3 ms·
Why would I become a farm worker when I could just collect unemployment checks? A proposal for reducing unemployment: anyone physically capable of doing farm w
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Why would I become a farm worker when I could just collect unemployment checks?
A proposal for reducing unemployment: anyone physically capable of doing farm work is not eligible for unemployment benefits. Obviously this is a non-starter with the current political leadership...
[edit: to be clear, this only applies until there are no further vacancies in farming jobs.]
- jeb 16y agoThat would mean that anyone who was out of a job in the city would either need to leave the city or prey on the people within the city who still have money. Your proposal would lead to a huge de-population of the cities. It would also mean that if by some weird series of events you became unemployed for a while, and could not find a job, you would be forced out to work the fields. It's much easier to start working the fields than to get back to society. When you need to work for minimum wage every day, you don't have time to find that programming job you're looking for.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoSub-minimum wage, I would imagine.
- cameldrv 16y agoThe problem is that with the immigration situation, those jobs pay less than minimum wage, have horrible working conditions, and people often don't get paid. That's why the solution is a) A border fence, b) Much more strict employer enforcement, and c) Amnesty for those here, once a and b are accomplished. That way, the workforce stabilizes, and there is work for people in the U.S. who don't have a lot of skills. There probably aren't a lot of these people on HN, but many people just aren't going to be able to work a high-end job. We need something decent to do for those people. The problem is that right now, you can't have a first world existence on what a farmhand job pays. The second step is probably drug legalization, because our drug laws have turned Mexico into a failed state, and it's impossible for Mexico to build a decent economy with the level of crime that they have.
- vinhboy 16y agoDo you think farmers can afford to hire workers at higher rates?
- thesethings 16y agoFrom my experience (read on), jobs illegal immigrants have get paid at least minimum wage (Not that this is livable). Most illegal immigrants get a social security number through underground document-makers. They give that number to the employer (who knows it's fake, but acts otherwise). I've befriended many Mexican immigrants, illegal and legal, and have even gone to a house that makes these documents. (It was surprisingly low-cost. ) Now this doesn't speak to your other point, about whether a farmhand job is livable for anybody. But my main point is: it's probably a legit job that withholds taxes and everything. There is a large set of jobs that has a high-turnover rate for everybody who works in them. Overnight cleaning crews in offices, table bussers, farmhands... This turnover rate is high for everybody, legal and illegal, who works there. My guess is that the employers assume anybody who works there will leave soon, and it's not worth thoroughly vetting whether the ss# belongs to a dead guy. As for my opinion on all this... I'm still working it out. I'm also biased, have lots of Mexican family on this of the border, and am admittedly sentimental about it. Ideally we can first focus on making any job livable, and THEN worry about who gets to have it.
- ryanelkins 16y agoSeriously? A border fence? I didn't think many people actually took that serious as a deterrent. Have you seen the Penn and Teller show where they pay (legally questionable) immigrants to build a length of fence using the same specs as the border fence - then pay them to go over, under, and through it? I just remember they were on the other side pretty quick. Then there's the cost to build and maintain... it's just such a ridiculous idea to me.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoDo you really believe that securing a border is impossible? Or are you simply suggesting that the US military is less capable of securing a border than the Indian, Chinese, Israeli or South Korean military?
- mechanical_fish 16y agoAre you suggesting that there are an infinite number of jobs for farm workers? The reason why farm workers have tiny wages and poor working conditions is that there is a massive global surplus of people who are looking for farm work. And if you're unemployed it doesn't matter what you are unemployed at. You can declare yourself to be an unemployed auto worker, or an unemployed farm worker, or an unemployed ballerina for that matter. There is an infinite number of jobs that I'm not employed at. You may ask, of course, why an unemployed software engineer collects more benefits than an unemployed day laborer. The answer is: Because unemployment insurance taxes are proportional to income. The engineer pays more taxes when employed, in order to collect higher benefits when unemployed.
- mmt 16y agoThe engineer pays more taxes when employed, in order to collect higher benefits when unemployed. Only in theory. The reality makes far less sense. Here in California, it's not the employee who pays the tax, but the employer, and it's only proportional to income up to $7000 per year (yes, year, not month) per employee. The payout is only proportional to earnings up to around $50k annually.
- ars 16y ago> it's not the employee who pays the tax, but the employer What's the difference? To the employer it's just added to the salary, they don't think about it any differently. You could give it to the employee first, and then take it from them if you like. It's identical.
- mmt 16y agoYou could give it to the employee first, and then take it from them if you like. It's identical. Not under current income tax treatment, it isn't. For mandated insurance, if the employer pays, then the benefits are taxable[1]. If the employee pays, the benefits are not taxable [2]. More importantly, since unemployment insurance premiums can be variable, depending on an employer's layoff history, the rate isn't influenced by the employee. Arguably most importantly, an employee-side tax would be visible to everyone on every pay stub. The bizarre inconsistencies wouldn't be hidden away. [1] Such as is the case with unemployment benefits. [2] Such as is the case with short-term disability.
- adamilardi 16y agoI think your analysis is a bit harsh but hits on a good point. If we give people benefits forever it doesn't make sense to work. Ie if you lost a higher paying job. You will make more taking unemployment than getting a lower paying job.
- yason 16y agoIncome trap. Taking a job, any job, should always increase a person's net income. Similarly, working more as opposed to working less should consistently do the same. Working several jobs should do the same as opposed to doing only one job or doing no job. This is not always the case, depending on taxation, subsidies, and other eases. Basic income would be a good solution for such traps. You would always make at least X money where X is large enough that it allows you to live but small enough to make most people not want to live like that. So, there would be no unemployment checks, just basic income. If you took the job as a farm worker, you would always get your earnings on top of the basic income.