10 ms·
Juicero Plans to Lower Prices and Cut 25% of Staff
- dghughes 9y agoThe squeeze is on.
- joshu 9y agoThis company is getting beaten to a pulp.
- atonse 9y agoThey may have to liquidate eventually.
- timothycrosley 9y agoReddit is this you?!?!!?
- timothycrosley 9y agoCan this get deleted somehow, it used to be relevant, but all the surrounded comments got deleted.
- nathancahill 9y agoStarting to sound like a fruitless labor.
- tomphoolery 9y agoOrange we getting off topic??? This is about people's livelihoods!
- middleclick 9y agoThey are getting the juice sucked out of them.
- _fs 9y agoCan we not do this? This is not reddit.
- atonse 9y agoIt's harmless fun once in a while :) Companies like Juicero and Theranos really kind of ask for it.
- BoiledCabbage 9y ago> It's harmless fun once in a while No it's extremely low effort, low quality content. Conveys nothing of value, distracts from interesting discussion, and is a habit that once adopted absolutely won't happen just "once in a while". Evidence? See reddit. There are a million places online for low quality content, let's keep HN as one of the few exceptions.
- Karunamon 9y agoThe insistence that HN be a completely dour, humorless place reduces its quality a lot more than a single subthread ever could.
- minimaxir 9y agoThere's a bit of nuance to humor; it's not black and white. Good humor is much, much harder to produce than code. Pun threads in particular are lazy attempts at humor, which is worse.
- Karunamon 9y agoI disagree and find puns amusing. Certainly not noxious enough to encounter the outright hatred expressed here.
- mrkrabo 9y agoIt doesn't have to be humourless. You're free to make jokes. You're not free to make a comment that just consists of a joke.
- simonsarris 9y agoIn case anyone missed the Juicero teardown in April, here it is: https://blog.bolt.io/heres-why-juicero-s-press-is-so-expensive-6add74594e50 https://blog.bolt.io/heres-why-juicero-s-press-is-so-expensi... > One Giant Misstep > The vast majority of the complexity of the Press is driven by one simple problem inherent in the machine’s design: the massive force required to press the packs across the entire surface at once. The machine must apply equal pressure to ~64 square inches of surface area at once, meaning the drivetrain must be able to apply thousands of pounds of force to squish all that produce. > On the contrary, when a human hand squeezes the same pack, we naturally use a very different technique [fingers create large amounts of pressure over much smaller surface area] > I have to believe the engineers that built this product looked at other ways of pressing the juice, but if the primary mechanism could apply force in a more focused way it could easily save hundreds of dollars off the shelf price of the product. That blog post is high art.
- theGimp 9y agoAvE also did a teardown. It's 40 minutes long, and evidently I watched the whole thing according to YouTube. https://youtu.be/_Cp-BGQfpHQ https://youtu.be/_Cp-BGQfpHQ
- Overtonwindow 9y agoWow that was painful to watch considering how much was invested in that company, and how much the machine costs. Wow. Thank you for posting this link.
- theGimp 9y agoHah. Yeah, it's quite the spectacle. I've gotten used to AvE's unboxing by now and in fact look forward to it, but I remember it being jarring the first few times.
- jandrese 9y agoHe also did a DRM bypass, by which I mean he hooked a power supply up to the motor and ran it manually. It really is the most ridiculous product. Even if it were engineered properly to a reasonable price point the entire product is unnecessary and wasteful. The difference between selling bags of juice vs. bags of mostly juiced pulp that you have to finish yourself is definitely not worth $800 or whatever they were trying to charge. On top of that they added DRM, some goddamn subscription thing, required internet connectivity, and every other annoyance you can get in a modern product.
- jnthm 9y agothe company is any way a sham to begin with/ I don't think it is solving a real problem anyway
- Dirlewanger 9y ago>The company was founded by Doug Evans, who has said his plan was to do for juicing what Steve Jobs did for computers. Dunn's letter noted that Evans was stepping back from daily operations but would remain a board member. Probably because he realized that trying to be the Steve Jobs of juicing wasn't going to be as fruitful (heh) as initially thought, but still wants to be a part of any potential exit.
- criddell 9y agoHe wanted to be Apple. Turns out, he's Keurig.
- metaphorm 9y agoThe plan was always to be Keurig while telling people they were Apple. It didn't work.
- monocasa 9y agoWasn't it fruit that killed Steve Jobs?
- gruturo 9y agoOh my god why can I only upvote you once. You win the thread. And it's so sad (yet true) we lost him (earlier, at least) over something so stupid. Love him or hate him, the man had great ideas and created so much (not alone, but you get my point).
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI wonder if there's a correlation between over-funded companies, and over-engineered products?
- koolba 9y agoCorrelation definitely, causation possibly. If you flip that around it's more clear: If you don't have excess funding, whether it's a VC funded startup or an internal project at an established company, you don't have the resource to epicly over engineer solutions; ergo it's only the ones with massive funding that do so.
- jandrese 9y agoIMHO, the juicer wasn't over-engineered, it was under designed. Whomever designed it wasn't given or didn't pay attention to cost constraints and didn't think hard enough about how to solve the problem in the most efficient manner. A well designed machine would probably be more like a roller on a worm drive mounted on some stamped sheet metal. It would look totally chintzy but get the job done and cost a fraction of what the Juicero cost. It would still be a stupid product that would probably fail, but at least the hardware wouldn't cost an arm and a leg.
- AndyNemmity 9y agoIt could be that by doing a roller system, it wouldn't be able to be sold at a premium and generate the funding they have. Some of this all works together, would they have been here with a workable, reasonable product? Probably not, they would have been just an appliance. But with a completely unreasonable product, they get to flaunt it's ridiculous merits as value. You could even imagine marketing around the full press having some bs nutritional value versus not.
- nolepointer 9y ago>Whomever *Whoever (sorry)
- kin 9y agoFreshly pressed juice is sold at a pretty high markup and little stands and shops seem to make a hefty margin. They charge like $10 for 12oz. of freshly pressed fruit and veggies. So, there's a ton of upside in selling packets and I can see how they made believers out of early investors. But wow did they go about it wrong, charging $699 for a machine that does a worse job than your bare hands!? Was there not one investor who did a technical due diligence? I'm so surprised.
- chx 9y agoInvestors put close to thirty million into a wireless charging company in four rounds completely disregarding it's impossible to create what they want according to the law of physics.
- bauerd 9y agoSource? I could use a laugh right now
- kgwgk 9y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?query=uBeam https://hn.algolia.com/?query=uBeam
- nimish 9y agouBeam ultrasonic charging is physically impossible
- phonon 9y ago...at a useful enough wattage to replace existing charging systems, while be small and convenient enough to attach to a cell phone. The actual technology works...just not well enough, and scaling it to be an order of magnitude more useful is probably physically impossible.
- Simon_says 9y agoI imagine he's talking about uBeam. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11852896 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11852896
- sriram_sun 9y agoSo I got on Linkedin and checked out some of the profiles of people working there. Some of them have MBAs from MIT Sloan and Harvard. Not saying I'm not susceptible to this, but group think / drinking your own Kool-Aid is something to be careful about as we engineers hop and skip through the startup minefield.
- jandrese 9y agoThey got paid a steady paycheck. They produced the product the founder wanted. I wouldn't hold it against the engineers and developers. We can rag on the guy who engineered the juice pressing bit, but it very much looks like a junior guy right out of school who didn't have an adult in the room telling him that his $800 first effort was beautiful but needed to be redesigned to be under $50 in parts. Everybody needs that experience to understand how stuff works in the real world.
- AndyNemmity 9y agoExactly. If you've worked in any startup, I'd imagine you've had the same experience, I sure have. When the founder wants something that doesn't make sense, you try to reason about it, you try to get other voices helping in a chorus that something doesn't work, but when the founder is the one with the money, the vision, and the ego, it can be impossible to move them off their idea regardless of the merits.
- ryandrake 9y agoExactly. He who has the gold makes the rules. I've seen this more times than I care to admit. It could be the silliest product in the world, with fatal flaws you can easily point to, doomed to failure, but he's the boss and you're not, and he doesn't want to hear "reasons". So, you go off and build it, keeping your resume up-to-date and ready...
- muglug 9y agoI imagine they signed on to work at a well-funded company with a pedigreed CEO in advance of the Businessweek article. Totally logical decision, especially if they have loans to pay off.
- 52074653 9y agoCompared with SeeFood app, I wonder which one of them is more useful.
- minimaxir 9y agoNo one has claimed Juicero is useless, just that the value-proposition is a very hard sell when a $0 substitute can get similar results.
- Finnucane 9y agoReally, I'm getting older, but my teeth still work okay. I can still chew my fruits and vegetables without having a machine do it for me. Is this something that people are having difficulty with these days?
- overcast 9y agoIt's actually worse than you think. If you look at what is inside those Juicero packets, it's basically just "chewed" up fruit pulp. That's why you can squeeze it with your hands so effectively. If it was actually a masticating machine, it might be useful. But this is literally a $700 device, that squeezes juice out of a bag.
- sdgerhyet343 9y ago"Some held up the countertop appliance as a symbol of all that was wrong with Silicon Valley..." Production of consumer luxury gadgets the masses can't afford is hardly limited to businesses in Silicon Valley. Maybe I'm over-thinking it here. But humans have great capacity for later justifying an opinion about something based upon what turns out to be nonsense. I wish journalism today would be more understanding. When I was a kid (in the 80s) I was home sick a lot and watched TV with my mom. It was full of kitchen gadget ads, and other home appliance type stuff we could never afford. The TV itself was a 10+ yr old hand me down (as an aside, I doubt the 1080p TV I bought in 2015 will last as long). If it's a problem in SV, it's because SV has become infected by a greater issue overall.
- mortenjorck 9y agoLower prices? While the article doesn't mention any specifics, juice that retails for $7 per serving and juice that retails for $5 per serving is still addressing the exact same market. The cost structure of a subscription-based, home-delivered, fresh, semi-prepared food product is not going to, even at scale, be close to price-competitive with a juicer from Bed Bath & Beyond and some fresh fruit from Whole Foods. Juicero will, by its nature, always be a premium product situated well beyond any home juicing options.
- noir_lord 9y agoAgreed, I bought a morphy richards blender/juicer for £24.99, I pick up a bag of fruit near the end of it's shelf life for 2-3 quid from the market on the way past. Cost per serving about 20-25p. Cleaning is taking the center out and running it under a tap, this was an insane product however you cut (or pulp) it.
- Shivetya 9y agowell worse, on the idea where many companies are trying to be environmentally sensitive its clear these guys weren't even considering that aspect. this is even worse than a Keurig simply because the waste is far greater and packaging is as bad if not worse because they have to carry all the liquid with them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DaggerDagger 9y agoI think a lot of the commentary on Juicero misses the real skeleton in the closet. The product was designed to specifically to justify the business model of the DRM pulp packets and thus MRR for the purpose of revenue and growth. Everything about it looks like they designed the packets and juice pulp DRM features first, then backfilled the rest of the mechanical design to support the REAL features (keeping people buying your fruit packages) and not the FAKE features (juicing?). Many people talk about the ring roller/ toothpaste squeezer method being easier. Of course! But how do you do DRM with that? It's trickier. How do you scan the barcode and also keep your customers from using off brand K-Cups, I'm sorry I mean, fruit pulp packets. It's obvious for $800 they could have designed an amazing conventional juicer, which actually would be a better product. But how do you get monthly recurring revenue out of that and thus justification for raising millions in venture capitalist money? Juicero is a great example of dark hardware design and a cautionary tail about the hubris of the "if you build it" risk management strategy.
- oh_sigh 9y agoWhy would drm be harder with a roller? If it's in the housing most people aren't going to open it and override even a simple drm mechanism
- option_greek 9y agoWhat they should have done is something like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CYA8HsM_Mg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CYA8HsM_Mg Instead they ended up with a costly dud.
- fpgaminer 9y agoYa know, for $400, they probably could have built a product that's a vertical micro-farm that plants, grows, and harvests the fruits for you, chucks them into a press, and juices it. Then it can turn that leftover pulp into compost and replant the seeds. That would actually be really cool and useful!
- purpleostrich 9y agoI would buy that That's a dream
- overcast 9y agoWell, it's been an incredible journey. Blowing through millions of VC money, to create the ultimate in over engineered nonsense.
- evervevdww221 9y agoto be honest, the Nest smart thermostat seems to me just like this juicero thing. I don't own one, but I heard from early buyers that thing is expensively useless. but somehow it receives less laugh and the company is still operating. but of course, the nest company has an ambition in smart homes and iot also, not just making thermostats.