12 ms·
83 percent of Bay Area renters plan to leave, says survey
- rhombocombus 9y ago...and come to Portland. (I kid, I kid. It's a neverending joke here)
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago...on their way to Seattle. (The Californian invasion has always been a thing in the PnW)
- snuxoll 9y agoDon't forget us down here in Boise. The constant influx of people from other regions is straining our housing market, especially since the vast majority of employment options still left (after HP split and Micron downsized) are in the service industry. My mom paid $900/mo for a 4 bedroom house in a south-Boise subdivision in 2010, I'm now paying $1200/mo for a 3 bedroom house 5 miles further out in Meridian. Our housing costs aren't SF-crazy, but when you consider the lack of public transport necessitating vehicle ownership and depressed wages (lots of people making under $10/hr at call centers) it's becoming unaffordable for the masses.
- seanmcdirmid 9y ago> I'm now paying $1200/mo for a 3 bedroom house 5 miles further out in Meridian Uhm...wow, that's cheap. If you had a decent tech job in Boise (at HP?) it might work out pretty well.
- snuxoll 9y agoSure, it's affordable for me now - back when I was making $32K/yr on a MSP's help desk it would have been almost half of my wage - and that's good money for the majority of the population here. Lucky me, I make $85K now working from home - but 4 years ago it was a different story, and there's still plenty of people in the area who are trying to make ends meet. Boise has been really slow to recover from the recession, where many people used to be able to get decent jobs at Micron, HP, Simplot, etc. there's much less available - call centers and other service industry positions have begun to dominate. The median cost of a house in the area is back to pre-2008 levels and rising fast, but wages aren't.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoSounds a bit like Spokane, though they have a lot of medical going on to keep things sane.
- Danihan 9y agoWow, great idea, thanks!
- S_A_P 9y agoFrom my outside looking in perspective, it seems the gold rush is waning in the Bay Area. There will always be a pretty healthy tech industry there but anecdotal evidence tells me that fewer people are heading west to make it big in startups. This is probably a good thing for everyone except real estate speculators though.
- regularfry 9y agoI'd be intrigued to know how much of that is because of remote working, and how much is because of traditional jobs growing in other places (and, of course, how much is people not doing startups). My gut says that remote working isn't big enough to cause this sort of shift, but I'd love to know if I'm wrong.
- delphinius81 9y agoOther cities with much better cost of living are gaining reputation in tech / start-ups and attracting talent (or just keeping the talent that went to school there).
- sidlls 9y agoReally? Which ones?
- jknoepfler 9y agoMinneapolis springs immediately to mind. Companies like Amazon are opening dev offices in medium-sized American cities now as well, because importing everyone into Seattle or Boston isn't sustainable. From my experiences in places like Minneapolis and Cincinnati, I'd project a pretty serious difussion of tech talent back into the Midwest.
- sidlls 9y agoI've interviewed with "tech" companies in some of the cities you mentioned. The compensation was substantially lower than anything I can get in the Bay Area (by about a factor of 2 compared to my current compensation, for example). The CoL adjustment wouldn't be greater than the reduced savings rate. These companies need to realize that the market rate for the kinds of engineering and talent they demand is set in the bigger cities, not their little slice of the Midwest. I understand why they're doing it, but for all the issues in the Bay Area the opportunities are still better than almost anywhere else and so is the pay.
- cal5k 9y agoTo what degree is this reflected by actions? Has anybody checked past survey results? It could just be that renters in SF are the grumpiest ;-)
- alexandercrohde 9y agoWell for context, having lived in SF for 5 years before leaving, yes 80% probably plan to leave, probably 80% do leave, but only after many career years. It's where I cut my chops because I could get a 6 figure engineering job without a relevant degree. Very few people expect to stay in a city permanently, and remember many of those workers aren't even citizens, so many of them plan to return "home" at some point. This doesn't mean anything unless the influx is less than the outflux.
- robbyking 9y agoI've lived in SF for close to 20 years, and I completely agree. That said, I'm part of the 83% who are planning on leaving, but there are two main problems: • If I leave, where will I go? As many faults as SF has, it's still a beautiful, world class city, rich with culture. Walkability is huge for me, and I don't want to live someplace where I'm tied to my car. • Salary. Usually the cost of living follows the pay scale of a local economy, but that doesn't help you when you want to buy things priced at a national level: computers, cars, bikes, etc. If you earn $160k/yr, buy a new MacBook Pro isn't a big deal; if you make $60k/yr, you have to put a little more thought into it.
- vonmoltke 9y ago> Salary. Usually the cost of living follows the pay scale of a local economy, but that doesn't help you when you want to buy things priced at a national level: computers, cars, bikes, etc. If you earn $160k/yr, buy a new MacBook Pro isn't a big deal; if you make $60k/yr, you have to put a little more thought into it. I see this brought up a lot, but these expenses are such a small portion of my outlay that it barely moves the needle. Maybe I'm just weird. Also, cars do vary across geographical areas. The MSRP may be the same nationally, but the drive-off price is pretty variable.
- aianus 9y agoDon't forget retirement. That's the number one lifetime expense for most people and it's priced at a global level. You reach that point so much faster working in the Bay Area.
- tmh79 9y agoIMO this is a terrible outcome, and its exactly what the NIMBY landowning class in the SFBA wants to happen.
- dasil003 9y agoIs it really what they want? Do they expect property values to keep going up even when people decide it's not worth it anymore?
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoIf you talk to them, they really do want that. They care a lot less about their properties values than they do about the amount of cars parked on their street and their daily commute times. You would think that they would simply sell their million-dollar bungalow and move to greener pastures, but that's just not what happens.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- schnevets 9y agoI'm noticing similar sentiments among friends in New York City. Everyone came here for jobs/culture/friends after graduating, but the mad-rush of millennials is making the city more and more unlivable. Nobody wants to spend their thirties in a cramped, overpriced studio, but nobody is ready to leave their hip, startup lofts for the drudgery of a Westchester office complex (let alone endure an hour commute into the city every day). Smaller cities (the Portlands, New Havens, and Columbuses of the country) will continue to inherit the overflow, with those cities that have the lowest cultural cachet taking the lowliest remnants. Given the demand for urban environments by businesses and consumers, it seems like the only thing holding back any city from heavy growth is incompetence or negative reputations.
- chaosbutters314 9y agoWhat is wrong with westchester? It doesn't smell as bad, you can get a place for the same price as nyc with 4x the space and you're only a 1 hr drive away if you don't try to go during rush hours. A big problem I see with going to westchester to nyc is the parking costs in nyc. Like $50/day is wayyyyyyyy too high to be sustainable. And the trains are just too slow, it is faster to drive from where I am in westchester than take the train.
- schnevets 9y agoI meant the Westchester comment as a bit tongue-in-cheek. More of the stereotypical opinion among my generation, rather than my own opinion. I'm actually shopping around in the Hudson Valley with my fiance atm. Regardless, the "corporate campus" will need to go through a reimagining if it wants to appeal to city-weary knowledge workers. This will require some more lateral thinking beyond replicating Facebook's Headquarters in White Plains, NY.
- tmh79 9y ago> but the mad-rush of millennials is making the city more and more unlivable IMO, the problem is the policies of the city that are unfriendly to growth and make housing a zero sum game, the problem isn't than people expressing their preferences.
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoThe Bay Area is only a place of permanence for those lucky enough to buy a house. For the rest of us, it's a place to get fantastic work experience and awesome pay. Even if you're paying $2k to rent a studio, if your take-home pay goes from $500 to $1500 you're coming out way ahead dealing with the headaches of living here. But you need to move away to truly realize those gains.
- autotune 9y agoNot to mention there are plenty of companies out here who are okay with their employees working remotely, so if you can make a 6 figure salary in a place with more arts and culture and where rent is $1500 for a luxury one bedroom downtown instead of $4500, then it's clear what the better choice would be. Also you'd be stupidly lucky to pay only $2K for a decent studio, personally I pay $2600 and that was a steal for the location (not getting stabbed at night, no homeless tents, close to MUNI), and amenities (washer/dryer).
- sebbecai 9y agoAnd then there's roommates... I used to pay $600 a month for an SF house, and did this by having 2 roommates and a live-in girlfriend. Saved enough for a house. Much comes down to delayed gratification.
- autotune 9y agoAnd then there's the ability to sleep at night without your roommate having a conversation next your door at 2 AM, a different set of roommates that expected only you to take out the trash, another roommate that blasted tv next to your door at 2 AM, having to switch out a good roommate with someone who might also be terrible when they leave, not having your own space to work and focus on the job and hobbies, etc. etc. There is no delayed gratification when there is nothing to work towards to as you slowly go insane living with people who have no idea what it means to be "quiet" at night nor have a basic level of accountability/self-awareness, even if they say they do.
- fapjacks 9y ago
- dmode 9y agoI would take this survey with a heavy grain of salt. From the article "The two-question survey (“Do you plan on settling down in another city?” and “What’s your biggest reason for leaving?”) covered 24,000 respondents nationwide." If I was living in SF and someone asked me "Do you plan on settling down in another city?" - my answer would be yes, somewhere in the Bay Area suburb like Palo Alto. I think very few people are looking to "settle" in SF.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cbtacy 9y agoSpeaking as a 20+ year resident - thank god.
- kevinburke 9y agoI'm a 20+ year resident - I grew up here. My friends and family are slowly leaving, and it's really sad.
- WD-42 9y agoSpeaking as someone who grew up in the Bay and then left: Thank god. Maybe I'll be able to move back someday.
- caseysoftware 9y agoI think the key question I don't see answered here is "When?" Most people want to move at some point and often do for jobs, kids, spouse's job, etc. But whether this is impending (this year) or "an acknowledged desire" is a big difference.
- pfooti 9y agoI have lived here since 2010, so somewhat early in the current bubble. I am lucky enough to rent a place that's fairly large (most of a house) but also rent controlled, so I can afford to live here. If my landlord sold the house and I had to find a new place, I'd have to leave. So: plan to leave? Probably. Want to? Nope. I love the outer sunset. I just foresee a time when I won't be able to afford to live here anymore.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoIf you had to pay market price you'd probably want to leave.
- leggomylibro 9y agoToo expensive, too crowded, too stifling, and nowadays sometimes even too bland. Without roots in the city, there doesn't seem to be much to recommend it these days besides the weather and the massive, insane availability of liquid capital compared to the extensive dearth in other markets. But as long as the money is there, and other sources of investment capital remain locked away, that's not a bad recommendation. SV VCs may be getting more cautious, but investors in other markets don't seem particularly eager to loosen the purse strings. So they may say they plan to leave, but I just finished a comic fantasy novel called 'Thud!', and this (lightly edited) passage comes to mind: - "I'd wonder...you know, if I were a king...I'd wonder why people were happier living in squalor in [the city] than staying back home. ... "There's dwarf bars all over, and they've got mining tools wired to the wall, and there's dwarfs in 'em every night quaffing beer and singing sad songs about how they wish they were back in the mountains digging for gold. But if you said to them fine, the gate's open, off you go and send us a postcard, they'd say, 'Oh, well, yeah, I'd love to, but we've just got the new workshop finished...maybe NEXT year we'll go back home.'"
- klipt 9y agoThe great thing about Discworld is that it's just like the real world - only funnier.
- dv_dt 9y ago> SV VCs may be getting more cautious, but investors in other markets don't seem particularly eager to loosen the purse strings. There is some sort of irony in SV VCs being at a keystone of the internet and yet somehow being unable to invest outside of SV.
- leggomylibro 9y agoIt does make a sort of sense - VCs in the bay area seem to congregate there because software companies can promise (if things go just right) stratospheric return rates. Those glitzy home-runs can fund a lot of flops, and the investors still win out. If you want to make something physical, you can't hand-wave and make wild assumptions about growth rates and user acquisition and ARPUs. You have a Bill of Materials, distribution costs, a slim margin, and rapid competition from cheaper and often outright dangerous knock-offs with little recourse. Look what happened with hoverboards. So in a market that is as jaw-droppingly risk averse as this, but people still want to grow their huge hoards of capital, the money takes the path of least resistance and follows the only available market that can theoretically produce an exponential growth curve more than once every few decades.
- mullen 9y agoHigh Speed Rail helps fix this issue. You can live an hour out of the city, where housing prices are much lower and the schools can be much better and then commute via HSR to the city. Unfortunately, there are too many short term voters and residents in California to see the vision of high speed public transportation to solve many of the housing ills that plague this state.
- compiler-guy 9y agoEven if all the municipalities suddenly jumped on board, even in the best case high-speed rail is a decade and a half off. It isn't a realistic solution.
- mullen 9y agoSF to Gilroy could be done in under a decade, which then would be connected to LA once that track was done. California is messing up the HSR project by not getting SF to Gilroy and LA to San Diego completed first. Sacramento to Nowhere is a PR blunder for the state.
- jonathankoren 9y agoIt's because that's the only places where they can actually build. The peninsula is full of millionaires that hate the idea of HSR. ("But I don't it at grade!" "But I don't want it in the air!" "But I don't want it in a trench!" "But I don't in a tunnel!" "It's all moving so fast!" "Can we put an HSR to stop every 2 miles?") https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/10/14/palo-alto-blasts-high-speed-rail-project-for-moving-too-fast https://www.paloaltoonline.com/news/2015/10/14/palo-alto-bla... http://www.smdailyjournal.com/news/local/high-speed-rail-met-with-concerns-in-san-carlos/article_6743a242-5d52-11e7-970f-f3255fe73447.html http://www.smdailyjournal.com/news/local/high-speed-rail-met...
- esmi 9y agoThe BART extension to San Jose was first voter approved in 2000. Many years and bonds later it's closer but a San Jose BART station still does not exist. I'm not sure CA could do SF to Oakland by HSR in a decade. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Valley_BART_extension https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicon_Valley_BART_extensio...
- gnahckire 9y agoDidn't live in SF but, I lived in the south bay and recently moved away. I'm glad I did. I'm making more & saving more living somewhere else. That being said, I do think the bay area is a great place to start one's career.
- dinedal 9y agoWhere'd you go to?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- arcaster 9y agoPlease don't come to Austin. All you Californians do is complain about the heat!
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoAnd bring their politics with them Edit: While you might not see it as an issue many of the people who liked the culture as it was prior do.
- klipt 9y agoBy politics do you mean like, not hating gay people?
- sndean 9y agoI think Austin is a "blue dot" city [0] and they have a large LGBT population [1]. [0] http://www.estately.com/blog/assets/Snapshot-62713-144-PM.png http://www.estately.com/blog/assets/Snapshot-62713-144-PM.pn... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin,_Texas#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin,_Texas#Demographics
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoI meant more along the lines of NIMBYism (which should really be NIYBYism since it's about what other people do on their property). I guess caring about your neighbor's politics is just NIMBYism of the mind. It's kind of a catch22 since wanting to live in a community where people don't care if your opinions are different or if you want to raise rabbits for food makes you one of the people who cares about what other people care about
- ausjke 9y agoYes please go anywhere else but Austin, enough is enough.
- hpguy 9y agoAlright, since this is not the first time I see this: what the deal about people from Austin trying to shoo people away? As if Austin was really that great and everybody wanted to come there? And isn't it the case that the more tech people go live in the Austin, the better the tech scene and thus benefit tech people like you (I assume you're in tech)? I had lived in the Bay Area, moved to Austin just to move to another place within a year. Austin has many nice things, but definitely not one of the top US cities I would consider building a family in. I can list out tons of things about Austin that would be deal breakers for many people and there are better cities out there in many aspects. I'm truly puzzled by this sentiment from Austin people.
- kevinburke 9y agoIf you grew up here, you'd like to stay here or start a company here, please get involved politically in electing candidates and pushing for policies that help lower the price of housing. - AB 71 would raise $300 million a year for affordable housing, call your CA Assemblymember. - SB 35 would take power from local NIMBY's for projects that meet affordable housing targets. Call your CA Assemblymember. - Email baylands@ci.brisbane.ca.us and ask them to build 4400 units of housing on the Baylands, just south of San Francisco. They are waffling but the local residents want to build an office park. - Email your C level employees and VC's and tell them about your struggles to continue staying here, afford a babysitter or find a good school, and ask them to get involved in developing better housing policy for the Bay Area.
- Nuzzerino 9y agoHow will more housing do anything other than make the traffic congestion even worse? More people will move here, prices will be close to the same, and traffic will be way worse. More VCs need to start supporting the idea of satellite offices and remote cultures for anything more than a dent to be made.
- blackguardx 9y agoTraffic congestion mainly exists when people don't live close to work. By building more housing all over the Bay Area, people will be more able to live close to work and thus reduce congestion. Not having enough housing forces people to commute from further out, which adds congestion all along their path.
- wang_li 9y ago> AB 71 would raise $300 million a year for affordable housing, call your CA Assemblymember. This is just an indirect subsidy of Facebook, Google, etc. By providing low income housing and food assistance to low income workers in high cost of living cities, it simply allows the well to do companies to continue not paying a living wage that corresponds to the situation that they've created by concentrating their businesses in the same area.
- HumbleGamer 9y agoNot a lot of reasons to stay if you will never own a home here. Stay in the bay so you can pay someones mortgage for the rest of your life or share an apartment? Meanwhile the cost of a shared room is more than people are paying for a mortgage in other areas not too far from here.
- nostrademons 9y agoHoly selection bias, batman. The data is taken from an Internet survey by ApartmentList. Why would you ever go on ApartmentList? Because you're looking for a new apartment. Why would you go on ApartmentList particularly, vs. a more common rental site like Craigslist? Because it's organized by city - the front page has glossy photos of major metropolitan areas - and so you can easily browse through other cities without knowing much about what neighborhoods exist in that city. Title should be "83 percent of ApartmentList visitors in the Bay Area plan to leave". While anecdotally I know a lot of people that are considering moving away, it's nowhere close to 83 percent, and the way the data was collected for this PR piece doesn't support that conclusion either.
- beambot 9y agoQuestioning the sampling methodology is fine... but why would you expect the percentage (83%) to be higher on ApartmentList than, say, Craigslist? As long as we're sharing anecdata... 83% sounds about right based on my friend cohort.
- nostrademons 9y agoCraigslist is organized primarily by neighborhood: if you go to sfbay.craigslist.com and visit apts/housing, the first level filter is by region (east bay, north bay, SF, peninsula, etc), and then before you even get to the type of housing, the next-level filter is by neighborhood (Mission, Potrero, Sunset, etc.) These regional filters are virtually useless for someone moving out of state; if I go to portland.craigslist.com and the top-level filters are clark/clackamas/multnomah/etc, I have no idea what these even mean. Even getting to another metro area's Craigslist is a challenge; if I hit www.craigslist.com, it defaults to sfbay.craigslist.com, and to go elsewhere requires finding the tiny "other US cities" link on the front page (the default is "Nearby", which gives other California cities) and selecting a metro area. All this facilitates within-region moves at the expense of between-region moves. If I go to ApartmentList.com, it defaults to San Francisco, but right underneath the three local metro areas (ironically, it doesn't have San Jose, where I am) are glossy photographs of Atlanta, Austin, Charlotte, Chicago, and 12 other metro areas. And if I click on one of them, the first filters that come up are by price, size, and amenities. Everything is located on a map, and I don't need to know anything about local neighborhoods. ApartmentList is clearly using "people who are looking to move between cities" as their market segmentation and features for them as a differentiator, which is great, but also means that their data is suspect if generalized to the population as a whole. (As for anecdata; I'd say that among my friends and acquaintances close enough to keep tabs on their life, maybe 50% are looking to move out of the Bay Area at some point, including myself & my wife. But only three - out of a sample size of several dozen, perhaps close to a hundred - have actually done it, and two of those moved back to their hometown to be close to family when kids arrived. Moving cities is a big commitment; people dream of it, but few do it.)
- abalashov 9y agoThis smacks of the folk threatening to move to Canada every time a Republican president gets elected (although with this particular one, they may really be onto something). If the Bay area's hold were this fragile, it wouldn't have got this way to begin with. Clearly, living within driving distance of 90% of the world's tech giants outweighs a great many other considerations, despite the rent pressure cooker. Disclaimer: don't live in the Bay Area and don't plan to, so have no dog in this fight.
- RickJWagner 9y agoRemote work is nice. You can get paid by the big employers, but live in a place where you can save a few bucks. You can always visit the big cities on vacation.
- iamleppert 9y agoI moved out to the bay area five years ago. Mostly, because I'm a nerd and wanted to be around other like-minded nerds and fulfill my nerd dreams. Fast forward to today. I've worked at startups, big tech, and generally have lived that tech life. I see my friends back in Ohio taking vacations, buying homes, and generally having a nice life. And I see myself here, paying more and more rent each year, working in the high stress of startups and in the tech scene as my own passion for the actual tech slowly wanes. Sure, I make a lot of money and I have a fancy job but money and prestige, I've learned, isn't everything. If you're pissing all that money away with no end in sight, except to become fabulously wealthy in some kind of exit that likely won't ever happen, you start to question your original motives. At this point I have decided to stay another five years here, mostly so I can say I had a "10 year career" in the bay area. I will then take that experience, most likely back to the midwest, and try to leverage it into a better job than I'd be able to get by spending 10 years back in the midwest. Hopefully, this strategy will be successful for me. I think by then I'll have a shot at becoming director or VP-level, and coupled with my experience out here I will stand out in the midwest. I'll also have a far better experience-lead "technical education" out here than I would have ever had in Ohio, and that at least stands for something.
- abalashov 9y agoIndeed, one of the functions of tech economy meccas is precisely to enable this type of economic arbitrage, and certainly, that's one of the reasons why the cost of living in them commands a sizable economic premium. :) Best of luck in your venture.
- pj_mukh 9y agoIt sucks that you have to choose between, "Mostly, because I'm a nerd and wanted to be around other like-minded nerds and fulfill my nerd dreams." and "taking vacations, buying homes, and generally having a nice life. " Ideally, you wouldn't have to choose between the two. In fact, the two should compliment each other instead of trade-off.
- chris_7 9y agoMy techie friends in New York tend to be the ones taking the interesting vacations because they have a lot more money. New York and Bay Area tech companies can pay two or three times what the suburban office park type companies pay, and they have other benefits that add up as well (i.e. fully-paid tiny-copay health insurance). While housing costs will eat into that somehwat, whether you rent or buy, I don't think that they come close to cancelling out that increase. Then, when we do go on vacation, there are more flights, since we're near major international airports. Since I live near EWR and JFK, I don't really need to consider connecting flights for European vacations, for example. There are other less objective things for describing a "nice life", of course (IMO, renting vs. buying should be categorized as one of these, neither is superior). For example, non-chain restaurant availability, quality of cultural institutions, etc.
- smcdow 9y agoNo surprise there. Does anyone think of the Bay Area as anything more than a way station in life?
- velobro 9y agoI'm moving the bay in less than two weeks from the Central Valley. I plan to stay there around 5 years or so then move. I'd like to own a home one day and there is no one in hell that is happening in the Bay.
- excitom 9y ago>In 2015, the US Census found that about 80,000 people left the SF-Oakland area over the course of a year. But then about 100,000 new people moved in to replace them. The sentence that explains it all.
- notadoc 9y agoThe bay area, like most of the USA, needs to build up. It is sprawling enough as is. Build up, not out.