6 ms·
California’s Housing Crisis Reaches a ‘Breaking Point’
- mars4rp 9y agoa war between home owners and renters! as a person that recently bought a house I don't want my house price to go down too much, I put everything I have in it. but I really know this is the problem for renters and it needs to be solved. when a group uses government for personal gain, other groups has to pay the price! it is called democracy, 49% has to pay for 51% !
- enraged_camel 9y agoIf I bought a house I would be happy if it's price stayed the same over the years, or even slightly decreased. As long as I come out on top compared to the alternative (renting) I'm OK.
- ouid 9y agoand, thanks to the mortgage interest tax credit, you probably will. Get rid of that though, and suddenly there's no economic incentive to own property. The MITC is a hugely regressive policy.
- johnbrodie 9y agoI must be doing it wrong. We bought a house in AZ with a 15 year, 2.99% interest rate. The MITC made almost no difference, even for the first year where I was paying mostly interest.
- ouid 9y agoyou need to spend more money on your house then.
- blobbers 9y agoYou get back roughly 30% of your paid mortgage interest. But yes, you should have taken a 30 year fixed if you wanted a larger credit. Its free leverage.
- vonmoltke 9y agoYou'd need to have enough deductions to itemize without the mortgage interest deduction and be making well over six figures for that to be the case. I personally don't come close to itemizing without mortgage interest, so I was seeing far less than that. My wife and I combined were barely in the six figures (taxable) when we actually owned our house as well, so we got back about $1k in taxes on about $12k in interest.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoPaying more in interest in order to get more back on your taxes is a losing proposition.
- kthejoker2 9y agoNot just more in interest, you're also reducing principal so there's some opportunity cost from an investment perspective. Really comes down to how long you intend to stay in the home.
- vonmoltke 9y ago> Get rid of that though, and suddenly there's no economic incentive to own property. How do you figure that? What about cost stability? What about not losing 100% of your payment (that is, retaining some as equity)? I'm not saying there is always an incentive; some markets favor renting over buying in spite of the MITD. However, saying the only reason buying is financially attractive makes no sense. Edit: corrected C (credit) to D (deduction), since it is technically correct and makes a big difference in it's usefulness.
- ouid 9y agorental rates are exactly the same thing as interest rates (+/- wear and tear and so forth). what you retain in equity, you would equally retain by simply not paying into some other investment. There's nothing special about owning your home, there's no arbitrage to be had beyond the MITC.
- vonmoltke 9y ago> rental rates are exactly the same thing as interest rates (+/- wear and tear and so forth). In what world? I have never seen a market where rents were below P&I for a comparably-priced house[1]. I would love to see a real example of this. [1] Note that this does not automatically make buying better, as rent factors many costs P&I does not.
- ouid 9y agoBecause if not there would be an incredible opportunity for arbitrage.
- rpearl 9y agothe home-as-an-investment-for-profit mentality leads to some really poor social interactions. I wish we had different social norms around housing. For instance, after a 1980s crash, Tokyo's housing norms shifted and the result seems really healthy: https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c60?mhq5j=e3 https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3...
- dredmorbius 9y agoIt does indeeed. I need to crack the paywall on that FT item, but I've had my own recent epiphany on asset price inflation of maslovian goods (and housing in particular). I'm thinking a lot about land tax. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_price_inflation_of_maslovian_and_productive/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_p...
- ac29 9y ago> I need to crack the paywall on that FT item https://archive.fo/Pf2Uu https://archive.fo/Pf2Uu Interesting article. I wonder if any Japanese (or someone familiar enough with the culture) could comment.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThanks, yeah, I got through -- googling the link gets through as well.
- pfranz 9y agoWhy does the price matter? I recently bought a house. There was "opportunity" in a "up and coming areas." It might have had up sides, but I didn't want the risk either. If the house price goes up I won't realize any of the gains until I sell it. That's likely going into another house. If the market moves as a whole then the price doesn't really matter (it would make "upgrading" more expensive). So I'm not worried about short term fluctuations in price. I, honestly, just want the price to stay the same.
- mars4rp 9y agobecause I can't sell my house and move to another one, I am stuck in this one until I die!!! I owe 80% of my current house value, if prices goes down even 10% I lost half of my down payment !!!
- pfranz 9y agoWell, yeah. That's why you can't finance 100% of the house and that's the problem with paying the minimum 20%. If the value drops 10% and that applies to the whole neighborhood, you still have about the same downpayment for a comparable house. You really don't want to be moving around often, anyway. If the house stays the same and you move in a year or two (before you build much more equity) you lose money in fees...not to mention what a pain in the ass moving it. The only time your'd fully realize any gains or losses (outside of being upside down) is when you downsize or move to an apartment. That's never really anyone's goal. A house is a terrible investment tool and shouldn't be seen as one.
- vinhboy 9y agoWe need a mindset change. Jobs that can be done remotely, should be done remotely. Making people commute to office buildings to fill cubicles is crazy. They should be able to live where they want and not waste 2 hours a day burning fossil fuel.
- bpicolo 9y ago> Jobs that can be done remotely, should be done remotely There are a whole lot of jobs that don't really fit into that. Programmer-sphere is pretty unique there. And not all programmers (certainly a minority) map well to remote work.
- bkohlmann 9y agoIt seems though that most people want to live where rents are already the highest (which is why rents are high!). The nurse quoted in the article who drives 2 hours to reach SF wants to work closer to her hospital in the city. That job in particular is hard to do remotely. From a practical standpoint, it seems like a large percentage of people in the Bay Area would prefer to live in the City or very near it. Yet, this is a physical impossibility. The ways to allocate scarce resources comes down to two methods: let the market decide or let government decide. Either way, folks will be left out.
- ouid 9y agoif the market were to decide, there would be more, denser housing.
- bkohlmann 9y agoIf there were no zoning regulations, you are absolutely right...and this would've resolved itself long ago. But there are strong zoning and property rights at play. I'm very libertarian, and was priced out of the Bay Area (recently left grad school for Texas), but I'm actually sympathetic to the homeowners there who are using democratic means (i.e. their elected city reps) to support their interests. Society (in the form of the state government) could upend the property rights they are leveraging...but that would have significant incentive repercussions down the line. It would greatly weaken property rights...which is a foundation of Western society. There are far deeper, and interesting, issues aside from mere housing stock.
- technojunkie 9y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14728194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14728194 There's no simple solution to this crisis and I'd bet we'll see several more states go through this sooner than later.
- thebokehwokeh2 9y agoEasy solution... triple the real estate tax on all second homes all over the world. There is no sensible logic in why real estate is treated like the stock market.
- avasylev 9y agoI like idea of taxing higher unoccupied homes. If someone wants to make investment, great make investment and either pay high taxes (support folks who do live there) or have to rent it.
- ams6110 9y agoRidiculous solution. Even pretending there is any taxing authority with jurisdiction "all over the world" using tax code to try to change behaviors just creates a lot of creative avoidance and unintended consequences.
- JKCalhoun 9y ago> using tax code to try to change behaviors It's what we do though. Mortgage loan interest deductible to get people to purchase homes, capital gains tax is low to encourage longer-term investing....
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoWhich property owners, or aspiring property owners, are going to vote for that?
- thesmallestcat 9y ago> Heather Lile, a nurse who makes $180,000 a year, commutes two hours from her home in Manteca to the San Francisco hospital where she works, 80 miles away. “I make really good money and it’s frustrating to me that I can’t afford to live close to my job,” said Ms. Lile. OK, that's a load of crap. I don't know what you're doing with your money, but you can definitely live in SF on $180k. And if you can't, well, name your destination that's within two hours, it'll be cheaper than most of SF. I'm guessing she needed/found the perfect home.
- ProAm 9y agoWith a family as a single parent?
- jldugger 9y agoDepends on childcare costs, but probably. My budget for SF requires about $150k and includes unusually high retirement savings.
- rconti 9y agoYup. And choosing to live in Manteca is utterly insane. It's FAR more than 2 hours at rush hour. Barely 2 hours with no traffic. That is 100% a choice. I don't know why she chooses that, but it's a choice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rajeshp1986 9y agoI don't understand why cities around SF are not building high rise buildings. If there is no space to expand, you should build high rise building which can accommodate more people. I understand there are zoning laws which prevent from building taller buildings, but if you see the landscape in south-bay they are all single story houses. The land could be utilized in a better way and build bigger housing complexes with multi-story buildings. I don't understand why city administrations are not taking this step and rather pushing the rent & house prices which is forcing people to spend 50% of their salary on housing.
- __jal 9y agoGo sit in on a meeting in Mountain View or Cupertino. Existing home owners don't want it and the elected admins don't want it. They are happy to foist the problem off on, well, just about anywhere else. They want wealthy folks in detached single-family homes, and the fact that they host companies that employ more people than can live there means constant upward pressure on home prices and the tax base. In other words, it is an externality just like pollution that the producers don't want to internalize.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoSouth San Jose are building condos and apartments (maybe 4 stories tall, skyscrapers only in the "Everything's up-to-date in Kansas City" sort of way). Still, this density of housing is only going to put more pressure on the already strained highways that take people north to the jobs. Next year the article will read, "California's Commuting Crisis Reaches a 'Breaking Point'."
- sbov 9y agoAll of those, plus a mini mall for good measure, on land that used to be a large source of tech jobs for the surrounding area. How many mini malls does a suburb really need? I have a friend-of-a-friend who used to work for a big company decommissioning these old campuses. He claimed they always pushed heavily for commercial because there are fewer lawsuits related to groundwater contamination and such.
- joe_the_user 9y agoI just want to point out that the "Cost of a Hot Economy" headline is baloney - or rather it's part of the story but the least important part of the story, used as a cover for the more important processes at work. Whatever the unemployment rate, the present level of "economic growth" is very much a product of a lot of money being pumped into the "real economy" and large portion of this money leaking out into investments like houses that are perceived as more solid and reliable than companies engaged in production [1]. The old effect of printing was a consumption-goods price spiral but the new, more hidden effect is capital-good price spiral (housing bubbles etc). But, of course, if wages aren't increasing and costs of living are, a little bit of increase goes a long to making people's lives unlivable. And it's worth noting that rent-increases are happening in a wide variety of town in the US. Everywhere they're attributed to local factors and that further muddies the wasters concerning the root cause. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_easing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_easing
- ac29 9y agoYou'd be hard pressed to see where quantitative easing began and ended looking at this graph of home prices in California, San Francisco, and Santa Clara County [0] (from a longer report here[1]). From your linked article, QE in the US lasted approximately 2008-2014, with some of the steepest decrease in home prices occurring during that period, and steepest increases occurring after it ended. I'm not entirely sure there is compelling evidence QE contributed to housing price increases in California or the Bay Area, but I'd be interested if anyone had data to the contrary. [0] http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/3305/Bay-Area-Home-Prices-Outpaced-the-State.png http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/3305/Bay-Area-Home-Prices... [1] http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3305 http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3305
- joe_the_user 9y agoSigh... The processes involved here are much larger scale than the particulars of the California housing market (indeed, if you read my original you'll I already mentioned that California is just one blip in world-wide trend). California just happens to be a place which attracts money when money is being "manufacturer". Whether one has quantitative easing in particular or too-big-to-fail banks issuing bonds or simple bubble-dynamics, you have a process where money flows from productive assets to stores of value. If someone wished to learn something about the current financial climate, I would refer that someone to Doug Noland's Credit Bubble Bulletin. http://creditbubblebulletin.blogspot.com/p/credit-bubble-bulletin.html http://creditbubblebulletin.blogspot.com/p/credit-bubble-bul...
- Mz 9y agoOne of the problems is that the average size of a new single family home has been increasing for decades: http://eyeonhousing.org/2014/01/average-size-of-new-single-family-homes-continues-to-rise/ http://eyeonhousing.org/2014/01/average-size-of-new-single-f... According to data from the Census the Quarterly Starts and Completions by Purpose and Design survey, the average and median size of single-family homes that began construction rose during 2013. For the third quarter alone, the average single-family square footage increased from 2,646 to 2,701, while the median rose from 2,446 to 2,491. In the 1950s, average size of a new home was less than half that, at around 1200 sq ft. It also held, on average, more people. I strongly suspect this is partly driven by tax incentives that are aimed at upper class families and help create or fuel a growing divide between the Have and Have Nots.
- pfranz 9y agoI don't know if that's the case for the large cities in California. As far as I've seen in Los Angeles, it's not new construction. If it is, it's major renovations to old buildings (tearing down a 80yo bungalow that had been extended to 1br and building a modern 2br) and they're limited by the lot size. In LA there's new luxury condos being built, but I've been in half a dozen apartments in the 12 years I've lived here and the newest was built in the 80's. You can definitely see the living space increases since the 20's, but it hasn't ballooned to the size of new construction in most of the rest of the country. Looking at my peers in houses, it's fairly similar. They all moved far out of the city, but none of it is new construction.
- Mz 9y agoFunny, I have lived in several California cities over the years. I am routinely appalled at the not terribly old, ginormous houses that I walk past. This has been true every place I have lived. I am currently at the research stage for trying to buy a house. My magic 8 ball increasingly suggests "not in California -- please move elsewhere, since you have portable income."
- pfranz 9y ago
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoI've said it before in other threads, but I highly recommend The Color of Law by Richard Rothstein for anyone interested in this topic. Much of today's housing crisis is a direct result of blatantly racist policies that were implemented to keep out PoC out of white neighborhoods. Ordinances like minimum lot sizes, heigh restrictions etc. are the very same tools used by NIMBYs to keep new developments out of their neighborhoods, and choking the US economy.
- JKCalhoun 9y agoThen the jobs should simply move away from the NIMBYs.
- nxsynonym 9y agoExcept the jobs worth moving for are built by, and favor, NIMBYs. The jobs won't leave city centers because they attract employees by exploiting the culture of the city they're based in, which is built on the backs of "undesirables". Why are none of the 'big 4' based out of middle-of-nowhere-America? Because nobody want's to live in a place where the idea of culture is TGI Friday's and an old navy outlet.
- ransom1538 9y agoTrue but a bit chicken and egg. If you brought a large company to a nowhere place - the hipster yoga, expensive wine bars, and snooty farm to table places move in eventually.
- MK_Dev 9y agoHow about taxing 2nd, 3rd, Nth properties, unoccupied properties and foreign investors? Right, the "T"-word...
- sliken 9y agoSeems silly to allow cities to allow development to add jobs but not housing. It's terrible for the environment, the state, traffic, pollution, etc. Doubly insane is that seems like it's standard procedure to mandate parking space per square foot of commercial space, but not a place for the workers housed within to live. What's more important, a parking space or a bed?
- brudgers 9y agoHousing prices reflect decades of public policy decisions. For example, HOPE VI took hundreds of units out of San Francisco [2] and about half a million units of public housing out of circulation across the US. [1] Even if there was a strong shift in public policy, the housing market in California would take decades to express the effects in a way that would be noticeable to most people...and that's assuming that the affordable housing policies don't simply enable more construction that quickly moves upmarket. [1]: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35913577 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-35913577 [2]: According to James Tracy, training institute coordinator at San Francisco's Community Housing Partnership, only by organizing did North Beach residents win a guarantee from the San Francisco Housing Authority and Bridge Housing that all of the units would be replaced. In fact, North Beach Place actually added units, from 229 units in the original project to 341 units today. (At Plaza East in the Western Addition, 276 high-rise units were replaced by 193 townhouses and flats; Hayes Valley saw 294 units demolished and 193 rebuilt; Bernal Dwellings replaced 208 units with 160.) "The success of Hope VI depends on your standard," Tracy said. "For the housing authority and developer, once a new building is up, that defines success. But from a standpoint of community preservation, losing units in the San Francisco housing market is not a successful project." http://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2005-03-01/hope-vi-san-francisco http://www.spur.org/publications/urbanist-article/2005-03-01...
- cjensen 9y agoHousing and Jobs need to be in balance. If there is "not enough housing" what you are really saying is "cities permitted more business capacity than housing capacity." Those two markets really need to be tied to each other. Doesn't matter if your personal view is "too much growth" or "let's keep growing", either way the capacities need to be in balance.
- dredmorbius 9y agoIf you go back to read the early classical economists -- Adam Smith, David Ricardo, Robert Malthus (who didn't just talk about births and food), John Stuart Mill (and his father), etc., you'll find a that much discussion is given to the price behaviour of certain economic goods and services, in ways that sounds odd today: commodities, wages, stock, interest, and rent. Wages and rent most especially. The reason for the discussion is that the price behaviours are, well, interesting. Economic rent (not quite the same as what you pay for an apartment) in particular, rises to absorb surplus value, whilst wages fall to the bare minimum necessary for survival (if that -- Smith's story of economic decline is bleak). https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations https://en.m.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Wealth_of_Nations There's an added dynamic -- one I've only just realised, though I'm sure it shows up in the literature, of the tendency for those holding any given economic asset (some store of value) to do what they can to see that its value increases. And why not: free money! This becomes quite problematic where those assets are themselves productive, or worse, Maslovian (that is, essential) goods: https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_price_inflation_of_maslovian_and_productive/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/608w97/asset_p... The upshot is that the prices of such goods, including housing, tends to increase. (This applies as well to professional certifications and licenses, taxi medallions (viz: Lyft, Uber), guilds, educational access, etc. etc.) The classic response suggested has been a land tax: a tax which applies to the unimproved value of a given lot. The economic notion is that the supply of land is inelastic (that is: suppliers cannot provide more of it, and won't withdraw from the market). The tax increases the costs of carrying unimproved land, or occupying land below its full utilisation. By tweaking the rate of tax reduction as land value falls (based on income-earning potential), it would be possible to encourage or discourage sprawl (slightly underpace value decline to concentrate development, overpace value decline to encourage wider development). The idea is most associated with Henry George (who came up with the idea ... faced with skyrocketing rents in San Francisco), but is absolutely grounded in classical economics and economists. What I'm slowly coming to realise is that what's almost certainly required is a joint policy which targets wages, on the one hand, and rents (or land value) on the other (and probably a few others). In addition to a land tax, some sort of employer of last resort which would pay at least a minimum living wage (possibly then bidding out labour to other entities, or utilising it for itself). Some form of UBI or needs-based support (children, elderly, disabled, students) would cover other cases. Without a land tax, this income is simply pocketed by rentiers. The combination of EoLR/UBI and Land Tax puts the income back into flow within the real (that is, commodities and services) economy. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_tax https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_tax I've also learnt just earlier today that the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy started as a Georgian Land Tax advocacy organisation, though I'm not sure if they continue to pursue this interest. http://www.lincolninst.edu http://www.lincolninst.edu And yes, California's Prop 13 legacy is one hell of an albatross. https://ballotpedia.org/Article_XIII_A,_California_Constitution https://ballotpedia.org/Article_XIII_A,_California_Constitut...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]