6 ms·
Verizon’s good unlimited data plan is now three bad unlimited plans
- atonse 9y agoCarriers must be having such a wonderful time with this new FCC. Uhhh unlimited but it'll never be fast! Uhhh we can re-encode your video, unless it's streamed from Verizon (you know this part's coming...), deal with it! Can't wait for VPN technology to become more widespread, so we can keep these crooks from altering our traffic.
- shedlight 9y agoWhat do you mean by "new FCC" and what do they have to do with it? Also, was the old unlimited truly unlimited in all ways? If so, how can every single customer of any company actually get unlimited data, all the time without unlimited hardware appearing from nowhere and radio wave spectrum that expands to unlimited use for unlimited people?
- shedlight 9y agoSeeing down votes but no comments? This is why Reddit beats HN in every single way.
- awinder 9y agoNew FCC refers to the party switch in the WH changing the FCC voting commissioner makeup from 3D-2R nominees to 2D-3R. The old plans and the new plans both defined “unlimited” as a number of GB of full speed which could degrade after so much use, so that’s never been at issue. That was a usage plan but the network traffic was not treated differently (or wasn’t supposed to be). Now the plans also perform content-based network degradation at all times, regardless of data usage, which is a shot at net neutrality for sure.
- pjschlic 9y agoI think the 'new FCC' comment is a reference to the current FCC Commissioner being a former general council at Verizon (though it was awhile ago). Additionally, he's been strongly opposed regulation of the telecoms and opposed net neutrality for awhile. It's not all him, but the FCC has sharply changed course on net neutrality since December.
- runjake 9y agoI think you mean the new FCC chairman: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ajit_V._Pai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ajit_V._Pai
- praneshp 9y ago> I think the 'new FCC' comment is a reference to the current FCC Commissioner being a former general council at Verizon This is a somewhat silly argument. I remember the same concern over Wheeler; everyone was tripping over themselves to praise him when he turned out to be pro-net neutrality.
- atonse 9y agoWhile many of us were delighted to be wrong about Wheeler, Ajit Pai has ended up being exactly the kind of spineless corporate shill that you'd expect him to be. Wheeler was the exception. Pai will be handsomely rewarded for all the billions he's generated for the telcos.
- praneshp 9y agoOh, I'm not questioning if Pai is/will continue to be a shill. Let's call him that for being a spineless shill, not because he worked at Verizon once. Sorry if I'm nitpicking, but it's an important distinction to me.
- dogma1138 9y agoThis isn't a net neutrality issue. Come to Europe and let's compare datacaps.
- awinder 9y agoTreating video bits differently from image and text bits is exactly a net neutrality issue, it’s content-based filtering
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- derekp7 9y agoBut the question then becomes, is it a good or bad thing? Is it better to pay $10 per GB, or is it better to not have to worry about gigabytes, with the caveat that video (which happens currently be a high bandwidth consumer) gets throttled? Then add onto it that the video quality for many consumers is still more than adequate for the size of screen they are dealing with. Personally, I don't do video over LTE, but I would like to use the mobile hotspot feature on my phone more often without having to worry about going over. And as long as it is enough for me to use ssh, RDP, or VNC, then I'm good. Other people, of course, have different requirements.
- atonse 9y agoBut RDP and VNC are essentially streaming video over the internet. How would they make that distinction?
- marklawrutgers 9y agoThat is until the multi-billion dollar lobbyists decide to push for VPN bans in Congress because only terrorists and child pornographers need privacy like that. Basically what's already happening in China, Russia, and the UK.
- DKnoll 9y agoHow is this already happening in the UK?
- 0x5f3759df-i 9y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/20/theresa-may-crackdown-snoopers-charter-encryption-terror-backdoor https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/20/theres... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_blocking_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_blocking_in_the_United_Kin...
- DKnoll 9y agoNeither mention VPNs, also first link is an opinion piece.
- TheAdamist 9y agoThey're traffic shaping to certain MBps, not re-encoding according to some of the articles, so a vpn wouldn't help depending on how they detect "streaming video".
- atonse 9y agoBut that's not what they're doing. Judging by their marketing language, it's likely their contract language does enforce caps on the TYPE of content. If they just started somehow throttling all VPN traffic, this is easy to detect, and they'd be in breach of contract. It still won't matter with the current crowd in the White House. Nobody will enforce anything.
- gr3yh47 9y agoDidnt verizon already lose a court case saying they couldnt do throttling and still call it unlimited?
- devy 9y agoThe "unlimited" in Verizon's unlimited plans refer to the number of exceptions in their "unlimited" plans.
- kchoudhu 9y agoRouting traffic through a VPN should circumvent this malarkey, right?
- wmf 9y agoFor now and as long as not too many people do it.
- _justinfunk 9y agoAlso, Netflix blocks "proxies" which generally include VPNs.
- chrishacken 9y agoGenerally speaking, there's no way to detect if you're using a VPN. They block specific IP ranges belonging to VPN providers.
- kchoudhu 9y agoLearned this the hard way when we moved abroad for a few months and wanted to get our American Netflix on. No biggie, now we VPN into my home and use that connection to check out US Netflix: their blocking is entirely IP-based.
- chrishacken 9y agoExactly what I said in my comment and yet it was downvoted.
- lobster_johnson 9y agoNetflix hasn't been able to block all VPNs. VyprVPN still works, for example.
- zzzcpan 9y agoWell, it's trivial to throttle VPNs for someone like Verizon.
- ikeboy 9y agoAnyone know if MVNOs like Ting get the same throttling?
- 4ad 9y agoTing is not on Verizon. Verizon doesn't have many MVNOs, last I checked all Verizon MVNOs came with lots of caveats that made them unsable for me at the time. FWIW, I chose Ting, no traffic shaping whatsoever and no artificial limits of any kind. Of course, T-Mobile and Sprint might do their own traffic shaping, but as a previous T-Mobile customer, this doesn't seem to be the case. It works better for me now on Ting than it used to work before on T-Mobile. No throttling, no video degradation, no bullshit. Definitely recommended. Unfortunately worse coverage then Verizon though, at least where I need it.
- ikeboy 9y agoThe article claims that all major carriers do something similar, so I'm wondering whether MVNOs are exempt.
- 4ad 9y agoPossibly depends on the MVNO and the type of contract they got with the MNO. On Ting you are definitely exempt, other MVNOs, not so sure. However, my understanding is that MVNO traffic has lower priority in the MNO traffic shaping, so you get affected if there's congestion.
- MBCook 9y agoLovely. I just signed up for the unlimited plan on Verizon about a week or two ago. Now I have NO IDEA what my situation is or which tier I'm effectively in.
- DanHulton 9y agoYou stay in the same plan, none of the new tiers. They don't morph into new plans magically. However, you're still restricted to the 720p video cap. So it's still pretty shitty.
- MBCook 9y agoGiven that I'm pretty sure I've been experiencing their "test" that's an improvement. I was more worried I was going to be stuck in the 480p tier.
- bitJericho 9y agoWorry not, you signed a contract. If they change the terms of the contract, demand they keep your service unchanged or cancel as a breach of contract.
- MBCook 9y agoKnowing phone companies there's probably a part of that contract it says that they're allowed to change it and that I can't sue, I can only choose to drop it without penalties. As if I would be allowed to use a lawsuit anyway, I'm sure I'd have to use mandatory binding arbitration.
- bitJericho 9y agoThere's no need need to sue unless you've somehow been damaged. Dropping service and keeping your 600 dollar phone or returning it used is more than damaging enough for them.
- MBCook 9y ago
- kingbirdy 9y agoSo no carrier anywhere offers true unlimited? It all comes with some form of slowdowns, either right off the bat or at certain usage thresholds, and throttles video to some arbitrary max resolution?
- bitJericho 9y agoThat's what a monopoly brings. It won't take very long for other countries to eclipse the US in tech.
- rayiner 9y agoWhat monopoly? There are four major nationwide carriers. That's more competition than in: search, mobile operating systems, package delivery, and many other markets we think of as competitive.
- kingbirdy 9y agoI don't think anyone on HN thinks those are competitive markets, they're all oligopolies
- tptacek 9y agoWhatever else they are, they're also the expected outcome for capital-intensive markets with difficult-to-differentiate products. It would be weird if we had 10 competing nationwide carriers. (Not "bad". Weird.)
- bitJericho 9y agoFour nationwise carriers? They are all colluding on territories, price, features and service! Why aren't there hundreds or thousands? That would be real competition.
- tptacek 9y agoWhy would there be hundreds of carriers? What purpose would that serve in the market? Each carrier would necessarily serve a far smaller number of customers, which would leave each with less capital to build out and maintain a network. We had this with independent ISPs in the 1990s (I ran technical operations for the most popular such ISP in Chicago, EnterAct). It was not an unalloyed good. Most of the independent ISPs were pointless. They were each independent re-implementations of the same basic architecture, each with its own idiosyncrasies and incompetences. Some couldn't bill correctly. Some couldn't keep a Livingston Portmaster online consistently. None of them could secure an email server or reliably monitor all their POPs. Internet service was drastically more expensive, drastically less reliable, and harder to buy.
- bluedino 9y ago>> Unlimited mobile hotspot, but hotspot speeds are capped at a maximum of 600kbps I see this as a bright spot - unlimited hotspot is great, 6mb isn't 'fast' but it's enough to be usable. And the other plan has the first 15GB on LTE speed.
- strictnein 9y agoWell, that's not 6Mb. It's 600Kbps == 0.6Mbps
- derekp7 9y agoSo that's fast enough for ssh. I wonder if it is good enough for RDP, VNC, or NX protocol. I don't think it would be good for raw uncompressed X11. Also, is that available as a standalone hotspot plan, or just with a phone hotspot?
- fencepost 9y agoRDP is absolutely fine at 600kbps, in fact it's just fine at 128kbps and still pretty decent at 56kbps. Bear in mind that it's not magic, so even with the improvements in newer versions that make video and audio suck less it's not going to let you stream any better than your base connection speed would allow anyway.
- isnotchicago 9y agoBy default, AT&T also throttles video playback to 480p, but it is an option that can be disabled: https://www.att.com/offers/streamsaver.html https://www.att.com/offers/streamsaver.html (instructions listed in the middle/FAQ).
- adamgamble 9y agoHow can they detect the video if it's over ssl? Are they just detecting big streams of data and throttling it? If so that's bad because it will certainly have false positives and throttle those.
- wmf 9y agoAFAIK they're detecting IP addresses of major video services.
- dplgk 9y agoAre they transcoding video down to 480p?