7 ms·
I really hope the ECC carries through. It irritates me to have to buy a "server" CPU if I want ECC on my desktop (which I do) and it isn't that many gates! Its
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
I really hope the ECC carries through. It irritates me to have to buy a "server" CPU if I want ECC on my desktop (which I do) and it isn't that many gates! Its not like folks are tight on transistors or anything. And on my 48GB desktop (currently using a Xeon CPU) I'll see anywhere from 1 to 4 corrected single bit errors a month.
For things like large CAD drawings which are essentially one giant data structure, flipping a bit in the middle of them somewhere silently can leave the file unable to be opened. So I certainly prefer not to have those bits flip.
- xiconfjs 9y ago1-4 corrected errors per month?! This sounds quite bad - which manufactor?
- kpil 9y agoIsn't that more or less in the range expected from background radiation bitflips when having 48 GiB?
- vel0city 9y agoI manage many servers with >=384GB RAM. They maybe detect an error once a year, with several never reporting an error in its life. If I noticed a server reporting errors more than twice a year I'd probably swap its memory, and if that didn't fix the problem I'd probably replace the server.
- StillBored 9y agoDepends on what you mean by "reporting an error". The default configuration for most machines I've used is to silently correct single bit failures unless they hit some threshold. So you actively have to run an EDAC (or similar) driver and poll the error counters. Its only with uncorrectable errors does it generally rise to the level of a full MCE.
- vel0city 9y agoMany server-grade motherboards will report ECC memory faults in the event log through IPMI.
- wolster 9y agoHow do these manifest themselves and how do you detect them?
- vel0city 9y agoThe error events are reported through IPMI in a system event log.
- ew6082 9y agoError rate would probably depend on the mass and quality of shielding above/around the servers.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoCrucial (six 8GB sticks). I don't put it into the 'bad' category. When overseeing 1600 machines in a data center with a collective 307TB of RAM suggests its actually on the 'good' side. Bad is multiple errors per day. Really bad is hundreds or thousands per day. Because they are corrected nothing actually happens on the system (other than what ever accessed them saw on the order of 700nS to access RAM rather than on the order of 100nS. If it gets a double bit error it will machine check so I'll know that my memory has failed me :-).
- sitkack 9y agoAll ram should be ECC (selective number of bits), then the processes that fab the ram can be made cheaper and sloppier. Zero bit-error-rate non-ECC RAM would actually be more expensive than ECC ram. A chip kill be on a much smaller granularity. I suspect these things haven't been done because the RAM cabal likes their high prices.
- tedunangst 9y agoAnd you haven't replaced it? The only time I had ECC memory report errors, I was also experiencing undetected errors as well. System was not stable. Pulled it out, happy ever since. I've always thought of ECC as a warning system (despite the correction ability). Like a spare tire.
- JohnTHaller 9y agoMemory errors happen all the time, at least they did several years back when the Google server farm saw "an average of one single-bit-error every 14 to 40 hours per Gigabit of DRAM": http://www.intelligentmemory.com/support/faq/ecc-dram/how-often-do-ecc-correctable-single-bit-errors-occur-and-how-about-double-multi-bit-errors.php http://www.intelligentmemory.com/support/faq/ecc-dram/how-of... This translates to "a mean of 3,751 correctable errors per DIMM per year": http://www.zdnet.com/article/dram-error-rates-nightmare-on-dimm-street/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/dram-error-rates-nightmare-on-d... I'm not sure how things pan out these days with newer memory types. ECC checks and fixes these errors so they're not an issue.
- dis-sys 9y agoCiting the results of a paper in which they studied the errors observed mostly on DDR1 memory? A far more recent study by CMU based on the entire fleet of Fb servers shows that correctable error rates dropped dramatically in the past decade. http://repository.cmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1345&context=ece http://repository.cmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1345&c...
- flamedoge 9y ago[Unless it's obvious to others,] paper doesn't conclude that DDR1 to DDR3 discrepancy correlates to error rate. It only concludes from empirical measurements that memory density scales with error rate (2).
- ChuckMcM 9y agoHere is a better paper to cite: https://www.cs.rochester.edu/~kshen/papers/usenix2010-li.pdf https://www.cs.rochester.edu/~kshen/papers/usenix2010-li.pdf
- frou_dh 9y agoThe typical PC-building online communities have been mindlessly drumming the line "Only servers need ECC" into each other's heads for so long that they'll probably end up refusing it, even when it's offered to them on a plate.
- yuhong 9y agoOEMs will probably still ship systems without ECC too. Does not mean it should not be an option. I wonder as a side note on Bristol Ridge for example, for 8GB of RAM would you rather take dual channel or ECC? (the fun thing is that 4Gbit DDR4 is cheaper per bit on DRAMeXchange spot prices than 8Gbit DDR4 again, but...)
- nsxwolf 9y agoWell, when people are shocked that someone is experiencing 1-4 single bit errors a month across an expanse of 48GB, it's not hard to see why people think it's not something they need.
- copperx 9y agoA single bit error is enough to create a misspelling in a txt file. There's a low probability of it happening, but if it does, it's unnerving to think that it will not be detected.
- sliverstorm 9y agoThere's a very low probability! - In consumer equipment, much of your RAM is often unused at any given time - Most lines in a cache are eventually thrown away, never used - Did you even save your text file, or just open it to read it? - What about all the space occupied by read-only information, like executables, media files, game files, and libraries? You might crash, but nothing will be written to disk You might get an error a month, but the odds you'll get an error that matters on your average consumer machine with average workloads is much much lower.
- alkonaut 9y ago
- ptomato 9y agoAre there any Ryzen motherboards that support ECC currently? ("support" defined as "corrects errors", not "can plug in ECC ram and it functions as normal ram without error correction") Last I am aware there are not.
- weinzierl 9y agoThere is a thread on overclock.net which collects the AM4 motherboards with ECC support [1]. You don't need complete support from the motherboard though. As long as the motherboard and BIOS/UEFI don't sabotage ECC you can at least use it from the OS, even if the motherboard doesn't explicitly support it [2]. [1] http://www.overclock.net/t/1629642/ryzen-ecc-motherboards http://www.overclock.net/t/1629642/ryzen-ecc-motherboards [2] http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-reviews/75030-ecc-memory-amds-ryzen-deep-dive.html http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-review...
- fcanesin 9y agoI have a Ryzen 5 1600 with a pair of Crucial ECC UDIM. It works perfectly on the ASUS Prime B350M-A/CSM uATX board. Stress tested. Errors are logged and halt behavior is confirmed (ubuntu 17.04).
- seanp2k2 9y agoInteresting, is there a list of boards and supported modules that work with ECC?
- arcaster 9y agoInteresting, could you possibly explain how "halt behavior" indicates that ECC is fully functioning? I've just read a lot about ECC being compatible but not tests explicitly showing it works.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOn my system if an uncorrectable error were to happen the system goes into a 'machine check' state (a halt). In theory, the BIOS supports 'chip kill' which is that it reboots with a bit set to not use that specific chip in the DIMM. I've never seen that happen on my desktop but in the data center when it happened a system that should have 128GB of memory would reboot and come back with less than the full amount (as expected by the DIMMs plugged in) reported by the BIOS.
- foota 9y agoInteresting, depending on the amount of RAM killed that seems like it could be a bit overkill for what could just be a cosmic ray flip. Though perhaps the rare frequency of cosmic ray flips makes that acceptable.
- fulafel 9y agoChipkill is an IBM name for the feature that corrects multiple bit errors in DRAM, are you sure about the reboot thing or are there two similarly named ECC techs that do different things?
- luckman212 9y agoSorry for the uninformed question but: With RAM sizes having ballooned to very large sizes (16-32GB now fairly common for a workstation) why is non-ECC memory even considered? Other methods used to safeguard large sums of 0s and 1s like hard drives, SSDs, modern filesystems (ZFS, Btrfs) have builtin error-correcting mechanisms. Why is getting hit with a cosmic ray and having a bit flipped in your CSV file any more acceptable than the same thing occurring on a "server" with ECC memory?
- TylerE 9y agoBecause ECC essentially takes 9 bits per byte for storage - typical implmentation is 9 chips per stick, not 8. You also need an additional controller to actually do the error checking. So, even if it weren't for the typical "enterprise/industrial" you'd be looking at a minimum of 12.5% parts cost increase. Multiple that out * billions of ram sticks and you're talking real money for something with dubious relevance for most users.
- throwaway2048 9y agoThe controller is already built into the cpu, and cost increases aren't linear like that at all when scale is factored in, especially considering packaging and assembly overhead.
- wmf 9y agoSkylake-X without ECC: $999 Skylake-SP with ECC: $3,000 There's your answer.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI agree with this, Intel uses it as a margin enhancer. My CPU was $150 more than the equivalent desktop processor.
- localhost 9y agoCurrent Ryzen CPUs support ECC, so presumably so will the Threadripper variant. See Lisa Su's comment(!) on Reddit repro'd on this page: http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-reviews/75030-ecc-memory-amds-ryzen-deep-dive.html http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-review...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sliken 9y agoXeon E3 pricing is very similar to the equiv i5 and i7, and supports ECC. Plenty of fairly cheap motherboards ($50-$100 more than the i5/i7 boards).
- deagle50 9y agoSome i3 models also support ECC when paired with the right chipset. My NAS runs on an i3-2100/Supermicro/ECC DDR3 setup. The i3 was a $100 Microcenter special. If I ever have to upgrade the compute portion I will definitely consider Ryzen.
- NightlyDev 9y agoCheck out the asus prime x370-pro. :)
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAfter reading it had both AM4 support and ECC I started planning a build based on it. Assuming the ECC implementation works as I need it will probably be my next desktop.
- redtuesday 9y agoThreadripper will have ECC support [0] just like Ryzen but validation depends on the motherboard manufacturer. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/6icdyo/amd_threadripper_supports_up_to_256gb_of_ram_942/dj5lhs7/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/6icdyo/amd_threadrippe...