16 ms·
Quoting Sundar Pichai (Google CEO), emphasis mine: > At the same time, there are co-workers who are questioning whether they can safely express their views in
by koolba 9y ago
Quoting Sundar Pichai (Google CEO), emphasis mine:
> At the same time, there are co-workers who are questioning whether they can safely express their views in the workplace (especially those with a minority viewpoint). They too feel under threat, and that is also not OK. People must feel free to express dissent. So to be clear again, many points raised in the memo—such as the portions criticizing Google’s trainings, questioning the role of ideology in the workplace, and debating whether programs for women and underserved groups are sufficiently open to all—are important topics. The author had a right to express their views on those topics—we encourage an environment in which people can do this and it remains our policy to not take action against anyone for prompting these discussions.
Good luck with that. You can't take a guy out back and shoot him for speaking his mind, and subsequently expect others do so.
I'm certain Google management knows this as well. They know exactly what they're doing and they're fine with it.
- se2 9y agoI believe you have misconstrued the message Sundar was giving. The difference between having the freedom to speak one's mind, and breaching a code of conduct that you sign when you agree to work for Google is clear cut in his note.
- lagadu 9y agoBy firing the employee they're effectively sending out a strong message about it no matter how they sugarcoat it.
- cdubzzz 9y agoA strong message about breaking the code of conduct, yes. The message here seems abundantly clear and I have trouble understanding how it can miscontrued to be anything other than reacting to a clear violation. I can't even think of how to restate what is so clearly laid out in the note. I wouldn't rule out the potential that there is uneven enforcement of such violations, and that would make this action look questionable. But I don't know enough about Google's internal operations to get to that conclusion.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- visarga 9y agoWhen calling it a "code of conduct" does it refer to concrete actions, or just expressing opinions? Other than speech, what was the violation here? Restricting free speech by threat of firing is the solution everyone is applauding? Apparently Google is declaring an attitude in opposition to what they did: "many points raised in the memo ... are important topics. The author had a right to express their views on those topics...". But got fired as a result.
- cdubzzz 9y agoSpeech is action and just as capable of breaking any rule or code as physical action. Free speech is also not really relevant here as it has to do with the government's inability to restrict speech. I think it is certainly a very fine line to walk and people (including Google employees) will definitely see it in a lot of different ways. But, reading this as an outsider, the note appears to me to address the situation very directly and conveys a real sense of urgency (more so than I have ever seen from any of my employers, at least).
- stefantalpalaru 9y ago> Free speech is also not really relevant here as it has to do with the government's inability to restrict speech. From the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: "Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers."
- tchaffee 9y agoExpressing opinions that make employees feel less adequate due to their gender is a violation of the CoC. I applaud restricting that kind of speech, as do most companies. At some companies the motivation might be strictly legal, but regardless of the motivation you're going to get fired if you open the company up to future gender discrimination lawsuits. "many points raised in the memo ... are important topics." So what? Other points were a violation of the CoC. Goodbye, good luck, see you around the campus!
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoThe bigger message is the actions, not the words. It is very clear.
- h4l0 9y agoMisconduct would be expressing these views under his blog while putting emphasis on Google and blaming his company for what he finds unreasonable. He used internal messaging services. Someone leaked the document. That "someone" is sitting in his/her office today getting no punishment whatsoever.
- humanrebar 9y agoI haven't read the code of conduct, and I'm disappointed the person was fired, but I presume there's a clause about saying bigoted things. And people consider parts of what he said bigoted.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> And people consider parts of what he said bigoted. Is it enough for some people to consider it that? Consider gay marriage. Each side thinks the other is being bigoted towards some group. Do we just take people's words for it?
- humanrebar 9y agoI agree. I'm just stating a possible justification for dismissal.
- josteink 9y agoLooking at the response in this friend it is worringly normal to let you ever get most easily offended define what is reasonable. This only leads to people getting increasingly sensitive over increasingly minor things and it's a vicious circle. So how do we break it? How do we re-establish open discourse?
- talmand 9y agoI consider what you just said as bigoted. You should apologize and fall on your sword for my feelings.
- shaggerty 9y agoIts intetesting how in the last couple years bigot has been redefined from "someone who is not tolerant of the opinions of others" to "anyone who disagrees with leftist moral thought"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- eeks 9y agoYou cannot pose as a parangon of free speech when your company just fired a dissenting voice. For all intents and purposes the content of the memo was balanced, polite, and restricted to the Google audience. The adult reaction should have been to punish the leaker (which I believe should be an actual breach of the code of conduct) and organize internal debates to allow multiple viewpoints to confront. Rallying with the hysterical mass and shutting down the minority voice is certainly not about supporting debates and free speech. It's about throwing red meat to the wolves so the company can quietly solve its all too real gender pay gap issues without making too much PR waves.
- jsf666 9y ago> real gender pay gap issues There is no such thing, there's been a plethora of research about this that disprove this false claim
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI agree. Having read the original memo, if anything in there actually violates Google's Code of Conduct, then they need to have a serious discussion about the CoC itself (and how they interpret it).
- xenadu02 9y agoUhh Pichai repeats exactly what the memo claimed: that women are >being “agreeable” rather than “assertive,” showing a “lower stress tolerance,” or being “neurotic.” Go ahead and claim women are more neurotic and have a lower stress tolerance. Don’t expect everyone to pat you on the back and claim you’re just expressing a minority viewpoint... because you clearly aren’t. James Damore didn’t bother to do any research on the topic - I guess he just assumed his feelings were correct? And he assumed he wouldn’t suffer any consequences for claiming 1/3 of his coworkers were meek easily spooked neurotics?
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> James Damore didn’t bother to do any research on the topic - I guess he just assumed his feelings were correct? Go and actually read the original memo at https://medium.com/@Cernovich/full-james-damore-memo-uncensored-memo-with-charts-and-cites-339f3d2d05f https://medium.com/@Cernovich/full-james-damore-memo-uncenso.... Which, for this particular point, links to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_psychology#Personality_traits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_differences_in_psychology#..., https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathizing%E2%80%93systemizing_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathizing%E2%80%93systemizin... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism (see in particular https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism#Sex_differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroticism#Sex_differences). From which you can access about a metric fuck ton of actual research. We can't expect to have any reasonable discussion on the topic if the standard of criticism is not reading the piece one is criticizing, and then stating obvious falsehoods (like "didn’t bother to do any research") as facts - probably hoping other readers also won't bother checking. EDIT: Also: > Go ahead and claim women are more neurotic and have a lower stress tolerance. Don’t expect everyone to pat you on the back and claim you’re just expressing a minority viewpoint... Those are actual falsifiable statements. They can be either true or false. The whole idea of considering them as "viewpoints" is ridiculous and it's precisely what's the problem with the whole environment surrounding the discussion.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoI totally agree with you and Google. It's like "you can choose your car color, as long as it is black." https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Henry-Ford-say-%E2%80%9CA-customer-can-have-a-car-painted-any-color-he-wants-as-long-as-it%E2%80%99s-black%E2%80%9D https://www.quora.com/Why-did-Henry-Ford-say-%E2%80%9CA-cust... Oh wait, maybe I don't agree with you...
- JustAnotherPat 9y ago>"each Googler to do their utmost to create a workplace culture that is free of harassment, intimidation, bias and unlawful discrimination.” Which part did he break exactly? Bias? Seems like something that can be construed to mean basically any ideology or opinion, conservative or liberal.
- unethical_ban 9y agoI think he went too far when he suggested women are inherently less capable in the computer sciences than men. Saying diversity training sucks, or that Google should re-evaluate how they encourage diversity, or that men are getting a raw deal, would have been tolerable.
- IshKebab 9y agoWould he have gone too far to suggest that women are inherently physically weaker than men? Or that they are inherently longer-lived than men? What about that they are inherently less interested in football?
- pgodzin 9y agoProbably, because longer-lived and interest in football are not inherent biologically. A male baby is not born interested in football, it is socialized. Men work more dangerous jobs and are socialized into more unhealthy behaviors, diets, etc that can result in lower lifespan than women.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoTestosterone has a direct, measurable effect on competitiveness and aggressiveness. Why wouldn't you think this would affect the overall sports preference between the sexes? In an environment where men have significantly higher testosterone than women, wouldn't there naturally be more men than women in an aggressive sport like football? Would you expect a 50% gender parity in such an environment? Culture plays an effect, but we really need to realize that biology probably pays a role too, and potentially affects gender parities in many careers.
- swat535 9y agoGoogle can indeed impose a code of conduct on its employees when they sign up. However, that does not give licence to Google to place unreasonable limits on employees constitutional rights. To do so would give privately entered contracts the power to overturn the constitution which society has enacted. The debate here is over whether his comments were reasonable in this context.
- tchaffee 9y agoWhich constitutional rights? The right that guarantees the government will not interfere with your free speech? Or some other right?
- CodeWriter23 9y agoIt's worse than that. Ex-Googler Zunger is being celebrated for refuting Damore's argument by advancing gender stereotypes suggesting women naturally possess skills essential to the engineering process. > All of these traits which the manifesto described as “female” are the core traits which make someone successful at engineering https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/so-about-this-googlers-manifesto-1e3773ed1788 https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/so-about-this-googlers-man... How is it ok to push a gender stereotype that is pro-female but not ok if the stereotype is pro-male?
- JshWright 9y agoNote that he says they are "described as", not that they are actually gender specific. The quotes also make it clear that he is referencing Damore's argument and pointing out an interest issue with it. He is not claiming that position as his own.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoNo. He's all but saying it. Mincing words may give a free pass in your book. Not in mine.
- JshWright 9y agoHow is that "mincing words"? He spends several paragraphs arguing those differences are not supported by science (right or wrong), then proceeds to allow them as a base assumption to point out the argument still falls apart, even if you allow the faulty premise.
- ck425 9y agoHe explicitly says near the start of his article that he disagrees with the views on gender differences that the memo espouces, and that he's not getting into then because others are more qualified to do so.
- tnone 9y ago
- baltimore12 9y agoWe all know that men and women are different but under no circumstances can you club a large section of population and say they are inferior in some respect ... hitler did it with the Jews, whites did it to the blacks , Japanese did it to the Chinese and history is rife with extreme examples of the Dangers of generalization of a large section of population. Our job as human civilization is to evolve positively and to survive by dispersion of empathy - not by corroding it every day and making a certain section feel weak and vulnerable. No matter what your point of view is there is no doubt the author of the article had touched a raw nerve deliberately which he could have easily avoided. Therefor Google is right to fire him and the majority is absolutely within their rights to condemn him.
- wolfgangK 9y ago> say they are inferior in some respect I do not believe that the author of the memo ever wrote anything like that. I'm not sure that you should equate all research scientists who published on gender/sex differences with nazis.
- granitosaurus 9y agoDid you really compare this to racial _genocides_? Maybe men are slightly better at something and maybe women are slightly better at other things - why is this an issue? Clearly the difference is not remotelly big enough to be impactful since we see men and women work in every profession. Average worker skill is pretty low so this "genetic advantage" would only really matter at top 0.1% of professionals. e.g. women are worse at some sports like Tennis, but to most people it will never matter since only few people play at that level where genetics can give you an edge.
- samsonradu 9y agoIndeed, but people will go as far as dismissing valid proofs and statistics just to boost their own ego and not feel inferior in any way. That's like me not acknowledging that a black athlete has a genetic advantage over me that would make a difference if we were competing at the 0.1% top level. I think Google's action is not a right or wrong approach, it's a measure of maintaining order and keeping everybody 'happy'.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ryandvm 9y agoThe moral of the story is something most adults figure out by their mid 20s: if you like your job, keep your mouth shut about your political/religious beliefs. And despite what any employer will tell you about their workplace being an open forum, they are full of shit. What they mean is, it's an open forum to agree with management.
- geodel 9y agoI agree. This kind of righteousness has no place in modern corporates. I will add even CEOs/management is not safe from getting fired. The difference could possibly be huge severance in case of such incidence.
- tedmiston 9y ago> At the same time, there are co-workers who are questioning whether they can safely express their views in the workplace (especially those with a minority viewpoint). Minority viewpoints in tech become silenced and their author(s) ostracized by the biases of a mob mentality. It doesn't even matter what you write because most people won't even read the original source, instead floating by on derivative tweets and extremely biased summaries (in whatever direction agrees with their existing views). Irrespective of the original memo, and this is something I've felt more strongly in the past couple years, it's just not safe to share dissenting viewpoints in tech anymore. We used to be the industry where anything could be discussed critically and the most objectively correct answer could win (logic! science!). Nowadays it's so political and heated, I've found it best to just stay out of the discussion and not share dissenting views anymore. I think the real problem we need to fix is being able to have rational critical discussion around topics we disagree with.
- uncletaco 9y ago> Irrespective of the original memo, and this is something I've felt more strongly in the past couple years, it's just not safe to share dissenting viewpoints in tech anymore. It is not safe to share your viewpoints anywhere where it is not considered germane: and the workplace is high on that list. A firm will fire someone who becomes annoyingly political or who makes a public ass out of themselves on social media. I work for a medium sized tech firm in the American South and we had one engineer that was very open and sometimes combative about her progressive viewpoints and people stopped wanting to talk to her, even those who agreed with her. She didn't last a quarter. Expecting firms to give their employees a forum to speak openly about anything not work related is a recent phenomenon across the board, and many still hold onto the view that if you want to engage in political discussions then do so outside of the workplace.
- cynicalkane 9y agoAlso from the memo: > However, portions of the memo violate our Code of Conduct and cross the line by advancing harmful gender stereotypes in our workplace. Our job is to build great products for users that make a difference in their lives. To suggest a group of our colleagues have traits that make them less biologically suited to that work is offensive and not OK. It is contrary to our basic values and our Code of Conduct, which expects “each Googler to do their utmost to create a workplace culture that is free of harassment, intimidation, bias and unlawful discrimination. He made his continued employment both a social and legal liability. This is a fireable offense even if he was "right". Also consider this. As part of Google's mandatory diversity training, one is presented with Google's internal research claiming that unconscious bias is real and measurable, and that diversity hiring yields both better individual and group performance. In short, Google feels these programs are scientifically valid. The author claims they aren't, but casually dismisses Google's position without really addressing it. Instead we get an evo-psych Chewbacca defense, phrased in a way that's sure to offend a large number of people. Even if he did that in good faith, it's a colossal mistake at best.
- pyroinferno 9y ago>which he wasn't. I'm sure you have sources that disprove his sources. How about you post them.
- intern4tional 9y agoHe's most likely referencing his next two lines down, "As part of Google's mandatory diversity training, one is presented with Google's internal research claiming that unconscious bias is real and measurable, and that diversity hiring yields both better individual and group performance. Google has a line which they feel is backed by research..." so he can't post that data publicly as it is Google's private research. It doesn't mean it doesn't exist though, just that we won't get access to it.
- elevenfist 9y ago> "... that diversity hiring yields both better individual and group performance." This is a well-known, well-researched fact of organizational psychology. Are you guys really this stupid? Think about it from a problem-solving perspective, in terms of the solutions individuals and groups will come up with. Sexism, racism, and discrimination in general doesn't benefit anyone but the wealthiest few, and only if they're really, really stupid.
- mc32 9y agoIn the other thread I asked one of the responders if they could even as a joke wear a Trump hat at Google MTV. and how they might feel/b treated vs wearing a Pussy or Hillary hat.[1] They compared a Trump hat at Google is the equivalent of walking in to (a presumably hardcore) biker bar in Iowa. That's a pretty damning response, even if they meant the opposite. [1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14957708 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14957708
- tchaffee 9y agoYou can express your minority views as long as those views don't violate company policy. That's reasonable. You certainly wouldn't expect to keep your job if you published a memo saying you should be able to call black employees "nigger" because _cite some pseudo science here_. That's a minority view, isn't it? The expectation that every minority view can or should be safely expressed is both naive and unreasonable.
- samsonradu 9y agoI agree with you, but _cite some pseudo science here_ might actually be a solid citation (eg. Wikipedia or any other reputable study). What then? On another note, I watched the 100m men's final this Saturday and noticed white men are worse at running than black men. Would that be racist towards whites if the stats were confirming my opinion?
- tchaffee 9y ago> _cite some pseudo science here_ might actually be a solid citation. The Google code of conduct is pretty clear. It is a primary duty of every employee to actively create an environment where others don't feel harassed or intimidated. If your science fact harasses or intimidates others, then science loses in that case and the code of conduct, and a harmonious workplace, wins. Google has a set of values, and priorities, and those might not be your priorities but you have the choice of working elsewhere if you feel those values don't line up with your own. Science and facts aren't the end all. I know plenty of folks who are super smart, know a tons of facts, and are miserable people to work with. I would never hire them, or join a company where they work.
- whipoodle 9y agoI don't think they can get away with "gotta hear both sides" on this one. They fired the guy as in my opinion they should have.
- mattnewton 9y agoPart of me suspects he could have stayed had his manifesto not gotten picked up on the front page of CNN. There was only one clear way for the Google brand to distance itself then. The message is clearly think what you want, but if your words end up next to the Google logo on national news... Edit: thinking about that, he couldn't have gone far in the company though without some serious apologies or something, because I can't see a manager assigning him to work in or lead a team with women on it, and that's 1/3rd the company. Maybe it's also a practical decision to fire him and be done with it even if it didn't leak.
- hncens0rship 9y agoThere is no scenario where he made it out with his job, SV silences dissent aggressively.
- Balgair 9y agoIt's funny to see how these 'hip-young-cool' tech companies have 'grown up' and implemented nearly the exact same internal cultures and processes as every other company. I had hoped they were going to really change things, and not just in a less racist/sexist/etc way, but in finding a new way to do HR and all that jazz. Like, they have enough fine grained data that Orwell rolling in his grave could power London, but they still slipped back into the same old paradigm as Exon and MS and Standard Oil (minus the racism/sexism/etc, for the most part). It's interesting to see it happen in ~ a decade only.
- xxSparkleSxx 9y agoSo much respect lost for google. If you're gonna be bigoted and fire people that don't have the same views as you, fine. But at least own up to what you are.
- metaphorm 9y agoI would imagine that they know exactly what they are doing and feel very conflicted about it, but they're weighing their options in the prevailing political climate and choose the least bad one. It's still very very bad though.
- borplk 9y agoSadly many young folks fall for it. It's all fake altruistic bullshit marketing/PR/corporate speak. It's just modern advertising and branding. And they try to one-up each other so you just get bombarded with this happy-language about all of these beautiful non-monetary things that they somehow seem to care so much about. These poses are just "corporate white lies". They are not meant to be tested. It's similar to companies saying things "we are like a family". And that is the adult version of "your dog has gone to the farm for a while". It's crap fed to you to distract you from the brutal reality so your resources can be extracted more smoothly for longer. Hear it, but don't believe it.