8 ms·
Sun Flyer, an Electric Trainer Aircraft
- purpleidea 9y agoI didn't read the whole article, but if they even mentioned how long it will fly for, they sure hid that carefully. Stop wasting my time until you have a decent product!
- livatlantis 9y ago> We designed the aircraft for the niche application of pilot training, where the inability to carry a heavy payload or fly for more than 3 hours straight is not a problem and where cost is a major factor. So a little less than 3 hours, I'd imagine.
- aphextron 9y ago3 hours of flight time is more than adequate for training purposes. Not only is it a huge win for fuel savings, but safety is the number one reason I can see primary trainers going 100% electric over the next decade. Learning to deal with the intricacies of an ICE across the full range of flight conditions is half your training time wasted, and the myriad of things that can go wrong simply wont exist anymore.
- sohkamyung 9y ago> Learning to deal with the intricacies of an ICE across the full range of flight conditions is half your training time wasted I'm not familiar with flight terminology or flight training, so could you elaborate on the meaning of that sentence?
- SideburnsOfDoom 9y agoICE = Internal Combustion Engine.
- sooper 9y agoICE = Internal combustion engine Off the top of my head: - At certain temperatures and pressures you have to consider icing in the carburettor, which will block air flow into the engine. - You have to tune (lean) the fuel input to reduce fuel consumption and prevent spark plug fouling, but not lean it too much that you overheat the engine. Some more in-depth examples at http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/engine-management http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/engine-management
- mpweiher 9y agoAnd when descending, you have to be sure not to shock cool it etc. Airplane gasoline engines are a mess, the technology is ~1950s at best and just hasn't advanced at all, with a few exceptions that, pardon the pun, never really took off.
- mnw21cam 9y agoA lot of that "mess" is due to a couple of critical requirements. Namely, low engine weight and reliability.
- pdelbarba 9y agoAt this point it's mostly certification cost and liability insurance cost that's keeping the tech back. You can easily modify modern aircraft engines to be more reliable and efficient (PMAGs) but you need an STC (certification procedure) to make the switch so the experimental home builders are the only ones who actually benefit.
- cjrp 9y agoRotax seem to be doing pretty well, they're used in a lot of popular trainers
- sokoloff 9y agoShock cooling as a concern for cylinder cracking is a fairly well debunked myth at this point, IMO, short of crashing your airplane into a cold lake. Agreed the tech is old, but the uncommanded in-flight shutdown rate for pistons is also very low. Part of that is driven by high maintenance demands (some of which introduces failures themself), but a lot is due to the simplicity and redundancy. Would I like variable spark timing (beyond impulse couplers for starting)? Would I like more automated starting, especially for hot starts? Would I like thermostatic cooling of cylinders? Yes, but not if they came with any substantial increase in failure modes. When I'm taking the family 700 miles at night in a single-engine airplane to grandma's for christmas, I'll suffer with arcane checklists and having to manually manage the engine if it reduces the chance of an uncommanded shutdown by even 5%.
- tjoff 9y agoWasted? Isn't that exactly among the things you need to learn?
- willvarfar 9y agoSo you can have an electric plane for primary training, and ICE as the next step? Lots of people learn to drive automatics and not manuals. Perhaps electric planes will become viable enough that many people will never need to progress to ICE?
- tjoff 9y agoSure, but that hardly means it is wasted. And perhaps that is true, but hardly the case in the near future.
- gruturo 9y agoUnfortunately that defeats the purpose of a trainer, because "real" planes, which the trainer is supposed to prepare you for, won't be electric for quite a bit, so you do need to learn all about the intricacies and issues which can crop up on those planes. Even assuming a rather speedy pace of improvement in battery tech, the power/weight ratio won't be there for quite a while. Batteries also don't get lighter as their energy is consumed, like fuel does, and many planes cannot even land with the same weight they are allowed to take off with.
- grecy 9y agoOf course, this means a student can start in this electric trainer, and focus on learning the flying right off the bat. When a student has that down, they can graduate up to a trainer with an ICE, and then learn all of that stuff. Exactly like learning to drive a car in an automatic first, then once you have the actual vehicle control/traffic/etc down, you graduate up to a stick shift.
- rowyourboat 9y agoExcept that in countries where stick shift dominates, you start off learning to drive a stick right away.
- mrob 9y agoUnlike airplanes, cars have no stall speed. You first lesson involves driving at very low speeds, away from traffic. If you have any trouble shifting you can just stop. Airplanes are less forgiving.
- pdelbarba 9y agoElectric vs ICE trainers won't have much in the way of differences. The main procedural differences will be engine start (just follow the checklist) and low power conditions where carb heat is required (becoming slightly less common now that fuel injection is available and relatively cheap). The most common trainer is the C172 which is high wing and therefore doesn't need an electric fuel pump or tank switching so that's about it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- snt 9y agoWhile doing circuit training, a student pilot can do 5 training circuits of 6 mins each using 30 minutes of battery. They'll probably be so overwhelmed and fatigued afterwards (well, I was anyway) that their day's training is over. That's five or six exhausted student pilots per exhausted battery. :)
- princekolt 9y ago> I didn't read the whole article You should have stopped right there.
- D_Alex 9y agoThey mentioned 83 kWhr battery, a peak power usage of 80 kW, and a "normal flight", whatever that means, usage of around 20 kW. I should note that a conventional airplane rarely cruises at less than 50% power, 65-75% would be more common. But even an hour endurance, plus reserves, is okay for a trainer airplane, so this product is pretty decent already, and your outrage over the waste of your precious time probably was not warranted. If this thing can recharge in ~30 mins, then it would be a pretty good option for a flying school, where pre-flight briefings and checks will consume a part of this time. And given the pre-orders and options, it seems the flying schools in fact agree that this is a pretty good product.
- awongh 9y agodoes anyone know the viability of hydrogen fuel cell electric motor airplanes? It seems like this is a more logical step, since from what I've read the energy density of batteries really isn't optimal for something like an airplane, even with technologies projected to come to market in the next couple of decades. And the whole thing still has the possibility of being zero-emissions.
- worldsayshi 9y agoAlso, perhaps it doesn't have to travel as far as conventional airplanes. Perhaps it can be okay to be twice as slow (because of more stops and lower powered engines) if it's only slightly cheaper. Trains and long distance busses are still around for routes that are also trafficked by airplanes. Presumably because they are often cheaper.
- awongh 9y agoI guess I was more extrapolating to jet engines, where I don't know if speed is as much of a factor in energy conservation, given the market.
- audunw 9y ago> And the whole thing still has the possibility of being zero-emissions. Well, so does a hybrid plane, if it's fueled with biofuels. Zero net CO2 emissions anyway. I would imagine other emissions are less problematic since it happens far away from populated areas. I'm not sure why hydrogen is desirable. Hydrocarbons have higher energy density and is easier to store and fuel. I can imagine that the closed loop of H2O + electricity <-> electricity + H2 + O is more efficient than the hydrocarbon equivalent. But neither technology is near their theoretical limits, so it's a bit hard to say yet. Regardless, if we build hybrid planes, we can use whatever technology makes the most sense. It shouldn't be too hard to swap out the energy storage mechanism. Who knows, maybe we'll invent a good rechargeable aluminum-air battery and replace everything with that.
- Tarrosion 9y ago
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>its high torque, available over a magnificently wide band of motor speeds A broad torque curve isn't really useful since aircraft engines are already optimized for sustained operation at cruising speed and the range of speeds you can operate at is limited by the propeller and physics. There's no need to have a ton of torque at 1800rpm and at 6000rpm >At 20 kilograms (45 pounds), the motor can be held in two hands, and it measures only 10 centimeters deep and 30 cm in diameter And what's the horsepower rating and duty cycle rating on this motor? Power density is not an area where electric motors have a large advantage over ICE unless you're trying to build a cylindrical package. The article talks about doing away with durability requirements that impede a lightweight design. >with no power-sapping transmission Most small aircraft are direct drive. Electric power certainly has advantages but this article may as well be a marketing brochure full of fluff.
- ImaMicroService 9y agoOh it's definitely marketing. The author constantly uses possessive semantics when describing the work done. It's a neat idea, and I'd like a cheap electric LSA in the future, but that article was pointed right at VC.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- blktiger 9y agoThe weight of the electric motors is definitely a lot less, but what most people don't think about is that the main weight of an electric airplane is in the batteries. The battery pack in a Tesla Model S is ~1300 lbs. The batteries required for an aircraft to have an hour long flight time still add too much weight. Batteries have gotten light enough to make it feasible, but we still need major advances in energy density to make electric airplanes make a lot of sense.
- sokoloff 9y agoPetro-fueled airplanes also have the advantage that they can be flown lighter for short trips, trading off either performance and/or cabin load for fuel load. They also land shorter (by virtue of being lighter) at the end of typical flights. Battery airplanes that carry the full weight of the batteries all the time have worst-case takeoff, climb, and landing performance on all flights. It's easy to notice even 100 pounds difference in loading on light airplanes. That's a little under 17 gallons of avgas or about 90 minutes' fuel burn for a typical trainer. If I want to take 2 extra 175# adults on a local flight, I can just leave off 60 gallons of fuel and have the same performance for a short flight.
- ph0rque 9y agoIs there any way to do the analogous of regenerative braking on the descent in an electric airplane?
- skanga 9y agoYes, the props rotate backwards - it's called windmilling.
- thearn4 9y agoI think the issue is that by the time you are on descent, the flight is nearing an end, so the benefits for range extension aren't great.
- pdelbarba 9y agoIn this case, the students will likely be doing pattern work in these aircraft which involves repeated takeoff and tochdown. In particular they will often do a touch-and-go where the aircraft maintains forward speed and takes off again. In this case, the regeneration should allow one extra circuit for every ten or so circuits.
- sokoloff 9y agoNot really. You take the potential energy stored in the airplane and use it to transit to the airport. On my (gasoline) airplane, I fly most of the descent under significant positive thrust/power (150+ HP worth of positive power, often over 200 HP). The only time I could see wanting net regenerative power is on very short final (the last 50 feet of descent) or for braking on the runway (especially on contaminated runways). But neither of those will be effective for regen/extending range.
- pdelbarba 9y agoFor the record, this is not new. Pipistrel has had a relatively successful electric trainer for a couple years now based on one of their popular LSA airframes. The only catch is that at this time I don't believe it has yet achieved FAA certification in the states. Flight instruction is currently about $100-120/hr for aircraft rental and $40/hr for the instructor (not paid if you are soloing). This would likely halve the rate for the aircraft as fuel is currently averaging about $4.50/gallon and a C172 burns on the order of 6-8 gallons/hour and requires more maintenance. Insurance on electric aircraft will likely be cheaper too given the lower mechanical complexity, though this has yet to be seen.
- blktiger 9y agoFuel ends up being about $50 an hour (depending on the price of fuel, but most C172 trainers burn close to 11 gal/h). While an electric trainer would save almost all of that money in fuel costs, most FBOs don't pay for a _new_ C172 they but one of the thousands of used ones. Buying a new electric trainer would be quite a bit more expensive than a used C172 and I'm sure that would change their rental rates for the aircraft. I think it's likely to offset the cost savings you'd get otherwise. Then again, maybe with the additional reduction in maintenance costs it might end up a bit cheaper to fly.
- pdelbarba 9y agoI actually just emailed sunflyer about pricing since that's the biggest factor initially. I will update if they get back to me. I suspect that they'll be relatively inexpensive compared to a new C172SP @ around $330,000. Maintenance is the biggest difference IMO. Aircraft ICEs burn through oil and parts like nobody's business and only last ~2000hrs before they need a $20+k overhaul. The motors should last the life of the airframe, but this will be offset by battery degradation. By the time these need battery replacement, it could be quite cheap though.
- timbre 9y agoWhy are GA aircraft so expensive? A C172 seems much simpler mechanically than a car. I can see that the price would be driven up by low volume and probably a much stricter QA/inspection process... Is that it, or am I missing something?
- god_bless_texas 9y agoPlease someone invent better batteries that can be mass produced. My drone, my airplane, my car and my phone desire you!
- HNaTTY 9y agoOne thing that always bothered me about airplanes is the energy used to take off. On aircraft carriers, they use a launch device, allowing the airplane to "push off" against the carrier. Compare this to airplanes taking off on land, they just nail the throttle and take off by pushing air... A land-based launch system would have a lot of advantages; lower peak power would be needed from the motor and batteries, the engines could be made smaller, the energy used to take off doesn't have to be stored on the plane, everything gets lighter and more efficient.
- subway 9y agoThat's a lot of infrastructure to maintain, and significantly increases the costs of airports.
- ndespres 9y agoThis is addressed in the article: "We designed and built a pneumatic rail launcher so that the plane does not have to take off under its own power." In the spirit of everything old being new again, the Wright Brothers' original 1908 flyer also used a catapult to launch the planes. https://simanaitissays.com/2012/08/13/vintage-aero-wilber-wows-em-at-le-mans/ https://simanaitissays.com/2012/08/13/vintage-aero-wilber-wo...
- larkeith 9y agoNote that this quote was in reference to the autonomous drone they produce, not the manned trainer that was the subject of the article. I would presume there are more challenges in building a launch assist catapult for a crewed flight.
- justadeveloper2 9y agoCatapults don't save energy--they shorten runway. The jet is at full throttle on takeoff and military aircraft are not exactly fuel misers.
- ndespres 9y agoSure, they don't save energy in the sense that the laws of physics must still be obeyed- but by using the power of the catapult to increase the plane's velocity at takeoff, the motor can be optimized for flight rather than takeoff and less battery weight needs to be carried.
- la6470 9y agohttp://www.extremetech.com/computing/126745-ibm-creates-breathing-high-density-light-weight-lithium-air-battery http://www.extremetech.com/computing/126745-ibm-creates-brea...