7 ms·
Amazon paid just £15m in tax on European revenues of £19.5bn
- rb808 9y agoIt didn't pay much American tax either because it doesn't make any profits anywhere. Lots of physical shopping chains aren't paying tax because they dont make money either. The real question is will Amazon ever make money and at that time - will it pay taxes then?
- conradk 9y agoThere is also a problem of large companies making it seem like they don't make money, through complex financial montages, when in fact they do.
- adventured 9y agoWhat does that have to do with Amazon? Their financials are public information, show me where they're hiding the massive cash production, because they must be hiding it from shareholders as well. Amazon is still primarily a retailer, one with historically horrific margins. The segment has notoriously bad margins in general (Costco & Walmart: typical ~2% net income margins, with very high income tax rates). Then there's Amazon, spending like crazy since its inception to fund growth. It makes perfect sense that they wouldn't be generating much in the way of profit versus their revenue.
- developer2 9y agoSaying that Walmart has "notoriously bad margins" makes it sound like they're working at a disadvantage. Walmart's margins aren't low out of necessity. Their entire business is purposely built around low margins, and refusing to hire full time employees with benefits, etc. It's intentional on their part - there is no sob story about margins there. Same goes for Amazon et al. The business strategy is to crush every small retailer by operating at slim to no margins, purely to make it impossible for anyone else to compete.
- pas 9y ago> The business strategy is to crush every small retailer by operating at slim to no margins, purely to make it impossible for anyone else to compete. Large retailers compete against each other. Small retailers can't do much anyhow. (Especially in heavily car based areas, if you have to go just a few more minutes and you can find more and cheaper products, why would you stop at a small shop?)
- conradk 9y agoYou are being subjective here. Maybe you like driving for more and cheaper products, but not everyone is like you: not everyone drives, not everyones wants to drive, some people prefer supporting small shops than big ones, etc, etc.
- pas 9y agoI don't like to drive, I like small shops, and luckily where I live we have a healthy dose of small groceries. (But they are part of large chains.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zsgoldberg 9y agotaxes aren't determined by revenue, i haven't even opened the article (yet) and it's already stunted its own impact
- meritt 9y agoThat varies by jurisdiction. Gross Receipts Taxes [1] (including Washington State [2] where Amazon is headquartered) are levied against revenue and not profit. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_receipts_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gross_receipts_tax [2] http://dor.wa.gov/content/FindTaxesAndRates/BAndOTax/ http://dor.wa.gov/content/FindTaxesAndRates/BAndOTax/
- wonder_bread 9y agoI don't like being rude in comments sections but that's a pretty dumb comment to make, to be honest. I don't think the writer needs any help understanding how tax bills are formulated, it's just meant to state a point. (Which you would understand if you read the article before commenting)
- rukittenme 9y agoWhat point is the author trying to state? "I don't understand tax bills"? It's meant to be deceptive and garner clicks. The author presents the full and complete story in the body of the text: "pre-tax profit of €59.6m last year" and "a tax of €16.5m". That's "only" a 30% tax rate. And not a story worth reading.
- wonder_bread 9y agoThe general point seems to be "large corporation doesn't pay its fair share of taxes". Something that seems to be more of a hot-button issue in Europe
- darawk 9y agoYa, and something that makes zero sense in the context of revenue. Nobody is taxed on revenue because taxing companies on revenue unfairly penalizes low-margin high-volume businesses (like Amazon). Revenue has nothing to do with tax rate. Nothing. Quoting their revenue in the headline is just meant to shock people that don't understand taxes. It's a bullshit headline and a bullshit story.
- adventured 9y agoI'm all for giving Amazon flack where it's deserved. This tax witch-hunt isn't one of those cases. 2016 pre-tax income: $3.89 billion 2016 income tax: $1.43 billion 2016 income tax rate: 36.7% That's one of the highest rates on earth. 2015: $1.57b pre-tax income. $950m income taxes. That's a 60% rate. They don't generate much taxable income. What exactly are they supposed to be paying substantial taxes on other than that? Should they be paying £30m (£50m?) in taxes on that £19.5 billion in European revenue instead? Ok, let's go with that, they're both meaningless figures. How is that a substantial matter to nail Amazon for (of all things) given the epic scale of tax schemes throughout Europe?
- beambot 9y agoSales tax?
- DanBC 9y agoIsn't income tax paid by the employees, and not Amazon? What's the employer's contribution? What you're missing is that the UK has been going through years of austerity. The UK public know some large companies have weird dodgy tax arrangements, and while there's some acceptance that no-one pays the real tax rate there's growing unrest about the very low rates paid by eg Starbucks or Google or Amazon. These companies can chose to pay a bit more tax, or face tighter regulation. The current EU VAT laws are proof the EU is happy to make onerous laws about tax
- tolien 9y agoAlso worth pointing out that a significant fraction of Amazon's (and Starbucks'; perhaps less so Google) staff (and especially the thousands that appear in the headlines when Amazon plants a big shed) are paid minimum wage and the taxpayer (via Working Tax Credits etc.) will be boosting that wage.
- wweidendorf 9y agoWhile $1.43 billion may be the GAAP tax rate they record, in practice they did not pay anywhere near that much. For the 2016 reporting period, cash taxes paid was recorded at $412 million, not the $1.43 billion you noted above. Given that, their effective cash tax rate was 10.6%, not the 36.7% you quoted. Source: Page 22, AMZN 2016 10-K (https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000101872417000011/amzn-20161231x10k.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000101872417...)
- titledlee 9y agoi hate articles that base what companies should pay based on revenues -.- bruh margins are shit for companies like AMZN , walmart etc
- withholding 9y agoNot at all. This is a myth.
- rukittenme 9y agoShow me in their financials where they are hiding their massive profit.
- jamhan 9y agoRelevant?: http://evonomics.com/amazon-accounting-corporate-profits-rich-peoples-income-invisible-bezos/ http://evonomics.com/amazon-accounting-corporate-profits-ric...
- pas 9y agoRelevant if you are talking about clickbait titles. Capital gains are taxed at 20% at realization. Tha articles (the site) makes the claim (by linking to an article on the same site) that capital gains are not counted as income. Yes, duh, because it counts as income when you close the position, sell the bond/stock/derivative/instrument/company/asset/capital and so on. Surprise, surprise, dividends, (bond) coupon payments, interest and other yearly direct monetary (cash) payments do count as income. And "some" economists don't ignore it: https://www.cbo.gov/publication/51361 https://www.cbo.gov/publication/51361 (neither did Piketty as far as I can tell)
- cestith 9y agoThe TL;DR of this article is the author dislikes the taxing basis put in place by the legislature and is blaming Amazon for paying taxes legally based on that. Never mind the 65,000 employees in Europe who presumably do pay income taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, and more based on the fact that they have their income from their employer. If someone wants to argue for a 1% or 2% revenue tax rather than a much higher rate but only on profits, that's the argument to make. Don't blame the players for playing by broken rules.
- falcolas 9y agoOoh, HN Comment Bingo! "Don't blame the company for exploiting the loopholes in the laws!" This is a very old argument that gets rather tiresome to see on every article dealing with how much/little corporations pay in taxes. I'd rather see some interesting discussion around whether they should be paying more (or less).
- rukittenme 9y agoITS NOT A LOOPHOLE. This isn't some oversight. The tax law was written that way with intent! People don't want companies to pay tax on revenue. And Amazon makes very little profit! No company on earth spends $100 so they can save $40 on their tax bill. It is nonsensical.
- runesoerensen 9y ago> No company on earth spends $100 so they can save $40 on their tax bill. It is nonsensical. How is that nonsensical? Seems like lots of companies expend/transfer/invest rather than being taxed on their profits? Edit: Replaced "to avoid" with "rather than".
- rukittenme 9y agoYes but they're not spending $100 to "dodge taxes". They're spending the money on positive NPV projects. You're mistaking an effect for a cause. Companies invest and expand and they pay less taxes as an effect. But in the future, they'll have to pay taxes on those revenue generating facilities they invested in. And if those investments go belly up then the company will LOSE more money than it ever gained by "dodging taxes".
- denysonique 9y agoCompanies are greedy, taxes are ultimately paid by consumers - should a tax become higher for amazon or any other company, they will immediately raise the prices of their products to compensate the profit losses.
- soperj 9y agoevery other company that does pay taxes loses to amazon on this though.
- abawany 9y agoOne difference is that when taxes are fairly paid by companies and they raise prices, then the company that can offer the lower price due to operational efficiency will win. Right now, the burden of taxation falls on other persons in society without such tax avoidance expertise and muddies the waters.
- potlee 9y agoBezos doesn't have to pay anything on the 10s of billions worth of unrealized gains in AMZN stock either. Income taxes discourage generation of income and sales taxes discourage consumption. Wealth taxes are harder to dodge this way and should make up more of the tax revenues.
- qaq 9y agoYou really think it's beneficial to take away ownership from a successful founder and transfer it under control of some pension fund manager?
- potlee 9y agoWealth taxes are supposed to be paid in cash not stock so he would have to liquidate of the stock
- valuearb 9y agoWhat's your point? You are still taking part of the founder's control away, and giving it to some third party. Bezo's has paid a huge amount of taxes on shares of stock he's actually sold. He shouldn't have to pay taxes on money he hasn't received or is even able to spend yet. What's best for Society is that both he and his capital remains in Amazon as long as possible as investment, not being turned into consumption (which would slow Amazon's growth rate down, slow it's ability to increase productivity and raise our standard of living).
- potlee 9y ago> He shouldn't have to pay taxes on money he hasn't received No one should have to pay taxes ideally, but the government needs money to provide basic services, keep us safe, etc. I don't think it is better to tax salaried people some of who can barely make ends meet before taxing someone who is sitting on $70 on unrealized capital gains just because he chooses not to sell.
- 9y ago
- cs702 9y agoAmazon has never paid income taxes commensurate with its size to any government, because it has never produced earnings commensurate with its size for shareholders. Amazon has always operated almost like a non-profit, non-taxable organization. That's old news.
- pravula 9y agoWhy is this so hard? If you want companies to pay a percent of their revenues, then write your tax code to tax a percentage of their revenues.
- elvirs 9y agopeople and companies behind amazon's desicions to keep growing instead of making income are amazons largest shareholders and made billions from amazons stock price going up. if they cant tax revenue then tax the capital gains from soaring stock prices
- mathperson 9y agocapital gains are only triggered when you sell the assets....taxing capital gains from paper moves would be a very bad idea.
- d_theorist 9y agoCorporations are not taxed on revenue, so I can only assume that the headline is designed to be inflammatory.
- sololipsist 9y agoJesus, I just found this place while looking for a reddit alternative, and seeing comments like these are making me soooooooooooo happy. This is going to sound pretentious as fuck, but I'm gonna say it anyway: I'm so tired of the hoards of people passively accepting whatever headlines reinforce their extremely simple, uniform bias / value set. Maybe this is just a reflection of the bias / value set of the crowd here, but at least it's a different one. I hope it's an indication of a higher level of general critical thinking, though.
- johngarrison 9y agoI'm happy to say I think you'll be pleased with the level of critical thinking here. I have also despaired at the state of Reddit. Though, depending on your interests, some days there may not be much on HR that tickles your attention.
- sololipsist 9y agoI'm noticing that, which is a little bit of a bummer. One of the other things I disliked about reddit is "science" or "technology" articles about things that are theoretically pretty cool if they exist, but don't, and likely never will. Like the article here about the gears for space - I just can't bring myself to give any fucks about a prototype. Put it in space and then tell me about it. That's fairly nit-picky, though. I'll take it.
- carterehsmith 9y ago"Corporations are not taxed on revenue" True. Now, perhaps offtopic: why are individuals taxed on revenue (ie salary, benefits ect), but corporations are not?
- tim333 9y ago
- adrianratnapala 9y agoCan we just change the title to "Guardian beleives Guardianistas don't know the difference between revenue and profit?"
- Veratyr 9y agoAnd? > Amazon Europe, which is based in Luxembourg and aggregates the billions of pounds of sales the retailer makes from individual countries across the continent, reported a pre-tax profit of €59.6m last year. As a result the company, which clocked up €21.6bn in sales across Europe last year, had a tax bill of just €16.5m. > Amazon is a hugely successful business but makes slim margins on the products its sells – the company recently warned it may report a loss in the third quarter – and with low profits comes a low tax bill. These are about the only lines in the article that really matter.
- molestrangler 9y agohttp://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-40884753 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-40884753
- aussieguy123 9y agoWhen it comes to corporate tax avoidance, the only headlines to take seriously are "Company x paid x amount of tax on x profits". If it says "Company x made x amount of revenue" or "Company x had x income last year" its not worth reading, companies are taxed on profit, not revenue.
- pas 9y agoThere are some revenue based taxes. (For example municipal corporate taxes in Hungary, about 1% of annual revenue.)
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoHonest question from someone who does not understand finance : why are companies taxed on profit while I am taxes on revenue? We have both costs, of different nature but still.