14 ms·
Uber drivers gang up to cause surge pricing, research says
- ada1981 9y agoGood for them. Someone should build an app they can run that automatically logs them in and out to maximize pricing. Though I imagine it wouldn't be hard for Uber to implement some basic security to thwart it.
- briandear 9y agoAnd if prices are high, customers will seek alternatives. So it could backfire. Also, this practice is illegal as it amounts to price fixing/collision. These are all independent businesses conspiring to raise prices. These aren’t employees of the same company – they are independent contractors which means they are separate businuess entities from each other which means they are committing a crime. Collusion is a crime and that’s exactly what these separate business entities (who happen to have Uber as a customer) are doing.
- briandear 9y agoTo the down voters.. is this not collusion? We are all welcome to our own opinions, but facts are what they are: businesses conspiring to force prices higher is the very diffenition of collusion. The size of the entity makes no difference under the law.
- rectang 9y agoI'm not a downvoter, but I see your analysis as extremely uncharitable to drivers. If bringing down the weight of the justice system on individual drivers is a logical consequence of structuring rideshare as individual businesses, that argues for reclassifying them as employees. EDIT: Full disclosure -- I drive for Lyft part-time. I have not participated in the gaming described in this article.
- mannykannot 9y agoThis is as economically rational as surge pricing itself.
- pgeorgep 9y agoSounds like a nice little loophole the drivers found to make a few extra bucks. It's always interesting to me when people find little tricks they can do the bend an algo their direction. This reminds me a lot of the LinkedIn algo hacks that's driving me nuts right now. If you post super long form, cheesy, generic paragraphs of text with no links/visuals - you get massive exposure. The result has been superficial posts filling up my feed talking about who knows what. Much like the nuisance of a pricing surge on Uber, these algo hacks can be a real pain.
- jxramos 9y agolol, looks like two can play at that game... "Separate research at Northeastern University has previously found passengers can game surge pricing with simple tricks such as waiting five minutes or crossing the road." I know I've waited out twenty minutes or so to bypass the surge or at least dampen the surge to a rate I was comfortable with. Sort of becomes an auction experience at that point.
- mikeash 9y agoObvious in hindsight. This sort of thing is inevitable any time you have dumb software on one side and humans on the other side. I'm mostly a fan of these non-taxi "taxi" services, but it seems like they are slowly and painfully rediscovering why taxis ended up so regulated in the first place.
- bbarn 9y agoYeah, I'm mostly not a fan, now that we're a few years in. Waves of people inexperienced, untrained in shuttling people around a major metro have resulted in downtown Chicago being an utter mess compared to only a few years ago. Chicago forced cab drivers to go through a training and certification course that at least forced them to understand the major routes and grid system we're on, and every time I've been in an uber they are completely tethered to their phones nav systems. So, now we've got an army of drivers who can't drive, don't know where they are going, playing with their phones all day. It makes for an unpleasant experience whether you're on a bike, driving you car, or sometimes just walking across the street.
- mring33621 9y agoFellow Chicagoan here. I agree. Used to be that cabs were the most annoying, unpredictable cars on the road. Now it's the Ubers and Lyfts.
- toast0 9y agoI used to think cabs were terrible drivers, but most of them (especially in heavily regulated markets) are very experienced drivers and simply disregard rules of the road that are inconvenient for them. In contrast, 'ride sharing' drivers seem to have no sense of direction, and are genuinely oblivious to the rules of the road. In short, when in either type of car, I fear for my life.
- tyingq 9y agoI'm somewhat surprised no app has popped up to be the driver private peer to peer network. For chat, news, stats, and automating things like this.
- freeone3000 9y agoTraditional means of communication seem to be sufficient, between driver forums and whatsapp groups.
- ph0rque 9y agoSo, they are forming an algorithmic flash union? Nice...
- nikon 9y agoI suspect this happens in London. I always take a "Gett" (fixed price black cab) if so, and it's usually the same price / cheaper and they know how to drive.
- erikb 9y agoedit Supporting comment apparently wasn't appreciated. No delete button.
- aianus 9y agoI drive part time and it definitely covers costs and then some. I gross something like $0.90/km and my costs including gas, maintenance, and depreciation are around $0.30/km. Net is something a little more than minimum wage ($11/h).
- rectang 9y agoUntil you get in an accident. The rideshare companies have offloaded lots of aggregate risk onto individual drivers. What would be a line-item cost to the umbrella company is now often a life-wrenching crisis for a driver.
- briandear 9y agoIt’s voluntary. If it becomes unprofitable, drivers leave. If they lose money, they won’t do it. They give a share to Uber because Uber is their lead generation. Many businesses give a share of their money to Google because Google brings them business. An Uber driver can market their own business and keep all the money if they want just like a business could go out and market without using AdWords. If you are unhappy with the pay Uber drivers make, you are welcome to pay whatever you want. It’s called a tip. Hand the driver cash for whatever amount you think compensates for the “exploitation” you imply (and are enabling by your own admission.) Otherwise, choose another transportation option and the market will respond. I rarely hear anti-Uber people demand that supermarkets charge more for tomatoes despite those that pick tomatoes working in extremely tough conditions for low pay. I used to drive a taxi for a summer and I know it’s a non-stop hustle and not the best job, but I was at least in an air conditioned car listening to the radio all day and not out in the fields picking fruits and vegetables. It ended up being a low profit pursuit, so I ended up moving on to something else. I have a hard time feeling sorry for people that do jobs like Uber because they, with some moderate ambition, could improve their lot – they already own a car, they could make deals with local companies that send lots of people to airports, for example. They could work on building an actual business while they pay the bills with their Uber income – just as an example. Still other drivers might start a mobile car wash service for other Uber drivers, etc. There are plenty of ways to evolve past depending on Uber as one’s sole income. But most people aren’t ambitious at all – they just want to just do what they’re told and collect a check no matter how meager. Other drivers use Uber for extra income or it’s a transitional job. Any driver thinking they will make a career out of Uber is a fool. If they don’t like the conditions, they should be working hard and to create something of their own. It doesn’t take much money, but it takes ambition.
- aianus 9y agoThe first guy to log back in (or the guy who doesn't log off at all) wins the game to the detriment of the others, limiting the extent of this practice. You can't have a successful oligopoly when there's no barrier to entry.
- alextheparrot 9y agoThe post seems to make clear that once the surge pricing becomes active more than on person can capture customers at that price level, meaning their earnings are likely higher by doing this.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoIt takes more than one ride dispatch to quell the surge. I've watched bar/club closings stay in surge for 30 minutes while cars stream in to pick up riders. I personally have given 5 surge rides in a row, albeit short rides, just by picking up at a particular hot spot, getting a local, drop them off, go offline, return to hot spot, wash, rinse, repeat.
- frandroid 9y ago> go offline So you're priming the surge pump, so to speak, since you know where the ride requests will be anyway.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoActually it's the opposite. When I drop off outside of the surge zone and go back to that zone to make a pickup inside, that helps quell the surge in that hot spot. I've never noticed surging in the neighborhoods I just left when I go back online. If I stayed online in the neighborhoods, I would likely get dispatched around the drop off point, prolonging the surge at the bar.
- frandroid 9y agoAhhh I see. So I notice your username, and I'm wondering; are you both a developer and an Uber driver? Are you practicing both jobs at a time?
- PinguTS 9y agoPeople game the system. Always. Have learned that for years when it comes to safety systems. Even uneducated people become very intelligent when it comes to gaming the system to their advantage. It is always a cat and rat game between technical adjustments and when people find a way to game the system again.
- losteverything 9y agoThis. People learned the phone company would refund any Denied All Knowledge of a long distance call. Call up, get a credit. Then phone company said you cant DAK calls 2 months in a row: so customers called in every other month. Then, they eliminated operator handled calls for small bills. Call in, get an IVR, get a credit. Phone company caught on and limited credits to $7 per month, every other month. Customers started crediting <$7... And on and in...cat and mouse. Then, few realized you only had to pay 91% of the past due balance to not get shut off.. Others finally realized that if your account gets associated with a elected federal official or a PUC complaint you account will never get treated for collections. --- Another simple one: having to press "0" 3 times to get to an agent on some IVRs..
- kennydude 9y agoPressing * or # constantly does it some IVRs too.
- asdffdsa321 9y agoJust 3? I usually mash that 0 button
- scrooched_moose 9y ago> --- Another simple one: having to press "0" 3 times to get to an agent on some IVRs.. I have better luck just making indistinct noises. After three "I'm sorry, I didn't get that"s it almost always transfers me to a real person.
- obsurveyor 9y agoSay "agent" has always gotten me a real person when the 0 or the */# buttons don't work.
- iamleppert 9y agoA simple solution to this would be to simply limit the number of times one can log in and out per day to something reasonable, or to place limits on the frequency etc.
- gregorymichael 9y agoIf you ask Uber drivers if they enjoy it, the #1 thing you'll hear is "it's flexible." They're willing to put up with all the other bullshit -- the low pay, the lack of benefits -- for the feeling of control. Chip away at that and bad things will happen.
- reaperducer 9y agoDon't need to do much research. Just read the Uber driver fora. They talk about it openly. Still, even with a huge surge, Uber is 1/2 to 1/10th the price of a cab in my city.
- yawz 9y ago> Still, even with a huge surge, Uber is 1/2 to 1/10th the price of a cab in my city. This summarizes why the model would continue to work. It's similar to low-cost airlines: most of us hate them, but most of us still use them.
- volkk 9y agoMain difference being uber is literally the same experience compared to a regular cab (most of the time), whereas a low cost airline is horribly uncomfortable (read: spirit) and charges for everything.
- johnhenry 9y agoThe article implies that this is an active, coordinated effort; but I have to wonder if any of this is/could be an emergent phenomenon based on the existence of the surge pricing algorithm.
- dawnerd 9y agoI think some of the surge times are built in. At WDW it's on the dot when the parks close. There will be tons of drivers on the map too. Uber (and Lyft) know that a all the people they shuttled in for cheap in the morning will need a ride home and didn't plan an alternative.
- GlickWick 9y agoI suspect it's less hard-coded and more a case of the algorithm realizing that there's a huge influx of riders every day at X location at Y time, and just auto-surges until there are a number of days without said influx. It's important to build a surging algorithm this way, as otherwise you'll have an awkward period of low prices with high demand that ends up losing you money in the long run.
- asdffdsa321 9y agoI see it more as an economic thing: surge incentives drivers when demand outweighs supply -> drivers manipulate supply to increase price. Kind of fascinating
- kgdinesh 9y agoUber Drivers in India have been doing this since 2015.
- cctan 9y agoWhat did Uber in India do about it? Does it affect the prices that much and frequently?
- calvinbhai 9y agoWhy would Uber do anything about it? Its in Uber's interests to not solve it. They get more money no? Same with its competitor in India, Ola.
- johndoe90 9y agoThis will be beneficial up to some point in the future, when riders decide to boycott Uber.
- calvinbhai 9y agoWell, this driver behavior will exist in all platforms and won't be in any platform's interest to solve it. Be it Uber, Lyft, Ola, Grab etc.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoI saw scrawled on the wall in one of the port-a-potties in the LAX TNC lot, "No Surge, No Drive". Uber went on a campaign of hiring cabbies. I guess the fact that cabbies congregate and organize completely eluded Uber management.
- qq66 9y agoNot to mention, cabbies are often socially, ethnically, and even often genetically connected with each other, making the penalties for noncompliance high. If you're spotted driving when you're supposed to be boycotting for a surge, you may find yourself getting dirty looks from your roommates, your friends, and even your family.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoUber is such a hot mess - with everything - it's fascinating to watch it all.
- gmisra 9y agoPrice hacking is the new growth hacking, these drivers are truly disrupting a regulatory regime that limits their freedom.
- EGreg 9y agoI am currently talking with Warren Mosler about implementing Unconditional Basic Income in local communities (Hi @sama! :) Cartels is the main danger with unconditional basic income. If you make sure everyone can eat, you create a moral hazard, where the insured are not sensitive to price anymore. Having said that, we already have means-tested welfare and food stamps, and cartels of fruit stores don't spontaneously appear everywhere. However, they may appear in food deserts and other places where there aren't a lot of participants. Competition is the only factor I can think of to combat this. But in some areas with few participants, this collusion can ultimately happen. And then of course there is this result: https://www.arxiv.org/abs/1201.3798v2 https://www.arxiv.org/abs/1201.3798v2 Does anyone here have constructive thoughts on how to overcome this problem? Price controls and collective bargaining via single payer is all I can think of besides competition.
- abakker 9y agoCompetition in this case is really a proxy for choice. UBI should rationally be about promoting the ability for consumers to choose how to spend money, rather than being constrained to have no choices due to lack of resource. to solve the problem you are describing, people still need to have the self-interest to make good decisions, and the willingness to carry them out. If consumers won't shop around, or make price sensitive decisions, then the market for the good in question becomes price insensitive. But, I think UBI is attractive primarily because it doesn't seek to tell people how to spend their money, or tell them what the right choices are. As an alternative to welfare, it should allow consumer preferences to play a greater part in the market.
- EGreg 9y agoThe problem with UBI versus, let's say, single payer, is that buyers compete and therefore drive up price. In short they "defect" from the price the other buyers pay. Think about patio and his posts in the past about increasing your rates. That's how it happens. When you have insurance, then the buyer and seller can join forces to raise prices - that's called a moral hazard.
- 9y ago
- 659087 9y agoUber drivers are just trying to mimic the sort of behavior the company they "work" for is so well known for.
- bagacrap 9y agoDoesn't uber itself game the surge pricing? That is, they'll show you surge prices more often if you have shown a tendency to accept them.
- xenadu02 9y agoI haven’t seen any proof but it seems like Lyft does this. I almost never accept surge prices and I absolutely will never accept anything beyond 1.5x. Often if I leave the app open or check back 30 seconds later it will lower the surge rate. It makes sense if you think about it: giving people who won’t pay surge prices a ride anyway makes drivers scarcer for those who will pay, raising surge prices even further. I’m pretty sure that surge pricing outside a narrow range will eventually be made illegal. It makes too many people too angry and they’d rather get on a car waiting list than see a 3x price. You can argue the economics all you like but people are irrational.
- gertef 9y agoDrivers are liquidity providers. If you are willing to wait, you can wait for a lower price.
- btreesOfSpring 9y agoI remember dealing with the emergency IT issues that popped up with our NYC offices after hurricane Sandy wrought havoc upon much of lower Manhattan's power grid. We were lights out for at least three days. Had to take lots of taxis to move hardware to places with electricity. Even if we wanted to be creative, the subway was certainly not a transportation option and foot was wight prohibitive. The pickup rules for taxi's were suspended during this emergency period. Taxis could pickup fares mid-ride, turn down any rider going to a undesirable destination, & charge whatever they thought they could get. Lucky for me, despite all other storm-born chaos, I was in a sweet spot for where taxis were more than happy to drive. Even so, seeing the number of people who were turned down for their destinations or who in turn declined a ride because of the driver chosen price hike was fascinating; a sort of real-time, impromptu emergent market in infancy rapidly growing into maturity. So not to say that these ride share services have moved to remove all these kinds of consumer protections that clearly were quickly dropped and exploited once they were removed due to the state of emergency but to a large extent, I feel like I had the chance to experience the larger forces of gamification that would happen if these protections were removed and circumstances were ripe for profit. Overall I am very happy with the changes ride sharing services have brought to supplement transportation options but there are certainly a lot more of these bumps and kinks to be worked out if these businesses hope to avoid a wave of government regulation.
- rch 9y agoThis sounds a good control systems approach that provides drivers with an indirect way to influence pricing. If Uber decides to 'out' cheaters somehow, then I'd worry about coercion by other drivers.
- mabey 9y agoYup. Last week I left a Dodgers game in about the eighth inning, and there was a huge parking lot full of Ubers and tons of people were standing around waiting but couldn't find drivers. The drivers wait until the game ends and the masses exit so that the real surge pricing kicks in.
- loceng 9y agoI wonder what, if any, ways are there to counter this kind of behaviour?
- rectang 9y agoDriving for Lyft/Uber in traffic jams is economically unrewarding, because the fee schedule is tilted towards per-distance-unit and the per-minute fees are a pittance. Raising the per-minute fees would incentivize drivers to take fares which are currently not worthwhile rather than wait for surge pricing. However, drivers do not set the per-minute pricing -- that's the rideshare company's prerogative.
- cpsempek 9y agoDuring a fare, an uber driver told me that when he goes to an area with lots of drivers, he will turn off his app for a minute or so to artificially decrease the number of drivers in the area. If this is practiced by multiple drivers repeatedly, the result can cause a surge. He told me that he does this, and, that he holds training sessions where he teaches this practice to other drivers, among other things. I do not know if this was actually effective or if it still is.
- wavefunction 9y agoDamn, a real hack!
- whipoodle 9y agoIt would be pretty easy to build a service to coordinate this. (And of course Uber would whine about it even though that's exactly the kind of thing they do all the time)
- exhilaration 9y agoI would think a Whatsapp group should be sufficient.
- RonanTheGrey 9y agoI have personally watched Uber drivers (Not in the USA) do exactly this - lots of them in a Whatsapp group all agreeing when to disconnect their apps and turn them back on again. In front of me. During the ride. They definitely do this and it happens all the time. I sent my complaint about it to Uber, to only get ignored. The drivers are gaming the system and the customers get hurt. Right now, Uber is still better than taxis where I am, but I tell you the absolute second there is a decent competitor I am switching. I absolutely despise Uber. It would be so easy to stop this. Prevent someone who turned off their phone prior to a surge, from participating in the surge price for a time window before and after.
- 9y ago
- afinlayson 9y agoUber is being disputed by what sounds like the Uber of unionizing. Ohh the irony.
- baby_wipe 9y agoAs the price for an Uber increases, the number of people who want a ride will decrease, resulting in less business for the drivers.
- frandroid 9y agoI don't really buy Uber's denial. They can profit from this; knowing their ethical framework, you'd think they're encourage it.
- GauntletWizard 9y agoHow is this unethical? This is the exact point of these marketplaces - The drivers are saying "I won't accept a fare at these levels", Uber is responding by raising the price (and it's pretty transparent to consumers - The whole point of "surge pricing" is to incentivize drivers that would otherwise not be on the road). The multiplier framework is pretty clear upfront when you're paying more. This sounds like a fix to one of my major complaints about Uber. The prices are too low. I like cheap rides, but I also like knowing that the people who are giving me rides (and providing me services, selling me goods, making those goods, etc) are making living wages. And, to some level - This is collective bargaining. This is precisely what Unionists want, without all of the mess involved in actual unions. The drivers are collectively demanding higher wages, and Uber is responding. On the other hand: There's a good reason we're seeing this pushback. Uber is a shitty, predatory company, and has relentlessly worked to drive down driver wages well beyond sustainable rates. (It's also a shitty company to it's full time employees, to which I will attest.)
- bozoUser 9y agoI use Uber pass fairly regular on my commute to work. One other minor unrelated thing I have seen is if the commute is within < 1-2 miles the drive ends up giving you a bad rating (not that ratings matter to me) but uber has no way to screen this fake rating. I made sure I was at the pick up point well before the car arrived, and minded my own business throughout the ride. On talking to couple of drivers on a few occasions they confessed that they do this to filter out folks asking for lower mile rides!! edit: This is obviously not in high uber/lyft density zone like a downtown SF where one can assume most of the rides endup being in the 2 mile radius.
- noncoml 9y agoI am not sure about this. I drove Uber for a month or so, and use to love short rides because: 1. I would stay in the region of my choice 2. They would help me reach my bonus # of rides targets
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mtl_usr 9y agoIt should be pretty easy to filter out, given that there will be a very strong correlation between length of the drive and rating. Passenger rating does matter when it comes to how fast you are getting your ride.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoIt seems to me this happens more frequently when the employer / employee relationship is perceived to be adversarial by the employee.
- habosa 9y agoThis. As soon as you have an adversarial relationship between buyer/seller (of any good, not just labor) all the bad behaviors come out. A prime example of this is the airlines. Southwest and Virgin have somehow convinced staff and passengers to be polite to each other, so boarding and other things go smoothly. The same flight for the same price on United or American is a mess of elbowing and passive agressiveness.
- kentosi 9y agoPassive "aggression". Also, would this be mostly BigCo vs SmallCo culture difference? United and American are kinda massive ...
- gertef 9y agoSurge pricing is technologically archaic, and really has been since the start. Uber should be running instant automated auctions like stock market and webads do.
- sgroppino 9y agoTake one or two stars off the rating of the trip depending on the amount of the surcharge. That seems to be the only way to fight back as a consumer.
- johndoe90 9y agoMight be a coincidence, but lately I've noticed the same thing in Russia.
- kusmi 9y agoWhen it happened to me I immediately filed complaint asking for a refund, and they issued it very quickly with an apology.