8 ms·
Rank-reversal aversion may be causing more social problems than we realize
- beeeebo 9y agoThis article makes me uncomfortable
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- log_base_login 9y agoThere is a lot to be said for not wanting to piss off the people who control the money that flows to you. I am not as certain that people would choose to keep things the way that they are if they also weren't keenly aware (as say, someone might especially be in China) that the State might be monitoring their answers. It's also very important to remember that most people who manage wealth well, on the other hand, do so in a way that benefits those who do not, and as such retain their responsibilities as money managers because they are one half of a financially symbiotic system of exchange. There are also a lot of social factors to consider that didn't necessarily (and understandably so) make it into the studies dependent or independent variable sets. The attractiveness of each party needs to be controlled for, as there is a definite bias to give money to those we find attractive. The age of someone is another control variable that needs to be accounted for, as the elderly are generally (and correctly, generally speaking) more adept at managing money, for how else would they have survived so long? All in all, I think mostly what this tells us is that we are cautiously optimistic about the belief that those who have less in our social hierarchy are capable enough to have more, but that it's important to preserve and honor the way in which wealth flows because it flows in a way that has kept us progressing for millenia. I would be much more interested in reading about how much wealth they believed should be distributed rather than simply if it should. That would give us more than a binary response from which to extrapolate data.
- graycat 9y agoOn the OP Web page, the lines commonly have about 96 characters. On my 14" screen with a Web browser magnification that lets a whole line show at once, the text is so small it is totally unreadable. With more magnification from my Web browser, there are still 96 characters per line so have to use the horizontal scroll bars twice on each line to read it. So, since I was interested in the article, I selected all of the text, copied it to my system clipboard, pasted it into a new e-mail in my e-mail program that reflowed the lines and used a larger font, and then read some of the article. With 96 characters per line, apparently the Web site is determined, feet locked deep in reinforced concrete, with iron-clad rigidity, to discourage as many readers as they can. Ah, since the OP is about psychology, the 96 characters per line and the whole OP is really just a psychology experiment? Curious that a Web site would want to work so hard to discourage readers.
- mercer 9y agoI also find text to often be uncomfortably small. I can highly recommend using a 'readability' or 'read later' bookmarklet (InstaPaper offers a decent one), as it will clean things up and allow larger font sizes with one click.
- graycat 9y agoI can get larger font sizes, plenty large, with just one keystroke to my Web browser, Ctrl-+. But for the Web page I mentioed, that keystroke doesn't solve the problem because the lines still have 96 or so characters. Then, as I mentioned, I have to use the horizontal scroll bar twice for each line to be read. Apparently the default in HTML is to have the window width fixed and let Ctrl-+ increase the font size AND reflow the text to fit in the same, fixed window width. If the window does fit on my screen, then I can just hit Ctrl-+ a few times and have fonts nicely large so that I can lean back and read the text. So, it takes some work in HTML and/or JavaScript to ruin this good default behavior. The Web page I mentioned is only one; the Web is awash with people using tiny fonts and packing a single page with all sorts of stuff. With the layout the page has, to have the fonts large enough to read would need a screen, say, 4 feet wide. Any wider and, then, instead of scroll bars would have to walk side to side to read the screen. Newspapers partially solved this problem long ago: Newspaper columns commonly have only about 40 characters per line. For the Web, 50-60 is about the upper limit. 96 characters per line is too many, way, Way too many, for newspapers, books, PDF files, Web pages, or anything else. I'd think that by now Web sites would notice that 96 characters per line was too darned many and cut it back, permit Ctrl-+ to reflow the lines, etc. So, I tried to make an issue of the 96 here. People with screens 4 feet wide won't agree with me.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoThis doesn't touch the real problem. Nobody intentionally creates a policy that will take $20K from someone with $40K and give it to someone with $10K. When that happens at all it's unintentional (e.g. 20 programs to transfer $1K that weren't expected to overlap) and people who discover that outcome find it outrageous. Because that was never the problem with income inequality to begin with. The problem isn't that one person makes $10,000 while another makes $40,000. Those people are both struggling. The problem is that one person makes $10,000 (or $40,000) while another makes $10,000,000. Reversal never even enters into it. If you took $9,900,000 of the richer person's money and split it between 1000 poorer people, the richer person would still have more money. Even though that would imply a 99% tax rate.
- ronilan 9y ago> This doesn't touch the real problem. Well, that. But also the real real problem: Economic professors making up social theories by conducting a "simple experiment using a game" (and childish slides).
- KekDemaga 9y agoNot if the poorer people start with $101.
- yorwba 9y ago10,000,000 - 9,900,000 = 100,000 9,900,000 / 1,000 = 9,900 The 1,000 people would need to start with more than $90,100 before rank reversal occurs.
- RangerScience 9y agoWell, right, but now you've got the issue of perception. The message I got from the whole "1%" slogan was just this: That it's not even close. If I think it's close, then what the researched observed may kick in, even if it's no where near close.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Nobody intentionally creates a policy that will take $20K from someone with $40K and give it to someone with $10K. When that happens at all it's unintentional" Actually, plenty of revolutions intentionally did just that, and much, much worse (as in executing aristocrats and land owners and giving all of their possessions to the poor).
- mnm1 9y agoThis says nothing about why people don't support realistic measures to alleviate income inequality which don't upset the social order. I'd say almost all if not all realistic programs and solutions proposed do not upset said order so why aren't they supported by over 70% of the population? Or maybe they are and our representatives just ignore us. I'm not talking about stupid ideas like communism but things like raising the minimum wage.
- ikeyany 9y agoThey don't upset the social order immediately, but they're a starting point. So it would make sense to be against that too, to maintain the current social hierarchy.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> I'm not talking about stupid ideas like communism but things like raising the minimum wage. The minimum wage is an old rally flag, but it affects the bottom 1% when the problem is the top 1%. It's not the difference between the 1st percentile and the 25th, it's the difference between the 25th (or even the 90th) and the 99.9th. The policies to fix that aren't the "help the poorest" ones, they're the ones that help small businesses and help consumers. Trust busting, lower housing costs (especially middle class housing), reducing regulatory compliance (paperwork) costs on small business, government spending on infrastructure, municipal fiber, patent-free basic research funding, etc. Minimum wage is a distraction from the things that would actually help.
- labster 9y ago> The minimum wage is an old rally flag, but it affects the bottom 1% I was skeptical when you suggested that it was that small, but the most recent Pew study says that only 2% of workers earn the federal minimum wage in the U.S. [1] But they go on to point out that 30% of American workers earn "near-minimum wage" i.e. ≤ $10.10/h. If minimum wage were increased to $9/h, that would probably affect the earnings of nearly all of those people. [1]: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/09/08/who-makes-minimum-wage/ http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/09/08/who-makes-mi...
- failrate 9y agoI assume that it has less to do with upsetting the social hierarchy than it does with the possibility that my wealth might be redistributed to someone else.
- spaceseaman 9y agoDirectly in the article: "What's especially intriguing is that this study reveals that people didn't like to see other people's fortunes reversed. So this isn't about selfishness or protecting what's yours. It's some kind of fear of upsetting the hierarchy that goes beyond greed." The article then goes on to present possible hypothesis for this behavior.
- failrate 9y agoI disagree with the thesis.
- meric 9y agoI think it's a good point and it could be more than wealth but also security... A social hierarchy undergoing chaotic changes could even pose danger to one's life - and in such a scenario you don't want to pick a side.
- throwaway842875 9y agoThis is anecdotal, but I've seen it in my own life. People treat you completely differently if they think you come from a privileged background (or a disadvantaged one), and one of those differences is their willingness to grant you opportunities, and how much they're willing to pay you. The fact that I come from a broken abusive home and a really messed up difficult childhood is a secret I guard pretty closely. The day I started wearing nice collared shirts and very subtly encouraging/allowing people to assume I come from privilege like they do (like almost everyone reading this does), I experienced an incredible reversal in career momentum. It completely turned my life around. Not only that, but it totally changes the calculus of what people are willing to pay you. If someone has nothing and is desperate, that means they'll be willing to work for less, and anything higher would be charity. Your expectation is that they will be happier with less, and that they will be thankful for it. If you think someone's parents own a nice lakefront house and a yacht, and they're young and white and wear nice shirts like you do and live in the bay, well clearly that person wouldn't accept less than $140k base. Your expectation is that not only will they demand fair and competitive pay, but also that dollar figures all seem low to them because they've been around money their whole life, so you better offer them more. I don't know if it's as simple as "rank-reversal aversion." I think it's much bigger and more complicated than that. In the broadest possible terms: People as a whole profile and categorize each other, and those categorizations are reflected in nearly every aspect of how people interact with each other. Part of the outcome of that is a tendency to reinforce success in the already-successful, and a tendency to reinforce failure in the already-failing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- interfixus 9y ago"When the researchers tested children, they found that rank-reversal aversion doesn't develop until children are 6-10 years old, which suggests that this aversion is learned culturally as the child grows up" "In addition, the Tibetan herders who participated in the study had a markedly higher level of rank-reversal aversion than other subjects. This also suggests the trait is cultural" An all too common kind of sloppy thinking, which generally kills my desire to read any further. No such thing is suggested. The trait may be learned, or it may be completely hardwired, kicking in action between ages six and ten. Different populations may have evolved different inbred attitudes to equality.
- danieltillett 9y agoJust like male facial hair - it doesn’t start appearing until the teenage years so its appearance must be cultural :P When you have a preformed ideological conclusion then logic is the first causality in any study.
- colordrops 9y ago> logic is the first causality Probably the opposite of your intended meaning heh
- adrianratnapala 9y agoNah, it's a special logic caused by the intended conclusion.
- danieltillett 9y agoLOL. Yes that should be casualty :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 9y agoYou seem to have made the common error of confusing “suggests” with “admits of no other explanation.”
- humanrebar 9y agoIt's hard to understand in a lot of detail what the experiment was doing. It seems like an alternate explanation is that people don't like to artificially pick winners and losers, but they're willing to lessen the gap between winners and losers if it's too big. There are philosophical concerns about justice and utility in messing with organic selection mechanisms. Perhaps a fear of instability plays into it, but it seems like there are more nuanced narratives that can be applied as well.
- mehwoot 9y agoIt seems like an alternate explanation is that people don't like to artificially pick winners and losers, but they're willing to lessen the gap between winners and losers if it's too big. Isn't that the same thing, just rephrased?
- humanrebar 9y agoI think the value implication in the analysis is different. An aversion to rank reversal applies value to rank stability itself. An aversion to picking winners and losers applies value to the selection process. You could argue that the signal is still strong if the winners made twice what others made, but that it's lost if wealth is wholesale shifted from the unfavored to the favored.
- meric 9y agoIt's notable this was a experiment from a Chinese university - in the 1950's and 1960's there was significant role reversals in Chinese society - landlords had their land confiscated, and those who resisted were rounded up and killed. This was followed up by the Great Leap Forward movement which ended up with millions dying from starvation.
- amluto 9y agoIt could be even more nuanced than that. I'd be averse to a top marginal tax rate over 100% (which would reverse ranks) but not to a big tax cleanup that would remove silly incentives to engage in certain types of business, even though the latter would surely also reverse ranks. The study seems to be looking at the former type of social policy to the extent that it's looking at a social policy at all.
- arieskg 9y agoInstead of overthinking and assume that people don't want to upset social hierarchy, I suggest the researchers to take a step back and consider that people prefer symbiotic over the antibiotic scenario. In this "game", we may not know how A came to wealth, but we would be certain how A lost wealth. Similarly in the second scenario, while we know B is still less wealthy compared to A, at least B is wealthier than before. Value creation vs Value transfer. (Entrepreneur v. Investment Banker)
- caseysoftware 9y agoI was wondering about this too.. when I got to the part about how the Tibetan herders were even more against rank reversal, it reinforced it for me. When someone is a herder, the only way to earn wealth is by working long hours, busting your butt day in day out, and being careful about what you have. I'd wager their mindset is that they know the pain, effort, and time it takes to accumulate wealth so they're loathe to take it from someone else.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"they know the pain, effort, and time it takes to accumulate wealth so they're loathe to take it from someone else" Except that the scenario was explicitly designed to make clear that the wealth in question was not a result of effort but was acquired purely randomly.
- unclebucknasty 9y agoYeah, but not sure that simple statement is enough to completely undo generations of cultural belief/experience regarding how wealth is earned.
- jonathankoren 9y ago> they know the pain, effort, and time it takes to accumulate wealth so they're loathe to take it from someone else Or they believe in divine right / hereditary caste system. In fact a long established hereditary caste system was dominate in 1959[0], Thinking that some long standing social construct is simply going to evaporate is a bit naïve. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_class_in_Tibet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_class_in_Tibet
- logicallee 9y agoif we could only get over these pesky biases we might finally start introducing 150% marginal tax rates and let the middle class taste life at the upper middle class level. (by taking it from them, exchanging their places.) as it stands the middle class really has no way of "trading places" with the upper middle class, who can always out-earn them. a marginal tax rate above 100% would close this loophole. yes this comment is sarcastic.
- venning 9y agoAnother way of interpreting the results: - 76.87% of subjects accepted a 25% tax rate intended for redistribution. - 44.80% of subjects accepted a 50% tax rate intended for redistribution. It's hard to infer much beyond that. Perhaps they need to test for a larger number or more fine-grained tax levels between 25% and 50% and see if there is indeed a step change (or other sharp decline) in acceptability when it "reverses social order". Or if there is a smooth distribution curve based on tax rate, not relative position. --- Even if you take the results as intended, that subjects were considering social order and not tax rate, you still have to concede that this could be about "fairness" and not "rank". It shouldn't be surprising that a majority of people dislike redistributing more than is necessary to achieve equality. That helps explain the results with the children. Ages 6-10 is about where they start to understand "fairness" from the perspective of both parties [1]. Additionally, taking the tax perspective into account, "Person B" appears to be subject to a lower tax rate than "Person A" despite ending up with more money, which subjects would likely see as unfair. [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2015/11/how-fairness-develops-in-kids-around-the-world/416520/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2015/11/how-fair...
- unclebucknasty 9y agoNot sure why they draw the conclusion that the aversion is about not wanting to upset the social hierarchy. That's an amorphous statement in any case and carries different connotations. Seems a more succinct conclusion is that it's about fairness. Most view the economy as a zero-sum game, and we generally measure our standing in society relative to others. So, the idea of redistributing wealth to the point where relative fortunes are being inverted may violate our sense of fairness.
- mempko 9y agoMost seem to miss the bigger picture with this study. People don't like rank in general, even when it's reversed. In other words most people, in there heart of hearts are communists and would prefer a classes society.
- barry-cotter 9y agoEgalitarianism is not Communism. Humans have had agriculture for about 5,000 years and states with hierarchy about the same amount of time. Before that behaviourally modern humans were around for ~200,000 years. They lived in bands and tribes that may occasionally have gotten as big as 200 people, almost all of whom would have been either related or in a relationship with a relative. Humans are egalitarians and would prefer a classless society. Ants are Communists. On human egalitarianism http://www.overcomingbias.com/2012/05/forager-vs-farmer-morality.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2012/05/forager-vs-farmer-mora...
- Banthum 9y agoHumans have and have always had social status structures, reaching back into evolutionary time. This is why such a huge portion of our psychology is devoted to dealing with status issues. Animals have status too. Various primates form stable status hierarchies in their bands. Chimps are a great example. Canine species do this as well. And other animals, too - all the way down to lobsters. Basically any animal with any intraspecies interaction has some concept of status hierarchy. And like the animals, humans like their hierarchies - the hierarchy fulfills a psychological need, the way being in a herd makes a herd animal feel safe. People like knowing where they stand. They like having a role to play and knowing others are playing their roles. Without a clear hierarchy people feel nervous, the way a dog acts out from anxiety when the humans don't take charge. Some people are driven to climb the hierarchy but most just want a stable existence somewhere in the middle of the pack where they can "camouflage against the herd" and avoid being noticed too much. Most people like security and dislike responsibility for hard choices. Having others of higher status to take on those challenges absolves them of the need to make such decisions. Egalitarianism is definitely also a part of human nature, but it's as a psychological counterpoint to the status hierarchy. People want the hierarchy to exist - but they want it to seem fair and legitimate and they want people to deserve their positions. People only dislike a hierarchy that seems illegitimate according to their mental heuristic. So no, humans would not prefer a classless society, and such a society can never exist. If it existed for a moment, it'd cease to exist the next since classes would instantly form along the various dividing lines between groups of different personalities, proclivities and capacities. Level everyone's wealth and you quickly just end up with the same distribution as before, as we've seen after various bloodbaths in China, Russia, etc.
- pizza 9y agoarrow's theorem can be used to point out problems with social rank-reversal aversion, too, imo
- tom_mellior 9y agoCan you explain?