9 ms·
The man who helped Facebook beat Snapchat
- nancyp 9y agoI'd rewrite the title: "Man who helped Facebook shamelessly copy Snapchat's best features without giving any credit"
- mkagenius 9y agoIts a game -- everyone is aware of the rules, so lets not get too emotional.
- tensor 9y agoMind, the title is pretty emotionally charged. I suppose a title like "Large company uses size to crowd out smaller company" isn't as catchy.
- danso 9y agoHow should credit be paid for copying such features? Through patents and licensing fees?
- hyperbovine 9y agoPatent those features or be left crying into your beer.
- dsacco 9y agoThere is nothing inherently righteous or honorable about allowing another company to lay exclusive claim to features. That "shameless copying" is an example of competition, and it's what turns the wheels of capitalism. What would you have Facebook do? "Well, darn. I guess we can't implement those features, Snapchat beat us to it! Time to just lay over and let them churn our users." This is not how any rational company works, and every major tech company has copied others many times.
- ouid 9y ago>an example of competition Not when you are leveraging monopoly power to gain market share somewhere else. This kind of capitalism tends to degenerate.
- majani 9y agoThey gave a massive buyout offer before copying. There was only one thing left to do after that.
- ouid 9y agoIf you're arguing that Facebook behaved rationally, then we aren't in disagreement. If you're arguing that Facebook acted in the public interest, then you're going to need a different argument.
- srtjstjsj 9y agohow is the public interest harmed by letting facebook users send snaps?
- kuschku 9y agoThe public interest is harmed by Facebook eliminating all competitors.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoSo you seem to be implying that ONE company having a feature is somehow better for public interest than TWO companies having that feature? Or that it is better for public interest that people prop up companies with multi billion dollar valuations on the basis of trivially copy-able features?
- ouid 9y agoIf that were a complete accounting of the variables then yes, that is what I would be saying. That is not a complete accounting of the variables though. It is harmful to the public interest to allow a company to use its monopoly status as leverage to monopolize other markets. Facebook is competing for image messaging in the same sense that Lance Armstrong was competing in the tour de france. Monopoly is the degenerate case of capitalism, and this kind of behavior by monopolies is how the degeneracy reproduces.
- rhizome 9y agoRight. How about a story that says, "Person who failed to make Snapchat's features uncopyable?" Just as interesting! The US does not have moral rights in IP, so you better conduct your business in a way that doesn't rely on their mere existence.
- briandear 9y agoWould a nice thank you note be appropriate?
- askafriend 9y agoThere is copying and then there is copying well. Almost every companies copies in some form or fashion - you'd be hard pressed to find one that doesn't - but few really do it well. I would argue that Instagram did it very well and you can see it in the success. The product is well designed, extremely polished, is far more stable, is more engaging (for me), and more complete in my opinion. I don't think your intended criticism has any value in the real world. It's a tired argument and deeply flawed. I think the reverse argument is a stronger one. That is to say that SnapChat's core innovations that got them this far were closer to a commodity than is ideal for a business like theirs. This is something that SnapChat acknowledges in their own S1. What I think investors didn't see or expect is: * The extent to which the SnapChat feature-set was a commodity in a world where several other similar friendship and interest graphs exist. * The speed and potency with which competitors like Facebook would attempt to compete. I think Facebook's strategy was far more successful than people were prepared for and that's reflected somewhat in the SnapChat stock price swings and analyst sentiment swings.
- danso 9y agoI agree; success was not inevitable. After FB failed to buy Snapchat, they attempted to copy it with their Pokes App, back in 2012: https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2012/12/21/facebook-poke-vs-snapchat-what-is-the-difference/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2012/12/21/faceb... I don't believe copying was inevitable either. Snap's main appeal at that time -- disappearing content -- was seen as completely anathema to FB's practice data hoarding. And adding features of any sort risks alienating the current user base. I confess that as a casual Instagram user, and a non-Snapchat user, I'm completely lost with all the new features and end points to what was a straightforward photo app.
- qq66 9y agoActually, credit was given. FB's head of product publicly admitted to copying Snapchat's features.
- xxSparkleSxx 9y agoNail salon opens with same services as the million nail salons before it. Big deal.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoEmbrace, extend, extinguish.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoDid Snapchat credit those they copied their ideas from? Or is every part of Snapchat entirely novel??
- adventured 9y agoAt the time the DOJ began seriously looking into Microsoft about anti-trust abuses derived from their monopoly, there were still a vast number of medium to large software & tech companies that competed head on with Microsoft. That of course meant there were a large number of parties that could sign on to the aggrieved list against Microsoft. As Facebook formally kills off Snapchat in the next few years, it's a curious problem of which companies will supply the ammunition to go after Facebook for anti-trust abuse. Said companies will be the biggest motivating factor for the US Government to act, their prompting will drive the case. Given the scale we're talking about now (Facebook is already more profitable non-inflation adjusted than what Microsoft was at the height of its power; and they might double their profit in a few years up to $20 billion before any government action would come through). I would expect companies to begin lining up with their hands out. Twitter as one example, stands to easily land maybe $5 billion or more as compensation for being one of the few survivors of Facebook's social monopoly. Something that has changed a lot in the last 20 years, corporate fines & costs of negative legal outcomes have skyrocketed in practically every industry. Google's worsening EU disaster is just the latest example of that. Facebook will need tens of billions of dollars set aside for settling with governmental entities and competitors (even semi-dead competitors like MySpace - its owners will show up with their hands out for a settlement, and they'll definitely get some crumbs as Facebook will settle just to move on as the lawsuits stack high after the blood hits the water). As the world witnesses Facebook intentionally kill off Snapchat by leveraging its monopoly in nearly every way it can, there are going to be few people remaining in the Facebook defender camp as the number of major social players in the US & EU markets drifts toward just a few small competitors left standing. Snapchat better have been worth it, as I can assure you that crushing Netscape wasn't worth what it cost Microsoft.
- boulos 9y ago> Facebook is already more profitable non-inflation adjusted than what Microsoft was at the height of its power As a nit, what's the point of using a non-inflation adjusted comparison? You wouldn't say have compared Facebook to Standard Oil :). It turns out that 1998 to today is only a 50% change according to CPI [1] and MSFT had $4.5B in net income for FY 1998 [2]. So your point still stands given Facebook's massive ~$10B FY2016 net income [3]. [1] https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm [2] https://www.microsoft.com/investor/reports/ar98/fins.htm https://www.microsoft.com/investor/reports/ar98/fins.htm [3] https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2017/facebook-Reports-Fourth-Quarter-and-Full-Year-2016-Results/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/...
- briandear 9y agoInstagrams revenues are increasing because Facebook advertisers unwittingly are having their ads run in Instragram. You have to opt-out. Found that out after blowing through and ad budget that got consumed more quickly because of Instragram. Instagram users as a cohort are the worst audience for advertising. Low conversions, lots of impressions and just all around less profitable than the exact same ad on Facebook itself. Even music acts that would seem to be a tailor made product for Instragram – still, in my anecdotal experience, a complete waste of money. Instagram the “thing” might be a fun product, but Instagram as a provider of cost-effective advertising, no way.
- quickthrower 9y agoUltimately this should hurt Facebook if advertisers are tracking ROI they may just stop campaigns and go into other channels entirely.
- briandear 9y agoOne would think, but I think big brands don’t care. They are after “awareness” and not actual conversions. It’s like TV, how does one measure the ROI on a national Coca Cola ad? (I actually don’t know.)
- quickthrower 9y agoIn that case the Instagram ads may be delivering some value!
- nocoder 9y agoWhat you seem to be saying is that Instagram is a good brand building platform over the longer-term vs platform to generate leads and transactions over the short term. Unless, there is a study to prove that I am not too sure. I usually find media agencies and platforms make this argument when they cannot justify the RoI of their platform in a direct and measurable sense. It is much like how Google tries to prove effectiveness of its display ads using a fuzzy metric called view-through impressions. On the coke bit, coke actually does measure the RoI on its TV using a mix of brand track studies and marketing mix modelling. I know this because I have worked with agencies that Coca-Cola engages to do both and is really scientific and serious about it.
- debt 9y agoMost of this will come down to brand equity anyway. I have to assume there are people using Lyft over Uber because those people have negative associations with the Uber brand. Uber and Lyft both provide the same products, but people prefer one brand over another. People prefer Gucci over Versace, North Face over Patagonia etc. Inevitably, the same will be true for Facebook vs Snapchat. Snapchat will likely prevail in a way because the "brand" ecosystem, talent pool(pr, actors, producers etc.) are concentrated largely in Los Angeles due to the existing Hollywood system. Proximity to the talent might not have much to do with it, but I imagine Snapchat has been developing those relationships for a while.
- abalone 9y agoThe interesting flipside to the copycat issue is that Snapchat intentionally did not copy Instagram. And that was probably a mistake. Spiegel was explicitly against the concept of "accumulative" profiles.[1] The accumulative feature they rolled out last year was Memories, a private gallery that only the user could see and show to people in person. And he was explicitly against making it easy to add tons of friends on Snapchat. He wanted it to be about your "seven most important people."[2] Well, turns out people do in fact like their Instagram accumulative profiles to store and share highlights with their followers. And it turns out people like getting engagement and adulation from a broader network of followers. So, as much as I dislike the crass copying that Instagram/Weil did and his attempt to pass it off as just a "format" -- that's bullshit, they copied vast aspects of Snapchat stories and messaging.. calling it a "format" is naked intellectual dishonesty. I noticed Weil back in the Twitter days and this intellectual dishonesty makes me respect him less. But Snapchat also did not make the right strategic product decisions here. Spiegel, to his credit, went with a bold vision and strategic analysis about what people want. Turns out it was just wrong with respect to how people want to engage with and present their experiences to a broader set of friends. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykGXIQAHLnA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ykGXIQAHLnA [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/17/technology/snapchat-ipo-video.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/17/technology/snapchat-ipo-v...
- ouid 9y agoI sometimes use snapchat, I never use instagram. There's nothing wrong with occupying a niche.
- jdavis703 9y agoExcept for when you go public and that "niche" isn't big enough to drive the returns public investors want. There seems to be many social media companies that should take the non-profit and open source route that Mozilla took. Twitter feels like a prime candidate, they provide an extraordinary useful service that might be impossible to monetize without losing some of the utiliy.
- 9y ago
- raz32dust 9y agoI am curious how many people actually feel this is cool that Facebook can simply copy everything Snapchat comes up with? I understand that this is the way of the world. Big fish eats smaller fish yada yada. But is it good in the long run? I don't know how to do this, and I understand any solution will probably be riddled to the core with loopholes. But I do feel like there should be some way to prevent this kind of monopolization. What do you all think from a long-term, idealistic perspective?
- ensiferum 9y agoAnd ofc you need this story with some 30-sonething superstars self promoting hotshot CEO who is the capable of coming up with the solution of simply copying the competition.
- tomcam 9y agoAny solution is hard to enforce. Idealistically, the computer world has largely decided cross pollination, while sometimes painful for just the reason you describe, is better for all of us (I agree, and purposely chose not to patent technology that has been worth millions for me and my competitors over the last 17 years).
- Nomentatus 9y agoThe law feels it is illegal - but we don't enforce laws meant to limit market power and they've been weakened (by no coincidence) over the years. Welcome to Feudal Capitalism.
- sosborn 9y agoHow do you feel about patent law?
- dsacco 9y agoI think it's perfectly cool, yes. I'm not concerned in the slightest with monopolization from Facebook implementing Snapchat features. Good for them, that must have taken a massive amount of business and engineering coordination.
- Eridrus 9y ago
- amingilani 9y agoThis may be an unpopular opinion but I feel strongly against titles like this. They could have very well gone with "...Facebook take Instagram Market share" but they wanted to make it personal and human. I'm disgusted by the choice of words here. One company gained an advantage over there other in a market, big deal! They're competing businesses and eventually one will up the other but there's no point in saying "down to its knees"
- adventured 9y agoYou're spot on that it's a bit ridiculous. It's intentional however and it's going to get a lot worse yet. Over the next few years the press will start using increasingly violent-sounding, negative, stark headlines against Facebook. Associated headline words will shift toward aggressive tones. It's a portrait. They do the same thing to most dominant companies once they grow out of the up-and-coming phase. Amazon for example is starting to get deluged by such press coverage; Google has been the subject of it for years; and of course Microsoft went through a solid decade or more of it. Once upon a time, Walmart was portrayed as a cute & fuzzy hayseed retailer just looking to save the good 'ol consumer a buck or two.
- seibelj 9y agoIt's not surprising that Trump rails against the mainstream media when it's becoming increasingly obvious that the news is written to rile people up and get clicks. The news is like professional wrestling - there are heroes, villains, story arcs, winners, losers, and the more you understand a topic the more you realize the press gets it completely wrong. But maybe it's always been this way, and I wasn't as aware before.
- pedalpete 9y agoInteresting perspective, but I don't think it makes sense to take sides politically in this argument. All media is sadly going this way, the argument could also be made that link bait titles are partly responsible for Trump's popularity. ALL media is sadly going this way. If you think Fox or Drudge or whatever are above these sad tactics, look closer. I'd like to ask the bigger question of, how do we fight/protect agains this?
- curiousDog 9y agoLooking at Linkedin, he's had a remarkable career. Wow. He's made it from Engineering lead at 28 to SVP and Head of product at 34.
- siliconc0w 9y agoI'm surprised it took Instagram this long to copy Snapshot. This guy seems super impressive but adding a competitor's features to your product to increase market share seems like a pretty obvious move.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoIt might be that it's all a part of execution of the product. Google tries and fails with their social networking efforts and they are also doing the obvious move and they can't .
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- saimiam 9y agoThis is such a good point. Personally, I'd rather not copy to win but in business, it's easily possible to copy poorly and fail hard. There's a saying in Hindi - you need brains to copy well.
- joelrunyon 9y agoGoogle had to shift an entire business model to attempt to do social. Facebook just had to add features.
- edpichler 9y agoI really dislike the feature of Instagram that imitates Snapchat. When a software tries to make more than one thing, it loses it's identity. I am surprised that people are still using it, but about the long run, nobody knows. I saw a funny tweet that someone just wrote "A fear" than an image of Twitter print, of the mobile version, with small spheres on the top (like the ones suddenly appeared on Instagram), so I realized that it's not just me that think Instagram got worse with this feature. And the design solution they found, really annoys me. Now we have this on all Facebook products (WhatsApp and Facebook itself). Talking about the software identity, I don't remember successful products that tries to do more than one thing. I think it's wrong, but it's apparently working, so I am observing and learning.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI'm on the flipside of this, I think my Instagram use is better as a result. I shared the same friend (mostly) list between Snap and Instagram and with the introduction of stories my Snap use dropped to basically zero. Instagram is a one stop shop for the accumulative feed, stories, and video DMs. No need to switch apps. That said, I didn't get a ton of direct messages on Snapchat, probably because I'm older and the kind of 1-1 communication I saw teens doing on Snap isn't as common for my age group, however that feature is there in IG. I might be an outlier, though I don't think I am judging by the numbers. On a more crass note, from the business perspective, Instagram is in a much better ad position than Snap because it's really easy to buy ad space. Not only that it's going to be easier to develop content for AR filters on Instagram because they have an actual developer pathway for that. As far as I can tell, Snap highly curates all broadcast content and advertising, and there is no third party developer support. Not sure why anyone wouldn't see how bad that is - if anything Snap should have learned from Twitter that third part devs are core to longevity.
- Zak 9y agoI'm a pretty casual user of Instagram and I hate the disappearing stories. I've never posted one, and I don't like the time pressure to view them rather than catching up at my leisure. I've never used Snapchat. Can you explain the appeal?
- ridruejo 9y agoGood prescient analysis of the same topic from a year ago https://stratechery.com/2016/the-audacity-of-copying-well/ https://stratechery.com/2016/the-audacity-of-copying-well/
- mola 9y agoThis seems like PR fluff...