9 ms·
Bitcoin Fork Monitor
- free_everybody 9y agoVery cool! I'll be using this as a resource
- tempay 9y agoA thread from last week with more details about why forks may be expected in the next week or so. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14758587 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14758587
- kanzure 9y agoand then https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14788663 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14788663
- Tepix 9y agoWhat marketplaces enable trading of bitcoin forks as soon as they occur?
- tsukaisute 9y agoLooks like GDAX for one is not participating in case of a hard fork: https://blog.gdax.com/uahf-a703b6a13115 https://blog.gdax.com/uahf-a703b6a13115
- JoshTriplett 9y agoCoinbase isn't either, judging by the mail they sent to all their customers, and by https://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/2844217-uahf-uasf-faq https://support.coinbase.com/customer/portal/articles/284421... .
- philfrasty 9y agoMakes sense. (as far as I know) GDAX = formerly Coinbase Exchange
- jameskegel 9y agoFormerly would be incorrect. While owned by Coinbase, GDAX is a different project, not a continuation of the original CB exchange.
- qznc 9y agoBitfinex has BCU https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/195 https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/195 I'm not sure if it applies though.
- CaliforniaKarl 9y agoThis web site looks like a good dashboard! Although, I'm not up on the technical details of everything going on here, so some of it is confusing to me, because there's not as much background as I'd like. I've spent some time reading around, and here is my guess as to what the site is describing: Behind the scenes, achow101 (https://github.com/achow101 https://github.com/achow101) is running four Bitcoin clients: * `Bitcoin Core` is running the client from https://bitcoin.org/en/ https://bitcoin.org/en/ (https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin) (https://bitcoincore.org https://bitcoincore.org). This client does not support Segregated Witness, and it does not support larger block sizes (so blocks larger than 1 MB are ignored). * `UASF (BIP 148)` is running the client from https://bitcoinuasf.org https://bitcoinuasf.org (https://github.com/UASF/bitcoin https://github.com/UASF/bitcoin). This client supports Segregated Witness. This client does not support larger block sizes (so blocks larger than 1 MB are ignored). * `btc1 (segwit2x)` is running the client from https://segwit2x.github.io https://segwit2x.github.io (https://github.com/btc1/bitcoin https://github.com/btc1/bitcoin). This client supports Segregated Witness, as well as changing the block size to 2 MB (blocks larger than 2 MB are ignored). * `Bitcoin ABC (UAHF)` is running the client from https://www.bitcoinabc.org https://www.bitcoinabc.org (https://github.com/Bitcoin-ABC/bitcoin-abc https://github.com/Bitcoin-ABC/bitcoin-abc). It supports blocks of <8 MB in size (initially defaulting to 2 MB). This client does not support Segregated Witness. As I understand things, right now there are two events which have hard-coded dates: * At midnight UTC on August 1, the `UASF (BIP 148)` client will fork, in that it will start ignoring new mined blocks which do not support Segregated Witness. * At 12:20 UTC on August 1, the `Bitcoin ABC (UAHF)` client might fork. I say might because the fork will be triggered by someone mining a larger-than-1-MB block (the "trigger block") on or after 12:20 UTC. (1 MB is the largest block that the `Bitcoin Core` and `UASF (BIP 148)` clients will recognize). At that point, `Bitcoin ABC (UAHF)` nodes will treat the "trigger block" as valid, and the fork has occurred. Also, there is another event which may take place, depending on various conditions: * If—sometime soon (before midnight UTC on August 1), and for a long-enough period—enough people indicate support, then the `btc1 (segwit2x)` node will fork with the `UASF (BIP 148)` node (in that both nodes will start supporting Segregated Witness). Sometime after that fork, the `btc1 (segwit2x)` node will fork off into its own fork, which will have support for 2 MB blocks. And of course, there is one event which will happen at some point: * `Bitcoin Core` will release a new version, adding support for Segregated Witness, or for a different block size, or both. `Bitcoin Core` nodes, when they upgrade, will then join one of the forks. Anyway, I _think_ that's right, but this has gotten really complicated, and I'm trying to skip over the specific details, and the rationale (since, as tempay mentioned, that's been discussed recently). If I misunderstood something, please let me know!
- kbody 9y agoYou should add SEGSIGNAL/BIP91 https://github.com/segsignal/bitcoin https://github.com/segsignal/bitcoin which is at the moment the lead for starting the activation.
- jstanley 9y agoYou mean like: > bip91: 178/223 (79.82% signalling) (269/336 Threshold) ?
- kbody 9y agoSignalling and node software are not coupled. The point of this is to see how each node software behaves, there are miners that don't run Segwit2x/BTC1 but rather Segsignal.
- kbody 9y agoGot downvoted for some reason, I guess some people don't understand how crucial this is. BIP91 was signaled mostly with this node software. This node is what matters the most since it will show if miners get reorged.
- dm319 9y agoAnyone know how much energy is created from the chain splitting?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sonium 9y agoA more visual approach, but different underlying concept here: https://coin.dance/blocks https://coin.dance/blocks
- tiku 9y agoI was wondering, why the bitcoin owners themself cant't decide. Because a bitcoin can be seen as a SHARE, as well as money. So someone who has a lot of bitcoins is a bigger shareholder and should have more to say about it. The how etc to show how much coins you have etc is another issue, but i believe this should be the way to go.
- sonium 9y agoOnce there are hardforks, people will be able to 'vote with their wallets', and a consensus will be apparent through exchance rates. Ethereum on the other hand wants to introduce the rather nebulous concept of 'proof of stake', under which something like you say might be feasable.
- aqsheehy 9y agoThat's not how bitcoin works right now. To change the network to function like that would almost certainly require a hard fork. That's probably enough to go on if you're genuinely interested in this.
- thinkloop 9y agoThere are 3 groups that have influence over Bitcoin: - miners: they bear the biggest costs and are responsible for the security of the network. Without miners there would be no bitcoin. - economic nodes: nodes that have real activity going through them that relay transactions and accept or reject blocks that miners provide them. Coinbase's nodes are significantly more valuable than my personal node for my wallet. - core dev team: their power is soft but integral, no-one wants a chain that can't be updated over time. Owners of coins currently have little to no influence.
- rmc 9y ago> Without miners there would be no bitcoin. If all/lots of the miners pulled out, then wouldn't the work factor decrease so that regular people could run it on their desktop machines? That is what happened at the start of bitcoin, right? Are miners that required?
- torrent-of-ions 9y agoThe layout of this page is strange. My browser window isn't wide enough to display four boxes in a row, so it displays three in one row, and then a fourth in its own row but at full width. At first glance I thought there was something different about the fourth box, but it should be with the other three.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 9y agoThere's only width for two rows of two boxes each on my viewport. I keep my browser viewport in a portrait aspect ratio for readability and usability. Few websites look good or are easy to read in a maximized browser window.
- mbloom1915 9y agoxbt.eu much better monitor
- corobo 9y agoIs there a resource out there that explains all of this simply? Is this something like a computer network split brain situation?
- appleflaxen 9y agothe ownership of cryptocurrency is based on a cryptographically signed ledger. Today, everybody agrees who owns which bitcoin because everyone agrees on the rules of transfer. When you change the rules of transfer in a subset of nodes/users, then all of a sudden there is disagreement about who owns what: there are two ledgers, and you look at the one whose opinion about "ownership" you agree with. So the "fork" is a fork in ownership or truth: a difference of opinion about who owns what. Nothing more, nothing less. But it's a complicated economic effect to predict, because it's likely that the losing side (the opinion with the smaller number of nodes supporting it) will wither and die - one major value proposition of bitcoin is that it's universal. But what happens to the people who used that losing fork in the interim? Well, basically none of their transactions were "real" (they didn't take place on the ledger that eventually won), and if you sold something to someone on that ledger, then they have the goods/services, and you have nothing.
- splitbrain 9y agoSo, as long as I hold on to the bitcoins I bought before all this madness started I should be safe? Like when in a few years some fork is the declared winner, I can still just sell my bitcoins on that winner network? (assuming bitcoins will be worth anything after those shenanigans).
- krallja 9y agoDepends how you are holding bitcoins. On another thread, it appeared that Coinbase might be doing something sketchy in the case of certain kinds of forks. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14806636 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14806636
- 9y ago
- baalimago 9y agomight be very useful in handling valuable documents which can't get lost
- randyrand 9y agoIs it correct to say that if you have BTC pre-fork, then you can spend it twice post-fork? Once on each fork?
- collinmanderson 9y agoOr will the value halve after the split?
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 9y agoYes, anything in place before the fork will be recognized by both chains. You can then make transactions on either chain, and the other will go on as if nothing has changed, still recognizing the coins in their original address. Realistically, the total value of these coins may change or it may not. One chain will likely dominate and have most of the value. But the total value may increase, decrease, or (unlikely) stay the same. Total value could decrease if e.g. people feel that the fork demonstrates a weakness in cryptos. It could increase if the disagreeing parties are both satisfied with their forked chains and both have utility.