7 ms·
The SEC should show that it protects everyone's rights and not just large firms with piles of cash to pay to them and to pay expensive lawyers. Otherwise we ha
by ilaksh 9y ago
The SEC should show that it protects everyone's rights and not just large firms with piles of cash to pay to them and to pay expensive lawyers. Otherwise we have to assume that this is largely about trying to tax things.
The way they can do this is by making a real effort to update their technical, documentation, and regulatory programs.
Is there a straightforward way to do an Edgar filing that doesn't require a bunch of training? Is there a web page that clearly lists the requirements for these types of securities in plain English?
How much do the company registrations and filings actually cost? What is the basis for these costs? Because an ICO can be created at no cost. Are the excessive fees due to a lack of modernization or streamlining of the processes, or they simply bribes that line officials' pockets and protect the incumbent firms from poorly funded startups?
In recent cases, how would fees and filings have actually protected anyone? Does the SEC have technical staff or software capable of evaluating Ethereum contracts for validity or safety? If not, how does their regulatory effort provide any benefit, except as an opportunity for them to collect a type of tax and make it harder for startups to compete with large firms where SEC officials have friends working?
- taysic 9y agoAre you genuinely asking what the value of the SEC is? I generally am pro low taxes but the crypto environment right now is so flush with scams that it explains itself
- siliconviking 9y agoPhilosopjically, why not let people make their own decisions?
- rficcaglia 9y agophilosophically, because the working "mass" (to quote Alexander Hamilton in the Federalist Papers, 68, I believe) would not have the leisure time to be informed enough to make sensible decisions. i came from a blue collar family where everyone worked 2 FT jobs to make ends meet and making savvy investment decisions was hardly possible. ignoring the lack of financial education and experience, a good sales scam promising you riches after your 16 hour workday with 4 hours of household chores still to do, kids screaming, and no hope in sight, can be highly effective. that said, look where the electoral college got us!! so philosophy and reality are different. in principle i agree, let people decide. in reality that leads to housing bubbles, global warming, donald trump...
- KirinDave 9y ago> Because an ICO can be created at no cost Except the cost to the participants who later have wasted money because the ICO contract was exploitable... At the current rate major losses are as perceptible as all successes. Maybe the industry needs some externally imposed speed bumps from SOME authority until folks can get their acts in gear?
- DennisP 9y agoI doubt the SEC is a good fit for improving smart contract security.
- saosebastiao 9y agoI'd trust the SEC that one other agency capable of doing so. The SEC actually has a ton of technically capable people who understand and audit technology...they do as much for e-brokers, stock exchanges, high frequency traders, etc. The only other agency capable of doing so would probably stockpile the exploits and use them to surveil the dark web to catch a million drug dealers and an occasional low level disposable terrorist.
- maneesh 9y agoCan you show me the losses vs successes?
- KirinDave 9y agoI actually cannot name any successes, I looked for a few moments. I presume they exist. For those thinking I am glib and downvoting, I am asking: Do you know of any? I searched, asked some friends in etherium. I presume they must exist in some for as we're no longer early-days with Etherium.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> the SEC should show that it protects everyone's rights One sure-fire way to get the SEC to go absolutely ballistic is to hurt mom-and-pop investors. This is why the commission was founded [1] and why securities law maintains "accredited investor" thresholds, controversial as they are. > Is there a straightforward way to do an Edgar filing that doesn't require a bunch of training? Securities lawyers are a few thousand dollars well spent. That said, the SEC has online self-help resources [2] and an online filing portal [3]. > How much do the company registrations and filings actually cost? It depends on how much you raise. Right now it's 0.01159% [4]. > an ICO can be created at no cost Until shit hits the fan. Then everyone needs to hire a lawyer. An SEC complaint, on the other hand, triggers investigations and potentially enforcement actions paid for by the filing fees, amongst other things. It's a public good that helps keep companies honest. > how would fees and filings have actually protected anyone? The SEC is constantly litigating [5], launching proceedings [6] and helping resolve failed companies [7] on behalf of investors. Audit requirements stop lots of crap before they get too serious, too. > Does the SEC have technical staff or software capable of evaluating Ethereum contracts for validity or safety? The SEC doesn't evaluate filings for fitness, just completeness. Its mantra is disclosure and transparency. That lets investors come up with their own informed conclusions. Especially small ones who can't afford corporate lawyers to pull managers' teeth. [1] http://www.columbia.edu/~hcs14/SEC.htm http://www.columbia.edu/~hcs14/SEC.htm [2] https://www.sec.gov/info/edgar/guidance https://www.sec.gov/info/edgar/guidance [3] https://www.filermanagement.edgarfiling.sec.gov/Welcome/EDGARFilerMgmtMain.htm https://www.filermanagement.edgarfiling.sec.gov/Welcome/EDGA... [4] https://www.sec.gov/ofm/Article/feeamt.html https://www.sec.gov/ofm/Article/feeamt.html [5] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases.shtml https://www.sec.gov/litigation/litreleases.shtml [6] https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin.shtml https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin.shtml [7] https://www.sec.gov/divisions/enforce/receiverships.htm https://www.sec.gov/divisions/enforce/receiverships.htm
- regulation_d 9y ago>> How much do the company registrations and filings actually cost? >It depends on how much you raise. Right now it's 0.01159% [4]. Those might be the fees. The cost of a registration is much higher. Gotta put food on the table of all those lawyers and accountants. https://www.pwc.com/us/en/deals/publications/assets/pwc-cost-of-ipo.pdf https://www.pwc.com/us/en/deals/publications/assets/pwc-cost... Certainly, money can be raised more cheaply with exemptions, but those come with their own tradeoffs.
- komali2 9y agoI mean, this describes tax code and legislation in general. I'm hoping we can get text parsing models to the point that they can be utilized to simplify legal documents or even the entire US Tax Code. Like, Google Translate can translate Chinese to English decently, imagine if one day it could translate Legal Tax Code MumboJumbo to English as well? Or even cooler, if you could plug in your personal details (well, terrifying I guess) and it spits out all the loopholes you can exploit. EDIT: I guess services like H&R block tried to automate this, but I'm thinking less like "oh you donated x dollars, make sure to put that on your forms!" and more like "Hey, you live in x city, did you know if you move a mere x miles away you avoid city taxes for y, county taxes for z, and can put a moving bonus for moving n miles!" or even "You are x type of contractor, consider switching your status to y because you will get these real number tax benefits."
- djsumdog 9y agoThe funny thing is, the IRS can already do this without any text parsing of legislation for domestic taxes. They have all the data and rule sets to completely automate the filing process. In Australia the government has official tax software. It pulls all your PAYG information and auto-fills most of what you need. In NZ, people don't file taxes at all. They login to the IRD website and their tax data is populated. You can accept what's presented or file for corrections. H&R Block and TurboTax actively lobby against the US IRS from creating the same type of filing system. Our entire banking system is 20 years behind the rest of the world: http://penguindreams.org/blog/the-american-banking-system-is-still-in-the-1990s/ http://penguindreams.org/blog/the-american-banking-system-is...
- akira2501 9y ago> They have all the data and rule sets to completely automate the filing process. My partner works in outside sales as an agent for a "Fortune 100" company, and the IRS in no way has all the data to automate any part of her taxes. From the way she's compensated, to the reimbursements, to the legitimate business expeses.. there's no way she'd get a good deal if she let the IRS guess at any of that.
- josh2600 9y agoComments like this are ludicrous. Do you really think the SEC doesn't understand distributed ledgers or ethereum contracts? Second, do you think anyone has technical staff that are capable of writing safe contracts in Solidity (Parity wallet would suggest not...). In short, the idea that people must be incompetent because they're in the government is pretty ludicrous. The SEC is consistently one of the best technical organizations despite the fact everyone lobbies for them to have the fewest resources with which to do their job. If you think all ICOs pass the smell test, maybe you haven't been fleeced enough in your life to appreciate scams when you see them? Source: I run a crypto hedge fund and have spent a lot of time evaluating ICOs. Some of them are legitimate, philosophically sound ideas looking for funding and some of them are outright scams.
- wuliwong 9y agoHow is it "ludicrous" for memossy to ask a question? In short, the idea that people must be incompetent because they're in the government is pretty ludicrous. The comment did not express that. It was mainly about transparency and communication.
- brooklyntribe 9y agoActually hung out with a JP Morgan Chase banker the other day. Big into crypto. He said the SEC had no clue what was going on. They leave at 5 PM, and head home to wife's and kids, and mortgages. While the "kids" are hacking, micro-dosing, and working 100 weeks. And they are all of 17. It's not in their world. A 55 year old banker is not hacking solidity contracts at 3 AM. No way.
- KirinDave 9y agoMaybe if they had a few of those 55year olds with kids who know how to write a goddamn language interpreter without it being a train wreck, the DAO wouldn't have been the crisis that it became. This veneration of the church of conspicuous effort is not a new idea. It's lead many people astray. Be careful.
- Gargoyle 9y agoThe SEC has been dipping into crypto regulation since at least 2013 when they shut down BTCT for running an exchange that traded shares in various bitcoin mining companies. There are people there who have been working in the field for years now and understand it quite well.