14 ms·
SoundCloud's Collapse
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoWorth reading to the end for the deadpan Correction.
- kumarvvr 9y agoUnintentionally hilarious.
- sgt101 9y agoI'd love to know the story behind that!
- deanCommie 9y agoI hope it was Jeff Toig who raised it.
- bartread 9y agoI was thinking exactly the same thing.
- thinbeige 9y agoI read this article few hours earlier when crawling through the new section. It's a surprisingly interesting piece from Buzzfeed but there's a lot of bashing of the CEO, the CTO and one recently hired senior for label relations (who seem to be really odd). This is typical: SoundCloud was an iconic company, its founders worshiped and idealized. Once money runs out, people but especially former employees start to backstab, blaspheme and blame loud and clearly. Why not before? Now when everybody is hitting SoundCloud it's easy and risk-free to join the hate. All the NDAs they once signed seem to be gone? To be fired also means fire and forget for them. I never believed in SoundCloud. The founders did a great job building a huge brand and DNA out of nothing but the business model is by design broken or to put it simply, you just can't do business with music labels. Btw, where is Fred Wilson? The biggest proponent and investor of SoundCloud who didn't miss an opportunity to tell us that sound is the future stays silent and hasn't commented this tragedy once. A VC just for good times? EDIT: Why the downvotes? Mind to share your view?
- cheetos 9y agoIn my experience, it's likely that the founders' problematic behavior has existed from the beginning, but employees feared retaliation and thus didn't speak up until now, when they are safe from being fired.
- Yokohiii 9y agoI cannot follow you. By no means you can openly criticize the managers of your own company. Even nowadays this could be handled as mutiny. On top of that, management is usually only half transparent at best. Causing doubt if the decisions are just bad or nobody got the whole picture.
- thinbeige 9y agoYou are right and I was not clear. What I mean: Since they all signed NDAs they are not allowed to openly criticize their company—ever. Not when being hired and not after being fired. Since 173 were fired it's easy to ignore NDAs because they won't get caught. But it's not right, they break a significant agreement and this is so typical for employees (just head to Glassdoor and how much internal stuff is disclosed).
- detaro 9y agoWe don't know what kind of NDAs SC employees had to sign/how valid they are. At least some of the issues are listed as only appearing after a while. Journalists likely are a lot more receptive to/asking around for employees with complaints when there is a general air of failure (or total overblown hype) surrounding a company.
- thinbeige 9y ago> We don't know what kind of NDAs SC employees had to sign/how valid they are. Every employment contract has by nature a NDA embedded. And those are much stricter than dedicated NDAs since employment contracts get rarely negotiated line by line, most employees just accept and sign employment contracts.
- MIKarlsen 9y agoThat's the second time this week I see Buzzfeed coming out with something that resembles decent journalism. Coincidence, or have they turned their ship around?
- Veratyr 9y agoThis is BuzzFeed News, which is run semi-independently from BuzzFeed itself and has actually had some decent quality journalism from the start. Apparently this happened in 2016: http://www.poynter.org/2016/buzzfeed-undergoes-company-wide-reorganization-separating-entertainment-from-news/427375/ http://www.poynter.org/2016/buzzfeed-undergoes-company-wide-... Their investigations team is especially interesting: https://www.poynter.org/2016/how-buzzfeed-built-an-investigative-team-from-the-ground-up/396656/ https://www.poynter.org/2016/how-buzzfeed-built-an-investiga...
- H4CK3RM4N 9y agoI think it's more that they have a few good contributors in with the nonsense. For example, their Australian political coverage has consistently been surprisingly good.
- mrkrabo 9y agoWithout reading a word of it, I imagine where it leans.
- hboon 9y agoThey have been doing this the last few years.
- bartread 9y agoIndeed. I discovered this after a friend mentioned to me that Buzzfeed News was decent and, well, basically I didn't believe her so I went to check it out. The first story I saw was breaking news of the Tianjin explosions and of course the story was so out there that, because it was Buzzfeed, I didn't believe it until I'd watched some of the footage and seen it reported elsewhere. Anyway, yes, they are surprisingly decent.
- xfer 9y ago> According to one former SoundCloud Berlin employee, a lack of direction from Wahlforss, who served as chief technology officer, made things worse, with some engineers going rogue and rebuilding their colleagues’ work in their preferred programming language. Does this happen at other startups?
- Mikushi 9y agoHappens everywhere. In corp I've seen engineers go behind their manager's back to write something in their favourite language knowing it would've been rejected if discussion had happen beforehand.
- reustle 9y agoThat sounds like a reasonable reason to fire someone
- WJW 9y agoThat depends on how well it works. If it blows up and costs the company a million bucks you get fired, if it works extremely well then you are a maverick genius. "Ask for forgiveness, not permission", etc. Not saying that the extent to which it was apparently done at soundcloud should be acceptable though.
- sgt101 9y agoThe extent indicates anarchy which indicates poor leadership. The issue must have been with the management culture - flat hierarchies don't mean free for alls!
- sgt101 9y agoIt depends on the outcome of the discussion - which depends on your capability as a manager. Sometimes this behavior is because the manager is an arse who can't run a reasonable process of team decision making, and the covert development is a reasonable appeal from someone who is disenfranchised in the decision making process and is making a very valuable point. The employee so doing is highly engaged and valuable and firing them is an act of self harm. In other cases this is an act of aggression by an unreasonable and arrogant individual who doesn't care about the team or the company and is simply doing what they want. You have to judge - call it wrong (either way) and you have a problem that will cost you dearly. But be aware there are two sides to this coin and you might be the one that needs to learn. My questions are always : is this part of a pattern (conflict, poor performance, bad behaviour?); why don't I want to sit with this person for 2 hours with a coffee and understand whats going on?; why didn't the coffee heart to heart work out?
- erikb 9y agoIf anybody else is also put off by the writing style: There is some actual content there. One just needs to get through the first third which basically just repeats the headline. TL;DR (without my opinion added): Top Management started too late to think about making actual money. They also hired an asshole for their US offices. When they got an opportunity to be bought by Twitter they asked for way too much money. And the CEO is bascially on a constant holidays trip since 2014, while not failing to rub it in everybody's face via Instagram photos. Personal opinion: I don't understand these CEOs who start cashing out before either selling their business or making it a viable paid service, while being so close to a lifetime solution to the problem of money. I mean he already went 80% of the way, much further than most.
- thinbeige 9y ago> If anybody else is also put off by the writing style: The writing style is just fine, it's surprisingly high quality considering this is coming from Buzzfeed (even if it's the new serious branch).
- mailshanx 9y agoMaybe he already cashed out? We increasingly hear of founders taking money off the table by selling a part of their share when it comes time to raise a series-B or later round. SoundCloud was likely well past the series-B stage, and i wouldn't be surprised if the founder already has a few million in the bank.
- 9y ago
- iagooar 9y agoThis shows us, that company valuations are ridiculous and actually mean nothing. Is SoundCloud worth a billion dollars? Well, it might be on paper or in the imaginations of the founders, but what does it really mean? To me, it's worth nothing. The real problem is: these companies start to operate from the perspective of "having" those millions of dollars. This is why they hire too many people for too much money. They spent hundreds of thousands on marketing. But in the end, you know what? They need to beg for money to pay their debts. They need to lay off dozens of employees because they don't have the money to pay them. What if SoundCloud would have kept a small, yet highly skilled engineering team of maybe ~20 people, some marketing and sales, and try to not outgrow themselves? Probably they'd be having a huge surplus each year because their costs would be small and sustained. When I read stories like these, I actually feel good about my bootstrapped, down-to-earth startup. We don't make millions, we don't "disrupt" the industry, yet we solve our customers' problems and delight them. We won't ever run out of money, as we carefully check each and every expenditure, and have growing savings in the bank.
- manmal 9y agoOnce you have investors, they want their money to grow, and this is not possible by staying small. We have invested in a startup we work with, and given the high risk of failure, I would not be happy with a meager growth rate of <10% per year. At that rate, my money is safer in the bank or some kind of low risk portfolio. If you have an 80% chance of losing the money, then you better expect at least a x5 return rate when selling your shares. I'm a big fan of bootstrapping myself, and it's the best model IFF you can get by without investors. If you, like SoundCloud, have a product that does not break-even, then you will need investors, period. Of course you could say - well, just don't make a product that nobody pays for; but obviously there is a market for such products, on the investor side.
- yeukhon 9y agoStaying small != don't grow business. I would never hire crazy so people in the startup can imagine spinning up new projects new microservice new crazy revolutionary database/big data/ new KV store/new cache layer out of curiosity. Till one point, when the business is so big, growing engineering team to over 100 is inevitable. But plently of really successful tech companies did not overgrow their team size for a number of years. E.g Facebook. Human captial spent is actually the most expensive even comparing space rental if you add up salary, bonus, and benefits. I also will not recommend startups in their early stage (or even until they can break-even for a long time) to flu candidates over. There is really no reason to fly people over until you want to hire that person. Flying and hotel adds up big time too. Google can offer this because spending a couple millions doesn't matter to them.
- tovkal 9y agoIt's always sad when a company has issues for months and nobody either sees them or acts during that time. Though 'Desde la barrera todo el mundo es torero'.
- k-mcgrady 9y agoSoundCloud could have been a nice business if they hadn't got greedy. From the beginning (or close to it) there have been various paid accounts for artists which a lot of people used. SoundCloud was the best place to discover new music from unsigned artists. There were unsigned artists with tracks on it that blew up and eventually got picked up by major labels. But: - SoundCloud neglected the platform. - Then they did one of the worst redesigns of any site I've seen (try reordering a track in your spotlight [paid feature] in Chrome. Crashes the tab and has done for years. I need to open another browser to do that.). - Then it became overrun with major label artists. - Then they started offering features just to the big artists - various UI/branding options - (forgetting about the artists that got them to where they were). - Then they did the whole paid streaming mess which they were never going to succeed in. Anybody could have told them that, I really don't believe anyone in that company thought 'Go' would work. I think they just needed to do something. I'm not sure if they've taken so much money now that this isn't possible anymore but if I were CEO I would take it back to it's roots. Focus on the unsigned artists. Fix the site. Offer a distribution system (like CDBaby/TuneCore) so that SoundCloud can be a one-stop show for unsigned artists. Now you've got paid accounts (for stats/spotlight/unlimited upload space) and a small cut of distribution on all paid platforms. I don't understand how in a world where more artists are getting big without label help nobody is offering a great platform for them. SoundCloud got very close in the past. BandCamp has gotten close too (although it lacks the social/sharing/viral aspect of SoundCloud). If SoundCloud does end up shutting down it's due to greed and poor management. Instead of focusing on what they do well and what people use them for they've tried to go after the money and they were much too late making that move to get any of it.
- thinbeige 9y ago> Then it became overrun with major label artists. So what. There also many excellent major label artist and it's good to have them. Many new album releases are missing on SoundCloud but available on Spotify from day one. Probably I am the only one but I find most 'DJ mixes' on SoundCloud lack in quality/creativity (I am into electronic music though). Maybe some like them I think 95% of them are subpar and sound like my nephew created a song with Magix Music Maker. These mixes and 'the extended repetoire' are no competitive advantage over Spotify and Co.
- Myrmornis 9y agoThis seemed to me a very sad story. The time during which SoundCloud as it was known and loved really existed was the era before they were really worrying about their "business model". As soon as they contemplated how they could exist long term, they started copying mainstream music services in a way that no-one loved. The real question is: given how much amazing free content there is, how are we going to nurture valuable cultural ecosystems like soundcloud, and create a meaningful and stable niche for them and their employees in our economies?
- narrator 9y agoThe problem with the music business is the problem with the art business in general. There are way too many people producing art and music these days and not enough consumers. The price of music is negative in that people have so much music available that you'd have to pay people something or massively promote to get people to spend time listening to a new band. Companies like distrokid seem to do ok because they charge artists to distribute music. Fans really can't be bothered to pay anymore. I never said to myself, at least in the last ten years: "damn, I wish I had more music". For me, music is "done". I have plenty, I don't need anymore and it is of much better quality than what it used to be back in the 80s and 90s when I used to spend a lot of money on it.
- tjr225 9y agoMay be a problem with the business but I think it is great for art and music, not that you disagreed with that sentiment.
- sgentle 9y agoNever do a music industry startup unless you have a billion dollars, can raise a billion dollars, or plan to be acquired by a company with a billion dollars to spare. That's the table stakes for going toe-to-toe with the big three. They'll bleed you to death with licensing fees, deputise you into their copyright enforcement police, upload their songs to your platform on one hand while suing you with the other, and all the while cry about how extracting monopoly profits is so much harder than in the old days. Just go disrupt something safer, like organised crime or the international diamond trade. At least with those the law probably won't change out from under you.
- Kenji 9y agoSeems to work for Bandcamp though (which I love by the way).
- thirdsun 9y agoThe difference is that Bandcamp doesn‘t need to make deals with major labels. Instead they have smaller and larger labels as well as independent artists coming to them. I really don‘t understand why Soundcloud tried to get into general, mainstream music streaming. Keeping their niche as paid host for DJs, radio shows, independent artists and small labels should have been their main focus. As a paid service for listeners (in contrast to artists) it simply can‘t compete with Spotify, Apple and others.
- cupcakestand 9y agoBest comment in the thread. It shows that one of SoundCloud's key problem is an oligopolostic industry they are dealing with.
- lukaslalinsky 9y agoSoundCloud's key problem is that they couldn't stay small because of VC money, not the music industry.
- 9y ago
- sddfd 9y agoWhat I never understood was why they were opening offices in SF, NY, and London, without having the revenue to back them up. In my eyes that was just flushing huge amounts of money down the drain.
- jackninja1 9y agoI think a few things are needed in order for SoundCloud to restore some of its value: - They need to evaluate how their (IMHO) only competitor HypeMachine does its things, and if possible consider an acquisition - While probably very costly they need to redesign their website (and app), their latest redesign was received very negativly
- whofailed 9y agoContrarian here: Soundcloud is an incredibly valuable property. They have obviously had a few managerial cock-ups, but in reality they have massive user buyin, huge network effect, and anyone who can get some equity in them during this current time of massive negative sentiment is going to do VERY WELL. I wish I had a way to buy in at this point.
- fungi 9y agolove it, live on it, its contributed significantly to my hearing loss. listening to https://soundcloud.com/silent-season/campfire-stories-24 https://soundcloud.com/silent-season/campfire-stories-24 as i type this spiel. would happily become a premium++ subscriber if money went to artists, something like humble bundle... but the paid plan is brain dead and offers no value ┐( ̄ヘ ̄;)┌ hope it survives or morphs into a decentralised platform that artists can thrive on.
- bartread 9y agoOoh: nice recommendation. I have somewhat mixed feelings about Soundcloud. On the one hand I've discovered a load of cool stuff through them, as well as uploaded a few tracks of my own. On the other I received a takedown notice from them after a complaint from Sony about one of my remixes - my most popular track by miles and, at the time, the third most popular remix of Rick Astley's Never Gonna Give You Up (long story) - which left something of a bitter taste in my mouth. To add insult to injury the notice arrived on my birthday last year. Haven't really touched Soundcloud much since.
- lupin3 9y agoSoundcloud is one the rare service I would be happy to pay for. However, their current subscription does not bring me anything interesting. One idea would be to have a monthly limit, and propose an unlimited subscription at around $1 to $3. And how come I have to pay for the artist album through Bandcamp after listening on Soundcloud? Is there no way to implement a payment straight from Soundcloud? Also, there is an obvious return of the podcast scene: here again, plenty of ways to make money from that.
- StreamBright 9y agoWell, there were several attempts from different groups, companies and people to build on their API that failed for no good reason. They simply decline the API access request without any reasoning. They could have made money from 3rd parties, or even through selling music directly on their site. I usually go to Soundcloud to discover music and than to Bandcamp to buy it. I am not sure why this was never a focus to them.
- kowdermeister 9y ago"Jeff Toig's preferred PowerPoint style is size 10 Arial font with a black background. An earlier version of this story misstated the color." This is the funniest correction I've ever read :)
- keithpeter 9y agoYes, I thought that was amusing, the idea that Mr Toig's main complaint about his portrayal in the article was the mis-statement of his preferences for presentations gives you some idea of what it must have been like in the section of the business that he was responsible for (we don't know who provided the correction of course). A previous manager of mine insisted on all documents using 12pt Arial with 18pt line spacing...
- netheril96 9y agoMaybe Mr Toig complained about many things, but the writers chose to only accept this correction.
- keithpeter 9y agoI accept the point.
- danso 9y agoThe correction might not have come directly from him. It was other employees who alleged that he got mad about that typeface not being used, and maybe the reporter got the detail wrong when publishing the story.
- cubano 9y agoSo what the hell is wrong with me? I use SC everyday almost...I don't get this "collapse"? Should I turn in my coolkid badge now?
- phaed 9y agoDid you read the article? They ran out of funding and fired 40% of their staff. The business collapsed, not the service.
- blitzprog 9y agoFrom a consumer perspective, SoundCloud lost my interest when I heard it's 128 kbps transcoded mp3 you're getting when streaming songs. No thanks.
- codegladiator 9y ago> 128 kbps transcoded mp3 How much are you looking for ? and how much are you willing to pay for that ?
- blitzprog 9y agoPaying for a music playback? I am paying for music storage, but playback should use source quality at all times. Exceptions are when the track is uploaded in a lossless codec like WAV or FLAC. Then it should be OGG compressed. If you use MP3, at least use 192 kbps or better 320 kbps. Example: https://clyp.it/ https://clyp.it/ allows 320 kbps streaming and it costs 0$.
- abhi3 9y agoSo until you heard its 128 kbps you had no idea? If that's the case then there's no problem with it streaming @128
- blitzprog 9y agoWrong, I simply wasn't using it and heard of the service. You can hear the bad quality by comparing it to a high quality version of the same song on good speakers.
- ThomPete 9y agoAfter 4 1/2 years at Square colleague of mine and I, left Square to start our own portfolio of small productivity tools some we are building ourselves and other we will probably be acquiring. Our first rule was that we will not get funding for anything than scaling a business once it hit some sort of product market fit. Until then there is only bootstrapping. This is to avoid something like SoundCloud where you become numb to the die hard reality of needing to build a business before you build an organization, get fuzzball tables and promote your altruistic business principles.
- misingnoglic 9y agoSoundCloud used to be /the/ place for indie musicians to post their work - now I think websites like Bandcamp have more or less taken over. This article explains why - they basically stopped focusing on the artists - but I'm surprised they didn't mention competitors.
- pasta 9y agoMaybe I'm missing something but this article is telling me Soundcloud is dead. But is it? Yes they are having a hard time but it there no way to continue with a small team? As a Soundcloud user there is nothing telling me it is dead. Fresh music every day. So it's not like an exodus is happening.
- chippy 9y ago>Maybe I'm missing something Yeah, this was in the first section of the article: "In early July, SoundCloud laid off 173 people — some 40% of its workforce" and the rest of the article outlines the collapse of their business deals and troubles.
- demarq 9y agoBringing up the bieber situation is entirely unfair. SoundCloud did the best any company could have done in that situation. His own label was also confused by the move.
- TekMol 9y agoIs there a collapse? They used their VC money to pay employees to build stuff. Now the money is spent. Employees get layed off. It could very well been worth it. What has been built might bring in return on invest for a long time. Isn't that normal? Isn't VC money intended to be used that way? Are VCs demanding to build jobs for eternity? Or is there some moral reason to not grow and shrink the work force while building a company?
- philipps 9y agoI would hate to see SoundCloud disappear or get dismantled in an effort to migrate its user base into a different social network. The core idea, to provide a way for amateur creators to share their music, and connect with an audience, is sound. I also think there is/was a gap in the market for podcast creators that SoundCloud authoring tools could have filled. Can some combination of charging creators for advanced authoring or analytics, and placing ads in a free listening tier, not provide sufficient income to keep something like this going?
- bokglobule 9y agoThe tech industry keeps repeating the same business mistakes. This period strikes me more and more of the 1998-99 era when there was so much euphoria that there was no way but up. Then March 2000 came, the first Internet high flyers started to fail, and very quickly the whole thing unraveled. We're on the same road again...
- bogomipz 9y ago>"In November 2014, SoundCloud closed a deal with Warner Music Group, giving the label an undisclosed cut of revenue from ads, a 3%–5% stake in the company and protection against past copyright infringement from the label." This sounds like terms dictated by the Mob. It's quite telling that the deal also conferred ownership on a content holder in order to be able to license and pay handsomely for their content. This is only one of the big 4 they were negotiating with too. By the time they get done negotiation with the other 3 they would have likely given up 15% of the company. Note the big 4 all have stakes in Spotify as well[1]. At any rate I think this should have been a sign that they were going down the wrong path. Propping up these labels and hitching your wagon to them, only to have to constantly renegotiate your deal with them every couple of years seems contra to a platform that gave artists direct access to music fans without the middle man. [1] http://www.swedishwire.com/jobs/680-record-labels-part-owner-of-spotify http://www.swedishwire.com/jobs/680-record-labels-part-owner...
- cookiecaper 9y ago>This sounds like terms dictated by the Mob. The simple fact is that copyright protections are far too strong. The copyright cartel doesn't need a shady network of 400 pound men to enforce their schemes; they just use the U.S. Attorney's office instead. How many bright technical entrepreneurs have been crushed by rent-seekers milking the royalties out of a 40-year-old track? Copyright has completely lost the plot. We need to rein it in, with the awareness that this will be no small task, as it amounts to taking away a license to print money from some of the largest companies in the world.
- bogomipz 9y ago>"How many bright technical entrepreneurs have been crushed by rent-seekers milking the royalties out of a 40-year-old track?" Anything after Jan 1st of 1978 is now capped at 35 years, so these are becoming less and less See: http://www.songwriteruniverse.com/gosainkaplanrecapture123.htm http://www.songwriteruniverse.com/gosainkaplanrecapture123.h... >"Copyright has completely lost the plot." Well the copyright of the of recording is there to protect the record label's investment. They aren't going to finance a record and it's promotion if someone else can come along and also release the same recording and collect money for it. That was always the plot. That being said artists don't have to sign contracts with record labels if they don't want. With technology and the internet it is possible today more than at any point in history to successfully release and promote your music without a record label. I thought this was the great promise of platforms like Soundcloud. If an artist decides they need the marketing muscle of a record label they can license their recordings to a record label and retain the recording copyright. I really believe this is the future: See: https://www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2009/jan/29/recording-copyright-ownership https://www.theguardian.com/music/musicblog/2009/jan/29/reco...
- loomer 9y agoIt seems Discord is in the early stages of something like this. They have dozens of employees and a pre-money valuation of 725 million US dollars. However, very few users are buying their premium service, with most saying it isn't worth it, with this paid version only coming out a year after the release of Discord.
- bogomipz 9y agoNot showing up to company retreats, circulating pictures of yourself taking private jets and hanging out with celebrities in Ibiza, doing a Ferragamo ad - CEO Alexander Ljung sounds like Erlich Bachman. It's easy to write those things off as petty gripes but I think they are important in that illustrate a CEO who doesn't understand that those are bad "optics" for employees who are seeing layoffs and lack of funds available to higher talent. And a CEO who doesn't understand the nuances of this might also not see the nuances of lots of other important areas of their business. Why does the board not remove him?
- jameskegel 9y agoWe aren't doing "optics" anymore; that was more of a mid-election phenomenon. CEOs are largely just figureheads these days- one could argue that in this music industry it is important to have somewhat of a splashy rockstar image to exude legitimacy.
- bogomipz 9y agoExcept that this usage of the word "optics" in popular lexicon predates the U.S. election by at least 4 years. See this "word detective" entry from 2012: http://www.word-detective.com/2012/01/optics/ http://www.word-detective.com/2012/01/optics/
- jameskegel 9y agoIt does not seem prudent to debate 2017 popular social vernacular with a publication from 2012. (Although your article goes on to support my argument of Optics being a term reserved for political discussion) Optics is a term largely reserved for the stage of political theatre, that is not my assertion, that is the zeitgeist of popular opinion.
- bogomipz 9y agoFirstly I am not debating anything, your assertion is that this usage is a phenomenon bounded by the US election season and I pointed you to a resource demonstrating that it has been increasing in usage for at least the last 4 years. It is not "passé" now simply because the U.S. election is over. >"Optics is a term largely reserved for the stage of political theatre" Yes and much of what a CEO has to deal with is internal politics. You realize that "politics" in the general sense has a meaning and usage outside of just government right? >"that is not my assertion, that is the zeitgeist of popular opinion." It's quite amusing that you want to take someone to task for their usage of word simply because you have decided it is no longer "fashionable" and then you go on to use the word "zeitgeist" incorrectly. See: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/zeitgeist https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/zeitgeist http://grammarist.com/usage/zeitgeist/ http://grammarist.com/usage/zeitgeist/
- shp0ngle 9y agoI would be interested in how BandCamp is doing. They seem to have a product that both sides of the deal actually like - both buyers and sellers - and they have a business model from the start. I have no idea how big BandCamp is, in terms of both users and developers.
- Rjevski 9y agoPersonally I lost interest in late 2013 when they redesigned their UI (and made it crap) and started adding ads soon after. No thanks.
- snakeanus 9y agoWhile I feel sorry for their employees I am quite happy that this happened. The censorship that they applied to the content that they hosted was quite disgusting.
- Briel 9y agoThere's a lot of focus on how they failed: strayed from their non-label musician roots. But how would they have been able to monetize? * Let fans support their favorite musicians a la Patreon and take a % from the donations? * Partner with music labels to help them scout their next upcoming talents? * Help musicians book shows at venues and take a % of the sales?
- parasubvert 9y agoOpen source remains an important force of continuity for technology professionals, as even though SoundCloud is failing, they brought us a very important piece of infrastructure that will carry on: http://Prometheus.io http://Prometheus.io It has been catching on like wildfire everywhere I look, even big conservative companies. It feels like the new Nagios (in a good way).
- glasz 9y agoyes. and it was about bloody time the ugly crap that nagios is gets some heat.
- drenvuk 9y agoIs it not possible to make a browser extension or app to "wrap" youtube and turn it into a soundcloud like service? Seems to me they could transition a lot of their users over to it and possibly save money.
- rv77ax 9y agoInstead of pursuing major record label, did they not even though about creating one?
- arihant 9y agoI think the reason is that music subscription services took off in last 2-3 years massively, and globally. Apple Music expanded to a good number of nations, so did Spotify and others. And so it has also become very easy for creators to put their music on those services. There are SaaS apps that put unlimited music on all platforms for artists for as little as $20 a year. You don't need to partner with record label any more to be on iTunes, Apple Music, Pandora, Google Play, Spotify, etc. You need $20 a year. The goliath that SoundCloud was fighting killed itself. As a creator, I know there are 10x more people listening on Apple and Spotify. There is simply very less reason to upload on SoundCloud except for community. And it is the community that they managed to piss off by partnering with the labels.
- briandear 9y agoArial? There’s the problem right there.
- playing_colours 9y agoAs one of the engineers in those 40% fired, I asked myself if I should try to start a startup: use this [0] money, plus try to raise more in the current situation. Say, to implement a good old vision of SoundCloud - a cozy creator-driven music catalog, with communities, and features like real time streaming. But I guess, even if we succeed initially, the company will be eventually killed by the major labels, copyright infringement cases, etc. It's a rough territory. [0] http://www.thefader.com/2017/07/26/wetransfer-soundcloud-employees-10000 http://www.thefader.com/2017/07/26/wetransfer-soundcloud-emp...
- BadassFractal 9y agoShould music creators who want a place to upload and get feedback on their work move to a different platform now or is SoundCloud going to be around for that for the foreseeable future?
- shmerl 9y agoThey could do what Bandcamp did instead. Bandcamp is growing.
- nunez 9y agoI haven't used SoundCloud that much, but the last time I seriously used it was in late 2015 for finding solid trap music. Finding unsigned material was a lot easier in 2014 than in 2015; everything in the first few pages was from huge signed artists. I also gave Go a chance so I could download stuff I liked onto my iPhone. It was such a confusing service. I paid $9.99/mo to download tracks. There was no way to download albums. It was also difficult to find things that I wanted to hear. I cancelled after a month or so.
- candiodari 9y ago> “Deals with the labels would have allowed us to have monetization,” said one former executive, who explained that no ads could be run across label-owned content without a revenue-sharing agreement.“We needed to make sure that we could grow unencumbered without a lawsuit.” This sounds like a serious mistake. All the ones that succeeded asked for forgiveness afterwards rather than wait until they had permission.
- Mikho 9y agoSoundCloud problem was that it tried to chase and copy competitors instead of being unique--but it has truly unique user experience which it completely ignores (probably need to write about it a blogpost). By following competition you don't win. You don't get a leadership position. You just lose slower. As a result, SoundCloud faced a notorious problem of wholesale transfer pricing [1] power. And it didn't have enough money to win or even participate in that battle. [1] Wholesale transfer pricing = the bargaining power of company A that supplies a unique product XYZ to Company B which may enable company A to take the profits of company B by increasing the wholesale price of XYZ.