5 ms·
The origin of the web was to disseminate scientific knowledge. The guardians of that knowledge- the journal publishers- have absolutely failed to make a viable
by dekhn 9y ago
The origin of the web was to disseminate scientific knowledge. The guardians of that knowledge- the journal publishers- have absolutely failed to make a viable business model out of this, while many companies who adopted the web made billions.
While I do not use Sci-Hub, I think that users who use it are doing so morally and ethically (in the sense of conscientious objection). i hope they are also willing to pay penalties if they are found to be violating copyright (this is generally considered a requirement for intential protest).
- TeMPOraL 9y agoSciHub shows the way papers should work on the Internet. The other day in a HN discussion, someone cited a paper in response to my comment. I was able, in 30 seconds, get to the full text of that paper, which allowed me to reevaluate my opinion in context of what I read. This is how science can, and should be useful for individuals. And beyond arXiv and SciHub, it generally isn't.
- benbreen 9y agoI'm an academic and fully making research open access. But when I read discussions like this I always wonder about the people who work at journals. The process of peer-review, copy-editing, and online publication is not something that can be done for free. Granted, the current journal publishers spend too much money on overhead, and I certainly don't support the for-profit ones like Elsevier that rake in huge profits. But I also don't see much allowance made for the fact that publishing research in a peer-reviewed format involves labor which should continue to be compensated in some way (incidentally, it's not entirely true that researchers themselves aren't compensated - publishing offers an indirect benefit but a real one in the sense that publications are directly linked to salary increases down the line).
- pizza 9y agoWould it make sense for the peer review to be uncoupled from the distribution? I don't know about if this were physical, but, digitally, if e.g. ACMEcorp serves the paper, and if review team 1, team 2, etc.. can all attach their signatures of peer review in e.g. PeerDB, doesn't that make the review more transparent and detangle incentives?
- JoshTriplett 9y ago> But when I read discussions like this I always wonder about the people who work at journals. The process of peer-review, copy-editing, and online publication is not something that can be done for free. Peer review is done by others in the field (peers), typically for free. Online publication is "where do I stick this PDF", and does not require per-paper work (or if it does that can be done by the author). That leaves us with copyediting, and in many cases, copyediting issues are caught by peer review rather than any paid editor.
- benbreen 9y agoI do peer review myself and am familiar with the model. IMO, when I'm contacted to review someone's work, the journal employee contacting me is performing a legitimate service. They did research to find my name and email and determine that I'm competent to assess the paper. They or another editor have also reviewed the paper in the first place to determine if it's worthy of being peer-reviewed at all, which requires some domain-specific knowledge. And if I pass on peer reviewing, they have to find another person to ask, and so on. Multiplied by dozens of papers, that can be a substantial amount of work. I also think that you underestimate the importance of copy-editors. It's not the job of a peer reviewer to make sure that the author uses an apostrophe properly, etc. There needs to be a specialist who is dedicated to catching those errors, particularly since, as you note, peer-reviewers aren't directly compensated so it's unfair to burden them with a whole other set of responsibilities.
- wongarsu 9y agoEven if we don't put all the copy-editing burden on the author (it's their reputation that is affected by the mistakes), the costs for organizing peer review and copy-editing could be covered by a fairly small submission fee, or alternatively donations or the sale of hard-copies. You could even offer freemium models where anyone can read the papers for free, but value-add options are sold to libraries and universities (integration into library catalog, better search, etc).
- benbreen 9y ago
- wbl 9y agoMSP does all of this for quite reasonable rates.
- WalterSear 9y ago> The process of peer-review, copy-editing, and online publication I'm confused that you aren't aware of this but, peer review and copy-editing is by-and-large done by other academics, not journal publishers, and, at most, for what amounts to an honorarium. And online publication is not a job, per se. We automated it a long time ago. Teenages have tumblr blogs now. There is no reason why the practical aspects of online journal curation could not be handled by a very small team of people working in the IT departments of a few universities. Journal article publication may contribute to academic careers, but that has nothing to do with the publishers' involvement: it has to do with the quality of the journal, which is driven by the academics in writing and reviewing for it. Simply put, journal publishers are >entirely< overhead.
- benbreen 9y agoSee my comment below. Copy-editing isn't performed by other academics (or at least it shouldn't be given their other responsibilities, in my view). And although peer review relies on specialists volunteering their time, finding and vetting those specialists still requires work. I'm not trying to say that the current publishing model is defensible, but I am pointing out that running a high quality peer reviewed journal still requires at least one or two dedicated workers. Whether you think they should be paid for their time or expected to volunteer is a different issue, but we shouldn't pretend that the whole apparatus is an illusion created by greedy publishers.
- dekhn 9y agoI always - always - sent my paper to at least one non-coauthor for a final copy-edit before being submitted. Also, no editor at any journal (I've published ~20 papers) made any edits to my papers.
- benbreen 9y agoThis must be highly field-specific then. I published a peer-reviewed paper a couple months ago that came back with around 50 suggested copy edits, as well as a few paragraphs of suggested changes from the journal editor. And then it went through the process again in a lesser form at the page proofs stage. Granted, a lot of those suggested edits were to make it conform to a somewhat arbitrary and tedious house style, but it also caught things that I or the other people I shared the paper with didn't see.
- peteretep 9y agoNapster apparently forged a reasonable business model for music publishers, let's hope this forges one for journals.
- Ar-Curunir 9y agoThe companies do not recompense the reviewers or editors meaningfully. They ride only on the coattails of prestigious venues, with all the work done by volunteers.
- Ar-Curunir 9y agoThe companies do not recompense the reviewers or editors meaningfully. They ride only on the coattails of prestigious venues, with all the work done by volunteers.
- dekhn 9y agoYes, I agree completely. I'd hope that the arXiv model would win - making SciHub unnecessary in the process. It hasn't yet.
- agumonkey 9y agoAlso if you're motivated and dig well enough, you'll find plenty of copies on college classes lectures websites. Albeit nowhere near scihub but still..
- 4bpp 9y ago> While I do not use Sci-Hub, I think that users who use it are doing so morally and ethically (in the sense of conscientious objection). i hope they are also willing to pay penalties if they are found to be violating copyright (this is generally considered a requirement for intential protest). I'm having trouble expanding this into a sensible-sounding general moral principle. Does this hold regardless of how large the penalties are? (Relevant considering the often very high punitive damages for copyright infringement at least in the case of entertainment media.) Is it specific to some kinds of laws or government system or fully universal in the sense that somebody protesting the policies of a stereotypical dictatorship is also morally obliged to be willing to be shot/flogged/whatever the corresponding punishment under that system is?
- dekhn 9y agoI agree with your comments. It's something a social studies teacher mentioned when I was in high school, and it never completely made sense to me, but it is the established principle. You can see more about the reasoning here: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/civil-disobedience/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/civil-disobedience/