9 ms·
Pittsburgh Gets a Tech Makeover
- thearn4 9y agoAs a Cleveland native, I look at Pittsburgh somewhat jealously as a city that is achieving what Cleveland has been slow to do over the last 30 years: find a post-industrial midwestern identity.
- tcbawo 9y agoCleveland would do well to create industrial and R&D ties to Pittsburgh. It's relatively close in proximity. Creating a regional tech hub would benefit both.
- moultano 9y agoCase Western has to step up its game.
- thearn4 9y agoCleveland Clinic and NASA could have a role too, but could really use some coordination.
- blackguardx 9y agoAs a CWRU grad, I don't really see what power they have fix Cleveland's problems. One of them is due to the high levels segregation (both wealth and race) and sprawl due to white flight from the inner city. This is slowly changing as Cleveland tries to revitalize the downtown, but I'm not sure there are any good plans to help out extremely poor areas such as East Cleveland.
- Kihashi 9y ago> I'm not sure there are any good plans to help out extremely poor areas such as East Cleveland. I'm not sure this is necessarily helping, but there was a plan to have Cleveland annex East Cleveland. The East Cleveland City Council basically nuked it and then recalled their mayor who had proposed it, IIRC.
- ntsplnkv2 9y agoFootball rivalries aside, Pittsburgh and Cleveland would do well to partner more often. Both are very similar cities, they have more in common with each other than others in the rust belt.
- thearn4 9y agoRather than settle football rivalries, I kind of wish Cleveland would just ditch the Browns and offload them to another city already. But for good this time. Their stadium is occupying probably one of the best spots on the Lakefront, and is entirely wasted there.
- bennettfeely 9y agoThere's no need to spell it out, we know Cleveland Browns fans look at Pittsburgh jealously.
- smaili 9y agoThe author seems to place most of the credit for the recent 'boom' on CMU for its rich history in the Machine Learning and Robotics fields. So my question is, what happens when other top universities begin to catch up or even possibly dethrone CMU? Would Pittsburg still continue to attract talent and businesses?
- munin 9y agoCMU has intense advantages that make that unlikely to occur within the next 50 years.
- Hydraulix989 9y agoCMU has consistently been ranked #1 in the world for computer science. Generally, university rankings are VERY consistent over time. Harvard isn't going to stop being Harvard any time soon. Also, "Pittsburgh" is spelled with an "h" at the end.
- DrScump 9y agoI think some tech people confuse it with Pittsburg in the SF Bay Area, if it was the one they heard of first.
- adventured 9y ago> So my question is, what happens when other top universities begin to catch up or even possibly dethrone CMU? What happens when CMU gains an even greater advantage over other top universities? Will Pittsburgh be able to handle the deluge of talent and businesses wanting to move there?
- graphitezepp 9y agoIt would be folly to not mention Pitt and their place as a top tier medical institution as an aside. It's not just CMU and comp sci making PGH what it is today.
- carrendi 9y agoI graduated from CMU (SCS) 15 years ago. The school is so far ahead of nearly every other CS school in the world in regard to machine learning/AI, it's laughable to think it will ever be dethroned. They have ties with DARPA and other government agencies that have deep pockets. They've also successfully courted every major tech corporation in the country. I have to applaud their board of trustees/president/provost. They know what they're doing. The article paints a rosy picture of Pittsburgh, but I remember these types of articles appearing back in 2000. The state of Pennsylvania even had a campaign (commercials, marketing, etc) to try to convince college graduates to stay in the state. It didn't work. Most of the talent will eventually leave. All but 2 of my 30 or so friends from graduate/undergrad left after they finished their degree. In my last semester I was dying to leave because the weather is absolute shit for half the year. CMU was really the only thing there that was worthwhile to me.
- melling 9y agoPaul Graham essay on Pittsburgh: http://www.paulgraham.com/pgh.html http://www.paulgraham.com/pgh.html
- joeblau 9y agoI moved to Pittsburgh a year and a half ago after living in SF for 5 years and I can say that I really love it here. Food is great, people are extremely friendly, and the town is just a great town to be in. I met a Pittsburgh native and I told him that I've noticed that parts of the city are getting "SFed." A few neighborhoods which no one would be caught dead in 5-10 years ago are suddenly bustling with tech company tees from google, uber, duolingo, ibm, amazon, apple and others. Pittsburghers are very prod of their city, as they should be. I just hope it doesn't reach the level of discourse that we've seen in San Francisco.
- CydeWeys 9y agoCan you speak to Pittsburgh's zoning policies? SF makes it nearly impossible to add a significant number of new housing units because the zoning policies don't allow less dense housing to be replaced with larger, taller apartment buildings. Hopefully Pittsburgh isn't like that.
- Hydraulix989 9y agoIt is not. I am a fourth generation Pittsburgh native. The bigger problem is the NIMBYs in SF that vote for things like "zoning policies" to protect the value of their houses. This situation is a very uniquely San Francisco one. The vast majority of houses in Pittsburgh aren't million dollar homes (yet) so this NIMBY-ism just doesn't happen. It goes without saying that ludicrous regulations like "historically protected" homes that you can't remodel without bribing the city and trees on your property that you don't own (the city owns) that exist in SF don't exist in Pittsburgh. On another note, the nice thing about Pittsburgh is that you don't have such an oppressively high cost of living compared to SF. You don't have $10 toast here, and you can rent a 1 bdr apartment for the cost of renting a single parking spot for your car in SF. Every single cost from utilities to parking to insurance for your car is a significant fraction of the equivalent cost in SF.
- pesenti 9y agoI was about to comment "no way, Pittsburgh also has the $10 toast"... but then looking around to the place I used to go to, I realize it's more like $4-$5 (see http://www.coca-cafe.net/breakfast.php http://www.coca-cafe.net/breakfast.php or https://www.facebook.com/B52PGH/menu/ https://www.facebook.com/B52PGH/menu/). Wow, I left Pittsburgh for NYC just two years ago and my frame of reference has already completely switched...
- pesenti 9y agoI lived in Pittsburgh for 17 years. I bootstrapped a company out of CMU, grew it to $25M/year in revenue and sold it to IBM. Pittsburgh is a great place to start a company, lots of tech talent, lots of support and exposure in the community, cheap rent. And it is today a much more enjoyable place to live than 20 years ago (great restaurant scene, bike paths, revitalized downtown). There are two big drawbacks: finding experienced non-technical talent (our C-suite ended up in DC) and raising significant funds. It's just really hard to get serious VCs to pay attention to Pittsburgh.
- nugget 9y ago> It's just really hard to get serious VCs to pay attention to Pittsburgh. I'm an angel investor in a few dozen tech startups, about half in the Bay Area and half spread elsewhere around the country. The biggest problem with those outside of the Bay Area is that for lack of a better term "they don't think big enough". A lot of the promising ones turn into lifestyle-type businesses (e.g. a focus on services revenue instead of software revenue) when, in my opinion, they could have achieved much greater exits. Whether justified or not, I know many other investors with a similar bias based on similar experiences.
- draw_down 9y agoOn balance, maybe not such a bad thing.
- pesenti 9y agoIt's a good point, I have noticed that as well. But it's both a cause and consequence of the lack of easy access to capital. Early stage big ideas that require a lot of initial capital just won't get funded in a place like Pittsburgh. Once they pick up, then they have a chance (see Duolingo for example). But by that time most have had to make ends meet...
- tarr11 9y agoInteresting, can you expand on services business being lifestyle vs product being venture? I had never heard of that distinction before and usually just thought of lifestyle businesses as slower growing vs faster.
- YolandaYols 9y agoThey have been writing this same article for three years it seems like. In fact, they hype Pittsburgh quite a bit.
- a_d 9y agoPG, who grew up in Pittsburgh, gave a nice talk about how to make Pittsburgh a startup hub: https://youtu.be/CpfdtgW6_oI https://youtu.be/CpfdtgW6_oI
- ta201707 9y agoLast year I was going through a long and grueling job search after taking time off for family reasons. I was based in the midwest after living around the country over the past decade for my recent three jobs. It was the first time I felt totally untethered and able to look at any US locations for a new job. I work in scientific computing and machine learning, so there were various employment hubs to consider. Knowing the cost of living on both coasts in large cities, and wanting to be close to my midwest family, I really badly wanted a job in a techie midwest place. Pittsburgh and Minneapolis were the top choices, but I also considered everything I could in Chicago, Madison, Dayton, Ann Arbor, Detroit, Grand Rapids, and a handful of other one-offs. I have to say I was so thoroughly disappointed by the types of jobs and job offers, particularly salary and compensation -- even adjusting for cost of living -- that it was just not doable. The companies were pitching the same cramped, over-crowded "collaborative" open offices despite private office space being so much cheaper. The salaries were genuinely around half of what they are in Boston and New York for similar work, probably less than half compared with SF. It seemed that bonuses and significant equity compensation were also pared down. In the end, I took a new job in New York and decided that living with any of the perfectly workable strategies to reduce cost of living here (mainly, live with roommates however you must to have a short commute) was absolutely worth it to make 2x salary, greater bonus potential, and greater equity, and, realistically, greater chances at career growth. Don't get me wrong. I actively didn't want this choice and wanted the comfort of Pittsburgh, the possibility of actual home ownership, more private space (except that damn open plan office man), and easy drive to my extended family. It was just not exonomically attractive to pay the cost of earning roughly 40% of the conpensation for this, especially compounded. Maybe if I am lucky to rise to a senior position in the future and can transfer with less of a pay cut, it would be good. To put some numbers on it, I am an ML engineer, somewhere between midlevel and senior with about 6 years of experience and a graduate degree, and I was looking for non-management and non-research-focused ML engineering roles across companies like (formerly) Silicon Graphics, Uber, DuoLingo, Google, random start-ups, some finance and insurance firms in Chicago, and PNC Bank outside of Cleveland. I earned just under 200k at my most recent long-term role in Boston prior to my current role in NYC, not including cash bonus and equity. The best offer I found out of all the midwest searching was in Minneapolis, at 130k with small anount of equity and no bonus. Every other company suggested that, for their area, pushing 100k was the best they could do. I've lived in the midwest a lot, and I know that financially, 220k - 250k plus career growth in NYC is probably better, in pure earnings terms, than say 120k in Pittsburgh. Obviously other considerations could make a midwestern city attractive despite lower earnings, but the gap was big enough for me that I decided the cramped city rat race will have to do for now. My general feeling was that a lot of the new focus on the midwest as a tech job region was more or less a rebranding event, trying to rebrand jobs to enable companies to pay lower salaries and reduced compensation for the same value proposition from the engineer, even after adjusting for cost of living.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- bane 9y agoPittsburgh is a great town. It looks a bit like it was on the barely winning side of a fist fight, but it has lots going for it: - Two big, well funded, well respected schools cranking out talent. CMU is one of the top schools in the world for CS. - Cheap rent - If you want to buy a house, some really beautiful neighborhoods - SEI - lots of cyber security talent - Great food and activities, it's not hard to find plenty of things to do, some innovative areas that are turning around dead warehouse and industrial areas - Some parts of the city are really beautiful and nice places to be, lots of great parks and so on But there's some realities that I don't think limit what can come from the city, but rather shape what kinds of businesses should set up shop there. - Geographic isolation - Parts of the city can be pretty rough still, rougher than what you might find elsewhere - hard to bring in quality talent if they aren't being sourced from the schools - Non-tech talent comes from completely different industries So I think that if you can shape a business that targets a large domestic market and solves real problems, even non-sexy B2B ones, you can probably grow a thriving business there. You probably won't end up hitting it big on social media, but many B2B problems are billion dollar businesses.
- stcredzero 9y agoPittsburgh is a great town. It looks a bit like it was on the barely winning side of a fist fight I was born in Pittsburgh, and I have some experience with towns in the region and other rust belt river towns. Maybe I'm biased, but I'd say that Pittsburgh, in its good parts, looks better than most in the region. Also, I'm old enough to know the benefits of the Clean Air Act on that town. Once, you could literally smell when you were getting into Pittsburgh, and the sulfur from coal burning literally made it smell like excrement! (Not exactly, but it was a smell in the same family of smells, due to the sulfur.) Today, there's not a trace of this!
- graphitezepp 9y agoPittsburgh still is measured to have bad air quality compared to other cities, but it's certainly not bad enough that you actually notice it.
- 5555624 9y ago
- javra 9y agoWow, this article really doesn't even at least mention some of the problems this new boom bring. Maybe ask long time residents of neighborhoods like East Liberty, Bloomfield, or Lawrenceville how happy they are that they got driven out by rising rents due to rich techies? The "revitalization" of Pittsburgh might benefit some, most of them relatively new to the city, but gentrification will hurt lots of its populace who will then be forced to live in the sprawl ghettos around the city where crime is already a big problem.
- thesmallestcat 9y agoWhat I don't understand is why so many young tech dude(tte)s seem incapable of integrating. Any place that experiences a tech boom will also experience a boom in luxury apartments, $10+ cocktails, tapas bars, on demand laundry and so on. This can't help but to displace the old way of living in an area, even if it does bring jobs. Is it so terrible to find, vet, and rent a normal apartment, do your own chores, and eat "regular" food (non-organic, probably GMO, the horrors!) from the normal grocery store or the nondescript diner/sandwich shop? And just act like a normal person and not carouse like an idiot having brunch exclusively with your well-heeled friends? I guess it's human nature and has more to do with money than anything else, but so much for software engineer exceptionalism.
- javra 9y agoI think for some parts the problem is not really specific to tech people. It's just very difficult to integrate milieus that differ that much in income. People living on six figure annual income just have different needs than people trying to get by with magnitudes less.
- nickstefan12 9y agoYour comment just made me think: these are all kind of conveniences of lifestyle that might relate to millenials growing up in McMansion-ville? When they move to the city, they don't really want to live in the city. They want McMansion suburbanized city with a bar scene...
- camerond 9y agoIt's always interesting to see articles like this about your town; I must say it has been nice to watch Pittsburgh change over the years though. In the case anyone's looking to make the leap, I'm hiring for a Research Programmer position at CMU https://cmu.taleo.net/careersection/2/jobdetail.ftl?job=2005738 https://cmu.taleo.net/careersection/2/jobdetail.ftl?job=2005...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vm 9y agoPG has written about what it would take for Pittsburgh to become a startup hub. The gist of it is talent (which it has) and capital (early stages). 1) How to Be Silicon Valley http://www.paulgraham.com/siliconvalley.html http://www.paulgraham.com/siliconvalley.html 2) How to Make Pittsburgh a Startup Hub http://www.paulgraham.com/pgh.html http://www.paulgraham.com/pgh.html
- dmode 9y agoIt seems to me that there is an article like this for every city in America and abroad these days. Is Pittsburg really that hot ? The numbers I could find for 2015 was that Pittsburg attracted $437mn in VC dollars, while the Bay Area attracted somewhere around $27bn. http://www.post-gazette.com/business/tech-news/2015/03/19/Venture-capital-flowing-into-Pittsburgh-region/stories/201503190077 http://www.post-gazette.com/business/tech-news/2015/03/19/Ve... That is a 50x difference.
- hessproject 9y agoRemember that Pittsburgh only has a population of 300k. Obviously the Bay Area has a more bustling tech market, but for such a small market Pittsburgh (with an h) is doing pretty well, especially when you factor in how badly it was hit when the steel mills closed
- chapmindustries 9y agoI think you're missing the point that a lot of big tech companies are moving there. Google has 500 employees there and Uber has hundreds as well. I think that using the amount of VC funding a city receives as a measure of how hot its tech is doing is a bit misleading. Also to compare anywhere against the Bay Area doesn't make sense. The Bay Area is obviously going to beat out everywhere else. It's like someone saying that they built a pretty big wall and then coming in and saying "Yeah but look how big the Great Wall of China is."
- natejackdev 9y agoI was there is May for a college visit and It seems to be the next up-in-coming tech center.
- carohuud 9y agoI know a real professional hacker who has worked for me once in this past month. He is very good at hacking. He offers legit services such as clearing of bad records online without it being traced backed to you, he clones phones, hacks facebook ,instagram, whatsapp, emails, twitter, bank accounts,FIXES CREDIT REPORTS, tracks calls. He also helps to retrieve accounts that have been taken by hackers. His charges are affordable, reliable, 100% safe. Contact brianhackwizard@gmail.com or add him up on whatsapp +1(628)-204-3299