11 ms·
There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
- ThomPete 9y agoThere is no such thing as IQ either its also a conceptual model. But agree there is no such thing as EQ.
- gaius 9y agoWell, yes and no. Its a thing that makes sense for analyzing entire populations, not individuals - same as BMI. But agree there is no such thing as EQ.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoIf you accept there's no EQ then why not apply the same logic to IQ? They're both based on the same false assumption that you can describe mental capacity with a number. It's not the same with BMI, which is about setting out guidelines for a healthy weight. That is something that's more appropriate to describe numerically.
- Scaevolus 9y agoIQ and BMI are strong predictors of income and disease. As the linked post describes, EQ is ill-defined, and lacks predictive power over any particular outcome.
- taneq 9y agoIf you know Bob is a genius coder, but is guaranteed to creep out a potential client, you're making a prediction based on your assessment of Bob's EQ.
- ralfn 9y agoIf Bob doesnt like talking to customers being extra rude or creepy is a sign of intelligence. The article wasnt stating that people dont have more or less or different social skills. But that they currently arent measurable in a scientific way (and likely never will be). The phrase EQ is therefor completely and intentionally fraudulent. Like the word "scientology".
- clarabrooks 9y agoSome months ago, my mom needed money to purchase our apartment but she couldn't afford to get a loan as her credit score was low and this was so painful but luckily enough, after explaining the situation to my friend he introduced me to a very good hacker who then assisted her in boosting her credit score. A problem shared is truly half solved so don't hesitate to contact him cybershiff@gmail.com
- ThomPete 9y agoNo they are not strong indicators of income. They are indicators of skills currently in need by society at large. But go back 400 years and IQ was not the primary predictor for that and my guess is that it won't be in the future either.
- c06n 9y ago> If you accept there's no EQ then why not apply the same logic to IQ? But that has been done, over and over again. By the established standard of "how to measure mental things", IQ is a very useful concept, while EQ is not. The argument Peterson (and a few others) are making is that there is no incremental validity of EQ compared to other personality traits. That just means that EQ cannot explain more variance than these personality traits + IQ. Therefore, it is a useless concept. (I tend to agree with this argument.) Describing mental capacity with a number is pretty straightforward, actually. You can test it yourself: Read 2 random digits. Immediately repeat them. Then do that for 3, 4, and so on. There will be a number (typically between 5 and 7) when you cannot repeat the sequence without error anymore. There you have it: A measure for mental capacity. If you really think IQ is garbage, how come we can ask people some weird questions, and actually predict based on these questions how successful they will be at age 40? In social science, there are few if any instances where there is such a strong connection between a measure and an outcome.
- wdroz 9y agoCool, so you can enhance your mental capacity by doing this test again and again. In less than a year I will be a genius!
- c06n 9y agoYes you can greatly enhance it, here is a thorough review of the state of the art: http://www.highiqpro.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Morrison_Chein2011.pdf http://www.highiqpro.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Morrison...
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoPDF warning, but thanks; that looks useful.
- MichaelBurge 9y agoSort of reminds me of how it's actually impossible to accurately value real estate. If you measure square footage, people will just fill the building with superfluous Hilbert curves. If you try to measure number of bathrooms or number of bedrooms, people will just make apartment complexes filled with dollhouses. If you try to measure profit(directly or from imputed rent), people will set up fake corporations and pay themselves outrageous sums of rent. So all of these measures are worthless and it's impossible to value real estate, because they can each be gamed and so are unable to be used to make any predictions.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- factsaresacred 9y ago> They're both based on the same false assumption that you can describe mental capacity with a number. IQ doesn't purport to "describe mental capacity". It assesses mental capacity and allocates a score. This score is information that can be used to deduce ability, and to the end it serves its purpose perfectly. Decisions based on IQ is another thing entirely.
- ZenoArrow 9y agoWhat's the point of deducing something if you're not going to do anything with that information? Beyond that, labels are hard for people to get rid of, even those we assign to ourselves. In the effort to categorise everything we grossly limit the potential of the individual. As Kierkegaard put it; "Once you label me you negate me.".
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoThe argument seems to be that there is no such thing as EQ because it is not a workable conceptual model whereas there is a thing like IQ because it is a workable conceptual model - definition of workable conceptual model that it can be used to make good predictions as one generally likes to do with conceptual models.
- ThomPete 9y agoI understand that but it's not a thing it itself. It's a concept which we use to describe certain abilities in humans but there is no IQ sitting somewhere. While EQ is definitely close to be "fraudulent" it's still sitting on a gradient with EQ being the best model we have when externally accessing someones mental abilities but it's not a thing, it's a human construct.
- fenomas 9y agoThis is a bit like saying there's no such thing as the color red, it's just an arbitrary label for certain wavelengths of light. Why claim "there's no such thing as" something just because it's a human construct?
- ThomPete 9y agoBecause it matters. There is no red you cant meassure red we will never experience red axactly the same way. One of the biggest mistake humans make is thinking that experience or qualia is what it represents itself as. Its important to understand that we simulate a reality not the reality.
- fenomas 9y agoIt matters how, specifically? If one person says there's no such thing as red, and another disagrees, there's no physical, observable thing about the universe that they disagree about. They're not disputing how light functions or how vision works, etc; they only disagree about which set of words should describe the whole state of affairs. Disagreements like that strike me as profoundly unimportant.
- ukj 9y agoYour world view too is a conceptual model. But as we know - all models are wrong, but some are useful...
- loblollyboy 9y agoYeah - at the end of the day your brain is different from mine on a physiological level. Just like your muscles and bones. And your gut bacteria too, and we are probably on different drugs.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoThe entirety of scientific knowledge is a conceptual model and all models are wrong.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- edco 9y agobased jordan peterson
- the_cyber_pass 9y agoGo home /pol/ your drunk.
- edco 9y agonothing about jbp is indicative of /pol/
- placebo 9y agoWow, so many wrong things with this answer... Of course, it would not surprise me to learn that measuring IQ as a predictor for success (or at least what a measurer defines as success) is much more accurate than "measuring" EQ for the same purpose. It makes sense - IQ is demonstrably measurable while EQ is some vague concept "popularized by a journalist". However, to go from this to a broad statement that there is no such thing as EQ is just silly. You could just as well say that there's no such thing as beauty because there is no accurate test to quantify it. For a simple demonstration that EQ is an important quality for prediction of "success", just think of all the successful people you know and ask yourselves whether you think they would be as successful if they had the emotional makeup of an 8 year old. This Quora answer has too much of a "trust me, I'm an authority" vibe to it edited: ok, removed stuff that upon reflection does not contribute to the discussion - my apologies for that. The main point however stands. The repeated claims of no such thing as EQ should be qualified with "in the field of psychology" - in that case, I have no objection to the answer.
- fpig 9y agoDid you actually read the answer? Nowhere did he say that those traits don't matter, or even that they are too hard to measure (although he did say they are less predictive of success than IQ). He says the concept of EQ is worthless because it just bundles together measurements of completely different character traits in a pretty much random way and creates a less-predictive mess as a result. It's like summing someone's weight in kg and height in cm and saying that's their "physical score". This "physical score" is pointless even though we can measure both components accurately and measuring them is not useless in itself.
- kevinr 9y agoIf I was marking this as a student paper, it would go back with demerits for plagiarism, faulty logic, poorly-structured rhetoric, and, to top it all off, bad grammar. ...Dude's a professor?
- chrisco255 9y agoI doubt people place the same amount of rigor into Quora posts and HN comments as they do into academic papers.
- kagol 9y agoHe's writing like how he speaks, it's not a paper. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCUhES_3-LE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCUhES_3-LE
- Geee 9y agoI think EQ was invented to make those with low IQ to feel better.
- the_cyber_pass 9y agoI think pop media needed a phrase to describe someone who was obviously smart but had a lot of trouble interacting with others. I am sure we all have run into Bob or Alice the cave troll who for lack of a better word can't pick up on any of the needs of other people no matter how hard they try. Pop media isn't going to go for words with academic rigor. They just know IQ = Smart and Bob is obviously smart, but Bob is also an idiot when it comes to reading social situations so Bob is also an idiot. People realize that Bob can't both be smart and an idiot at the same time so society created a way of differentiating that Bob is both an idiot and genius at different things aspects of life.
- rurban 9y agoI would rather say the dishonest ones, who favor agreeability, politeness and easy to be manipulated, over the honest straightforward ones.
- droidist2 9y agoIt reminds me of how STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, Mathematics) was invented to dilute the importance of STEM
- nmca 9y agoHe quotes an interesting sounding stat - "In fact, if you could choose to be born at the 95th percentile for wealth, or the 95th percentile for IQ, you would be more successful at age 40 as a consequence of the latter choice." Does anyone know the source?
- cdavid 9y agoI was curious as well, as it smells made up and rather unlikely to be true given current wealth distribution. Where you are born (e.g. developed vs developing country) is a very strong causal factor in how much wealth you get during your life, much higher than IQ.
- Snackchez 9y agoThe quote is mentioning success, rather in the sense of accomplishments not of financial worth. For example, I could be a billionaire and just hand my fortune to my children and someone with a high IQ might never reach that level of economic status. But comparing success in the sense of accomplishments, a high IQ person might have reached certain milestones, for example getting a PhD, maintaining a successful business, moving up to a higher socioeconomic status, etc.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoWhat does 'successful' mean?
- cbcoutinho 9y agoRestricting your analysis to the US, research indicates that IQ is actually more beneficial than your parents socioeconomic status in determining future success. Here's some small articles touching on the subject http://spartanideas.msu.edu/2015/04/04/income-wealth-and-iq/ http://spartanideas.msu.edu/2015/04/04/income-wealth-and-iq/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/12/would-you-rather-be-born-smart-or-rich/281828/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/12/would-y...
- tnzn 9y ago
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoThere comes a point in these things where someone always comes in with their thoughts on what the term under discussion must mean. If there were a thing such as EQ I would suppose it is just intelligence with a focus on understanding other peoples, their feelings, goals and how to get them to work together. Often this use of intelligence is not found in people who have focused their intelligence on technical mastery of particular non-human areas, although it is not impossible. I believe people often neglect areas for intellectual achievement based on finding those areas difficult or their subjective feeling that those areas are not important or just not suited to them, thus some intelligent people may neglect math because they are "not good at math", and some intelligent people may neglect learning to understand people because they "just don't understand people", while other intelligent people may not care to read or understand poetry or programming because that stuff isn't important or is for a particular kind of person that is not the kind of person they are. Time and intelligence being limited for any one person that person will in some way have to choose what they will use them for. I myself have devoted more time and intelligence to logic than most other people do, and I have found that in periods where I devote extreme energies to logical analysis that my skills with humans are diminished by a commensurate degree. In conclusion, I agree there is no such thing as EQ in the standard formulation, but perhaps there is a usage of intelligence that would counterfeit it in practical experience.
- blablabla123 9y agoWell yeah, Psychology is an almost empirical science, EQ 2.0 is a hands-on approach. When you read it, you may acquire skills that otherwise a Psychologist might teach you. As you might guess, I read the book. I went through some difficult experiences in my life, that made it at some point really difficult to make new friends, feel happy or reasonably successful at work. That book helped me a lot. It's not answering all questions to life, rather it gives you a set of tools. You can decide by yourself whether you want to use some of them and which. Anyways, this book falls into the category business books / self-help. I assume they are competing with Psychologists except it's not so stigmatizing maybe. Maybe... if you tell someone in the face which exercise you are doing from this book, the person will probably think you are completely insane... ;) But yeah, it's great that non-Psychologists are allowed to write such books.
- jwdunne 9y agoWell, if you're a dick, there's gonna be an upper limit on how far you go with your intelligence. I don't think there's value in quantifying that with some hokey quotient. Take, for example, Shkreli. Major dick but pretty clever by the looks of it. Now found guilty of fraud. Bill Gates was a major dick. Made tonnes of money but yet reviled and found himself in the dock because of it. Steve Jobs. Really intelligent but still booted out of Apple due to sheer dickheadery. Now they all found major success, hence why EQ means fuck all. It seems they, or some, found out they had to do some serious thinking. Bill Gates is arguably the most redemptive. Imagine you had average intelligence or just above and you were a major dick? People like that get asked to leave more often than not.
- oskarth 9y agoHave you ever actually met any of these people in real life? Reading headlines about famous people doesn't mean you actually know them.
- jwdunne 9y agoThere is enough evidence out there to show they treated people they worked with less than well. Are you saying that Steve Jobs wasn't a dick to his staff and to the board? Are you saying that trying to stage a coup in the workplace isn't a dickhead move?
- ac2u 9y agoI think you're arguing past the point a little. From what I've read, what got him booted out was Apple hemorrhaging money and the board wanting to keep the Apple II gravy train going and Jobs disagreeing. My point is that questionable behavior didn't oust him initially compared to it being a fundamental disagreement over the direction of the company. I'm sure the behavior didn't help, but if they were still making money hand over fist, the board wasn't going to turn around and say "you're too much of a dick so we're ousting you".
- jwdunne 9y ago
- js8 9y agoI always had trouble with the term EQ or emotional intelligence, because it in my opinion confuses (at least) two things. One is empathy, our ability to read and perceive emotions of other people. The other is actual social intelligence, that is understanding of how other people are motivated, what to do in social situations, and so on. There are plenty good people who have lot of 1st one but little of the 2nd one, and plenty of psychopaths that have the 2nd one but only little of the 1st one. These groups of people are completely different.
- stared 9y agoUsually it combines one more thing - ability to understand and control one's own emotions. Which, at least for me, looks as a perpendicular dimension.
- ralfn 9y agoYou didnt have trouble with the term EQ because it tries to suggest it is like IQ? Eventhough one of them is science and the other is less scientific than a gossip magazine?
- richmarr 9y agoYes, incentives in scientific publishing, tenure, etc are messed up and have caused reproducability problems. That problem is systemic and will take a long time to fix. There are serious people working on areas such as this; and they don't deserve the level of scattergun disrespect that you're displaying here.
- clarabrooks 9y agoSome months ago, my mom needed money to purchase our apartment but she couldn't afford to get a loan as her credit score was low and this was so painful but luckily enough, after explaining the situation to my friend he introduced me to a very good hacker who then assisted her in boosting her credit score. A problem shared is truly half solved so don't hesitate to contact him cybershiff@gmail.com
- 9y ago
- edem 9y agoThe "THERE IS NO SUCH THING AZ EQ....." part reminds me of the famous "you can't parse html with regex" answer on StackOverflow: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1732348/regex-match-open-tags-except-xhtml-self-contained-tags https://stackoverflow.com/questions/1732348/regex-match-open...
- marcosdumay 9y agoWait, it that answer famous for completely ignoring the question and discussing about some completely unrelated problem in a caricature of the SO community, or is it the one famous by the "you can't parse HTML with regexes" line? Because if it is the one famous by that line, too bad. I always expected that to became famous as an answer about how to parse HTML, not one about how to decide the kind of a tag.
- edem 9y agoThe answer is relevant, it answers the question and it is also famous. I don't know what are you talking about.
- chillacy 9y agoIt's famous, funny, and a classic, but the original SO question was about "matching open html tags" with a regex while the answer was about "parsing [X]HTML" with a regex. So the poster made some assumptions about what the original question's author was intending to do. Ultimately the choice between which tool to pick is a tradeoff that has to be made by the author, as hinted in the (much better) second answer: https://stackoverflow.com/a/1733489 https://stackoverflow.com/a/1733489
- marcosdumay 9y agoJust to add to chillacy's answer, regular expression are a perfectly valid and reasonable tool to do what I understand the question author wanted to do. His proposal was buggy (he misses a single situation), and I would use something more than pure regexes myself, but it's perfectly reasonable to use them to detect opening HTML tags.
- skywhopper 9y agoWhile I'm certainly willing to accept that "EQ" is unscientific claptrap, coming at this from outside the apparent controversy, this answer is off-putting to me partially because I don't have the context this author assumes (a context which includes enough technical jargon and name drops to make me wonder who exactly this response is written _for_, as presumably academic psychologists are not pursuing professional discourse via Quora). All that said, his slavish devotion to "IQ is king" makes me seriously question the value of attempting to pursue understanding his point. IQ may well strongly correlate to societally normative positive outcomes, but elevating a single quantitative measure to this degree reveals a worryingly inhuman approach to the field. I would not want to discuss my health with a doctor who ranted like this about BMI being the most important measure of health we have. And I don't really want to learn about the psychological aspects of emotional health and human interaction from someone who rants this angrily over the transcendent value of reducing human mental capacity to a number, either.
- katzgrau 9y agoI read through the comments knowing someone would have already said what wanted to, and better than I would have. Fully agreed. Sometimes what could have been an intelligent answer is diminished by overconfidence and well, what I might even suggest is small mindedness.
- fenomas 9y agoOne presumes he's just coming at the question from his niche. I understood his rant to mean essentially that EQ has no validity as a psychological metric used to predict real-world measures of success, and that IQ is the king of the same. Within which terms, AFAIK he's correct on both counts. But that doesn't mean he's claiming IQ is the most important thing about a person, he's just saying it's the only psychological metric that's a really strong predictor of certain future events. (Of course, the questioner probably didn't care about any of this, so I agree that the answer is weirdly off-putting in that sense.)
- uyhso8 9y agoI'm a psychologist whose research is close to this area. (Maybe in this area?) The Quora post is kind of a trifecta of topics that tend to elicit very internet-y types of controversies for lack of a better way of putting it. I can't speak for Peterson, to provide some context, I can understand where he's coming from. There are researchers of all sorts of backgrounds who spend a fair amount of time studying empirically the contours of human behavioral and psychological individual differences, and there are certain ideas that come up in the popular discourse, and persist despite their being a scientific literature that speaks against them in one way or another. They resonate with people because they do have variously sized kernels of truth to them, but somehow the scientific literature never gets injected into public discourse. This eventually feeds back, though, in textbooks and standardized exams, and it's like you're constantly fighting a battle for precision of terms. Here's a small sampling of things that will trigger a response like that of Peterson on Quora: EQ, grit, Myers-Briggs. The new MCAT is an example of this--the behavioral sciences section is horribly outdated in certain sections. I'm not sure how it got the way it is. But it's a major test, so now you have to teach to it, which then leads to a distorted perception of psychology and behavioral sciences by who are interested in the biomedical sciences, which then leads to all sorts of strawman arguments, and so forth and so on. It's like if the biology section included a section on intelligent design or something. Anyway, the problem with something like EQ is that yes, there are non-cognitive determinants of success: empathy, social perceptual skills, perseveration, conscientiousness, socioeconomic background, and so forth and so on. So EQ captures this vague idea that IQ isn't everything. The problem is that saying "IQ isn't everything" doesn't mean that a construct like EQ, which basically means "non-cognitive traits", is empirically precise and contributes something meaningful above and beyond other constructs mentioned by Peterson. These kinds of discussions create problems, because they create this false sense that if you argue against EQ, you're arguing against the idea of non-cognitive determinants of functioning, or arguing that IQ tests can't be improved, which is a false argument. Rather, what Peterson is saying is that there are well-characterized constructs like Big Five Agreeableness, or Conscientiousness, which have demonstrated predictive validity, and that are empirically coherent and precise enough to be more-or-less workable for lots of theories. That doesn't mean you can't be more precise; it just means that they represent a certain baseline of precision. Contributing to this a certain confusion about what's meant by "thingness" in these literatures. Behavioral scientists are often studying actions, states, experiences, which are not physical in the sense of being objects (even though supervenience holds, so physical things underlie them), which is a little more abstract than what people are used to thinking about. So there's predictably some offshoot discussion about that issue. It's a bit like arguing that DL nets aren't things because they aren't instantiated directly in neuromorphic chips. You're right to be critical of the idea that IQ is everything. But I can see where Peterson is coming from in certain respects.
- jgh 9y agoJordan Peterson is a bit of a white nationalist, isn't he?
- ac2u 9y agoThat's a cheap, intellectually-bankrupt addition to the conversation if you don't add anything to back it up. It's hard to believe you wrote it in any sort of good faith.
- jgh 9y agoOh please, these guys go on parroting IQ and "race-realism" as if it weren't intellectually bankrupt itself. The guy's apparent obsession with IQ is suspicious enough, not to mention any time I hear about Jordan Peterson it's in the context of alt-right nonsense. Edit: to make this relevant to the conversation - a white nationalist has a dog in the race when it comes to the idea that "IQ is above all else". IQ has long been used as a reason for, e.g., why there is more poverty in the black community. Why is there more poverty? Simple! Their IQ is low and therefore they're not able to succeed!
- ac2u 9y agoWhere in the link is "race-realism" mentioned? "These guys", who are you talking about? It seems to me like you took one look at the guys name and decided you were going to leave a "here be dragons" style comment to sully the conversation. The only problem is that your comment came across as lazy. You might not like certain followers that you may have come across, you might even be right about them, but it's cheap and nasty to lump someone in with such a disgusting accusation (and done so casually) based on that rather than his own words. I doubt you'd like to be held to account if someone of questionable character liked a blog post of yours and then someone else plastered you with an identity because of it.
- jgh 9y agoI edited my comment above to make my point more relevant.
- Bar_Code 9y agoEQ is definitely something that can help one in life, particularly leadership. He is certainly correct that EQ is not scientifically valid. Goleman took the valid work of others and "interpreted" it to create/support EI. It probably should be called a theory, a process, a framework, whatever. After learning about EQ, and practicing it, my leadership abilities took off. I've taught it to dozens of engineers who say they are now much more influential, better team players, and better communicators. Some have said it's changed their careers. EQ is most certainly a thing, just not a trait. It's sort of like saying being a good listener (active listening, listening with intent) is not a thing because you can't measure it.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoAny pointers you could give for those of us looking to learn such things?
- mrtinkery 9y agoThe better title is "EQ is a redundant concept".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cozumel 9y agoThere's also 'no such thing' as SQ (spiritual quotient) and no such thing as VQ (varna quotient) although both have been around and in use longer than our (western) civilisation.
- kazinator 9y ago> There is nothing that will provide you with a bigger advantage in life than a high IQ. Nothing. To repeat it: NOTHING. Parents with bags of money.
- Flenser 9y ago> The idea was popularized by a journalist, Daniel Goleman, not a psychologist. Looking at Daniel Goleman's wikipedia page it's clear he was actually both a psychologist and a journalist: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Goleman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Goleman