, given the original article.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoSurprised this wasn't title "Millenials killed the logging industry" As the sole representative of everyone aged 8 till 40, I would say we are turning a new leaf here. I feel like this is an outreach problem more than anything. Recruit at high schools and job fairs and you'll get bodies.
- wahern 9y agoI don't know too much about the industry except that it can be incredibly dangerous, especially with the sophisticated machinery. I knew somebody who impaled himself--he wasn't paying well enough attention (so I was told) and drove a tree trunk right into his cabin and into his abdomen. Miraculous that he survived, last I heard he was still packing and disinfecting a gaping open wound a year after the incident. I don't think he received nearly as much training as described in the article. And IIRC he hadn't been on the job for more than a few months. But this was in Alabama, where workers are disposable.
- Analemma_ 9y agoWhen even a left-wing outlet like The Guardian is willing to uncritically echo capital's BS about "labor shortages" when the real cause is a lack of willingness to pay real wages, you know we're in trouble. Seriously, $18/hr. for the most dangerous job in the country? I'd tell those people to get fucked.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- TheCowboy 9y agoI'd argue the problem is the lack of economic literacy before suggesting The Guardian is in cahoots with 'Big Lumber'. The headline should be: "Why won't logging companies increase wages to fill positions?" Business and economic journalism aren't critical enough of people who complain about a "skills shortage" and accept their argument at face value. This is where capitalism should excel: you can't attract necessary talent at price point $X, then you pay >$X. Partisan ideologies can cut in multiple directions. For example, if you have an ideology where you view capitalism as inherently evil you may be ignorant of where it could be of benefit. If you view workers are excessively self-entitled, you won't call out companies and managers for not paying enough.
- mikestew 9y agoI'm old enough to remember a time when shit jobs paid really well because, well, they were shit jobs. Let's take the bottom of the barrel: bailing hay in the August heat of the Midwest. Dead simple job: take heavy bail of hay, put it on truck. Alternatively, take bail from truck, put in barn. Anyone with two working synapses could do it. And it paid the equivalent to $16/hour in 2017 dollars. Great job for a high school kid who had no real skills. Hardest job I've ever had by a long shot. Longshoreman? Hard, dangerous work, but pays really well. Logging? Who the hell wants to be a logger? Anyone that has few skills but wants a decent living. But it seems that over the years these shit jobs have started to have the shit pay to go with it. I'm sure there are multiple factors involved, starting with a downturn of union membership, but something or things has changed. And now industries wonder why they can't find anyone. Well, actually, I truly doubt they are wondering, as they ought to know better than I do what the reason is. But "they" would like to continue to live in the fantasy land where people stand in line for a minimum wage job that is likely to get them killed or seriously injured.
- hangonhn 9y agoHang on. The longshoreman part is a bit more complicated than that. Longshoreman was actually not a shit job. The workers had a great deal of flexibility and good pay for the hours worked. The labor unions protected them too. What caused that job to decline and disappear was the container box. The container box moved the packing and unpacking part from the source and destination instead of the ports. During the Vietnam war, the US military basically forced the ports to adopt container boxes. This dramatically increased the efficiency of shipping and eradicated longshoremen jobs. Nowadays though, the people operating the cranes loading and unloading the container boxes from/to container ships actually make 6 digit salaries. The problem with shit jobs is that they tend to be "muscle" based jobs in unpleasant conditions, which makes them vulnerable to automation and mechanization. (Source for all this is: The Box (https://www.amazon.com/Box-Shipping-Container-Smaller-Economy/dp/0691170819/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1503601940&sr=8-5&keywords=the+box https://www.amazon.com/Box-Shipping-Container-Smaller-Econom...)
- paultopia 9y ago
- an27 9y agoIt's a dangerous job, it doesn't earn much, most people have better options and then there's the decline in societal appreciation of manliness, so I understand no one wants this job. No perks at all, not even bragging rights. Perhaps it even is safer to join the military nowadays?
- bm1362 9y agoI'd argue that the military is an order of magnitude safer and you'll get a decent wage, prestige, the GI bill and free housing.
- hkothari 9y agoI'm surprised the article doesn't mention any sort of social stigma against the work (beyond the low pay and danger). Logging is cutting down trees and in a world where we're raised now to conserve our forests I'm not surprised that logging as an occupation is not on the forefront of people's minds. Even if it's done in an environmentally sound way, I'd assume that there's a stigma that would be hard to get past.
- maxerickson 9y agoMost people don't care that much. Especially people that aren't confused about where toilet paper comes from.
- ddebernardy 9y agoThe first three paragraphs of the article describe a job that is essentially guaranteed to be taken over by autonomous vehicles and AI in the coming years. Plus pay is low, and the work is dangerous. It's unclear why the rest of the article laments that millennials don't want to learn that work.
- gozur88 9y agoWood is ridiculously expensive. On a percentage basis I doubt a big increase in wages would change the price of the end product much at all. This article reminds me of the one we get from growers periodically. They're having trouble finding people to do the work they need done, so instead of paying higher wages the solution is to start a media campaign to get immigration restrictions relaxed so they can flood the market with labor.
- twunde 9y agoAnother contributing factor not discussed in depth by the article is that loggers have to travel to remote sites, often without cell service or internet and usually without the ability to go grab lunch at a nearby deli. You're essentially cut off socially for the duration of the job, while having a high likelihood of you or someone close to you dying or being maimed on the job. I can't imagine too many of the current lumberjacks recommending their children follow in their footsteps.
- microcolonel 9y agoWho cares? If they don't get enough fellers then they will raise wages and overall comp. until they do. If they have enough, they will lower wages until they don't. It is a functioning labour market, and the degree to which people desire to work for lumber companies is reflected in the wages, and in turn the price of lumber. If anything, at $18/hr for dangerous hard labour, they obviously have plenty of people who want to be fellers. There's no other way that wage would be so low. If they have a shortage, lumber simply costs a bit more.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoWhy don't people want to work in the most dangerous job in the country for 2.5x minimum wage? It's baffling.
- mistercow 9y agoThis sounds to me like a clever reframing to justify automating these jobs. It's not "we don't want to pay enough to get humans to do this". It's "nobody will do these jobs, so we built machines to do them instead". I'm totally for job automation, and think we should find better solutions to the problems it causes than "be less efficient". But I also think we should own up to those negative effects instead of playing a game where we pretend not to understand how markets work.
- foxyv 9y agoBasic microeconomics here. There is no labor shortage, the jobs are just priced too low.
- wand3r 9y agoI work at a tree service which is a fairly similar profession. We clear land or remove large trees with heavy machinery. I take home about ~$15 an hour cash. The job, it's dangerous as fuck. My boss went to a funeral today for someone who had been doing this 30 years or so. S