17 ms·
Twitter Fails to Grow Its Audience Again
- crispytx 9y agoTwitter's problem is that they let Ev Williams walk away from the company, and then he goes and creates Medium. Medium could have been a product of Twitter Inc., and then no one would be talking about their lack of growth.
- JonFish85 9y agoIsn't Medium struggling in its own ways, cutting costs & laying people off? If it was a Twitter product, I imagine the stockholders would want it shut down, seeing it as a distraction to the main Twitter product.
- CM30 9y agoYeah, Medium's having trouble finding a good business model itself: https://blog.medium.com/renewing-mediums-focus-98f374a960be https://blog.medium.com/renewing-mediums-focus-98f374a960be It's got the same general issues as Twitter has. No clear business model, a more limited audience than the creators of the service want it to have and a severe with too much noise and hostility (especially when you go away from recommended articles to random ones).
- crispytx 9y agoI think Medium's financial problem is that they aren't charging for their services. My blog is hosted by Medium at my own custom domain, and the only thing they charged me for was the SSL certificate. They ought to charge for that like Wordpress.com does. But yeah, Medium has some problems and a long way to go, but it has so much potential. One of their problems in my opinion is that most of the articles that show up in your feed at Medium.com have a BuzzFeed like quality to them. They should integrate some sort of RSS functionality into the feed, and start adding all of the best blogs, regardless of whether or not they happen to be hosted on Medium. But that's just what I would do, not that anyone cares ;) For example, if you follow the "startups" tag on Medium, you ought to get cool stuff in your feed like IndieHackers. They could include IndieHackers and great blogs like it in their feed, and if people happen to click on those stories, they could just redirect people to those sites. So it would be sort of like Reddit, but instead of people submitting links, the editors at Medium would currate what gets added from other sites, and Medium.com users could obviously add blogs to their own personal feeds via RSS.
- untilHellbanned 9y agoMedium will get acquired by twitter in next few years.
- euroclydon 9y agoTwitter’s business troubles contrast with its increased profile in the political world, as U.S. President Donald Trump frequently uses the platform to reach the public in an unfiltered manner. Despite his daily fusillade of tweets, Trump hasn’t helped Twitter’s growth in its home country.
- eb0la 9y agoMaybe he is one of the reasons 2mm users left the platform... Not the only one, but one factor.
- dforrestwilson 9y agoTwitter is such a fascinating platform. I use it on a professional basis and I really enjoy it. I get the opportunity to interact with the rock stars of my field. These are people whom I would probably never have the chance to ping otherwise. I consume more media on TWTR than FB at this point because I trust the people I follow to be great "taste makers". Clearly the company has some value, but how they fix the business model is a big question mark. I wonder if the Microsoft-LinkedIn complex would be the most natural home for Twitter at this point.
- mox1 9y agoI mean interact is a strong term here. You send 0-140 characters towards them and they get to send 0-140 back. Yes I'm sure sometimes meaningful conversations happen, but I doubt that is the norm. I get to interact with a rock star if I hang out near the exit door after the concert. I can shout at them and (s)he might say something back. If I'm lucky and it's a cool musician we might be able to have a brief conversation... As a professional, if I wanted to interact with a leader in my field on a meaningful level I would e-mail, write them, attend a speech by them, etc. etc.
- jerrylives 9y agoYou've clearly never used the product in a while because you can DM more than 140 characters. Who is to say the value of "meaningful" is dependent on the number of characters? You have no idea what you are talking about. Go to a speech? What if you're in another country? What if their email isn't publicly available? What if they prefer to communicate via twitter precisely because its so low-stakes and informal? I know many devs who love it precisely because of that. Brevity is key.
- icebraining 9y agoPersonal attacks are not allowed in HN. Your last line crosses over what's acceptable here.
- deleted 9y ago
- sickbeard 9y agoMaybe the audience is already grown? I mean it's being used by presidents and heads of states and is a major communication tool for businesses and governments. Maybe it's just not hip anymore.
- AznHisoka 9y agoTwitter needs to: 1. Charge businesses that tweet $20/month. ok, so you are a small business and can't afford it? nobody will miss you and you will contribute less noise to Twitter anyway. 2. limit the number of links you can tweet a day based on your overall popularity. you can still post an unlimited number of replies and tweets with no links. 3. show less tweets from unverified accounts that never reply or interact with other users. in other words, throttle those bots and broadcasters. I believe the noise problem is a huge issue in twitter. it gradully causes people to pay less attention to their feed and as a result less attention to ads. i would even go as far as banning apps like Buffer and social schedulers from Twitter. They are a net negative for users (note: I said users not marketers)
- unethical_ban 9y agoBusinesses would have to get some kind of value-add (honey) otherwise literally everyone would tweet as "Owner at Business" and just happen to tweet about their business all the time. Regulating that would be a nightmare.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AznHisoka 9y agoif you are not a business nor journalist/celeb you cant tweet more than x links a day.
- pjc50 9y agoThat ruins it: the businesses and celebs are mostly posting pictures, or some businesses are using it for tech support, while some of the most interesting accounts are just streams of links from random people.
- na85 9y ago>and as a result less attention to ads Why is this bad for users?
- 9y ago
- eb0la 9y agoQ1 and Q2 MAU are the same: 328 million worldwide. Only in the US -2 million MAU less than in the first quarter. Not tragic, in my opinion.
- wongarsu 9y agoAnd 328 million is 4.5% of all humans. That sounds like a pretty solid audience.
- johannes1234321 9y ago... but how many of those 328 million are in fact bots?
- grenoire 9y agoAnd those are not all humans.
- intoverflow2 9y agoAnyone still actually having a good time on this service? Just feels a cacophony of (US Centric) political screaming and foot stamping from both sides the past two years. Just utterly draining to scroll through my timeline some days and I only follow artists, devs and designers. I grew to rely on Twitter to find interesting content after Google killed Reader. But starting to think it really needs a big "Politics" checkbox in settings and an algorithm to filter it all out. I'd rather get my news and politics from elsewhere. Twitter isn't even good for news because most of the time you enter half way into the conversation and have to dig to figure out what people are upset or gloating over today. Filtered words was a good first step but a lot of politics talk doesn't actually mention the words exactly. Edit - Mass replying to the careful follow question: I already choose who to follow carefully (Current count is 1000) and unfollow if it's really tiresome. No one I follow is a pure internet personality or journo, they're all people who actually do things outside of comment online. To me it's a case of I want to read my followers at their best (Posting interesting and creative work), but can't handle them at their worst (Political hot takes).
- influx 9y agoI moved to https://feedbin.com/ https://feedbin.com/ after Google killed Reader and stopped supporting me as a customer. Feedbin supported the use case I had which was nicely aggregating my RSS feeds. YMMV.
- pjc50 9y agoPolitics is kind of ruining it. As is the fallout from politics - harassment. You can never be sure whether saying something and getting visibility is going to result in being quote-retweeted by a hostile party sending their followers to have a go at you. Some of whom seem to be bots, or multi-purpose Trump/Brexit promotion accounts.
- levesque 9y agoFollow people that only tweet about stuff that interests you. Don't hesitate to unfollow or mute people. You can tweak your follows and end up with a pretty low signal to noise ratio.
- skewart 9y agoTwitter is so disappointingly annoying to use. Reply threads are a pain. Tweetstorms get old. And all too often there is way too much spam. However, there are amazing communities of people sharing interesting content and having great conversations. Twitter needs to realize that there value prop is the community using it and not the app itself. They need to make radical design and product changes to make for a better user experience if they want to grow. The vast majority of internet products evolve significantly as they grow, surfing the wave of changing user behavior and taste as they reach new markets.
- visarga 9y agoScrolling is very inefficient on Twitter - to read the equivalent of a single screen on reddit or HN means to scroll 20x more on T. When reading comments I have to be very careful not to click outside the column because it gets closed and position lost. Another big one - you can't filter out the political crap from the domain specific stuff.
- icebraining 9y agoWhen reading comments I have to be very careful not to click outside the column because it gets closed and position lost. That's also my experience - I have to be very careful not to click on anything, lest I lose my position on the thread. I don't understand how the developers themselves don't get frustrated about this, frankly.
- freehunter 9y agoYou think the developers of Twitter use Twitter?
- mrkrabo 9y agoThat's actually one of my concerns. As a heavy Twitter user for like 8 years (I spend at least one hour a day in that app) it is obvious to me that those involved with Twitter do not use the product at all.
- tormeh 9y agoTwitter is amazing, but it needs to ditch the 140 chars, improve discoverability, and get more modest in its expectations. Twitter is an interest network, where you follow interesting people and read what they write, re-tweet what they write and sometimes interact with them. Given that a lot of people don't have that much interest in things that can be expressed in Twitter form, Twitter has a low ceiling on how big it can get. Most sports fans would rather watch sports than following an athlete. I think Twitter should try being better at what their users use it as.
- kasey_junk 9y agoI think I'd probably stop using Twitter (the only social network I use) if they ditched the 140 character format. I don't want to see long form facebook style posts there, its literally their differentiation.
- tormeh 9y agoI would say that their differentiation of Twitter is that all posts are public and connections are uni-directional. They could implement 140+ using the same kind of GUI that's already there for text-as-picture, which is already widely used.
- kasey_junk 9y agoSorry let me rephrase. Its their differentiation to me. I don't want to see 140+ character posts. I like the terseness of the format.
- pzone 9y agoWell if they remove the 140 character limit I'll start using Twitter again. Looks like they're breaking even.
- kasey_junk 9y agoSo umm exactly what they are being criticized for in the article?
- wongarsu 9y agoMy primary reason for not using twitter is the lack of a Windows client that I like. All I want is to see tweets from people I'm following in a compact, not screen-filling, undistracting way. Just something simple to keep up with the tweets of a handful of people. All such clients I could find are discontinued and broken by now. The current clients are either are oriented at power-users (Tweetdeck & co) or turn what could be 8 lines of text into a screen-filling experience that you have to dedicate time to to follow (official Twitter windows client & co). I don't care enough to code something myself, so I just don't bother with Twitter.
- nimchimpsky 9y agojust go to https://mobile.twitter.com/home https://mobile.twitter.com/home
- vxNsr 9y agoThis is what I get[0] which is much worse. [0]http://i.imgur.com/sJ6qAQE.png http://i.imgur.com/sJ6qAQE.png
- nimchimpsky 9y agomuch worse than what ? Its simply the tweets of the people you follow - no fluff.
- vxNsr 9y agoMuch worse than the desktop version, I can only see two tweets the info density is terrible.
- nimchimpsky 9y agoIts only two tweets if each tweet has a picture attached. And I can only read one thing at a time, I prefer scrolling than being bombard with ads and other shit.
- 9y ago
- akilism 9y ago328 million monthly active users and still not happy.
- CM30 9y agoI read somewhere that the issue with Twitter is that its platform doesn't have the level of mainstream appeal the likes of Facebook or Instagram have. It's good for journalists and influencers sure, but for the average Joe it's not as intuitive to use.
- SonicSoul 9y agoside point, but i really hope Twitter doesn't try to mimic FB type algorithms that serve content im likely to click vs content as is from people I follow. This includes withholding updates so that users keep pulling the lever to get a trickle of content. I hate it so much when i F5 on a window in Facebook (or hit the back button) and completely different front page loads.
- glastra 9y agoThis is probably happening already. The feed itself is no longer sorted by date (you get some highlights that you can dismiss but hey, here they are again), and then even content liked (not retweeted) by people you follow shows up. This makes absolutely no sense for the user, as it happens on Facebook. I assume it's a way to tackle the lack of original content generated from individual users / content consumers (e.g. friends you follow).
- AznHisoka 9y agothis is an elephant in the room. most people simply do not produce any useful content. they just auto tweet links or comment on something random and specific that is uninteresting.
- sp332 9y agoBut on twitter, it doesn't bother me if most people aren't interesting. I only follow the people I want to follow.
- fgandiya 9y ago> Twitter began investing heavily in video, aiming to draw a more mainstream set of users and premium advertising deals What's with this whole "pivot to video" trend among websites? Why is it preferred to text which is probably easier to write, needs less network and is more accessible than a large number of videos (which don't have captions)?
- swiley 9y agoFirefox/chrome is the new television. People don't want to read they just want to scroll and watch videos and get emotional.
- Eridrus 9y agoVideo ads pay much more.
- kasey_junk 9y agoAnd autoplay video jukes the stats to make it look like the consumers are more engaged in video ads than they are in banners.
- silverbax88 9y agoAutoplay ads/videos are the fraudulent lie that corporations are attempting to use to inflate their ad impressions. It will come back to bite them.
- fwn 9y agoTwitter can embrace video, which is a new format, without the need to alter their foundation, the text fragment feature.
- Tistel 9y agoTwitter owns https://www.mopub.com https://www.mopub.com an ad exchange too. I think its one of the bigger ones. Ad exchanges are the things that provide revenue to app devs. Basically, when you open a free(mium) app there is a market bidding for the right to show you an ads. There is all kinds of tech trying to characterize you based on your phone's id so you see relevant ads. Having an audience of 320+ million people and ad tech powering a significant portion of the app world seems like nice problems to have.
- yttrium 9y agoPart of the problem is the sheer amount of racism and harassment. How many times do twitter eggs and other hate speech peddlers get reported without anything happening? Why does Twitter drag their feet over this? Nobody will miss the neo-nazis.
- j_s 9y agoAre there any desktop or self-hosted tools designed to archive my Twitter feed? Every time I remember seeing something useful it is nearly impossible to get back to.
- yakshaving_jgt 9y ago[opens Twitter] EVERYONE: How dare you be a cisgender, heterosexual, able-bodied, white male?!?!??!?! ME: …Ok then. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- mrkrabo 9y agoYou're not following the correct people. I agree it's sad that almost everybody involved with tech is a die-hard liberal :P I'd love to get my tech news from Twitter but I simply don't like to be told how to think regarding politics, which tech people do all day. So I just read Hacker News...
- librvf 9y agoI don't mind die-hard liberals who are actually open-minded believers in individual rights and equality. The whole white, het, cisgender stuff is coming from intersectional feminism, which is anything but a liberal philosophy.
- tomjen3 9y agoChange who you follow and block every single on of those words (well maybe not male, too many false positives).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Rjevski 9y agoWhat I don't understand is how can they burn so much money to still not be profitable despite millions of users. Their platform is already built and they've got a way to monetise it (promoted tweets). Why don't they just cut their costs down to actually make enough profit from those promoted tweets to become sustainable, instead of burning through even more money endlessly with their useless "experiments"?
- criddell 9y agoTwitter has something like 3000 employees. I'd love to see a breakdown of where they are. Before I heard this number, I would have guessed they had 300 employees (based on Instagram having 20 employees when Facebook bought them). At some point, I think Twitter is going to accept that they are pretty much done growing. Shift some of their user acquisition budget to user retention. Make Twitter better for those of us that love it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dirtyaura 9y agoBased on their last 10-Q filing, I would estimate that - ~500 in operations (data centers, sysops, related managers) - ~1000 in R&D (developers, designers, researchers, and related managers) - ~1000 in Sales and Marketing - ~500 in general & administrative (finance, legal, H&R, IT support, management, misc) If you compare to e.g. Google, this sounds pretty similar split.
- criddell 9y agoEvery one of those numbers sounds an order of magnitude too big to me. Is it wrong to compare Twitter at 3000 people with Instagram at 20?
- dirtyaura 9y agoYes, I think it is wrong to compare them directly. I think Twitter has room to cut employee count, but not by order of magnitude. Instagram had 20 at the time of acquisition, I bet it's much bigger now. They had a single product, no ad tech platforms, no working business model. Twitter has multiple products and several (acquired, partly failed) ad platforms. Also Instagram were able to build on top of modern cloud technologies and scalable infrastructure services like AWS. Twitter was launched same year that AWS, so I think Twitter has paid a price by building it's own infrastructure. Instagram likely used a lot of outsourced people too to run all non-core things. Both Instagram and Whatsapp were clearly amazing, well-functioning technology teams to be able to execute with such small teams, but they were still very early in developing their revenue engines. I think employee count and costs are not Twitter's biggest problem per se. They still have quite good financial situation, $4B in cash and equivalents, IIRC. The problem is that they haven't found a working ad model. Performance marketing has made both Google and Facebook the revenue engines that business has never seen before. Twitter could still do something similar but on the smaller scale.
- jaxondu 9y agoDiscovery for new content/people to follow on Twitter's iOS app (Explore tab) is appallingly bad. Its astonishing that they made so little improvement in this area after so many years. Its sad when you compare with what you get on Weibo, its China clone.
- Taylor_OD 9y agoI got off twitter because it felt like they were constantly changing the app to make it worse / more covered in ads but mostly because I didn't like the way it was changing my thinking. It's the first app I've felt the pull to compulsively check and I really didn't like that.
- richardknop 9y agoI have just deleted Twitter app from my mobile phone today. I am getting fed up with constant push notifications I don't care about. It seems like push notifications from other social apps are more relevant, notifications from Twitter rarely are about something I care about.
- kbullaughey 9y agoIs there any way to deduplicate tweets? Some accounts seem to have the same tweets scheduled over and over again.
- agumonkey 9y agoMaybe it's naturally limited from it's format and doesn't need to grow more. - I like the website for quick feed and "real time" data - I wished the logic was thinner, it's still a heavy site in a way - maybe a 3 real columns UX would make the thing blossom
- overcast 9y agoTwitter should just focus 100% on real time news. That's the only time I've ever seen anything valuable come from it. If a major site is down, it's generally on there instantly. If some event just happened in the world, it's on there instantly. All this other nonsense, interacting with celebrities, businesses, or coding "rockstars" is just noise. Overhaul the horrendous UI, focus on world news ONLY.
- xj9 9y agokeep up the failure twitter! i love it. every time they make a serious mistake and alienate users, the federated timeline on my private mastodon server is flooded with new people. quite beautiful actually. fun to see how people show up ready to fight only to find that there are a lot more ways to interact with people, if you can believe it. fights break out. people show up to try to cool the situation down. some people decide to stick around. lovely. https://joinmastodon.org https://joinmastodon.org https://cybre.space https://cybre.space https://ephemeral.glitch.social https://ephemeral.glitch.social https://sunshinegardens.org https://sunshinegardens.org
- protomyth 9y agoTheir usability keeps going downhill. This showing me other people's favorites thing is one step too far. I know they must feel a bit putout that the community invented the retweet, but making favorites act like retweets is just dumb. Also, the amount of data the service uses is obscene. The auto-play even if I have the preference not to is a cell plan killer.
- Flow 9y agoBut is it a safe space yet? :) Autoblocking list bots going crazy can't hardly be a good thing for growth. Facebook with their groups concept feels like a better model than the free-for-all model Twitter uses. And I've always felt that text-only and limiting to 140 chars is a great way to ensure there's misunderstanding between people.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoWhat if a company like Amazon bought Twitter? They could also charge for accounts. Something like more than 100 followers you need to pay.
- cJ0th 9y agoInstead of focusing on growth they should focus on their business model. More users cause more noise first and foremost. How is noise going to help long term sustainability?
- skoocda 9y agoThis comes up semi-regularly when Twitter is mentioned on HN, but I've moved all my Twitter attention over to Nuzzel and have enjoyed the change. Twitter started to feel like such a poor return on my time due to the format- having an aggregator makes a huge difference. It partially solves the clutter problem of having hundreds of Twitter followees, and partially solves the problem of not wanting to check Twitter perpetually. What I don't understand is why Twitter hasn't implemented more direct methods to see the generally/statistically good content. Anyone remember 'Texts from last night' and 'Fuck my life' and the like? They had this _incredible_ feature that allowed you to sort by top posts of the week, or even, can you believe it- the month! Nuzzel provides this as well, but it doesn't have much effect unless you follow enough people to decimate your normal Twitter experience.
- byuu 9y agoAnd here we all really thought their recent redesign to add border-radius: 50% to literally everything on the site (avatars, text boxes, buttons, etc) and to strip all contrast away from the icons by hollowing them all out would bring about massive growth of the platform! How many more times do they have to listen to exactly what their users want and add things like more complicated reply-to functionality that most can't seem to figure out still, live auto-playing sports video on the frontpage regardless of your interests, temporary automatic bans for using adult language in replies to verified accounts when yours isn't, moments, reordering your timeline so that it's no longer chronological, hiding tweets behind "show more replies" (with no opt-out), hiding even more tweets behind a second "show even more sensitive replies" (still with no opt-out), invading others' discretion and flooding your timeline with other peoples' likes, replacing the dreaded egg avatar with a person silhouette, etc before the platform starts to grow? /s
- cwyers 9y ago> A long-term turnaround depends on Twitter expanding its audience. That number stands at 328 million monthly active users -- the same as in the prior quarter, the San Francisco-based company said in a statement Thursday. Revenue fell 4.7 percent and the company’s net loss also widened, affected by a $55 million writedown of the value of its investment in SoundCloud, the German music streaming service. This is insanity. This is utter insanity. Twitter is at over 300 million monthly users. How have we created a system where that's not enough? Twitter is incredibly relevant. The president's Tweets are basically driving the news cycle now. And yet it needs to grow? Why? (Okay, okay, I understand why -- to feed all the VCs that invested in it. I just... ugh.)
- kosievdmerwe 9y agoBecause at the end of the day companies are supposed to make a profit and Twitter isn't managing that. They also aren't managing growth, which people believe is a good reason to delay profitability in favor of a future larger amount of profit. This is hardly ridiculous. EDIT: and moreover this is a situation that has existed for multiple quarters now, adding to the reasonableness of the frustration and lack of trust in the future of Twitter.
- cwyers 9y agoCould Twitter be profitable if they weren't spending so much money on new customer acquisition?
- kosievdmerwe 9y agoI honestly don't know. I heard mutterings that they can become profitable if they become more lean (layoffs and less office extravagance).
- shostack 9y agoAs an important comparison, Facebook just posted 2B monthly actives in Q2. From an advertising industry standpoint, the space has quickly become consolidated such that Google and FB own the vast majority of ad inventory in the market. Advertisers, particularly large advertisers who contribute a substantial portion of this revenue. As a buyer, I can state from a position of experience that managing an ad buy at scale is just as important as potential performance. If I'm an agency for example, and I can reach massively more people on FB than Twitter, I'm likely going to focus my efforts there even if ROI may suffer from diminishing returns to some extent. A big part of the reason for that is it would take significantly more hours to setup, manage and report on Twitter (or any other ad platform) separately than it would to just focus on FB in that case. So from a business level, the overhead of managing multiple ad platforms can often be a critical deciding factor in addition to just the actual ad performance. Time is money, and lots of people hours cost lots of money, particularly those people who have the technical specialization to effectively manage digital media campaigns at scale. All of that is to explain why total ad spend is increasingly consolidating around FB and Google. And that is REALLY bad news for Twitter from an investor standpoint because it puts a big cap on their growth potential.
- abiox 9y agotwitter's core interaction mechanism was always ripe for trolling, brigading and other abuse. the ui in general is pretty bad.
- davidbwire 9y agoTwitter is it's own enemy. There's no way to adjust video quality for a smoother streaming experience. Twitter Lite has a horrible user experience; you have to manually click on each image to load and the images seem to be full quality which defeats the purpose of data saving. Why can't they build an app like Facebook Lite? Facebook lite is small in size to download (less than 1.5MB) and has nicely compressed images and videos.
- iandanforth 9y agoI use twitter's web app primarily with heavy editing with uBlock origin. I don't see trends, or suggestions or moments. I block 99% of accounts that show up as 'promoted'. I always click 'show less often' for 'In case you missed' and 'Who you should follow'. With all that, I love it. It's indispensable for keeping up with machine learning news. The core product is the best curated news feed around, but you have to do the curation. Almost all the content twitter itself pushes is noise. To survive twitter needs to start serving ads that are extremely tailored to me and my feed. Just like with google, the quality of ad results needs to match or exceed the quality of organic results.
- altotrees 9y agoThey brought on the global creative director from Beats by Dre. He had a hand in some interesting campaigns, but clearly it didn't do the trick. Twitter is still insanely enmeshed in the American cultural fabric right now. Any newscast or radio show usually mentions it, businesses and publications fight for impressions, etc. There have Been multiple times I think Twitter is finally on it's way out, but it somehow remains relevant.
- pier25 9y agoThe problem with Twitter is that it has an identity crisis. It wants to be as massive as Facebook but the way it works is only attractive to a minority. For example the 140 characters limit which was a novelty at the launch is more of a nuisance than anything. It's very common that users are replying to themselves to be able to say more. The other big problem is noise. For example I recently started following one of the NPM devs and my feed was flooded with LGBT content. This is not Twitter's fault, but the way its users are using Twitter has become part of the culture. Twitter could probably solve those two problems, but at the same time it would destroy what Twitter is about for its current users. The only solution for Twitter is to realise it can't really cater to a mainstream audience and to become profitable it needs to lower its costs.
- StreamBright 9y agoShould not be a big surprise, Twitter has an absolutely questionable policy when it comes to content filtering.
- dkrich 9y agoTo me it seems that Twitter is less of a back-and-forth engagement platform like Facebook, Snapchat, or Instagram, and more of a platform for anointed experts/celebrities to use as a megaphone to anyone who will listen. Accepting that, I wonder why Twitter doesn't charge people to use the service to either have a verified account or beyond some # of followers after which it's capped? Celebs obviously get a great deal of value from the service and have the means to pay, so why not charge them? I refuse to believe that there would be a noticeable decline in accounts if you had to pay some fee per, say, 30k followers.
- dkrich 9y agoTo me it seems that Twitter is less of a back-and-forth engagement platform like Facebook, Snapchat, or Instagram, and more of a platform for anointed experts/celebrities to use as a megaphone to anyone who will listen. Accepting that, I wonder why Twitter doesn't charge people to use the service to either have a verified account or beyond some # of followers after which it's capped? Celebs obviously get a great deal of value from the service and have the means to pay, so why not charge them? I refuse to believe that there would be a noticeable decline in accounts if you had to pay some fee per, say, 30k followers.
- unsoundInput 9y agoI'm wondering why they're getting more and more adamant that people register an account, even though a lot of people don't care about having an online persona outside of Facebook and wouldn't ever contribute anything to the platform. I honestly believe that could do much better by providing a good experience to people that just want to stay up-to-date and follow a few people that they find interesting.
- talmand 9y agoGotta pump up those numbers. Can't show growth without people signing up for accounts.
- unsoundInput 9y agoI don't buy it. At least two core products of the biggest advertisement company in the world have no problem providing you value and generating ad-revenue without you having to be logged in. Google and YouTube would be nowhere near the success they are if they'd force you to log in.
- thrillgore 9y agoI guess i'll be the only contrarian here and say that Twitter has become the preferred communication platform for some notable political figures (including the current Sitting US President). On that simple premise alone, I can't for good reason work up the nerve to use it anymore. There was a time when I relied on Twitter to get details about life in a rather medium-sized city. We had tweetups and I even used it for business networking. As it grew bigger, I felt less interested as the value increased on other platforms like Reddit and LinkedIn. Even now, I still find dedicated Subreddits more valuable than Twitter. To me, Twitter is now a space for low effort comments and input on media. I'm sure it works well for others, and good for you. But I have no time to cultivate relevant trends, and it seems philosophically wrong to suggest a platform should enable or mandate the culling of an audience. Especially since by design, Twitter is supposed to be the cross section of humanity (with its inherent downsides).
- f4rker 9y agoTwitter is like facebook but with less features, and broken.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoTwitter has been actively banning various accounts, usually alt-right but some even satirical in nature. They banned GodfreyElfwick for instance. Each time that happens, Twitter loses some of its appeal. They could very easily put more filtering power in the hands of their users, but don't (to give me more control over whose tweets show up as response to my tweets, which is the main complaint people have about accounts they vehemently disagree with).
- Cardiologist 9y agoThe twitter morality police who use their San Francisco Bay political lens to decide who should and should have a "platform" is losing users? Strange
- blister 9y agoTwitter has caused serious harm to myself and my family. I'm a big fan of the platform, but I've been "doxxed", harassed, and was even SWATed once by different people trying to get me to give them my username. I'd release it, except that'd be almost as big of a pain. I'd have to release a new edition of my book, change all my websites. Ugh. People are dicks. I wish I'd picked a less desirable handle.
- rchaud 9y agoEvery discussion on Twitter on HN talks about UX issues like the threaded comment layout, as though these are what's responsible for driving away Twitter's audience. I think the simple answer is that you don't actually have to ever visit Twitter to know what Trump, Nicki Minaj, Drake etc. are saying. Whatever is said on a tweet will be screen-capped and re-reported on your favourite gossip website, news site, Instagram page, reddit, etc. That's what you get with a 140-character limit. Whatever you said or pic you snapped can easily be reproduced on a different medium in its entirety.
- shostack 9y agoThat's a great point. Text and images are easy and damn near free to copy and distribute (unlike video). So it is very easy to copy content from Twitter and post it elsewhere (where those publishers can then monetize it themselves). Compare that to say...video hosted on YT/FB where, when embedded, can still include ads that allows those platforms to monetize people sharing their content offsite.
- good_vibes 9y agoI follow 44 accounts, a mixture of Eastern philosophy, interesting entrepreneurs/economists, Quanta/Nautilus, Patagonia, one design showcase, a few people in tech industry. Twitter is mostly noise, little signal. Social media in general is to be honest. I get a little value from each of the major platforms. Reddit and Instagram are my two favorites.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- investjtravolta 9y agoThe shares fell as much as 14 percent to $16.85? Lucky bird! Almost 60% of Twitter Top-100 audience is a cheap poor-quality imitation. The total number of unique level 1 bots is 310,537,272.