12 ms·
A reuters story on how it works: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mazda-strategy-idUSKBN1AO0E7 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mazda-strategy-idUSKBN1AO...
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
A reuters story on how it works: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mazda-strategy-idUSKBN1AO0E7 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-mazda-strategy-idUSKBN1AO...
So this is 'gasoline' diesel. Or diesel without the NOx. Which, in theory, would give better fuel economy and possibly better torque. And it will ship in cars in the 2019 model year (so possibly as early as late next year).
To me, it sounds like a "Don't pass"[1] bet on electric cars. Which they also are working with Toyota on electric cars so perhaps it is a fall back plan. It will be interesting to see how it fares. There are a lot of products that are built as the other side of an industry change bet. Sun created a workstation on the 68040 in case the SPARCStation didn't meet expectations as an example.
[1] In the dice game Craps, the "Don't Pass" bet is against the current player 'winning.'
- bsdetector 9y agoOr a bet on hybrids. Hybrids enable new types of engines that for instance operate at constant rate or that are under-powered for acceleration from a stop or going uphill.
- mtgx 9y agoI don't think hybrids have any future except in the heaviest of vehicles, where batteries won't make sense for another few decades. We're already seeing companies being interested in making battery-only buses, tractors, semis, and even airplanes. Not all models of those types of vehicles may work with batteries, but it's a sign of what the future could bring.
- komali2 9y agoTotal individual perspective here, but my dad took me on his worksite like 15 years ago to see the big super gorram awesome trucks (seriously those things are HUGE). When I asked about the engines, he said the trucks had massive diesel generators that powered motors, that in turn powered the wheels and hydraulics. So in a way, lots of construction equipment has kind of already been "hybrid."
- ClassyJacket 9y agoI believe that's also how diesel trains work.
- pkulak 9y agoAnd submarines.
- fnj 9y agoAn electric power transmission is hardly hybrid. You just have two extra conversions in your transmission, mechanical to electric and electric back to mechanical.
- jhayward 9y agoThe diesel-electric system used in Locomotives and heavy off-road mining trucks are literally examples of series hybrids. You may be objecting to ththe lack of battery storage, which isn't useful in those applications.
- bluGill 9y agobattery only buses make sense because the bug needs to run over rush hour and then can sit all do to charge. Battery operated tractors do not make sense without vastly better batteries because a tractor needs to run for 16 hours at max power (500hp). Sustaining 400000 kw for 16 hours is not easy. For semis and airplanes you need to consider your use: for short in town loads/short flights batteries can work, for longer distances we don't have the battery technology today to make it work. Someone once told me battery technology has 2-3 more doubling left and then we hit chemical limits and cannot get more out of them. If this is correct batteries can never do the longer distances, but I don't know if it is correct.
- petre 9y ago> battery technology has 2-3 more doubling left and then we hit chemical limits and cannot get more out of them We still have energy cells which are essentially bateries that you charge by pouring in some fluids just like in a regular car. However the tech is not mature enough yet.
- garretraziel 9y agoWhile I don't believe hybrids will survive in the long run, I think that hybrids (and plug-in hybrids specifically) will play important role in transition period of passenger cars (use EV in cities, use gasoline if you want to go >100 km, refuel whenever you want). A have Toyota Auris with hybrid synergy drive and even though it has really small battery (so it costs less than $25000 including tax), I am able to ride through small town using EV mode only and then use ICE between towns. My mileage is 4.4 l/100 km which is ~53.5 miles per gallon and I'm driving in city most of the time.
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoI bet on plugin hybrids, specifically ones with large batteries. This seems to be an unpopular opinion, but I think the Voltec drivetrain shows what's possible here. Pure EV purists dislike PHEVs because they have the complexity of an ICE car + an EV car, but I think there's some serious advantages. Like you say, Atkinson cycle for electricity generation for when the battery drains beyond smaller commute ranges. Something like this new Mazda engine in that context would make quite a bit of sense for overall fuel efficiency.
- kbenson 9y ago> Pure EV purists dislike PHEVs because they have the complexity of an ICE car + an EV car, but I think there's some serious advantages. I would imagine most the complaints are for when the ICE actually powers a drivetrain. If it's essentially a generator to keep the batteries from depleting too far, that's not much extra complexity it all. Have a problem with the generator? Just swap it out with a new or rebuilt one from some vendor (if designed well such that you can do so). I'm seeing that a Tesla uses about 300 Watts a mile @ 55 Mph.[1] Honda seems to have generators much more than capable of supplying that need for under $1000.[2] I'm not familiar enough with electric systems to know how accurate that assessment is (whether the voltage requirements complicate it, for example), but that seems promising. Then again, I imagine if it was really that easy, Tesla would have put a generator charge hookup and exhaust ventilation capabilities in the trunk already. Edit: Hmm, I'm definitely missing something, since the $1000 generator says it can go 8.1 hours on a gallon of gas, and it doesn't seem likely for that to translate into powering a Tesla for 8 hours of travel. 1: https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/average-wattage-for-driving-at-55mph-or-in-town.11240/ https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/threads/average-wattage-for-... 2: https://powerequipment.honda.com/generators/selecting-a-generator https://powerequipment.honda.com/generators/selecting-a-gene...
- fnj 9y ago> a Tesla uses about 300 Watts a mile @ 55 Mph This is nonsense. The dimensions are wrong. Watts are instantaneous power. To be meaningful, you would have to give either kWh/h or kWh per mile or km. Besides that 300 W is only 0.4 hp. Sorry, but that is just not credible.
- usrusr 9y agoFrom what I read about HCCI engines (the brand-neutral name for the general engine concept: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homogeneous_charge_compression_ignition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homogeneous_charge_compression... ) I suspect that they are not easily operated over a power band as wide as conventional gasoline or diesel engines. If that is the tradeoff, they could be a perfect match for hybrids.
- oatmealsnap 9y agoGasoline engines aren't going away for a while; even when every self-driving car is electric, there will be a market for people who want gasoline engines. If it gives a bump in fuel economy to the next (last?) generation of gasoline and hybrid vehicles, great! I also wonder if the maintainability of these engines will be the same as with diesel. That would be another big benefit.
- mbreese 9y ago> I also wonder if the maintainability of these engines will be the same as with diesel They also include traditional spark plugs and the engine automatically switches between modes. So, I fear that maintenance wise, it may be the worst of both worlds -- but with less wear and tear on the spark side, perhaps it will be better.
- mohaine 9y agoI'm pretty sure "wear on the spark side" is an all but solved problem at this point. Most car engines made in the last 15 years have 100k mile lifetime on the entire spark system.
- paulirwin 9y agoI know for more recent vehicles that is probably true, but as an owner of a 2006 F-150 with the 5.4L 3V Triton V8 that had the infamous spark plug issue, I had to lol with a tinge of sadness at your "last 15 years" comment. Backstory: Ford came out the gate with a new spark plug design for the 2004 F-150 3V Triton 5.4L V8 engine (after their previous spark plug design failure in the 2V Triton where the plugs would shoot out) and told everyone that the spark plugs would last 100k miles. Turns out if you let them go that long, they would get stuck in the cylinder head and break off when you tried to remove them, leaving stuck broken pieces of spark plug behind. Conveniently, 100k miles happens to be when most people's warranty expires, leaving people with a best case a few-hundred-dollars-extra tune-up bill, if not thousands of dollars if the heads had to be removed. Ford faced a class-action lawsuit over this debacle, and there are still companies selling special broken spark plug removal kits designed solely for this engine to this day. Of course the root cause of the problem is faulty design, but it would have been mostly avoided had they not claimed a 100k mile service interval for the plugs. So yes, Ford went from an engine where the spark plugs would shoot out of the cylinder head, to one where they would get stuck so hard they would break. I know all of this not because I am an engine geek, but because it happened to me. Two spark plugs broke off while being removed and I came this close to needing to have the heads removed and machined. Fortunately those special removal kits I mentioned earlier really do work. Given how relatively cheap spark plugs are, you can bet it will be a while before I trust that 100k mile number :-)
- cmrdporcupine 9y agoMazda is only working with Toyota on electric because they have to for compliance reasons in CAFE states. The CEO has quite recently panned EVs and said they will die when subsidies go away[1]. I'm sure they will produce a compliance-only vehicle available only in California and probably only for lease, like Honda has done with the clarity. [1] http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1111876_mazda-exec-engines-can-get-cleaner-evs-will-die-without-subsidies http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1111876_mazda-exec-engin...
- cromulent 9y agoIt's good work, but I suspect Mahle's TJI (as used in current F1 cars) is a better bet. - Fuel efficiency gains over 17% - over 40% thermal efficiency - over 99% reduction in NOx - significant reduction in CO2 http://www.f1technical.net/news/20316 http://www.f1technical.net/news/20316 http://www.mahle-powertrain.com/en/experience/mahle-jet-ignition/ http://www.mahle-powertrain.com/en/experience/mahle-jet-igni...
- fnj 9y ago- over 40% thermal efficiency - significant reduction in CO2 CO2 production is directly inverse-linearly related to thermal eficiency. It is silly to list both.
- ComputerGuru 9y agoThis is far from a universally-realized/appreciated fact; it's good to list both for those that weren't aware.
- cromulent 9y agoWould you mind explaining why (to a layman)? The Wikipedia page on thermal efficiency makes no mention of the CO2 relationship.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoThermal efficiency basically refers to just the efficiency of an ICE (or any heat engine for that matter) – i.e. how much of the chemical energy of the fuel you manage to convert into mechanical energy in the drive train. The better the efficiency, the less fuel you need to produce the same power output, obviously producing less CO2 in the process. (To be more specific, the terms are often used interchangeably. Thermal efficiency has an exact definition in an ideal heat engine and even ways of calculating the theoretical maximum for given conditions – but CO2 or chemical reactions have nothing to do with an ideal heat engine to start with. I'd personally perhaps prefer to talk about just the efficiency in an actual ICE – even if just to be clear none of the losses are conveniently left outside the calculation.)
- 33W 9y agoThey also have an interesting somewhat-hybrid called i-eloop that uses regenerative braking and a capacitor to power auxiliary systems: http://www.mazda.com/en/innovation/technology/env/i-eloop/ http://www.mazda.com/en/innovation/technology/env/i-eloop/
- SeanLuke 9y agoI considered i-eloop when it came out for its first generation, in the 2014 Mazda 3. It was estimated to bump my city MPG by 1. And was only available in a very expensive package. I passed.
- 33W 9y agoI have a '16 Mazda 3 without. I agree that it is non-economical, but interesting. I'd like to have it with a larger lithium-ion that can remote start only my AC for a few minutes while I walk to the car in the summer.
- richdougherty 9y agoIn the linked page they say they're pursuing both internal combustion and electric vehicles and they explain their rationale: - In line with this policy, continue efforts to perfect the internal combustion engine, which will help power the majority of cars worldwide for many years to come and can therefore make the greatest contribution to reducing carbon dioxide emissions, and combine the results with effective electrification technologies - From 2019, start introducing electric vehicles and other electric drive technologies in regions that use a high ratio of clean energy for power generation or restrict certain vehicles to reduce air pollution
- jonsen 9y agoSomeday someone might invent an efficient process for making gasoline from renewable energi sources.
- Neliquat 9y agoLike ethanol? Biogas? Methane from farming and landfills? We are already doing all of those.
- trhway 9y agoit is called battery charging :). Basically it is making the fuel - Li - out of the ash - lithium oxide. The amount of Li and available for "burning" oxygen in the current batteries is very small and where is no principal reasons it can't be increased 10-fold to something like 10% by weight (especially in the metal-air schemes) at which moment it will leave gasoline engines well behind in all respects.
- coredog64 9y agoLANL published a paper circa 2007 or 2008 on how to make carbon-neutral hdyrocarbon fuel using carbon in the air and the electricity and waste heat from a nuclear plant. According to the paper, it was competitive with oil-based gasoline at around $5/gallon.
- philipkglass 9y agoYou're referring to the Green Freedom concept: http://bioage.typepad.com/greencarcongress/docs/greenfreedom.pdf http://bioage.typepad.com/greencarcongress/docs/greenfreedom... Its authors badly underestimated how much new American nuclear reactors would cost. We performed economic analyses on a partially optimized baseline concept based on a single Gen III PWR to provide power for the process. The analyses estimated a capital cost of $5.0 billion for an 18,400 bbl/day synthetic-gasoline plant and $4.6 billion for a 5,000 tonne/day methanol plant. Nuclear power accounts for more than 50% of the total plant capital investment. If just over 50% of that cost is supposed to be nuclear plant, it would be $2.5 billion for a Gen III pressurized water reactor. ($2.9 billion now, accounting for a decade of inflation.) The just-abandoned VC Summer project was supposed to build two new Gen III PWRs in South Carolina. They pulled the plug because estimated cost of completion had spiraled up to $25 billion ($12.5 billion per reactor). https://neutronbytes.com/2017/07/31/utilities-pull-the-plug-on-ap1000s-at-v-c-summer/ https://neutronbytes.com/2017/07/31/utilities-pull-the-plug-...
- fnj 9y ago> So this is ... diesel without the NOx NOx is not peculiar to diesel engines. Gasoline engines also generate NOx. All internal engines make NOx. As long as you burn fuel + atmospheric air you get NOx. The atmosphere is 78% nitrogen. Some of it gets oxidized.
- teraflop 9y agoThis makes me wonder whether it would be theoretically possible to use some of the engine's power output to extract nitrogen from the incoming air. You'd effectively be trading more CO2 pollution (because of the reduced efficiency) for less NOx pollution. My back-of-the-envelope calculations suggest that off-the-shelf oxygen concentrators aren't efficient enough to make this practical, but I don't know whether there are fundamental thermodynamic limits that would prevent the efficiency from being improved.
- maxerickson 9y agoA typical NOx reduction is to feed some exhaust gas into the air intake to reduce the amount of oxygen in the chamber. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaust_gas_recirculation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exhaust_gas_recirculation
- Govindae 9y agoYes, but stratified charge combustion produces significantly more NOx in cylinder because of the excess oxygen.
- spitfire 9y agoI believe it's a "luxury/enthusiast" strategy. I believe the auto market will play out something like the watch market did with the introduction of the quartz watch. Most people just want to tell the time, so they buy a quartZ. Similarly most people just want to get from A to B, so will buy an electric (automated) car. Some people enjoy the mechanics of the thing. So they buy a nice mechanical watch. These watches went from being simple utility pieces to works of art. Similarly I expect that car companies will continue to sell a set of "enthusiasts" models for a long time. They might revert back to manual gearboxes, and become more and more outrageous works of art - turned polished engine bays (Think Perlée, etc). When all your actual needs can be met by a self driving electric car, why do you own a physical mechanical car? For the enjoyment of it.
- DennisP 9y agoProbably true, but at the same time, some electric cars are pretty darn fun to drive.
- rootusrootus 9y agoOf currently available models, isn't that essentially ... one of them? And only in a straight line. Electrics have a ways to go before they're suitable candidates for things like track days.
- outworlder 9y agoEven a Leaf is fun due to the constant acceleration.
- Viper007Bond 9y agoModern automatics though provide similar constant acceleration. Even better are dual clutch transmissions. About 8ms between gear shifts.
- petre 9y ago
- devy 9y ago> To me, it sounds like a "Don't pass"[1] bet on electric cars. Which they also are working with Toyota on electric cars so perhaps it is a fall back plan The Toyota/Mazda collaboration is a pure compliance play, just like what Honda has done in California for years (read: Honda Fit EV.) The official announcement had a subtle hint: From 2019, start introducing electric vehicles and other electric drive technologies in regions that use a high ratio of clean energy for power generation or restrict certain vehicles to reduce air pollution as The Verge clarified it in more details here[1], Mazda have to sell EV in regions where regulations are so tough that they can improve the efficiency to pass or in regions where ICE cars are/will be banned altogether. Also the new Toyota/Mazda auto plant is not going to manufacture only EVs but also other ICE (Internal Combustion Engine) cars. And yes, without their own EV or the resolve to electrify their model lineups, Mazda might not even survive after 2025 when they plan to use SKYACTIV-X on all of their cars. For EV, the old saying is true: driving is believing. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/8/16099536/mazda-compression-ignition-engine-technology https://www.theverge.com/2017/8/8/16099536/mazda-compression...
- varjag 9y agoTook my car for service to a mixed Nissan/Mazda dealership here in Norway. All salespeople were busy working on Nissan side selling Leafs and electric vans..
- oh_sigh 9y agoI don't necessarily see this as a don't pass. There are some questions to the jerkiness of the power supplied, so perhaps this kind of engine would couple nicely in a hybrid design - it can charge the batteries 30% more efficiently than the closest hybrid, and the user isn't getting power to the drivetrain directly from the engine, eliminating any jerkiness.