15 ms·
“You’re Not the Customer, You’re the Product”
- j_s 9y ago2007: “You are the product.” 2017: “You are the training data.” https://twitter.com/chrisalbon/status/857609299731791872 https://twitter.com/chrisalbon/status/857609299731791872 - 27 Apr 2017
- harryf 9y agohttp://geekandpoke.typepad.com/geekandpoke/2010/12/the-free-model.html http://geekandpoke.typepad.com/geekandpoke/2010/12/the-free-...
- seanwilson 9y agoI find this quote is always used in a really over the top way. I don't find free services that show me ads I can easily ignore scary. People talk about ads and recommendation systems like they're going to brainwash you into buying things you never actually wanted as if you have zero critical thinking skills.
- savanaly 9y agoI know right? Additionally, ads do serve an economic purpose. As a reductio ad absurdum, picture a world with all advertisement banned. If you were an inventor or innovator who came up with a superior product or streamlined some process and inclined to start your own business to compete on cost or quality, your options are a lot more limited if you can't buy ads. People are rightfully concerned about the privacy invasion from precisely targeted ads. But they should decouple that concern from the benefits of more targeted ads which are more efficient, because that benefit is real. It does not just benefit businesses either (which are, after all, owned by people in the end), advertisement will increase consumer surplus in many cases as well.
- seanwilson 9y ago> As a reductio ad absurdum, picture a world with all advertisement banned. If you were an inventor or innovator who came up with a superior product or streamlined some process and inclined to start your own business to compete on cost or quality, your options are a lot more limited if you can't buy ads. Yeah, I don't understand what people who peddle this quote expect individuals/companies to do to get their product noticed if ads are unethical apparently. You're just meant to rely on word of mouth starting from nothing? I don't see what's wrong with telling people about your product to see if they're interested. Ads in specific newspapers, posters in a street, handing out leaflets in a certain area, ads during a specific TV show etc. are all forms of targeted marketing as well.
- blub 9y agoI think you must have missed the last ~15 years and where the advertising industry has turned more and more to spying on the customers of their real customers for profit. The misconduct of the players in the ad business is legendary. If I were you, I would try to educate myself before continuing to write here.
- seanwilson 9y agoObviously I'm against spying on people. You can show people ads in ways that isn't invading their privacy.
- majewsky 9y agoIt's not just privacy. It's also attention that's invaded. Among the many buzzwords of recent years is the "attention economy". It has already existed for quite a long time (newspapers selling ad space are actually selling their readers' eyeballs), but since a few years ago, ad companies have the technology to optimize for maximum attention. The effects of attention economy can be witnessed in reports of people quitting Facebook temporarily as a kind of detox, or the general uncluttering movement (caused by sensory overload which is in turn caused by attention parasites like social networks, and our generally hectic lifestyle). In my opinion, the costs of the attention economy outweigh its benefits.
- sintaxi 9y agoSeeing ads don't brainwash you. Seeing ads that are targeted to you based on the content you consume and your browsing patterns brainwashes you.
- seanwilson 9y ago> Seeing ads don't brainwash you. Seeing ads that are targeted to you based on the content you consume and your browsing patterns brainwashes you. I know to be extra skeptical of claims in ads and to do proper research before I buy things. Friends and family give recommendations all the time which I apply critical thinking skills to as well...I don't just blindly do things people suggest to me. Have you honestly ever felt you've been brainwashed by ads somehow?
- blub 9y agoThis is an extremely naive point of view. Advertising influences purchasing behaviour and feelings about particular brands. You can apply critical thinking skills left, right, up, down and sideways, it won't matter if you're flooded with ads for Samsung. And if you somehow figure out that Samsung's products have a tendency to catch fire, Coca Cola will get you. And if you figure out that Coke is sugary crap, one of the other tens of thousands of products will get you. Because you're probably not applying critical thinking skills to pick your toilet paper, detergent, dog food, toothbrushes, light bulbs and so on and you're not doing that non stop. People that think they're immune to advertising are ironically the easiest to influence, like fish in a barrel.
- rosser 9y agoThe far more insidious part of (some) advertising is how it makes "consumers" feel about themselves. Poke that little nugget of self-doubt someone carries (because we all do), and then tell them you have just the thing to make it better. You don't even have to be explicit about it; just show them people onto whom they can project not suffering that doubt, and associate those people, and the fantasy of feeling that way too, with your product. Cha-ching! EDIT: phrasing.
- 9y ago
- onion2k 9y agoIt's the ubiquitous and often insidious profiling of everything you do that's scary. The ads are just part of the mechanism of how the profiling is paid for and delivered. The data about what you do, as the basis of a model of your future behaviour, is what has the potential to be incredibly damaging.
- rosser 9y agoIt's not about being scary. Why on earth would you think that? It's about creating cognizance of the fact that someone else is making money off your behavior. You can be scared of that if you want, but creating that fear is certainly not the aim. I personally think things which increase people's general cognizance of the world around them are net goods. There's damned little enough of that as it is.
- seanwilson 9y ago> It's not about being scary. Why on earth would you think that? Telling someone they've been tricked and have been turned into a product is ominous sounding to me.
- rosser 9y ago> ...to me. That's your choice, consciously or otherwise. There's no trickery here. It's not like this is being hidden from people. It's just not widely recognized.
- saimiam 9y agoSin of omission vs commission.. When a cop doesn't explicitly read you your Miranda rights because they want you to incriminate yourself by delaying access to counsel, they aren't lying per se. You are expected to know that cops can exploit you but you, naively, expect good faith behavior from them. FD - see my profile.
- stubish 9y agoIt is ominous. You are being farmed. If you are not aware what the service is costing you, you are being exploited. Are there some more benign terms to use to spin this? Or are the correct terms negatively loaded for a reason? This is particularly important if you believe minors should not be able to enter contracts. By using 'free' services, they are selling something unknowingly, maybe something they can't get back. "additional terms or product requirements (including age requirements) may apply" is there for a reason; an attempt to avoid liability.
- egypturnash 9y agoSo When the real product is eyeballs on ads You start to optimize for that. You get users to keep reloading. You get users to stick around. Because the more pages they load, the more money you make. It doesn't matter why people keep reloading. Doesn't matter if they're being shown things they really need. Doesn't matter if they're being shown truth or lies. Doesn't matter if they're reloading a lot because they're in the middle of a flame war. Doesn't matter if they're left happier or stressed out by using your product. It just matters that they saw a lot of ads. This is why the much-loathed algorithmic timelines happen: here's something a lot of your circles spent time engaging with, maybe you'll like it too! Stick around. See more ads.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lazaroclapp 9y agoNot completely untrue. But if the model is a paid subscription the same pressures apply: doesn't matter why the user keeps paying their subscription, so long as they pay. Incentives are almost never perfectly aligned between information providers and information consumers. .
- donmatito 9y agoThe incentives for "as long as you're happy with our services, you'll keep paying us" may not be 100% aligned with user interest (see: services difficult to unsubscribe and so on) but they seem much better than the alternatives.
- dsabanin 9y agoBut doesn't "as long as you're happy with our services, you'll be using our product and we get to show you ads and make money" work the same way?
- donmatito 9y agoAt first, probably, yes. But then you start to optimize for different things, because the interests are not aligned : you want "engaged eyeballs" on your service, which may or may not be best for the user. Hence tactics like gamification, notifications, the whole Hooked model, and so on. Of course we can debate on the definition of what is "best" for the user. Maybe users like and need clickbait headlines and fake news. But to me it's just a softer version of "Maybe users like gambling machines and being addicted to cigarettes"
- trophycase 9y agoThe fact that the companies that sell these ads are wildly profitable suggests otherwise.
- dsacco 9y agoThere is no a priori reason to conclude advertisements are brainwashing people based on their profitability.
- beagle3 9y agoTwo of those wildly profitable companies, namely Google and Facebook, are monopolies in their niche, and can thus extract a rent that would seem untenable if competition were around. Are there any other wildly profitable companies that sell ads?
- dingo_bat 9y ago> I don't find free services that show me ads I can easily ignore scary. Please tell me how to ignore google search and google maps.
- icebraining 9y agoI think seanwilson is saying that the ads are easily ignorable.
- piyush_soni 9y agoBy like ... not using them?
- RandomKid 9y agoBy using duckduckgo and openstreetmap. I've been using both for many years and they are quite good, I would say.
- lloeki 9y agoOn iOS luckily enough I found Apple Maps to have crossed the good enough threshold for most of my purposes and area, except for the occasional live and timetable transit info.
- logicallee 9y agoGoogle search: alight your eye on the first result that is not clearly and distinctly marked "Ad" (you may have to scroll.) For example I did this search since I expected it to be heavily ad-based: http://i.imgur.com/j4ezbjF.png http://i.imgur.com/j4ezbjF.png everything above the fold (visible in my browser) was an ad. I then scrolled down and got to the organic search results: http://i.imgur.com/hlVB36Q.png http://i.imgur.com/hlVB36Q.png Those are not advertisements. There is nothing to ignore. Google is not paid to show me those, and they fight link-spammers every day to attempt to get the best organic results. I find Google's search results ads to be exceedingly easy to ignore. I also find them useful and sometimes click them.
- cooervo 9y agoIf you think ads don't work in you it means they are doing a great job in lying to you and deceiving. Ads and marketing are more subtle than you can imagine. Some example: * You don't need to change toothbrush every 6 months, that's BS. Toothbrushes are plastic they are going to last hundreds of year more after we are all dead. * You don't need to put so much toothpaste on your toothbrush, it was Colgate ads that started showing people putting a fat and thick long toothpaste on toothbrushes to encourage more use/consuming of toothpaste. * The alkasetzer guys wanted to double sells, what did they do started showing commercials of people throwing 2 tablets instead of one. * Also shampoo and hairproducts, they started showing people putting a ton of shampoo in their hands and making bubbles in their head. Actually you don't need that much shampoo.
- dmurray 9y agoI'm sure you're right in general, but I notice a huge difference between a new toothbrush and one that's I've used for a couple of months. The bristles are stiffer and straighter. If my gums are sensitive, the new one will make them bleed, which is probably a good thing. Sure, it hasn't physically decomposed, but there's no reason to expect a $1 piece of plastic to keep the same performance after hundreds of thousands of abrasions in a wet, acidic, bacteria-ridden environment.
- mstade 9y agoBleeding gums are NOT a good thing. Bleeding gums may be a sign of inflammation, gingivitis, which ultimately could lead to loss of teeth if untreated. Always go with the softest brush you can find, to spare your gums, and also try not to use all that much tooth paste. You really don't need more than just a thin flat spread over the brush, or a ball about the size of a small pea. If your gums often bleed after brushing, you should go see a dentist. Even if it doesn't happen every day, please go. Source: my father is a dentist and I worked for him a number of years in the past, so picked up a few things.
- l0b0 9y agoHe's not my dad, but that's pretty much exactly the opposite of what my dentist said. Yes, healthy gums don't bleed, but if they do that's usually a sign you're not brushing enough.
- Bakary 9y agoThe danger comes from the illusion that you are somehow above the influence.
- jacobwilliamroy 9y agoMy concern is mainly that my attention is such a huge source of revenue for facebook. So much so that their advertising revenue is consistently several times more than their actual cost of revenue [0][1]. The gap is so wide, it's hard not to feel like I'm being robbed every time I see an ad on one of these "free" websites. [0]Earnings release: https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2017/Facebook-Reports-First-Quarter-2017-Results/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/... [1]Q1 2017 income statement (excel spreadsheet): https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_financials/2017/FB-Q1'17-Income-Statement.xlsx https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_financials/2017/FB...
- InclinedPlane 9y agoIt's far scarier than you have considered. Is it going to ruin you as a person? No, but it creates an incentive structure which is warped. Consider media (news or otherwise). If ads are how dollars are made then quality, and accuracy, is only important in so far as it serves as a vehicle for bringing in eyeballs. Consider 3 different examples of content. The first is expensive to make but high quality and people value it highly, they consider it extremely important. The second is inexpensive to make and low quality, people don't care about it much if at all. The third is also inexpensive and low quality but people generally dislike it. The important thing to understand here is that ads incentivize the 2nd and 3rd types of content over the first. When people pay for their content directly they will pay more for higher quality and more important content (if they are able). When content is just a vehicle for advertising it's much easier to turn a profit on content that is easy to produce and yet has a mass appeal (clickbait, humor, tabloids). And, as we see, that's the sort of thing that becomes plentiful easily today. Stuff that takes a lot of work to get right struggles while stuff that is trivial and salacious blooms. And that's only the tip of the iceberg.
- RodericDay 9y agoThe whole point is that even if they are easy to ignore for you, they aren't easy to ignore for others. I find it callous to decry the poor decision-making of poor people, eg: someone buying a fashion accessory when they're struggling to pay rent, and then go on to defend advertisers in a cavalier buyer-beware kind of way.
- wodenokoto 9y agoA better quote is "Privacy is a currency for which you don't know the exchange rate" I think it is better, because you are a customer, you just don't pay with cash. Instead you pay with your privacy, and as normal users, we really don't have a good concept of what that is worth.
- brandonmenc 9y agoWhat's scary is that ads may only be worth a fraction of what people are currently paying for them, and all the free services you use will be immediately underfunded and disappear once this is discovered.
- jzl 9y agotl;dr version: There are versions of this quote going back to the 70's, starting with one by artists Richard Serra & Carlota Fay Schoolman. But the modern incarnation seems to have sprung from a comment on metafilter that became popularized when Tim O'Reilly tweeted it out (with attribution) in 2010. Here's the tweet: https://twitter.com/timoreilly/status/22823381903 https://twitter.com/timoreilly/status/22823381903 I thought it was interesting to see the history of this.
- golemotron 9y ago"In essence, the private media are major corporations selling a product (readers and audiences) to other businesses (advertisers)." ― Noam Chomsky, Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media (1988)
- simula67 9y agoYou are not the product, your attention is the product. Companines like Google are not engaged in human trafficking. Similar problems can be seen in management : thinking of human beings as resources. Human beings are not resources, their time spent advancing the company goals is
- vog 9y agoNot sure what this nitpicking is good for. For the moral argument, I don't think it makes a difference which part of a human's mind is the product. This is like saying: "He didn't run him over - only his legs!" Or, less drastically: "The whole program isn't full of bugs, just the Foo, Bar, Baz and Main functions."
- simula67 9y agoThe term 'You are the product' carries heavier connotation than 'just the mind'. Also in the case of Google it serves a brief span of your attention to advertisers. They are not engaged in selling minds, wholesale or in part. I have enabled Google Search ads on all my machines for this reason. This distinction is worth making, since in some cases, it is an algorithmic matching between buyers and sellers. This helps consumers discover products and services they need and advertisers to discover demand they may otherwise be unable to tap
- bretthopper 9y agoI prefer "if you don't have a fork, you're on the menu"
- saimiam 9y agoHuge shoutout to The Attention Merchants by Tim Wu who invented the term "net neutrality." He's also an engaging correspondent if you write to him. I cannot recommend a better business book, bar none.
- chris__butters 9y agoThis can be twisted to companies like Google and Facebook, who collect so much personal information about us as users and then sell that data to their advertisers; we literally are products then.
- vog 9y agoWow, I didn't know that this quote is so old. I thought that it originated with Google and Facebook in mind.
- chris__butters 9y agoSo did I especially after watching videos like Free is a lie by Aral Balkin that takes this premise and attaches it to the big free tech companies.
- vinceguidry 9y agoWhat I really hate is when an entire industry segment colludes to force me to change a preferred aspect of my lifestyle to something that's more lucrative for them. An example of this is the subscription economy article posted a few days ago. Companies like Adobe decide to not sell licenses anymore, rather to rent access monthly. Not that I use Adobe, but Feedly dinged me for $69 for their Pro option again this year. Do I really need to pay yearly for a damned RSS reader? The other one is music. The music industry doesn't want to sell you perpetual licenses for individual tracks or albums anymore. It's too hard to manage. Apple managed to force them to do it, and Google got in under that umbrella, but the music industry wants to move directly to subscription services rather than build out a customer-friendly rights management regime for individual tracks. I hate subscription music services with a bitter passion and absolutely refuse to use them. If the industry manages to wipe out individual track sales, I will pirate music. I would hate to go back to those days, but it's preferable to not having control over my music. It's already absurdly, ridiculously hard to move music from one iPhone to another. To be told, 'no, you can't have this track you fell in love with because it wasn't released yet on your stupid service', is an even greater snub. The music industry will have to pry my music library out of my cold dead fingers.
- dalore 9y agoThe music industry don't have to pry the music library of your hands. You will eventually die. They get the kids young and hooked instead.
- turc1656 9y agoThis sounds like the description of a drug dealer.
- moreorless 9y agoSounds a lot more like religion to me.
- PeterisP 9y agoOn this note, I fully expect that after my death my kids will be able to listen for free anything of my music that they'd enjoy, just as I am able to listen to my grandfather's records. The earlier physical/analog artifacts could degrade with time if not properly preserved, but anything that's ever sold digitally will last until the copyright expires; the songs ripped from CDs that I bought in 1990s will be available to my family forever.
- EGreg 9y agoAs a side note, people seem to think there is a corollary: if you're paying, the company is no longer monetizing your data on the other side. Where is proof of this corollary in the real world?
- chii 9y agoThere's no proof that a paying service isn't also selling your data on the side. The only way to prevent a company from selling your data is to not give 'em any!
- Practicality 9y agoLike those privacy policies you get from your credit card companies: "Do we share your personal information with other companies? Yes. Is there anything you can do about it? No." I always laugh at these. At least they are telling me.
- jozzz 9y agoIs this quote the difference between Google and Apple? With Google, you are the product - you pay $ and have your data harvested and used for advertising. With Apple, you are the customer - you pay $$$ for a locked down, secure (they try?) system, that doesn't sell your data. I grew up as an Apple hater (no particular reason), but now that privacy is becoming more of a concern, it seems that the Apple ecosystem offers a better product? Am I being naive about Apple?
- fullstackhuman 9y agoI can't say that I pay anything to Google and I've used their products for years. I haven't purchased anything through them directly, so it's unfair to say "You pay Google and they harvest your data for the privilege." I'm aware that they're providing a "free" service to me (Gmail, search engine etc) and in return I "pay" in personal data.
- rdtsc 9y ago> You are the product of TV. Off topic of course, but there is a deeper double meaning there -- that your your personality, preferences, hopes, dreams are shaped by the media you consume. Things like what you think success is, what you think happiness is, heroism, kindness, friendship etc many of those things were shaped by the movies you saw, books your read, games you played. It's common to hear that "you are what you eat". That's true at the physical level of course. But this is also true that "you are the media you consume". Now to the topic at hand. I think any totalitarian or brutal government regime would salivate getting access to the data people freely and voluntarily share with Google and Facebook. Imagine a combination of a Stalin's regime and Facebook as a partnership. Or Google working with the Stasi. It's hyperbolic to make that connection today, but with things like watching this happening: http://fortune.com/2017/05/24/mark-zuckerberg-disrupt-for-president-pac/ http://fortune.com/2017/05/24/mark-zuckerberg-disrupt-for-pr... we are getting just a bit closer to it. People are wondering why a tech guy like me doesn't have a Facebook account and that's one of the reasons.
- Fnoord 9y ago> That's true at the physical level of course. No, not really, this is way too simplified and is factually incorrect. Lets take the example of a pig. If you eat a pig you don't become a pig. Certainly not overnight. Here's a more factually correct analogy which does explain what happens: Whatever you throw in your stomach (engine) gets burned and becomes fuel. If you regularly throw in too much fuel, the engine becomes overburdened and you become overweight (+ other obesitas related diseases). That's a rather subtle but significant difference. > But this is also true that "you are the media you consume". The same is true here. Its not a A -> B process; the process is much more subtle, nuanced, and complex. E.g. here's also other aspects such as genes and personality which meddle w/the process.