6 ms·
It's pretty rich how these companies are well known for the rigor they apply to interviewing candidates on technical subjects, yet actually drop the ball in pro
by Apocryphon 9y ago
It's pretty rich how these companies are well known for the rigor they apply to interviewing candidates on technical subjects, yet actually drop the ball in production with poor engineering like this. Where does that rigor go after the interviews are done?
Are there any examples of well-known apps from large organizations that aren't excessively large in size?
- jamieomatthews 9y agoI work on Amazon Prime Photos iOS app. It's currently 60mb in size, and a good chunk of that is the Swift runtime. Even the main Amazon shopping app is less than 100mb.
- hengheng 9y agoI'll bite. In what ways can you use up 100MByte with a fancy reimplementation of an online shop? That should be enough for a text to speech engine, or a 3d engine with quite a few assets. I am being deliberately ignorant, having no idea what functionality one might add, but I'm actually genuinely curious. All that I see is a small databse and a lot of assets that are being downloaded on the fly.
- Nightshaxx 9y agoI believe it does have a text to speech engine......the Android app has one.
- acdha 9y agoI don't know the division of work between the app and server but don't forget that the app includes some level of voice recognition, and has not just a bar-code scanner but enough of a computer vision system that I can pretty reliably look up products simply by taking a picture of them.
- swrobel 9y agoThose apps are standouts but generally Amazon iOS apps are appalling. Alexa is 78MB of pure UX hell.
- abc_lisper 9y agoWait. Do you have to include the runtime with the app? That seems backwards.
- intoverflow2 9y ago>Even the main Amazon shopping app is less than 100mb. 109 on my device, not sure why it needs over 100 for a menu/search and checkout function that relies entirely on external data. Also another commenter said Alexa was 78 when it's 124 for me and does even less than the shopping app.
- maccard 9y agoNot exactly large organisation, but the slack app is 80MB. For reference, discord is 17.
- AstralStorm 9y agoPlease also count in server side data downloaded for identical functionality. It does not help if 80% of the app is downloaded after installation.
- maccard 9y agoI'm on iOS, so checking the sizes in Storage. Slack is 74MB with 14MB extra downloaded. Discord is 18MB with 6MB extra downloaded.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Are there any examples of well-known apps from large organizations that aren't excessively large in size? This is nothing new. Look how much memory your typical Java desktop app, or worse, your average Java server app, uses. As soon as you have enterprises involved where it's regular occurrence for devs to be outfitted with the shiniest and beefiest (as perks or per standard company policy) developers won't care about resource usage until it's so excessive it either slows down their machines or accounting knocks on the door and asks who ordered dozens of x1.32xlarge machines... Seriously, another huge problem is assets. In ye olde PC days, you included ONE version of an image and that was it (okay maybe a 16x16 favicon for the small start menu and a 32x32 one for desktop)... these days with loads of different combinations of resolution and DPI, and across multiple platforms (if you're doing a Cordova build and don't split the assets before packaging), stuff can and will grow.
- richardwhiuk 9y agoIt's not that Devs don't care. It's because every metric anyone has ever gathered says that users don't care.
- jcelerier 9y ago> It's because every metric anyone has ever gathered says that users don't care. A lot of people go to wal-mart. Doesn't mean that it's a good thing overall for mankind
- emodendroket 9y agoIf you're looking for apps to be developed "for the good of mankind," without consideration of profitability, then you're going to have to have a different model than the pursuit of profit.
- jcelerier 9y agowell of course, and I think there should be legal action in this direction. No reason to waste CPU cycles on the technologie du jour.
- vkou 9y agoBecause the customers are the ones who are paying for that inefficiency, not the company. You can bet that those companies' infrastructure is optimized to hell and back.
- Aqua_Geek 9y ago> You can bet that those companies' infrastructure is optimized to hell and back. You'd be surprised. (Source: I work at a unicorn.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 9y agoYou know, I'm not currently an Uber customer because their app is too big and I don't have enough spare space on my phone. There were a few times already that I thought about using them, but couldn't install it right at the time.
- emodendroket 9y agoOK, so that's one. How many people even look? I have no idea what size the applications on my phone are.
- Apocryphon 9y agoDo you have a lot of space on your phone, or just not use a lot of apps or media? People might not have the same situation as you.
- emodendroket 9y agoI have a 64 GB phone with a fair amount of apps and media. I don't know if it's more or less than average.
- Azkar 9y agoIt's hard to move fast and have a well engineered product.
- LeoNatan25 9y agoThen don't move fast. It's as simple as that. Move at the pace that you can sustain a reasonably engineered app.
- richardwhiuk 9y agoAt which point everyone who moves fast will beat you.
- marcosdumay 9y agoWill them? Amazon differential is not the quality of their app. Unless they create something really impressive some day, they can only lose customers by moving faster there. Besides, none of those are small startups anymore. All of them have something to lose.
- flukus 9y ago> Amazon differential is not the quality of their app. For my only real experience with amazon (audible) the quality of their app is a negative, I'd much prefer they made an API available. The same can be said of others, I'd much rather native apps connecting to a netflix API than use their awful web player.
- chii 9y agoThere might be countless number of failed chat/social apps that failed due to their time spent engineering something like size reduction or code quality. You probably just never hear about them, since you know they failed to get traction. So size being a problem seems only true for engineers. A normal user don't care as long as their device still works. And apple won't care since they can use this as an opportunity to up sell larger devices.
- 9y ago