4 ms·
[In full disclosure mode I've made money buying out of the money calls on Tesla stock, so everytime he "succeeds against all odds" I get a few pennies.] That s
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
[In full disclosure mode I've made money buying out of the money calls on Tesla stock, so everytime he "succeeds against all odds" I get a few pennies.]
That said, the fundamental message is a good one, which is "Don't look at what a mature market does, look at what it could be." My first experience with this was the iPhone introduction by Apple. Like others, I scoffed at the "Jesus phone" where Apple PR claimed to have invented phones. And I thought, really just a glittery phone that you can run some games on or listen to your music?
What I completely missed was that Steve Jobs didn't see it as a phone so much as an entirely new nexus of interaction in our lives. Where before that might have been the television set, this was changing the rules at a very fundamental level about how people would think about a phone going forward. I could not see that at the time. Looking back I can see it, but at the time I could not.
When the first Tesla Roadsters started showing up at Google[1] I started looking at what Elon was trying to achieve and I got the same feeling of "really? this is just a car with batteries and a Lotus body, sort of the rich person's version of the Bradley GT[2]" But as I looked at what he was trying to achieve I recognized that he, like Steve Jobs, was thinking about cars in a way that wasn't even in the same ballpark as I was.
Knowing that, and knowing people who don't understand things bet against them, made it pretty straight forward to arbitrage that disconnect into money.
[1] I have a photo of four parked in a row in the Google colors and tagged, "yes you are working among the crazy wealthy types."
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bradley_Automotive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bradley_Automotive
- MBCook 9y agoThat's why I voted the article up: the discussion about how Dertroit/Japan/et al are fighting the wrong war and still handicapped by the dealer system and old ways of thinking. An electric Honda is just a Honda without gas. I'm sure I'd be a great car. But you still have to go through the dealer system to buy it. And it won't get software updates without dealer involvement (so basically never outside safety recalls).
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhy did you not disclose in this comment? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14921274 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14921274
- ChuckMcM 9y agoBecause I think of Tesla as a car company and not a battery company? But its a fair point. When I read this article the author disclosed that they don't own any Tesla stock and so in that spirit when I commented I disclosed that I have made money off options on Tesla stock. That said, this comment was also fairly subjective, the comment on batteries more quantitative. I've read the press on how much capacity the Gigafactory has and really do wonder how much of its output constitutes the 'world' output.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoDo you currently own any stock or options related to Tesla?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoNo I do not.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoFair enough. I still think that disclosure is necessary when entering a conversation broadly about batteries and making it specifically about Tesla.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt's an internet forum. Whether people hold stock or not you'll usually never know so the safe thing is to disregard anything you read here when deciding whether or not to buy a certain stock but to refer to the official sources: company press releases, annual reports and other relevant information. For every person nice enough to declare their position there are 100's that won't.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoSure but that doesn't mean we shouldn't expect better or excuse it when we catch people doing it. The four big Tesla-y threads in the past 24 hours or so have had people with financial interests upvoted to the top comment. ChuckMcM's comment was the top in this thread when I commented on it, and so was his comment in the Li-ion battery thread for a while. Then simonsarris is at the top of both of these threads: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14919074 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14919074 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14914310 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14914310 At least those were declared but really Hacker News can be better than that. I'm sure the bitcoin threads are even worse with conflicts of interest, but if I saw someone doing what ChuckMcM did in those threads I'd call it out there as well.
- nostrebored 9y agoSteve Jobs' was not completely dependent on both a redistribution of money from competitors (to fund luxury cars, it's honestly ethically repulsive) to his company, local and federal subsidies. He also was 1500 times less dependent per unit on slave labor to exfiltrate cobalt in the Congo. The US already has legislation around buying minerals from the Congo, but Cobalt is a specific exemption, and one that is entirely necessary for the entire electric car industry to function. Were we to decide tomorrow that we did not want 7 year olds to be forced to mine, Tesla as a company would disappear! Tesla as a company does not exist without government intervention or exploitation.
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoThe entire United States would not have existed without government intervention and exploitation. Picking on Tesla in particular is kind of a moot point.
- nostrebored 9y agoSo we should not be critical of anti competitive market situations just cause? The fact is that Tesla is a company that is amazing at rent seeking.
- chillacy 9y agoYou could have also picked on the iPhone for their (especially in the early days) terrible labor conditions for assemblers in Foxconn too. There are plenty of rare earth minerals that go into the supply chain there as well. The US gov definitely plays favorites anyways (including with existing automakers) so if you're going to do business, you might as well try to build political favor for your industry as a cost of doing business.
- nostrebored 9y agoRare Earth minerals have significantly more regulation. They used to not, but now Cobalt is the exception. Labor conditions in the war torn Congo in which literal slaves mine Cobalt is a little different than adults working in awful conditions.