7 ms·
IMHO the inflation of housing costs has many factors, but one of the ones that gets overlooked is the concentration of wealth near the top. Rich people need sa
by jandrese 9y ago
IMHO the inflation of housing costs has many factors, but one of the ones that gets overlooked is the concentration of wealth near the top. Rich people need safe places to stash their money, and they end up buying real estate all over the country. This isn't just Americans either, US real estate is a popular investment all over the world. But when you are buying real estate as an investment where do you buy, not out in some no-name town in some flyover state. You buy in a place where the market is already hot and ride the wave. Thousands of millionaire investors piling into a market end up pricing out regular folks who just want a place to live.
I'm frankly surprised that we have not seen more real estate bubbles pop over the years. It's clearly unsustainable, yet somehow the market keeps going. Ask your parents if they could afford to buy their home today, even with their best yearly income. Most of them will say no if they lived in the city for a couple of decades or more. I know so many who bought their house for $70k-$100k in the 70s and now see their neighbors sell for $1m-$1.5m. It's insane.
- nemo44x 9y agoInterest rates were also very high in the 70's and early 80's. If we could get housing interest rates up to 8% you'd see a large decline in housing prices. If it got up to 1970's and 1980's rates it would be around 17%. This would dramatically reduce the price of a typical house and become a darling market for people who have can pay in cash.
- icantdrive55 9y agoYea, but the 1% er's, and REIT's would just have more no brainer deals/units to add to the portfolio. Personally, I would like to see changes on whom can buy real estate. 1. Disavow all foreign ownership of residential/commercial land. (This I don't get at all.) 2. Get rid of REIT's 3. Put a cap on the member of units(homes, buildings) a entity can own. We might prevent another Trump dynasty? Personally, I don't like looking at a home as a investment.
- colechristensen 9y agoI'd assume it was forced by all of the initiatives of making the "American dream" of owning a home a reality for as many people as possible. Real estate shouldn't be an investment, it shouldn't raise in value, and it shouldn't be possible for a huge chunk of the population to fund the financial sector through mortgage interest. It's a tax on everyone designed to funnel wealth upwards towards a sector of capital owners that get paid for doing very little. Regulations and taxes should be arranged such that it is very expensive to own real property that isn't for your own personal or business use. If you want to act as a gatekeeper for real estate, at least a large chunk of the profit should go to the state for the benefit of the public. If it's expensive and not beneficial to own things so others have to pay you to use them, the market will shrink dramatically and more people will actually be able to own homes.
- seanp2k2 9y agoYep. And as you also know, there's so much money in it that we won't see it change in our lifetimes. Why work when you can let the land work for you?
- sokoloff 9y agoWhy spend all your income today when you can save and invest some for the future, thereby allowing you to consume more later in exchange for consuming less now? Investments, including land, are owned on the backs of consumption foregone in the past.
- ItendToDisagree 9y agoJust no. All investments are not owned on the back of consumption foregone in the past. Unless you believe that someone with 100 million dollars is "foregoing consumption" when they invest (particularly in real estate).
- sokoloff 9y agoI do believe that. They can take that $X MM and put it into an investment xor into a yacht/airplane/supercars/vacations. One is consumption; the other is investing.
- sokoloff 9y ago> I know so many who bought their house for $70k-$100k in the 70s and now see their neighbors sell for $1m-$1.5m. It's insane. Yet those returns (10x-20x) are lower than having invested the purchase price in the S&P500 (with dividends re-invested), which returned a 21x to 30x total return over that same time period (depending on which exact spot you chose to be the "70s") https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/ https://dqydj.com/sp-500-return-calculator/ The house also provided a place to live, so you need to goose the house effective returns a bit there, but that place to live also came with overt property taxes, maintenance expenses, etc.
- sigstoat 9y ago> The house also provided a place to live, so you need to goose the house effective returns a bit there, but that place to live also came with overt property taxes, maintenance expenses, etc. indeed. there are also more transaction costs involved in real estate, too. driving around to look at properties, real estate agents, significant paperwork, etc.
- SilasX 9y agoUnfortunately, homes have a lot more protection from taxation of the returns than mutual fund investing: you can only put a small amount each year into a tax-protected account, and if you don't, any rebalancing or dividends produce a taxable event. In contrast, the capital gains from owning a home are exempt for a certain amount, and "imputed rent" (the savings from not having to rent a similar house at current rates) is untaxed, like any other cost-saving purchase. [1] (One small advantage the other way is that you don't have to pay "property taxes" on mutual funds, though you do have to pay management fees, which, even for index funds, are of similar magnitude.) [1] IIRC the original income tax did cover imputed rents of sufficient magnitude.
- sokoloff 9y ago> you don't have to pay "property taxes" on mutual funds In my view, the tenant is paying the property taxes on the space they rent to live in, so the mutual fund investor (who is also a tenant) is paying property taxes, just on their housing not on the funds. It's rolled into the rent, but there's no reason to me to think that the landlord is paying it when the tenant is the one bringing the money into the system.
- Retric 9y agoIf you look at the US, people mostly congregate around areas with nice weather and flat geography. The rust belt is arguably a reaction to Air Conditioning not offshoring. 100 years ago being north of Virginia meant trading milder summers for worse winters. But, summer with high humidity and no AC can be brutal.
- nradov 9y agoPeople also mostly congregate near bodies of water.
- Retric 9y agoI think that has been somewhat broken as small ports and small farms have become less important due to contanerized shipping. Las Vegas is a rather striking example, as it's close to lake mead but not centered on it like say NYC, DC, or SF. The draw of living near other people still pushes people to the coast, as does recreation.
- santaclaus 9y ago> If you look at the US, people mostly congregate around areas with nice weather and flat geography. New York City and San Francisco beg to differ...
- Retric 9y agoNYC is flat, and pre-AC had very nice weather. San francisco is on the flat part, look at a topo map from San francisco to San Jose and compare elevation with population density.
- pascalxus 9y agoHere in CA we're riding one hella of a Macro bubble that no one sees. This certainly can't continue. The unwillingness of voters to expand the housing supply is one the greatest social ills of our time. I can accept and understand that those who benefit don't want to address the issue. But, there are countless many who don't benefit from it at all. Why is this not a great national issue of enormous debate? Why is there so little visibility? everytime i see a list of voter related issues, housing is never mentioned. Shelter is a fundamental human need - it's at the very bottom of maslow's hierarchy of needs. If humanity can't even get past this bottom layer, we're not going anywhere. The entire concept of real estate is wrong. You hear it all the time. Whenever real estate prices go up, people react like it's a good thing - it's not. For society to make progress, prices must come down. It's not just for those who don't have a home. Property owners should benefit too, with lower tax bills. Of course prop 13 creates more perverse incentives than i can count... I could go on, but we've already discussed this millions of times.
- closeparen 9y agoThey benefit in the form of less congested streets and easy-to-find parking, light coming through their windows (rather than blocked by tall buildings across the street), low building heights giving their neighborhoods a familiar small-town feeling, etc. To be clear, I think it's unconscionable that we prioritize these concerns when rents are so high, but average people absolutely do benefit from restrictions on housing supply as long as they are secure in long-ago mortgages and grandfathered rent control. One of the NIMBY talking points is that upzoning creates a profit incentive to destroy rent-controlled buildings and replace them with higher-density market-rate buildings. Rent-controlled lease holders actually become more secure in their positions when the neighborhood downzones. This is really about seniority/tenure in an area, and if there's any serious reform, it will likely be to further protect those with grandfather status from newcomers.
- gwbas1c 9y ago> Whenever real estate prices go up, people react like it's a good thing The problem is that, based on how things work, a significant amount of our assets are tied up in real estate. If you're a homeowner and your home's value tanks compared to the rest of the market, you're screwed! You can't move to another place because you've lost all of the money that you put into your home. It gets even worse if you need the money: Think of elderly who sell their homes and use the profits to pay for assisted living. Or, look at how we pay for education: We use our homes as collateral for education loans!
- BurningFrog 9y agoI think this confuses cause and effect. Rich people buy real estate because it steadily rises in value. Not the other way around. If motorcycles had the same price development, they'd buy motorcycles instead. The interesting question is why real estate prices behave like this.
- uiri 9y agoOn average, (after smoothing out the bubbles like in 05-07 and the crashes like in 08-09) real estate prices track inflation. Deflation is exceedingly rate, so this behaviour of nominal prices rising steadily is to be expected. Unless you mean real estate prices rise steadily in real terms, in which case I'd like to see data behind that assertion along with corresponding interest rates as mentioned in another comment.
- BurningFrog 9y agoAcross America prices may follow inflation on average, but in the high tech/low construction centers I think it's rising much faster than that. And that's where people buy housing as investment.
- uiri 9y agoThe only high tech/low construction center is the San Francisco Bay area. Seattle has had a lot of construction over the past few years. Since housing supply isn't perfectly elastic, it can take a few years before supply shifts to meet demand and in the mean time, prices rise. New York is definitely a high tech center but it is also a center for a lot of other things too. I'm not sure if it is high or low construction but there are other factors at play in the high rents there that aren't at play in other tech centers.
- InitialLastName 9y agoThis is exactly why property taxes should be higher for non-resident owners. Squash the real estate as foreign money stash urge a little.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ScottBurson 9y agoHenry George explained it all a century ago: http://www.henrygeorge.org/pcontents.htm http://www.henrygeorge.org/pcontents.htm
- conanbatt 9y agoIf rich people just stashed they money in housing, you would see a higher gap between housing and rental prices (because if there isnt demand to rent those places, but there is demand to buy them, the gap would increase). I dont think thats whats going on. Concentration of work in cities is a global effect, and although china erupting cash over the world might change some numbers,it wouldnt explain the migratory movement from rural to cities. The easiest and most classical explanation of housing prices in the US is that construction took a huge hit in 2008, and getting the whole system to produce more housing for the demographic growth is lagging. I remember seeing some data about that happening. A more esoteric one is that we are living in a world with a curious monetary policy, with low interest rates but no inflation, and that as money gets more expensive, housing demand will lower and so will its prices.