6 ms·
Incredible shrinking airline seat
- mc32 9y agoMy discomfort increases with time in the air. 2-3 hour flight, I can take lots of discomfort. Long haul there is no-where and nothing you can do but get lucky with an exit seat or pay up for first class. There is only so much wriggling you can do. People are only getting taller, but leg room is deceasing. My hope would be to see regulation require more leg room for long haul routes.
- jtbayly 9y ago"leg room is deceasing" I hope that was an intentional pun. Leg room is vanishingly small these days, but I'm not so sure it's entirely gone. ;)
- jeffdavis 9y agoWhat's the point? If people were willing to pay more, airlines would make seats bigger. But people want cheap flights, so they get small seats.
- phreeza 9y agoThe question in the article is: is it a safety issue?
- jeffdavis 9y agoDoes the article answer it, or just spend the entire time on the more poulist point that airline seats are uncomfortable because airlines are greedy?
- GordonS 9y agoThe point is that it's a safety issue. Regulation seems like a good way to deal with this, although I expect there will be heavy pushback from the aviation industry.
- jeffdavis 9y agoNo, they are reconsidering the relevence/quality of studies done that show it's not a safety issue. That doesn't mean that it is a safety issue.
- jessriedel 9y agoWith 3 million flights a year in the US, there's no way the cost is possibly justified by any reasonable cost-benefit analysis. > Nobody died in a crash of a United States-certificated scheduled airline operating anywhere in the world in 2016...it is the seventh straight year that nobody died in a crash on a United States-certificated scheduled airline operating anywhere in the world. https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielreed/2016/12/28/in-the-last-7-years-you-were-more-likely-to-be-run-over-by-a-car-than-to-die-in-an-airline-crash/#4c5d0ec4428a https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielreed/2016/12/28/in-the-la...
- GordonS 9y agoHow often do planes actually crash? Is it often enough to get statisically significant data about survival rates in the event of an evacuation? Also, evacuation after a crash is not the only safety issue - there is deep vein thrombosis, for example.
- jessriedel 9y agoThere isn't nearly enough real-crash data for something as specific as seat widths, but the FAA gets lots of info about this stuff by simulating evacuation procedures with real people. http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2006/03/how_did_airbus_ace_its_airplane_evacuation_test.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20...
- obsurveyor 9y agoAll the more reason to do research into making sure there isn't a safety issue here. Stats like this just make people and companies complacent until the next tragedy strikes.
- amelius 9y agoOne problem here is that average size people are the majority.
- tacostakohashi 9y agoI suspect average size people are quite rare, actually - definitely not a majority.
- amelius 9y agoIn the PDF sense they are.
- Idontagree 9y agoIt also makes it hard for people like me who are far above the average height to even fit in a seat. If I'm forced to travel for work, I have to either be very uncomfortable or pay out of my pocket because the company doesn't want to pay for first class. My knees dig into that little metal rod the seat back pouches have or they go into the armrest in front of me, it's absurd how small cabins are now.
- jeffdavis 9y agoSo why should we make all seats bigger and all flights more expensive?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Retra 9y agoMaybe people want cheap flights because they can reliably anticipate having a miserable experience.
- kgwgk 9y agoDo they pay more for a bigger seat on their next flight?
- ilyanep 9y agoI'm generally all for government regulations, especially when the market is such that true competition isn't really possible, but here I have to entirely blame the consumer. There are more than sufficient airlines on major routes for competition (and you can see this when they get into fare sales for stuff like LAX-ORD for $50). Consumers could be flying airlines like Southwest and Virgin. The fact that they instead choose to fly on airlines like Frontier and Spirit shows that they don't actually care to spend the extra money to have reasonable seats or service. I especially have to scoff at tech workers, who don't lack the money to make their travel experience more pleasant, but still take redeyes to save money and then complain about how much they hate travelling. I feel like the people who are fighting for regulations on seat sizes don't understand that those regulations will cause ticket prices to go up. If you're fine with paying extra for a bigger seat, that's cool, but you can also already do that today (Economy Plus or First) without any political fighting. All you'll be doing is removing access to flying for the poorest people. As for the safety issue, I'm no expert and I haven't seen the original complaint, but the FAA already has a regulation about the maximum time it can take to evacuate a plane (and therefore a limit on the number of seats per door on the plane, effectively). This hits the airlines with no first class cabin hardest, as they actually can't pack the entire 737 full of their standard economy seat.
- GordonS 9y ago> but you can also already do that today (Economy Plus or First) True, but there is generally a big increase in price. Premium Economy is generally twice the price of Economy. Regulations to push up the Economy seat pitch to a safe level would increase prices for Economy tickets, but given the small size difference, the price increase should be rather modest.
- ilyanep 9y agoI wonder if you're conflating non-US carriers' Premium Economy (usually about the same size as US domestic First Class) with US carriers' "Economy plus" or similar (which is basically 4ish inches more of pitch than Economy at the same width). You can generally get the latter for a transcontinental US flight for about $200ish extra.
- jeffdavis 9y agoSmoking in public places was banned because it's annoying/unpleasant for a lot of people. But they didn't just say that, they called it a safety issue. This is the same thing. People are uncofortable, and they want to frame it as a safety issue.
- GordonS 9y ago> Smoking in public places was banned because it's annoying/unpleasant for a lot of people. But they didn't just say that, they called it a safety issue Eh... no. Yes, smoking was annoying and unpleasant for a lot of people, but 2nd hand smoke is absolutely a safety issue.
- jeffdavis 9y agoMaybe, but that's not why it was bannned. It was banned because it's unpleasant. Tons of things are safety issues that get little attention. Second-habd smoke got tons of attention.
- dpatrick86 9y agoI think the evidence is pretty strong at this point that 2nd hand smoke has real health consequences.
- jeffdavis 9y agoBut that's not why it was banned. See my other comment.
- whiddershins 9y agoThe parent comment is mostly correct, at least according to the Slate article here: https://slate.janrainsso.com//static/server.html?origin=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.slate.com%2Farticles%2Fhealth_and_science%2Fmedical_examiner%2F2017%2F02%2Fsecondhand_smoke_isn_t_as_bad_as_we_thought.html https://slate.janrainsso.com//static/server.html?origin=http...
- 9y ago
- cordite 9y agoMy company isn't going to pay for leg room. Much of the people I meet at airports are doing so for business, not personal.
- phreeza 9y agoYea i think that is a large part of the problem, a kind of variation of the principle agent problem. Either your company forces you to take the cheapest option, so you cannot take into account legroom, or your company doesn't care, and you don't either since it isn't your money, so the airlines can charge ridiculous markups for extra legroom. Google seems to have a good intermediate policy where you can keep money you save on one trip and use it for upgrades on future travel.
- laydn 9y agoI would really like to see a study of the economics of the smaller legroom. My napkin math tells me if you remove two rows of seats from an all-economy 737, every remaining seat would get an extra 2.5-3 inches of legroom, which is significant. I wonder how much revenue would this change cost to a major airline.
- tacostakohashi 9y agoSeems easy enough to work out with further napkin maths - such planes usually have 24 rows or so, so 2 rows is almost 10% of the capacity / revenue lost (or, at least, you'd need to be getting 10% more for your remaining seats to break even). Or, in absolute terms - 2 rows = 12 seats, so if you imagine $100 fares, with a few flights per day, you could easily be looking at 5 or 10 thousand dollars a plane per day.
- laydn 9y agoWell, that assumes all planes are always 100% utilized, which is probably not the case.
- tacostakohashi 9y agoSure, but it's the main case worth thinking about, because from the airline's perspective, when the plane is 100% utilized the fares are highest so that's when the extra 2 rows make the biggest difference. From the customer's perspective, nobody cares about small seats if the seat next to you is empty anyway.
- ebalit 9y agoIt might be possible to adapt the layout based on utilization. Fold the first rows and move every rows forward a bit. Doing this while minimizing the weight and complying with regulations is seems challenging though.
- pgrote 9y agoIt appears 80% and above is the norm. http://aviationdb.net/aviationdb/SeatUtilizationByCarrierQuery#SUBMIT http://aviationdb.net/aviationdb/SeatUtilizationByCarrierQue...
- jccalhoun 9y agoIt isn't just the seats. Every time I see I'm going to be on an Embraer I cringe because I can't even stand up in those. If I ever meet the person responsible for that I will have some strong words for him/her.
- danellis 9y agoWhat's the goal of reducing the width of seats? The cumulative reduction can't be enough to fit in another seat, even on a wide body aircraft.
- tacostakohashi 9y agoIt is enough - on 777 in economy class, you can do 9 abreast (the typical option, 3 + 3 + 3), or 10 abreast (3 + 4 + 3), which airlines are starting to do now.
- danellis 9y agoHow? If they went from 18.5" to 17", they'd need to have had more than 11 seats already for that to make room for another seat.
- valuearb 9y agoI don't think there is any attempt to reduce width on narrow body planes, on them seat width is basically determined by cabin width. 17 inches means you are on a Boeing 737 derivant, 18 inches means you are on a Airbus A318/319/320 derivant. The decline in average width probably means a higher percentage of 737 flights. That increase could be driven by retirement of older planes such as MD-80s that had an 18 inch seat width.
- Zelmor 9y agoThis is not an issue in Europe, as much as I can tell. The seats are acceptable, and the people are much less inclined to be overweight.
- GordonS 9y agoI'm 6", not overweight, and from Europe: seat width and pitch is a big issue for me. Economy seat width is typically an uncomfortable 17-18 inches, and pitch typically a painful 31". I have to fly long haul in economy with work (who won't pay for anything else), so my choice is either several hours of pain and discomfort, or to pay a large sum to upgrade myself - if the fare is even upgradable. Bring on the regulation!
- chiph 9y agoWhile the overweight-passenger issue is a real thing, in this case the seat pitch affects people who are taller. 28" (711mm) seat pitch (which includes the thickness of the seat), doesn't leave much room if your femur is longer than that. So all the Dutch and Scandinavian fliers would really suffer on a 4+ hour flight.
- zaroth 9y agoRegulations can be used appropriately to stop a race to the bottom, and I think airline seats are a good example. When credit card companies started tweaking terms and conditions to make their cards more and more hostile to consumers, it's hard to be the company that still offers the "right" terms (e.g. Payments above the minimum apply to the highest interest balances first) when most consumers don't even understand what I just wrote. Similar with airline shopping, seat pitch just isn't visible enough, and even if it was right there next to the price, do most shoppers understand what 28" pitch really means? A perfectly functioning free market relies on perfect information available to the consumer. Today, we get a price and (usually) a brand name and that's about it. So competition is almost entirely on price. In cases like these, it benefits everyone to make some regulations setting reasonable ground rules. Freeing airlines from having to compete against 28" seat pitch is like freeing credit card companies from having to compete against predatory terms and conditions. Yes of course this has an impact on the bottom line. It would marginally increase the cost of tickets the same way the CARD Act made it less profitable to issue cards to certain people, and the same way airbags make cars more expensive. There are other practices I disdain, like charging extra for a seat assignment or a boarding pass, but those are more visible when buying the ticket and I can more easily avoid it. I do think if we could get much better and clear labeling on the differences between available seats (pitch, width, recline, power, screen, entertainment, food) it would help a lot. But airline shopping is already very painful, data overload is a real problem.
- ilyanep 9y agoIf the problem is that the data is there but people don't understand it, then you'd see consumers flying a shitty budget airline like Spirit once and then going back to another airline. People will regularly come back to these budget airlines. I really do think that consumers' revealed preferences are just not what most people think they should be.
- zaroth 9y agoI can tell you for me, that's exactly what happened. I flew Spirit exactly once. I couldn't stop telling people how horric it was for weeks and absolutely I would never even consider flying with them again.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoAir travel has become a commodity. Not that it has to be, but most of the airlines approach it that way. Therefore, and the market parrots this, price is the driving force. "Race to the bottom" comes to mind. Simultaneously, most Westerns consider air travel a right. It's not a proper holiday unless a plane is involved. I'd be curious to know how much air travel is necessary, and how much is simply a choice. I suspect it's the ladder, though the market certainly acts like it's the former. Long to short, if it we're THAT bad (over a 3+ hr flight), less people would fly. That's not the case, is it? p.s. I think when you factor in body size, the seats are even more proportionally small. But that too is often a choice. Moral of the story? Human make bad choices. Not to worry i'll refrain from making a comment about politics :)
- angelic 9y agoIt's strange how Americans can complain about how enthusiastically they give up their rights and safety to corporations. I guarantee you that if a bill was introduced to enforce humane conditions on airline flights, it would be shot down for being communist anti-business government overreach. The same people who complain about inhumane conditions are often the same ones who perpetuate them.
- justboxing 9y agoAirlines seats shrinking, while waistlines are expanding. Seems like a recipe for an increase in the number of in-flight altercations.