12 ms·
Google and a nuclear fusion company have developed a new algorithm
- MrQuincle 9y agoThere are two directions within the energy world that I don't completely get. One of them is hydrogen storage, the other nuclear fusion. From what I always understood is that the high-energy neutrons produced by the fusion reaction irradiate the surrounding structure and that there is still considerable nuclear waste (although lifetimes are better than with nuclear fission). Do the scientists not care or is this outdated info?
- openasocket 9y agoYou're thinking of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_activation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutron_activation You need to use materials that stand up well to neutron bombardment. Many materials upon neutron capture have a half life measured in seconds, which isn't a big deal. As nuclear waste disposal goes, this really isn't a concern.
- MrQuincle 9y agoOn this EU site they state that a site remains active for 50-100 years, https://www.euro-fusion.org/faq/does-fusion-give-off-radiation/ https://www.euro-fusion.org/faq/does-fusion-give-off-radiati.... I know it's better than fission, but still not nice. If is indeed seconds, then it doesn't matter of course. I was kind of hoping to understand more about material design in the recent scientific past with this question.
- pm90 9y agoThe comparison is not b/w fusion and a hypothetical waste free source of energy. Its b/w fusion and fission. The waste products of fission are much more dangerous, expensive to handle and we still haven't found foolproof, effective ways of disposing them. OTOH, danger from irradiated materials (whatever that is, this is the first time I'm hearing this TBH) doesn't seem very pressing. I highly doubt any of the irradiated stuff would have a half life of millions of years.
- wbl 9y agoHalf life is inversely proportional to radiation intensity. The big issue with fission waste products are the nucleotides radioactive enough to kill and long lived enough to be annoying, not the nasty ones that go away in a few decades or the almost inert ones.
- xrange 9y agoMight as well put a Wikipedia link here about the fission product isotopes and their half lives: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fission_product#Radioactivity_over_time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_fission_product#Radioa...
- Symmetry 9y agoThe neutrons coming from the fusion reactor do have the potential to make the surrounding material radioactive. But that depends on exactly what the surrounding material is, some elements will become dangerous when exposed to neutrons and some won't. An important part of designing a fusion powerplant, and one of the reasons it is difficult, is that you have to make sure that the materials you use can safely handle the neutrons coming from the fusion reaction without transmuting into dangerously radioactive forms. This is in contrast to a fission reactor where the fuel itself turns into dangerously radioactive elements when exposed to neutrons. EDIT: The exception is that fusion powerplant designers will want to surround the reactor with lithium in the hopes that it will absorb a neutron and turn into tritium. The tritium is then carefully gathered because it forms the the fuel for the reactor and it's hard to get except in a nuclear reactor.
- DennisP 9y agoI saw a presentation by the head of MIT's fusion department, in which he said that the waste would only need to be contained for several decades. It's very different from fission, where the fuel itself produces long-lived high level waste. With the reactor discussed in this article, the situation is even better, because it would use boron fusion. That reaction doesn't produce neutron radiation at all. There'd just be a tiny amount from side reactions.
- haterswillhate 9y agoWords like google facebook just put chills on my spine.. really scary words indeed
- JohnJamesRambo 9y agoGoogle didn't enter the race. They helped a company with some calculations.
- dang 9y agoOk, we changed the title to the first sentence of the article, which basically says that.
- grayhatter 9y agothank you! I was very confused... twice...
- quickben 9y agoOutside of the title being misleading, I'm sceptical. It's one thing to have the hardware for research, and completely other to have the expertise for the research. Google entered the self driving cars research, and we have yet to see them driven around. This heavily reminds me of Intel and their diversification, up until recently, they were in IoT, makers market and what not. One solid push from AMD and they jumped out of everything way too fast to track. Google seems the same with the nuclear fusion. They have the advertising money to throw around, but that just it, they are in different segment, and from investing side I'm more inclined to stay away from their stock then buy it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- The_Sponge 9y ago>Google entered the self driving cars research, and we have yet to see them driven around. You see their working prototypes flying around mountain view all the time. And, they've been transparent with their progress. People have been working on this since the 80s.
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoConsidering “the whine of the electric motor in Waymo’s 25mph prototype is mildly annoying when my window is open and they drive by several times an hour” is a real thing in my own life as a resident of Mountain View, it’s odd to see the assertion that they don’t drive around. And I live on a side street.
- whatrusmoking 9y agohuh? https://www.theverge.com/2017/5/10/15609844/waymo-google-self-driving-cars-3-million-miles https://www.theverge.com/2017/5/10/15609844/waymo-google-sel... https://www.slashgear.com/waymo-launches-early-rider-beta-program-in-phoenix-25483242/ https://www.slashgear.com/waymo-launches-early-rider-beta-pr... They're easily 5 years ahead of the competition.
- bllguo 9y ago
- EternalData 9y agoGoogle might try to become the conglomerate of all forward-facing things but it is somewhat funny to see how through it all, it's their advertising revenues that form the core of the business.
- fishnchips 9y agoWhich is exactly what they're trying to change - both with "conventional" offerings like Android and Cloud, as well as with what they call "moonshots".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 9y ago> it's their advertising revenues that form the core of the business. You'd think the advertising staff would get pretty good treatment at Google. Do they?
- euyyn 9y agoWhy wouldn't they? All Googlers get very very good treatment.
- dekhn 9y agowhen I worked in the ads part, it was not glamorous (as compared to search, or mobile, or social, or whatever the hot area was at the time) but I think we were treated well, and acknowledged for running a critical service that provided revenue that allowed other parts of the company to do research and development into new things. I can't speak for the entire advertising staff, of course.
- sgt101 9y agoI think it's their compute capability and massive interaction with the concerns of humanity expressed via search; in the short term that's leveraged to create advertising revenue, in the longer term who knows?
- DrNuke 9y agoDiversification of the business, me thinks... nuclear is so big (but slow) that a penny invested today may become a tenner tomorrow, just in case.
- mtgx 9y agoI think their universal quantum computer (to be announced later this year) could accelerate fusion research even more, as I imagine it could more accurately simulate the atom reactions and experiments on it. Practical quantum computers may just be what we were missing to finally be able build working fusion reactors. The millions of possible "solutions" and algorithms for working fusion reactors may be what has made fusion research so expensive and fusion reactors seem so far away. Quantum computers may be able to cut right through that hard problem, although we may have to wait a bit more until quantum computers are useful enough to make an impact on fusion research. I don't know if that's reaching 1,000 qubits or 1 million qubits.
- _FKS_ 9y agoEven if you had the computing power AND if you were simulating your fusion reactor's plasma in realtime, while it's running AND you know/can predict the plasma instabilities in realtime (under a few ms), you still need a way to "counter" those instabilites in the said plasma. And you need to counter fast, before the instability "poisons" the entire plasma, something that should happen within a few ms. If you don't, your entire experiment stops, and it takes a while to get it back (minutes). Currently: 1. nobody really understands the instabilities, why and when they happen; 2. there's no way to 'counter' them. So it's not only about the computing power.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abefetterman 9y agoThis is actually a really exciting development to me. (Note, what is exciting is the "optometrist algorithm" from the paper [1] not necessarily googles involvement as pitched in the guardian). Typically a day of shots would need to be programmed out in advance, typically scanning over one dimension (out of hundreds) at a time. It would then take at least a week to analyze the results and create an updated research plan. The result is poor utilization of each experiment in optimizing performance. The 50% reduction in losses is a big deal for Tri Alpha. I can see this being coupled with simulations as well to understand sources of systematic errors, create better simulations which can then be used as a stronger source of truth for "offline" (computation-only) experiments. The biggest challenge of course becomes interpreting the results. So you got better performance, what parameters really made a difference and why? But that is at least a more tractable problem than "how do we make this better in the first place?" [1] http://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-06645-7 http://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-06645-7
- jlarocco 9y agoAs a complete outsider, I don't understand what's special about the "optometrist algorithm." As described in the Nature article it's just hill climbing using humans as the evaluation function. Isn't it basically the same thing they were already doing but more granular?
- abefetterman 9y agoBasically nobody was using automated gradient descent / etc because of the proclivity of these algorithms to get stuck on a boundary. The problem is the boundaries are not well defined. One example might be a catastrophic instability. If it gets triggered it has the potential to damage the machine. But the exact parameters in which the instability occurs are not well known. So with this algorithm you mix the best of both worlds: the human can guide away from the areas where we think instabilities are, the machine can do it's optimization thing. It's pretty simple overall but enables a big shift in how experiments are run. Edit to add: these instabilities often look just like better performance on a shot-to-shot basis, which makes the algos especially tricky. Using a human we could say "this parameter change is just feeding the instability" vs "oh this is interesting go here"
- hailmike 9y agoI want to start placing "Google and " before stating my accomplishments. "Google and a nuclear fusion company have developed a new algorithm" sounds way better than: "Nuclear fusion company has developed a new algorithm using Google" They may not mean the same, but in today's world faking it until you make it might pay off.
- briankelly 9y agoFrom the actual journal article: > Two additional complications arise because plasma fusion apparatuses are experimental and one-of-a-kind. First, the goodness metric for plasma is not fully established and objective: some amount of human judgement is required to assess an experiment. Second, the boundaries of safe operation are not fully understood: it would be easy for a fully-automated optimisation algorithm to propose settings that would damage the apparatus and set back progress by weeks or months. > To increase the speed of learning and optimisation of plasma, we developed the Optometrist Algorithm. Just as in a visit to an optometrist, the algorithm offers a pair of choices to a human, and asks which one is preferable. Given the choice, the algorithm proceeds to offer another choice. While an optometrist asks a patient to choose between lens prescriptions based on clarity, our algorithm asks a human expert to choose between plasma settings based on experimental outcomes. The Optometrist Algorithm attempts to optimise a hidden utility model that the human experts may not be able to express explicitly. I haven't read the full article nor do I understand the problem space, but the novelty seems overstated based on this. Maybe they can eventually collect metadata to automate the human intuition. Edit: here's their formal description of it: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-06645-7/figures/2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-06645-7/figures/2
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pm90 9y agoI mean, if it has not been done before, it doesn't look like they're overstating the novelty. Most algorithms look "obvious" in hindsight :).
- euyyn 9y agoIt's a well-known technique in the out-of-fashion world of knowledge-based systems: To create an expert system, your experts often won't be able to articulate their utility function, so you extract it by presenting them A/B choices.
- 9y ago
- ZenoArrow 9y agoSounds like some promising results, hopefully this approach will continue to be useful. Addressing the wider article, it always surprises me that the focus fusion approach is never mentioned in fusion articles put out by the mainstream media. I don't know what to attribute that to, but it's surprising that one of the most promising fusion approaches is constantly overlooked. To give an idea how drastically overlooked focus fusion is, here's a graph showing R&D budgets for different fusion projects... http://lppfusion.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/fusion-funds-pie-chart.png http://lppfusion.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/fusion-funds... ... and here's a graph showing energy efficiency of fusion devices (running on deuterium I believe)... http://lppfusion.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/wall-plug-chart.png http://lppfusion.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/wall-plug-ch... You'd think that the second most efficient device would've gotten more than $5 million in funding over 20 years (I think the original funding was from NASA back in 1994).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dwaltrip 9y agoThere was a talk about the state of nuclear fusion by some MIT folks linked here on HN a few days ago. One of the biggest takeaways was that many fusion efforts are very far away (3 to 6+ orders of magnitude) on the most important metric, Q, which is energy_out / energy_in. Additionally, much press and public discussion completely fail to discuss this and other core factors that actually matter for making fusion viable. I remember Tri-alpha being listed on one of the slides near the bottom left of the plot, 4 or 5 orders of magnitude away from break even, where Q = 1 (someone please correct me if I'm remembering incorrectly). Is the 50% improvement described in the article meaningful, as that would only be a fraction of an order of magnitude? I understand the broader concept of combining experts and specialized software on complex problems is a powerful idea -- I'm just wondering if this specific result actually changes the game for Tri-alpha.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- a1371 9y agoI also watched that MIT talk and it was quite insightful; however, as I searched a bit more, I realized that the metrics involved in the presentation are only for achieving surplus in the generated energy from fusion. When it comes to industrializing the idea, the scope is far broader. For example, the speaker was saying that they can use the neutron streams as the result of fusion for creating tritium. In reality, capturing the neutrons is much more complex than that [1]. Some of those may deposit on the inner surface of the tokamak and have to be recovered by 99% to have breakeven. The nuclear waste is another concern in the opposite case. Given all these, you get a sense that why companies like General Fusion [2] get funded. He showed that General Fusion is very far away in his metrics. But the pinching technology the company is offering, allows for continuous use of the fusion in rapid bursts (like an automatic rifle). When I met them at the Globe conference, they were claiming that they will be ready for production within 5 years of achieving a surplus. I am not sure how fast the tokamak can get there. Source: 1. http://thebulletin.org/fusion-reactors-not-what-they%E2%80%99re-cracked-be10699 http://thebulletin.org/fusion-reactors-not-what-they%E2%80%9... 2. http://generalfusion.com/ http://generalfusion.com/
- 9y ago
- siscia 9y agoI do have a naive question. Suppose a big breakthrough comes out of a private company, and such innovation is necessary to use nuclear fusion. The company will be free to do whatever it pleases with the technology or it will somehow "force" to let other use, maybe behind the payment of some royalties.
- crusso 9y agoIf they have a patentable breakthrough, they would be able to restrict use of their discovery for the duration of their patent.
- jccooper 9y agoPatent law generally recognizes the option of the state to enforce compulsory licensing, though it's rarely exercised. Eminent domain may also be used to take patents. The modern approach seems to be to just let people find a way around the patent, or simply ignore and litigate.
- dekhn 9y agoyep. They could keep it a trade secret (no patent), patent it and not license it, or patent it and license it so others could use it under some terms. This only matters for the life of the patent, and is consistent with the intent of patents.
- ekun 9y agoIt probably also depends on funding they have received from places like the Department of Energy and contracts they have signed for their research being publicly available, but if Paul Allen is the funding and not the government maybe it's all private. My own naivety would say billionaires investing in clean technology would share it with the world, but who knows?
- markvdb 9y agoA related economics question, a thought experiment really... Suppose a private company manages to lower the cost of electric energy by 90%, using a device self produced fast with virtually no capex. From an economics point of view, they build free money printing presses, essentially. How would they benefit from this the most possible? Selling the energy? At what price? Take over sectors of the economy where electric price generates most added value? Aluminium production? Data centers? ...
- suzzer99 9y agoAm I the only one that never reads these articles but just goes straight to the comments? It seems like reporters always get the facts bungled and go for the simple story - out of necessity of course.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoOn this article I clicked on it, realized The Guardian was going to be waaay to general, and then went to the comments knowing I would find a quick break down of the facts written by "my people" for an audience like me. Often I'll skip the article entirely.
- suzzer99 9y agoYep - same thing with that "Roomba is selling maps of your home" thing that's going around. Turns out they're considering partnering with Alexa or something, and you'd have to opt in of course. I just skipped straight to the comments to get the real scoop instantly.
- trhway 9y agofor me it is about page loading - pretty much straightforward successful and predictable on HN and slow and/or heavy, jerking current position/scroll around and full of whatever else surprises the page of the source. I want to know what it is about immediately, i.e. basically it is an issue of instant gratification for me :) If information on the HN comments page isn't enough (which is rare), or the source is really vouched/confirmed to be interesting by itself - then i take the bullet.
- suzzer99 9y agoI bet you love usatoday.com.
- twic 9y agoI also do this. HN comment pages are extremely varied in their quality, but they do tend to be good at shooting down articles which aren't as good as their titles suggest. Plus, HN loads fast. So, open the comments, check to see if the article might be worth reading, and if so, open it, flip back to the main page while the article loads.
- grnadav1 9y agoYou jusk KNOW Elon Musk is gonna beat'em to it ;)
- dokem 9y agoElectric cars and rockets have existed for decades.
- yousefvi 9y agoAs a psychologist, this looks an awful lot like computerized adaptive testing methods, only instead of estimating some parameter vector about a person, you're estimating some parameter vector about plasma. Even the title "optometrist algorithm" is telling, because that paradigm is a basic model for how a lot of testing is done, except that it's not the optometrist doing it, it's a computer.
- marcgcombi 9y agoAn amazing amount of irrelevant comments.
- j7ake 9y agohow does this nuclear fusion company hope to make money ? Their product is decades in the future.
- detaro 9y agoQuite possibly, it never making any money at all but getting the world closer to usable fusion is an acceptable outcome for investors like Paul Allan. And it could make money by being the first ones to sell said product, decades in the future, or by at least holding valuable IP at that point?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- j7ake 9y agoone possible alternative would be to put the money into academic research so there is no pressure from investors to have a return on investment.
- DennisP 9y agoI'm not convinced that having no pressure to get a return on investment is a net benefit. I've seen arguments by fusion scientists that the field has historically been much too focused on pure plasma physics, with too little emphasis on practical results or on the economics of reactor designs. People invest in Tri Alpha because if things work out, a practical reactor is more like one decade in the future, and it would be very economical. The return on investment would be enormous.
- Necromant2005 9y agoIt's nothing. Even if Google is invented something we will never see a product customer can purchase.
- janemanos 9y agoMaybe I'll see commercial fusion within my lifetime... how nice is that!
- rurban 9y agoNo, they have not. They developed a very useful new program. But simple assisted hill climbing is not a new algorithm, you might call it "Wizard" though. This would attract the right audience.
- medalist 9y agoDamn. If humanity can figure this out we might actually be able survive long term.
- Horizon_Blue 9y agoWith renewable prices falling so much, even if fusion is attained relatively soon, how long will it be before its economically feasible? It will it be able to compete on price?