18 ms·
According to https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzahlung_in_Deutschland.png https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzah...
by mtmail 9y ago
According to https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzahlung_in_Deutschland.png https://www.cashforless.de/ec_cash_info/Fakten_zur_Kartenzah... methods for payments in stores 2011 was 57% cash, 5.3% credit card, 33% debit card (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_cash).
> "of course, [the Germans] attitudes toward currency must owe something to Germany’s tumultuous monetary history. During the Weimar-era hyperinflation that peaked in 1923 [...]"
> "the German tendency to settle up in cash undeniably reflects the fact that for much of the last century, Germany has been either on the brink of, in the midst of, or struggling to recover from, disaster."
As a German I call that theory into question. Our currency has been stable for 60+ years. It would've been nice if other countries with recent disasters (war, hyperinflation, sanctions) and their attitude toward currency was compared against.
- egeozcan 9y agoDebit card is pretty equivalent to cash, though. When my friends and family from my hometown (Istanbul) visit me the first time, they are usually quite shocked that most shops here do not accept credit cards at all. In Turkey (a place I call micro-USA), many credit cards automatically divide the payments for some transactions to 3+ months, whereas here in Germany, there's always some bureaucracy involved, even if you explicitly ask for it. 11 years ago, when I was living in Istanbul, I had bought bread from a supermarket and I paid with my credit-card, vendor of which had a deal with that supermarket-chain and automatically divided the payment of the bread to 10 months. If I remember correctly, they later banned the postponing of the payment of basic goods because it was getting ridiculous.
- BartSaM 9y agoNot really. Debit cards are debit cards, not cash. You are comparing CC to DC as far as I can tell, but they are completely different products. There is a huge difference between having currency in your hand or use a medium to access money held by the private organization that can go bankrupt (and this happens much more often than, for example, governments with their currencies).
- gehwartzen 9y agoWhen paying with cash you are also only exposed to the risk of loosing what you have on hand. A debit card is a bit more akin to handing over the key to the vault with a contractual agreement as to how much can be taken.
- yxhuvud 9y agoIf you think that is a problem with debit cards you should go get a better bank.
- swimfar 9y agoAre there banks that provide credit card-like protections for debit cards? I thought you couldn't reverse debit card transactions. There are usually daily limits, though, which would limit how much you could lose.
- gehwartzen 9y agoI haven't had this problem with my bank just pointing out the inherent differences. With a debit card you are relying on the cyber security and data retention policy of the store, the bank, and the electronic network provider. Now I realize that if your account is used without authorization most banks refund the money. This can take a certain amount of time and could lock up your remaining funds in the meantime.
- yxhuvud 9y agoLess than a month ago my card details (the magnetic stripe) got swiped. However my bank noticed the funky payments, automatically detected the issues, temporarily froze the card. Then when I noticed it didn't work and called them they temporarily locked up the card for a single use, and then blocked it permanently and sent out a new card. I noticed it on Thursday, I had the new card and all unwanted transactions rolled back on Monday. This for a debit/Visa hybrid card, which acts as Visa out of country and on the Internet. Also, the bank requires me to temporarily unlock the card for 'unsafe' Internet purchases before usage, which basically is all purchases that don't involve 2FA.
- DougWebb 9y agoI've never heard of anything like the dividing of payments you're describing. Are you saying that the CC company doesn't pay the merchant all at once, by default? That seems really shady. They should either have enough capital to pay the merchant in-full right away, or they should pay the merchant the interest they're collecting from the buyer if they buyer isn't paying the CC bill in full each month.
- egeozcan 9y agoThe bank pays the full amount immediately, unless they have a special agreement with the seller. You get different treatment according to your CC provider. Here is an example: http://www.gold.com.tr/BankaKampanya.aspx http://www.gold.com.tr/BankaKampanya.aspx (Turkish). "Peşin fiyatına 3 Ay taksit" means "3 months payments without interest". They usually inflate the price beforehand to account for such payments, so you are disincentivized to use a debit card or to pay in cash. Such tactics are fought against by the national banking organization but they always find another way (like having ridiculously low, "symbolic" interests for specific sellers/goods). The whole situation used to be grim when I left Turkey many years ago, but I don't imagine it being better now.
- DougWebb 9y agoAh, I see. In the US a common marketing offer for credit cards is that they let you make one charge that will be interest-free for 6 or 12 months. You can pay it off whenever and however you like, but if you don't pay the whole thing before the deadline you'll owe all of the interest for the whole period. They make money off of this two ways: 1) People forget to pay it off before the final date. They're not always clear about when that date is; you know exactly how long it's been since the charge, but you don't know for sure when your payment will be applied. It's best to pay the total off at least a month before the final date, to be sure it's paid during the billing cycle before it is due. 2) If you use the card for anything else, there's fine-print that says that any payments will go towards non-promotional charges first. It can get very difficult to determine if you've paid the promotional charge off or not, and they typically do not assist you in figuring that out. They also benefit from extending you more credit than you need for the one charge you want to make, especially since you're unlikely to use it in order to avoid trap #2. And they benefit from having an additional customer on the books. I'm sure these benefits make them money somehow too.
- herbst 9y agoThis sounds like the most fantastic way to get a literal wage slave.
- egeozcan 9y agoExactly, I mean, maybe it's not clear from my comment but it was very hard to calculate how much disposable income I'd be left with after the monthly payments. In the statement, you see how many payments left for each transaction but when you buy practically everything like that, one would need dedicated software to figure out his/her financial situation.
- stevesimmons 9y agoThe Turkish payment system really is an eye-opener for its sophistication. I used to work in credit cards and did a study tour to Istanbul in 2004 to see it first hand and talk to both merchants and the issuing banks. One big difference in Turkey is many shops had 5 or more card terminals, each in the colour of the issuing bank. Banks competed for both merchants and consumers by offering value-added features unique to their terminal, such as instalment credit instantly accessible to only their customers. Instalment credit was popular in Turkey following the economic crisis in 2001 (3000% interest rates) because many people simply didn't have the cash to pay up front for major purchases such as whitegoods or even shoes. In most other countries, shops have only one payment terminal, supplied by the acquiring bank (acquiring = acquires payment transactions, as distinct from issuing = issuing payment cards to consumers). That terminal has to support all cards equally, using the base Visa/MasterCard standards. Hence there are no value-added payment options.
- egeozcan 9y agoThey are still popular, and they are doing everything they can to reduce your ability to compare their offerings: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=tr&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.hepsiburada.com%2Fbanka-kampanyalari&edit-text=&act=url https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=tr&tl=en&js=y&prev...
- ant6n 9y ago> As a German I call that theory into question. Our currency has been stable for 60+ years. Also as a German, OUR currency has been stable for 26 years. I'd still question the theory.
- danielbln 9y agoYeah, what a silly theory. Not once have I thought "oh, gee, I better not pay with CC because remember what happened back in the 20s/30s". And yes, you could argue for some sort of cultural trait that stems from that time, but I don't know anyone who pays with cash because they inherently distrust the financial organisations.
- jdboyd 9y agoWouldn't it be only 15 years? (Since switching to a new currency)
- ant6n 9y agoRe-unification was in 1991. The Euro transition was stable.
- jdboyd 9y agoWouldn't it be only 15 years? (Since switching to a new currency)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoAs a German a.) I mostly pay cash because it's faster b.) some shops that can afford it only have cash payments to save on CC costs Not because of inflation or because something happend 100y ago.
- sparkling 9y agoAs a German a) I don't want to feed the Visa/Mastercard/Amex/Whatever leach earning a few cents of every transaction.
- wila 9y agoNot German, but I simply don't want to leave my trail of what I am spending and where.
- eatbitseveryday 9y agoAnd what of purchases made on websites?
- theEXTORTCIST 9y agoWas waiting for this comment. I often ask myself, "Do I want any entity to have a copy of the exact dates and amounts of my entire daily consumer activity?". Whether anonymized or not there is a tremendous amount of knowledge that can be gleaned from non-itemized debit card ledgers.
- 9y ago
- sparkling 9y ago> Euro > stable
- laumars 9y agoYour economy is much more stable than mine in the UK yet anecdotally I've observed we use cards to pay for everything. Even silly little things that only cost a couple of £. In fact it is rare that I ever carry cash. The same is true for a fair number of my friends and family as well.
- macspoofing 9y ago>Even silly little things that only cost a couple of £. I use a credit card to pay for a $1.25 coffee. I never have cash, partly because I forget to take some out.
- arjie 9y agoContactless is faster than making change, so it's just far too convenient to use a contactless card.
- dspillett 9y agoSame here, though I think a lot more recently than a few years ago because of the growing ubiquity of contactless options which are very convenient for those small payments. Is that payment option as common in those countries at this point?
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoI'm pretty sure I used my UK (debit) card, the other day, to pay for something absurdly cheap - maybe 49p? I was about as surprised that they accepted it as I am when a shop requires me to pay a huge minimum - e.g. £10 - and it's not quite as straightforward as "big shops do this, small shops, that".
- laumars 9y agoThe "I only have my debit card on me. What's your minimum spend" conversation used to be annoying. Thankfully that's been less of an issue since contactless as shops now often expect you to pay for small items on card.
- discombobulate 9y agoDid you learn about the inflation @ school? In the UK we weren't taught about the Weimar Republic's hyperinflation (in education up to 16 y/o). My friend who did history @ a more advanced level was, however.
- killercup 9y agoYes, I learned about the Weimarer Republik and it's economic issues in school in Germany. (I guess it was in 8th or 9th grade and that history class was mandatory.)
- discombobulate 9y agoLooks like the Bitcoin laws are v favourable in DE. You can pay taxes in BTC(!) & BTC is a unit of account[0]. That makes sense if the memory of WR hyperinflation is written to the citizens' mind. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_bitcoin_by_country_or_territory#Central_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_bitcoin_by_country...
- germanier 9y agoYou can't pay your taxes with Bitcoin (the Wikipedia author probably means something else?). You can't even pay most tax in cash even if you wanted to. Bank transfer in EUR is the only way.
- icebraining 9y agoThe Wikipedia author cited a quite unclear CNBC story that said that bitcoin "can be used for tax and trading purposes". From what I can tell from other sources, what it really means is that one must pay VAT when purchasing stuff with it.
- icebraining 9y agoReally? It's standard in Portugal, as part of the context of WWII. My textbook even had a picture of people with a pile of bills.
- conanbatt 9y agoArgentina has rampant cash usage at all stages of inflation, mostly for tax evasion purposes (VAT is 21%)
- zeta_ 9y agoWe had hyperinflation in Brazil (end of 80s and begin of 90s) and you can use credit/debit card almost everywhere (I even saw a video of a Brazilian that lived in Japan for 10 years commenting how weird this is for him)
- felipelemos 9y agoBrazilian here. We had a three-to-four-digit annual inflation rates that last 14 years, from 1980 to 1994 (and it topped 5000% on the last year). Almost everyone uses debit or credit card nowadays. Even transport cards machines, taxis, small vendors, food trucks accepts credit cards. Usually I only carry cash for some emergency to the point I don't even remember how much I left on my wallet.
- lanevorockz 9y agoTo be fair, in Brazil we usually prefer cards because of the risk of being robbed.
- mrisoli 9y agoTrue, Uber's decision of allowing cash payments in Brazil(because a lot of people can't get a credit card approved) was met with a very negative drivers' response due to increased robbery risks.
- mrisoli 9y agoFellow Brazilian here and I don't carry a lot of cash with me because that was how I was raised, mostly my parents taught me to be scared of being robbed with a lot of money. Even though I am not living in Brazil ATM I still act like this. Plus fraud is becoming rarer with chip credit cards(and apps which allow you to lock your card much faster in the case of theft), while counterfeit bills are also harder to reproduce these days you can still find some.
- triztian 9y agoI can add that in Mexico the culture is to also not carry that much cash - due to risk of robbery and losing the wallet or it getting washed in laundromats.
- richardknop 9y agoAlso remember that whole Eastern Europe (including East Germany) had no electronic payments before fall of Soviet Union. So credit cards took off in US in 80s but half of Europe just got out from under communism in early 90s and they were not very trustworthy of western banks so would prefer cash. Also the banking and payment infrastructure was non existent so needed to be built from scratch. This probably slowed down uptake of credit/debit cards considerably. Cash is still king in Eastern Europe today.
- germanier 9y agoNot sure how far east you want to go but in both Poland and the Czech Republic card payments are far more prevalent than in western Germany.
- richardknop 9y agoWith young people yes. But older generation still uses cash heavily.
- exelius 9y agoMy theory with Germany specifically is that the Germans I have known have all been extremely protective of their privacy. I'd be interested in seeing stats on social media adoption in Germany, because my hypothesis is that they lag the rest of the world. If privacy is such a concern (and particularly privacy from one's own government), then the use of cash makes sense. My guess is that this distrust of government did grow from the abuses of domestic surveillance by the Nazi regime and East Germany. I'd be curious to see how this breaks down between the old east/west lines as well. And I'm sure individuals don't use cash for these reasons; but because the system in Germany functions that way out of historical legacy. As a consumer, it's simply easier to buy things with cash.
- george_kaplan 9y ago>I'd be interested in seeing stats on social media adoption in Germany, because my hypothesis is that they lag the rest of the world. Not only do they lag in general, but I also remember a study which showed that in Germany higher education levels are associated with significantly less social media use, while it's quite the opposite in the rest of the world.
- true_religion 9y agoThat's true. The fastest growing social network within German universities was an anonymous one. This is opposed to the USA, where Facebook was the fastest growing network based on the ideal of knowing exactly what classes Y person on your campus went to.
- jshevek 9y agoDoes that social network still exist, and can you share its name please?
- ahartmetz 9y agoJodel https://jodel-app.com/ https://jodel-app.com/ I had it installed for a few days once. I decided to uninstall it because it took too much attention (there are MANY users in Berlin) and I kind of felt too old. The typical user is a student in the first few semesters.
- lkrubner 9y agoOur currency has been stable for 60+ years. Older osti don't see it that way. When I say "older" I mean "everyone over the age of 40" so not really that old. They've seen their currency change.