13 ms·
My mind always boggles at humanity's general inability to standardize on one thing without great pain and fighting. Whether it's Metric vs. Imperial, Beta vs. V
by ryandrake 9y ago
My mind always boggles at humanity's general inability to standardize on one thing without great pain and fighting. Whether it's Metric vs. Imperial, Beta vs. VHS, Blu-ray vs. HDDVD, OpenGL vs. DirectX, USB speeds, power connectors, instant messaging protocols. Nobody can just sit together and cooperate--we always have to go through that painful period with multiple incompatible standards that fight it out until (hopefully) one of them wins.
- pmarreck 9y agoYou may be interested in this article on the general topic of interface wars: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Format_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Format_war
- unabridged 9y agoLanguage is probably the oldest (and most sentimental) version of this problem
- andreasgonewild 9y agoOnly because of isolation, look at what's happened in only a few years since we got our hands on a global network.
- zanny 9y agoThere is still an incredible amount of isolation. My primary forums are reddit and hacker news, and both are so disproportionately Americo-centric its scary. Google only ever gives me results from American publications and even Duckduckgo has a hard time finding relevant information to my searches from outside the US or West Europe. Meanwhile, more people in Africa have cell phones than plumbing, and there is realistically almost nowhere in the world without some form of cellular data service now. All these people, however, are in isolated language specific silos of content. Even the Indian Internet is radically different from what I see despite both being in mostly the same language (with some Hindi mixed in). I am always worried about how little interaction there is, through a medium of effectively no barriers than the ones we make ourselves, between the people of western powers and everyone else who is currently online but either not informed about what the Internet is (and thus just uses SMS) or is isolated from us by language barriers.
- andreasgonewild 9y agoThat would be capitalism's general inability.
- hugi 9y agoI'm actually rather impressed with humanity's ability to standardize. It's perfectly natural (and in many cases desirable) for multiple parties to go through that "painful period" with different solutions that will compete to become "standard". It just takes a little time for everything to align and settle, that's perfectly natural. As for the U.S. refusing to adopt the planet-wide metric system? You've got me there. That's just… Weird.
- snarfy 9y agoThe US government adopted it in 1975, and Reagan abolished it 1982. It's frustrating not being able to repair the tools I buy from home depot using tools bought from home depot. I couldn't even go metric if I wanted to. They don't sell raw materials in metric. You get 4x8' sheets of plywood and something called a 2x4 which seems to have nothing to do with either measuring system. It's not even Cartesian.
- dekhn 9y ago2x4s are measured using nominal sizes- "nominally" they are 2" by 4" but in reality a bit less. There is a lawsuit over this right now.
- zanny 9y agoIt should be obvious why the US stays on the imperial system. There is an opportunity cost to switch that is greater than the current ongoing cost of translation. Thus, someone has to bite the bullet and assume losses to push metric. Throughout the world, the organization that put the foot down and ate the bill has almost always been the government - but the US government operates on short term results. The politician that inconveniences the public today with a metric conversion doesn't have his seat tomorrow, and his replacement immediately halts proceedings. Language isn't close to a solved problem. Hopefully the next hundred years can finally see the reconstruction of the Tower of Babel for a generation of the world soon to come. But there also needs to be a legitimate reason for us to want to unify language. If we operate independently of one another and let businesses control any interactions by proxy of money, we will stay separate.
- zanny 9y agoStandards forfeit control. If you can become a de facto standard, without standardizing, you wield insane power over lives and business. Of your examples, Blu-ray, DirectX, and the "new age" closed silo IM protocols like WhatsApp that superseded an XMPP world are all corporate controlled properties that have no standards body considering the needs of the industry. They behave and act to fulfill the needs of their creators, to the detriment of the users and broader ecosystem. That is why standards are hard. Because it requires those with power to voluntarily relinquish it, which very rarely will happen. And then to never try to circumvent standards with first mover advantage to reclaim that kind of monopoly power. At least right now societies around the world are very poorly structured to align the incentives towards cooperation.
- esolyt 9y ago> Whether it's Metric vs. Imperial To be fair, humanity did standardize that long ago. There is a country that is refusing to switch to the standard.
- mmmpop 9y agoMaybe if every American took a thermodynamics course where the teacher insisted on memorizing the unit conversions we would not have this issue! What an awful semester...
- refurb 9y agoWhen you're the only super power you can get away with it!
- pmarreck 9y agoIf you're not in that country and are speaking English and it's your native tongue, then it's highly probable that your country (or its foreign ruler's Queen) is the one that originally imposed this system on us
- jdboyd 9y agoWith regard to OpenGL vs. DirectX, the competing standards push each other to keep improving. I suspect that graphics APIs and thus hardware would have really stagnated without the competition.
- cr0sh 9y agoThere's more to the history of DirectX and OpenGL than you may be aware of. Personally, I believe Microsoft helped to engineer the downfall of SGI, via the whole Fahrenheit graphics "co-operation" - which also led to SGI making Windows NT workstations (in place of Irix). That isn't to say that SGI didn't have some bumbling management of the time, but I do think that Microsoft took advantage of the situation to get them to chase a red herring to accelerate their demise, while also gaining a lot of new knowledge and IP via the sharing agreements they had for Fahrenheit. Then again, had SGI not imploded, we wouldn't have NVidia today...
- kuschku 9y ago> Then again, had SGI not imploded, we wouldn't have NVidia today... nvidia is basically one of the worst actors in the market, though. Artificially increasing prices and artificially segmenting the market, using anticompetitive methods to gain an advantage (oh how everyone loves gameworks), etc.
- Theodores 9y agoMicrosoft also bought SoftImage and didn't do much with it except make sure it worked on NT. This breaking of the SGI toolchain was not a friendly move. You are right about fahrenheit, it doomed everything.
- justin66 9y ago> That isn't to say that SGI didn't have some bumbling management of the time Understatement of the century. > Then again, had SGI not imploded, we wouldn't have NVidia today... That gets the timeline all wrong. Nvidia is a much older company than you are probably aware of, and might have been quite successful (and quite capable of attracting top talent) had SGI managed to stagger along for quite a bit longer. SGI never, ever had a shot at making the mass-market stuff that let Nvidia grow as quickly as they did. It wasn't in their DNA.
- Denvercoder9 9y agoWell, different systems have different tradeoffs. It makes sense that people have different priorities, and thus prefer different systems. Almost everyone likes cooperation, but for that compromise is needed, which is always difficult to achieve in a manner satisfactory to all parties involved.
- cmurf 9y agoMy favorite example of this at the moment is UEFI Time Services. Time is current local time, TimeZone is an offset from UTC in minutes, and Daylight establishes whether DST should apply, and if it has been applied. So yay, no more time incompatibilities with multiple OS's. Except no, not even Microsoft Windows 10 sets the TimeZone value to the actual UTC offset! They set it to EFI_UNSPECIFIED_TIME. And so does Linux. And so does macOS. So we're still fakaked.
- Avernar 9y agoUEFI is a good example of a standard that was over designed by a committee. Way too much bad decisions that are now part of the standard. My favourite is using the FAT file system format for the system partition. No checksums, fragile on disk format, and no built in support for mirroring just to name a few. And why they kept the idea of having the clock in local time is baffling. That just leads to errors when DST failed to apply or was applied twice.
- Tharkun 9y agoBlame all those cheeky buggers who built machines powered by steam engines or water turbines. They basically built their machines to run on whatever was available. Got a waterwheel doing 1000RPM and you need a big saw attached to it? Your saw will be running at 1000RPM (~16Hz). So many crazy machines were built before there was either a need or an effective way to standardize anything power related. Keep in mind that many kinds of manipulations of electricity are easy and cheap now, but that certainly wasn't the case when people started converting from steam/water to electricity!
- cr0sh 9y ago> So many crazy machines were built before there was either a need or an effective way to standardize anything power related. One of my favorite, somewhat related, such machinery was those multi-pole "generators" that were used to create carrier waves for radio transmission between the thin era of spark-gaps and vacuum tube oscillators.
- spqr0a1 9y agoCalled an Alexanderson alternator for those curious. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexanderson_alternator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexanderson_alternator
- mirimir 9y ago> Got a waterwheel doing 1000RPM and you need a big saw attached to it? Your saw will be running at 1000RPM (~16Hz). Most "waterwheels" turned far more slowly than 1000 rpm. More like a few hundred at most. They used pulleys and belts, and eventually CVTs. Edit: http://www.alternative-energy-tutorials.com/hydro-energy/waterwheel-design.html http://www.alternative-energy-tutorials.com/hydro-energy/wat...
- elihu 9y agoSometimes standards are mostly arbitrary, and it doesn't matter which one "wins" as long as we all agree on one. However, it can also be frustrating when society adopts a standard nearly universally, and then that standard becomes an impediment when some new alternative comes along or some new use case is found that isn't supported by the old standard.
- nnq 9y ago> nobody can just sit together and cooperate Doesn't work. If you want fast standardization at all costs, only way to it by forced standardization with "obey or goto gulag" orders send from a "tyrannical government" and "violent" and feared standards enforcement authorities. When you let people vote standardization takes aaaages. When you let corporations vote, it gets even worse... it may never truly happen because the agreed upon "standards" have purposeful ambiguities sprinkled everywhere 'cause "but that's too hard to implement", and practical implementations never fully obey because "what you gonna do, can't practically sue us for not implementing this". Also standardization favors commoditization, hence doesn't make much business sense to do it if you're the "big guy", and isn't so easy to do if you're the little guy (and you're also eating away your future profits if you're the small guy that knows it's gonna grow bug fast).