17 ms·
Roomba Inventor Joe Jones on His New Weed-Killing Robot
- Gibbon1 9y agoI expect that one thing that will come out of deep learning is mechanical weeding for industrial level agriculture. Instead of spraying crops with herbicide, mechanically remove weeds. Bonus is agricultural machinery tends to be high capital cost anyways, which allows for a lot more processing power and sensors than a garden robot.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoNo piece of equipment that will be used on a farm deserves more than the bare minimum of sensors.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoSounds ripe for a shakeup.
- justinpombrio 9y agoWhy?
- tengbretson 9y agoBecause they will probably be purchased by the thousand, if not 10 thousand. Furthermore, they will be exposed to rugged environments where every extra component that can fail is a huge liability.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoExactly. Better to figure out a novel way to use fewer sensors equally well (cheaper) or the same sensors to better effect (more results). Those things are hard though, plugging a few sensors into a Pi, slapping a LAMP stack on it then creating a web interface and smart-phone app you can show the VCs is easy by comparison.
- pavement 9y agoslapping a LAMP stack on it then creating a web interface You know, that'd be really great and all, but please, please, please don't discount the potential for rampant, malicious destruction of food supply for kicks, revenge or maybe even strategy/tactics in state conflict. Consider how warlords and pirates operate in other countries and failed states. Food security is important, and a robot that can selectively clip and gouge weeds can do the same to both critical food and cash crops too. Furthermore, simple competition, big corporate espionage and personal differences can still affect small organic growers as well. Human factors are real, and novelty is good but it doesn't cure quite everything.
- thom 9y agoThis seems an important point that hadn't occurred to me. Our food chain is already pretty dependent on Internet-connected infrastructure working correctly, but it seems absolutely plausible that this will be a future attack vector if we network and automate farming machinery.
- noir_lord 9y agoIf you can build a robot to go around destroying crops you can built a hunter-killer to go after the crop killing robots. The future gets scary fast when you consider the almost inevitable tick-tock between capability/defense.
- jessaustin 9y agoThe threat is not from unknown robots sneaking in to uproot crops (after all why not do something fast and cheap like spreading salt?). The threat is that the farmer's own weeding robots will be hacked to uproot crops, probably by ze Russians. Firmware updates should be secured.
- noir_lord 9y agoA threat not the only threat. Someone somewhere is working out how to weaponise them, we've as a species weaponised everything else we've ever invented pretty much.
- givemefive 9y agoI don't really understand what he's talking about. Most farm equipment nowadays has thousands in dollars of GNSS equipment and a multitude of other sensors.
- sideshowb 9y agoThis. I suspect quite a lot of techies here would be surprised by modern farming.
- noir_lord 9y agoI've followed what's happening in that sphere tangentially because I find industrial programming fascinating. I think a lot of techies would be surprised what all that stuff costs as well.
- tda 9y agoI really hope we get there soon. Not only could this eliminate usage of herbicides, but many smaller autonomous robots vs one really big John Deere could also remove the need for monocultures. And that would really be a major improvement for both crop yields and the environment
- noir_lord 9y agoWould be fantastic to sit and watch an army of spindly legged robots stride around the place doing that. Would be straight out of sci-fi. Robot horticulture has long been a staple.
- mrkrab 9y agoA step closer to this. http://i.imgur.com/f7hccDn.gif http://i.imgur.com/f7hccDn.gif
- xyrnoble 9y agoThe premise of the matrix violates the first law of thermodynamics; It's just a plot device.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Namrog84 9y agoExcept although the movie does say battery. That's not the original plot device that was written. They were originally written as human based cpu computers. But some higher up thought people wouldn't understand "human processors" so just everytime you think about or watch the matrix again. Just think it's a poor mistranslation that made it into the movie, "processor->battery"
- slyall 9y agoOf course battery is just what Morpheus and the others from Zion think is the story. Considering how wrong they were on other important matters the battery explanation could easily be wrong and the CPU correct.
- deepGem 9y agoThere are some crude versions out there https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBRZUtIDqbU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBRZUtIDqbU I don't think any of them employ deep learning for visually recognizing weeds. This one from Bosch comes close I guess https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8Aq6qVQOkw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x8Aq6qVQOkw
- dEnigma 9y agoThis one came as a recommendation after watching your second video: https://youtu.be/15tovWSnJe0 https://youtu.be/15tovWSnJe0
- ekianjo 9y ago> Instead of spraying crops with herbicide, mechanically remove weeds For large surfaces would that financially make any sense though?
- qq66 9y agoIf you are organic certified, and you could build something as fast and big as a combine harvester to remove weeds... why not?
- ekianjo 9y ago> organic certified That may be a use case, but the large majority of grown food is not organic-certified. Does it make sense for such productions?
- jeromenerf 9y agoNo. Large size monoculture should rely on preventive methods to control weeds, such as always covering the soil. It's even possible to plant seeds on an existing live cover. No plowing, no pesticides, just preventive coverage and good tools. In the long run, those large monocultures don't make sense anyway. Robots can be great for a lot of high maintenance, Human intensive, high value cultures such as fruits, greens ... I guess they could also help expand vegetables farms to non cultivated areas, in some autonomous ways.
- Tempest1981 9y agoA drone (or tractor) with high-powered lasers? Or a 10000 psi water stream?
- bluGill 9y agoThat depends. Farmers used to mechanically remove weeds with a cultivator. (a fancy hoe attached to a tractor) Those cultivators will remove all weeds and no weed grows resistant to them. However they have many disadvantages: Cost - $500 worth of fuel for the tractor vs $250 for chemical + $50 for fuel to run the sprayer is the big one (These cost numbers are what I've heard but I might remember wrong). CO2: that $500 worth of fuel vs $50 directly translates into CO2, which in turns translates into global warming. (this is the only one that you can argue doesn't have a financial impact on the farmer - and it isn't clear that those arguments are valid) Soil disturbance. Every time you til the soil you disturb the natural soil. It isn't as bad as deep plowing, but it is still harmful. Soil compaction. A repetitively light sprayer can cover 100+ feet of crop in just two tire tracks (the first wheel the runs over the ground does the damage, the second barely adds anything so the 4 wheels result in two tracks). A tractor is heavier (the impact of weight it not linear though so figure 10% worse), and can only do 30 feet so you end up with just over 3x as many tire tracks compacting and harming the ground. Labor cost. Sprayers can run at 15mph in the field. Cultivators are probably running at 5mph. Not only are you taking 3x as many passes, each pass takes 3x as long. You pay the operator by the hour. Now for your robot which applies? The weed pulling robot will only disturb the soil where the weed is. However the robot needs to get to the weed which increases compaction along each row. My guess is farmers will spray everything as a primary prevention. Then they will fly drones over the field and send a robot down only the rows where there are weeds. That is just a guess though, you can imagine your own parameters for future robots which will change everything. Note, herbicides are not nearly as dangerous as popular press makes them out to be.
- elihu 9y agoAnother use case is invasive species control in parks and large public lands. As an example, Portland has a large park that stretches along a ridge-line for about ten miles, and it's getting overgrown by English ivy, which kills the trees. It's a big enough area that pulling it all by hand would be very expensive. Ivy-pulling robots would be pretty awesome, but it's a hard problem. Vegetation is thick and the terrain is everything but flat. You'd probably need some giant hexapods or something just to move around, and maybe some kind of Ivy-grabbing appendage. Just mapping out the ivy infestation with drones and image recognition software would be impressive. There's enough room for a quad-rotor to move around in theory, but it would have to have some pretty sophisticated obstacle avoidance algorithms.
- sitkack 9y agoIvy growing over trees can be easily handled by humans.
- traek 9y ago> It's a big enough area that pulling it all by hand would be very expensive.
- elihu 9y agoForest park is about ten square miles, and maybe a third is overrun by ivy. That's solvable by a sufficiently large human work crew, but it wouldn't be easy. Developing, manufacturing, and operating a crew of robots just for this one particular ivy problem wouldn't be worth the cost, but invasive species are a widespread problem and are sometimes on much larger scales, like hundreds or thousands of square miles. At some point, using people isn't a realistic option. If we can solve larger invasive species problems for less money than a human work crew, then that seems like a win.
- drodgers 9y agoThe best part? Weeds will still evolve resistance — just like they do for herbicides — but they'll do it by growing into shapes that the ML models misclassify.
- zupa-hu 9y agoUpdating the robots can be done much faster than it takes for the weeds to mutate. And for mutations to happen, some proportion of the weed population must survive in the environment, as no weeds can not mutate. I doubt they have a chance, unless some species figure out how to live under the earth, in which case, we won't care as those would not be "weeds" any more.
- thesehands 9y agoI expect John Deere copyright lawsuit will have a big impact on how free one will be to update the models. I can see weed updates as a form of IRL DLC
- drodgers 9y agoYep. John Deere will collect all of the recognition data and not allow their customers to see anything except high-level statistics (for an additional fee). Then they'll use it to train next year's model and charge for the upgrade.
- drodgers 9y agoI'd wager that some will survive by: 1) Getting very close to the crops and intertwining with them to make weeding very hard 2) Looking almost exactly like real crops (as-in, to the point where most humans can't tell the difference and the machines need to start taking genetic samples) You're totally right though; the machines have an adaption-speed advantage, so I'd expect this to be a very effective technique overall (assuming that the robotics pan-out).
- agumonkey 9y agoAre we writing a vegan Jurassic Park reboot ?
- visarga 9y agoI envision a robot gardener that would create a paradise from a plot of empty land. Each plant would be placed, cared for and trimmed in such a way as to obtain an artistic effect. Another kind of bot I am hoping to see is a waste collector. They would find plastic bottles, bags, glass and iron in forests, on roadsides, and even underwater, around beaches. Unleash 100 bots in a forest and in one year, it's pristine. We can also have some collect floating plastic from the oceans.
- Balgair 9y agoA trash bot would really be something to see. I'd pay a lot in taxes for that. Add in some ML matrix-stirring to watch out for fauna, and you have taken out ~70% of forest rangers jobs. Heck, just make a Park Ranger bot, cleans trash, scolds tourists, takes entry fees, fights fires; it'd be pretty nice.
- soperj 9y agoEmpty land?
- agumonkey 9y agoAllow me for larger anticipation. Light and tiny electromechanical machines (aka cyborg insects) that can be released to monitor and clean weed, other insects, maybe bacterias.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoGenetically modified squirrels! They pull weeds, put them in a bin and get a kibble! Its work or die, which keeps the gene line pure. And self-replicating too.
- agumonkey 9y agoI so wish we had a squirrel google translate. Green, clean and cute world.
- nashashmi 9y ago> Light and tiny electromechanical machines ... to go through landfills and mine for recyclables ... the list goes on.
- Aardwolf 9y agoThey would even recycle their own kind!
- lostlogin 9y agoIf anyone hasn't seen the Black Mirror bees episode, please do. It's great.
- davexunit 9y agoThe term "weed" feels pretty outdated at this point. People consider many beneficial plants to be weeds just because they didn't put them there. For example, people remove clover, a wonderful nitrogen fixer, from their lawns in order to maintain their unsustainable monoculture of nonnative grass. Is a weed-killing robot solving the right problem? Modern agriculture works against nature rather than with it.
- andygates 9y agoA seedling-removing bot (which is what this is) absolutely helps compared to chemical sprays or time-consuming faff. Once a gardener decides to keep a plant, they're not weeds any more.
- tengbretson 9y agoAgreed. I think the term undocumented cultivar is a more appropriate word to describe what these plants have to offer to us all.
- lostlogin 9y ago... and the wall around your plants keeps them safe. Solar power pays for it all.
- dpark 9y agoA weed is essentially any undesired plant that self propagates effectively. The fact that some of them are beneficial in some aspect is irrelevant if they are unwanted. The entire point of a garden is that it's full of stuff that some human wants.
- reustle 9y agoTheir point is that if a clover is necessary for healthier vegetables, maybe the education around what weeds are should be fixed.
- jessaustin 9y ago
- rmason 9y agoThis looks like it would be fine for a homeowner that wants a garden but doesn't like to weed. But looking at it from the commercial standpoint it doesn't make much financial sense. You'd need to spend nearly $109,000 per acre and that is a pretty small vegetable commercial farm. In fact ten acres would probably be the minimum for one family to make a living and you'd spend over a $1 million! You can hire a whole lots of high school kids every year for a whole lot less money. Doesn't mean it isn't cool technology, but then again so is a $450,000 Ford GT. Still believe that commercial herbicides will soon be an endangered species. Didn't get many farmers to agree with me twenty years ago but maybe more would now.
- tengbretson 9y agoI imagine once this is made to fit into the row spacing of commercial row-crops, and purchased at scale, larger operations would be able to deploy these at a cost competitive with herbicide applications. And once it gets even within an order of magnitude of traditional herbicides, the implications for organic crops could be huge!
- rmason 9y agoAgree with you more than you do yourself. Herbicide costs are rising while technology costs are declining. First use will be organic crops but I think it will make sense for non-organic ones as well.
- tengbretson 9y agoOnce technology like this hits a critical mass, I'm not sure there will even be the need for a distinction between organic and traditional agriculture. edit: Though I suppose there will still need to be distinctions made to make clear the differences between GMO varieties such as BT corn and the like. However, maybe by then the definition of organic will widen to allow for the incredible advancements that genetic engineering allows us.
- mc32 9y ago
- modeless 9y ago> Currently I’m thinking that cameras connected to deep learning networks is the technology with the most promise to enable a new wave of low-cost robotic applications. After his earlier comments about fancy sensors being too expensive I was surprised to read this. But I agree. Once some cheap neural net ASICs come out I expect a revolution in robotics will follow soon after.
- melvinram 9y agoAn alternative outcome might be that sensor prices drop due to mass production with more adoption.
- modeless 9y agoCameras are pretty cheap and already mass produced like crazy. The expensive part is the processing you need to extract high level information from the pixels. That's why we need cheap neural net ASICs.
- deepnotderp 9y agoHeh, sorry for the shameless plug, but that's one of the big target applications for our chip: deep learning for robotics.
- oh_sigh 9y agoI'm not sure if I understand your main thrust, but running data through a trained NN can be done in relatively few operations - it is training the network which takes a lot of compute resources.
- oh_sigh 9y agoHow long will weeds last if you keep decapitating them? I'd imagine they would deplete the soil even faster than just letting them grow(which brings it's own problems with shading out plants and propagation)?
- djb_hackernews 9y agoAs a hobby gardener and wannabe roboticist I've thought a lot about this problem. Before I continue I love this thing and am seriously thinking about getting one. However, a concern that I'm sure they've thought a lot about is in it's technique. I really only care about making sure there are no weeds within, say, 8 inches of my plants (or put another way, my level of concern about a weed is proportional to it's distance from my vegetable or flower plant). This looks like it will weed everything except the 8 inches around the plant. Never mind things like cucumbers that spread out on the ground and have important bits that are short and can't be contained by the wire protectors. Still, an exciting place to start.
- prawn 9y agoIt looks like they started with a Roomba and went from there, which leaves them with a robot that can't deal with raised beds or (as you said) weeds integrated with plants. I have raised beds and then raised side gardens which would render this device useless to me. Same with the other hobby gardeners I know. I always imagined something with long spindly legs that would cut, inject or spray things that it identified as weeds by leaves. For me, the weeds that are the most trouble are those close to or mixed in with plants. Anything on its own isn't that hard to pull out.
- cctan 9y agoOne workaround is that I hope that it can climb up and down slopes that lead to the raised beds. Does it detect cliffs or edges and avoid falling down?
- pxndx 9y agoRoombas do, it would be weird if this new iteration didn't
- c3833174 9y agoRoombas have to deal with stairs while this thing will probably get it's underside covered in mud (especially since it has that unshielded trimmer) and is supposed to run only inside a fenced area, so I doubt it has any provisions for that.
- adolph 9y agoThe article pointed out the inventor's book, Robot Programming : A Practical Guide to Behavior-Based Robotics. [1] Are there any other interesting/recommended texts for this domain? The book refers to a website that seems to have been domain squatted by GoDaddy. An alternate .net tld is present, but unfortunately uses old Java applets. [2] 1. https://smile.amazon.com/dp/0071427783/ref=rdr_ext_tub https://smile.amazon.com/dp/0071427783/ref=rdr_ext_tub 2. http://www.behaviorbasedprogramming.net/manual.html http://www.behaviorbasedprogramming.net/manual.html
- khrm 9y agoAm I the only one who had to click to find out that weed being talk about isn't Marijuana?
- quickthrower 9y agoYes you are. Why would you need a robot to kill plants you want to keep?
- snarfy 9y agoI think the traditional solution (weed barrier) is still better, and cheaper. http://www.homedepot.com/p/Vigoro-3-ft-x-50-ft-Polyethylene-Weed-Barrier-Landscape-Fabric-1142RV/206684876 http://www.homedepot.com/p/Vigoro-3-ft-x-50-ft-Polyethylene-...
- pkulak 9y agoCertainly not cheaper if you include installation.
- stusmall 9y agoI'm not a huge fan of landscape fabric. It works for a season or two but over time it forms holes that weeds push through. You still have to manually weed but now you are less likely to pull all the roots up. The previous owner of my house used a ton of it as a quick solution to a weed problem so they could more easily sell the house. I've spent a lot of time ripping out their quick fix. I had a nice surprise of finding a bed of sad irises under one.
- sapote 9y agoMight work on the East Coast or in water-intensive gardens elsewhere, but in California almost any reasonable garden will have a layer of rough mulch to reduce evaporation (and suppress weeds). Maybe this robot could navigate my mulch but I'm doubtful.
- rmrm 9y agoCommercial organic farms mulch heavily, which nicely controls weeds. Non organic farms spray. Home gardeners apparently aren't mulching, which has myriad other benefits besides weed control. I love robots, but mulch is a much better solution.
- sitkack 9y agoMulching robot?
- rmrm 9y agoI am planning on getting 75 yards of wood chips delivered to mulch an orchard we are putting in. For me the mulching robot will be a bobcat I rent to help spread it :) For reference, 75 yards of wood chips (3 tractor trailer loads) + bobcat rental to spread costs $1000 in Bay Area. And provides years or weed prevention, water retention, and soil improvement.
- sitkack 9y agoI have already submitted a YC application about our new SkyMulch Drone powered by Google Cloud ML Engine.
- lostlogin 9y agoPresumably you have seen those vacuum things that pump the mulch out? They do all the motorway berms with them here. Take care you don't go too thick with the mulch as it burns very well and when fresh gets very hot. It's midwinter here and the inside of a pile was too hot to comfortably touch last week.
- topspin 9y ago>> "Home gardeners apparently aren't mulching" Yeah.. wow. Stop by a Home Depot sometime next spring and observe the mountains of bagged mulch they stock. Home gardeners and hobby farmers do indeed mulch. A lot. Where I am they stack mulch between gas pumps at every station. If that's too much trouble a single call will have a truckload on your property inside a week. Simple weed killing robots of the sort depicted here will find their home on lawns. We're not all living in a coastal desert; ample fresh water affords nice lawns and that means squabbling with weeds.
- Animats 9y agoThe wheels look too tiny for the real world. Nice idea, though. This guy invented the Roomba? He must have been really screwed by iRobot if he has to do a Kickstarter to fund his next project. He should either have enough money or the reputation to talk to VCs.
- usaphp 9y agoWith VC you are giving up part of the company and control, with kickstarter you are still the boss and get all the profits
- mastazi 9y agoYes exactly, and "having to do" a Kickstarter doesn't necessarily mean that he "must have been screwed", I think regardless of how much capital you may or may not have, there is no shame in raising funds, is there?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ingenuous2 9y agoIt seems possible to me that he wants to use that reputation so he can get just as much money without giving up equity. Just like this news article showed. Guy with this idea? MEH. Inventor of the Roomba? Let's write it up! Why would he give up money when he has the best marketing he can't buy? (cheaply)
- icebraining 9y agoKickstarter is also used for market validation.
- TulliusCicero 9y agoKickstarters are also a useful way of generating hype.
- jaclaz 9y agoI am also perplexed. The "goal" on KickStarter is set as US$ 120,000 (at this moment it reached more than double that US$ 265,213). So he asked to receive between 108,000 and 110,000 US$ (net of the Kickstarter fee of 5% and of the additional - absurd BTW - "payment fee between 3 and 5%). This can be a rather large or a ridicoulosly small amount (of course it depends on points of view) but I propend for the "ridicolously small". A (hopefully) succesfull robotics engineer in his fifties should have (or can procure through relations) that amount of money easily, and he is "only" a co-founder (and CTO) of the new company. It seems to me - I have noticed it on other projects that ask for otherwise senselessly small amounts of financing - that Kickstarter is used only to give some visibility to the product/invention. Seen this way the 10,000-12,000 US$ (financed by crowd BTW) are more "advertising expenses" than anything else, and even if at the end Kickstarter gets (thanks to the higher level of founding contributions) double of that, it is still peanuts for the amount of visibility it provides.
- sitkack 9y agoNeeds lasers, invasive bugs are worse.
- fragsworth 9y agoAs a Roomba owner, I have to say that I'm not really impressed with their decision to make another product when their first one barely even works. > "Some 15 million of them are cleaning floors all over the planet, and they’re doing so reliably and affordably and autonomously enough that people keep on buying them" It is absolutely not "reliable". It's barely better than cleaning the floor myself. Some days, cleaning the floor myself would actually be easier, or ends up being what I have to do anyway. The number of issues I've run into with the damned thing is absurd and I feel like they should be fixing those before making a new product. I think people are for the most part getting tricked into buying these. They're not that great.
- jfries 9y agoThis is not Roomba creating a new product. Same inventor but different company.
- 205guy 9y agoFirst of all, it's not the same company as roomba (irobot). Sounds like you had issues with your roomba (you don't say what they were), but I don't see how that is related to being "tricked." My anecdata: we've had three since 2009, the earlier ones cleaned well but got dirt inside and eventually stopped working after 2 years. Our latest one bought 3 years ago seems better designed and more reliable, zero problems so far. Ours runs 2-3 times a week, mostly on wood and linoleum floors, and fills up with pet hair and dirt each time. We don't fiddle with the IR barriers, we just put a box in a doorway if we don't want it to roam, and we don't worry about docking, we just pick it up wherever it stops, empty it and dock it manually. Overall, it does a good job of getting most of the dirt in an area, but there is still the need to do a deeper clean once a month. Not affiliated, just a satisfied customer.
- secure 9y agoI’ve had a Roomba 780 cleaning my apartment daily since 2013. Issues I’ve encountered so far: 1. It occasionally doesn’t properly return to the home base, because it’s hard to find a good place for the home base where it can’t be moved/knocked over accidentally. This happens maybe once every 2 or 3 weeks, and is just a mild annoyance: you just need to carry the Roomba to its home base yourself. 2. After 3 years of usage, the battery died in such a way that it emptied rapidly enough for the Roomba to not be able to return to the home base. This was easily fixed by installing a new battery. I recently upgraded to the Roomba 980, and it seems to work better than the 780 — it cleans more quickly and returns to its home base more reliably. Also, less cleaning required due to a different brush design. Overall, I feel that I’m definitely getting my money’s worth out of the product, and it’s doing a great job at vacuuming. YMMV, but for me, it’s great.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoJoe Jones is one of my heros, I've still got my copy of "Robots: Inspiration to Implementation" that was such a great focal point for robotics in the 90's. Tilling seems like something that would be pretty challenging though. The whole "weed/not weed" thing has a lot of interesting questions around it. I always thought something that would keep your driveway and sidewalk clear of snow would be the next bit opportunity to automate.
- sgustard 9y agoIt's not clear from the article, but if I let this loose on my lawn, will it eliminate all the grass?
- jprissi 9y agoDoes anyone know why the wheels are inclined this way? I guess it has much more grip on the soil this way but is there something else?
- colordrops 9y agoIt's explained in the video. It scrubs the ground to prevent weed saplings from growing.
- jprissi 9y agoThanks, I didn't pay attention to the video the moment he said that.
- purpleidea 9y agoWhat stops someone from walking up to your garden and stealing your robot?
- ginko 9y agoThe law?
- visarga 9y agoThe fact that it isn't worth the effort to steal it? I mean, it's a nice demo, but it has to be better than that to be useful. They say it needs planks all around the work zone. That could be solved with a camera placed at some height. What if the soil has small ditches, as it is the practice when planting? It needs nice level soil to work, as well. It's not using computer vision, or not an advanced form of CV to distinguish good from bad plants. So it requires manual identification for each plant. In my opinion, it's not ready for prime time yet.
- paapi__gudiya 9y agoCCTV cameras, my dog, my grandma.
- martinmusio7 9y agoTertill solves a big issue. Lots of ppl want to have a weed free garden and don't have time/ don't want to pull out weeds all the time. But I do hope, though, that Tertill is just a very basic starting point. I can immediately think of 20-25 improvements.
- c3833174 9y agoThe main issue with just trimming is that sprouts coming up from roots of nearby trees have infinite energy and will get thicker every time you cut them. Not to mention that the worst weeds also spread horizontally
- Davidbrcz 9y agoHave a look at naio technologies (http://www.naio-technologies.com/en/ http://www.naio-technologies.com/en/). They make agricultural robots for easing farming. They have a bunch of robot to remove weed
- PerilousD 9y agoI can think of two very specific (for me) use case. Kill weeds in driveway pavers / patios where anything growing green is fair game and a Poison Ivy extreme prejudice terminator. I don't want to use pesticides since I have dogs and enough land to see the occasional rabbit, turtle, garden snake and I don't really want to harm them either.
- monochromatic 9y agoDoes Roundup actually hurt animals?
- devrandomguy 9y agoWhich animals has it been tested on, and where are the studies? Chemistry is presumed dangerous until proven safe.
- bluGill 9y agopubmed is your friend: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10854122/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10854122/ is a good example. "Multiple lifetime feeding studies have failed to demonstrate any tumorigenic potential for glyphosate" Roundup is about as safe is it comes - common vinegar is more toxic.
- Jemmeh 9y agoWell there's still a lot of back and forth on this from my understanding. Earlier this year some emails came to light from Monsanto regarding ghostwriting some research, aka they wrote an article and more or less had some scientists sign off on it as though they had done the research. They were also tipped off about the International Agency for Research on Cancer's determination for being a probable carcinogen so they were able to "prepare a public relations assault on the finding well in advance of its publication". Relevant Times Article: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roundup-safety-lawsuit.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roundup...
- Shivetya 9y agoIt feels like everyone gets their own Martian rover to me. still a world of solar powered helpers for menial tasks is interesting. with low enough costs eventually you won't care about how many you need.
- Twirrim 9y agoGah. I have to wonder who thought the ieee.org website design was a good idea. 2/3rds of the page taken up with not the article, but a whole bunch of noisy, visually intrusive links to everything and its mother? The article sort of squeezed in on the left 1/3rd seeming almost like an afterthought.
- EdwinHoksberg 9y agoThis is what it looks like on a 2560x1440 resolution monitor: https://i.imgur.com/08mYqWq.jpg https://i.imgur.com/08mYqWq.jpg Yes the small column on the left is the article.
- deepinthewoods 9y agoYou've both zoomed out in your browsers. Press CTRL+ a few times until you get back to 100%. Article takes up half the screen for me in Chrome+FF, 100%zoom @ 1440p.
- cjensen 9y agoIt's not zoomed. That's how it appears by default in Safari. It's insane.
- Twirrim 9y agoNo I haven't. Standard 1080p display, multiple machines, multiple browsers (Safari, Firefox & Chrome.) On all I get the same thing, the article is taking up barely a third of the page. http://imgur.com/8Ce68DO http://imgur.com/8Ce68DO http://imgur.com/5nnteHu http://imgur.com/5nnteHu To make it worse, those other three columns of links to other articles contain animated gifs, really dragging attention away from the actual content.
- chiph 9y agoThe "if it's small, it's a weed" is probably ok for a v1.0 product. They might want to talk to Toshiba - they bought IBM's retail Point-of-Sale business a few years ago, and they had a product called "Veggie Vision" [1] that identified produce at the cash register via a camera. Insert "Not Hotdog" joke here, but having a wifi connection to the cloud where heavy-duty weed classification software could be run would keep the device costs low. [1] http://researcher.watson.ibm.com/researcher/view_group.php?id=2021 http://researcher.watson.ibm.com/researcher/view_group.php?i...
- jaclaz 9y ago>Insert "Not Hotdog" joke here, but having a wifi connection to the cloud where heavy-duty weed classification software could be run would keep the device costs low. Actually I would like to insert here that time the connection was down for half an hour and the thingy eradicated all aunt Julia's plants, and it's not a joke (at least according to aunt Julia, who didn't laugh at all).
- macawfish 9y agoThis is ridiculous but I'd rather see people going this route than spraying glyphosate or some other poison. That said, the root of this is a dangerous kind of hubris. The idea of weeds is a tragic fallacy. There are some "weeds" that are selling for up to $15/lb (nettles, lambs quarter). Most weeds are beneficial for cooking and herbal medicine. And most any weed can have some kind of beneficial role in the garden. Same thing goes for "pests". One plant's pest is another plant's companion. Yet people are all but obsessed with exterminating misunderstood creatures from their local ecosystems. In my view, this robot is not so far off in the grand scheme of things from a robot that goes around killing other animals and even people, based on shallow, superficial misunderstandings of another being's potential. I wish as much engineering effort went into understanding as it does into stuff like this.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoLets not get hyperbolic - folks pull plants for a local monoculture of beneficial botany. That's all. Its not a skynet extermination program or anything. Heck, I pull volunteer flowers from my flower bed if they don't jibe with this years' layout. Its not about what's a 'weed'. Its about what I want in this here bed, and what I want in that one over there.
- macawfish 9y agoOn one hand, I feel you. Actually, I think a "weeding robot", programmed well, is a much better alternative to the chemical/GMO program. But weeding as an act of moderate human selection isn't what irritates me. It's peoples' blind acceptance of an entire false taxonomy of "good" vs "bad" plants/organisms. It's dualistic and dangerous in the long run. It's stupidity posed as common sense. It's a kind of eugenics that's directed not just at humans but at entire ecologies. Right now what Monsanto is doing with chemical resistant plants is unconscionable. The glyphosate scheme is obscene. It's worse than some skynet extermination program. In the midst of a massive loss of the earth's sustaining biodiversity, we have unchecked corporate powers playing out obscene world domination plans. The stakes are too high. Why do people feel so nonchalant about the Roundup scheme? Why do we eat their corn? Cause they're only killing weeds. There's a massive extinction happening right now. What are we doing? Programming robots to decrease biodiversity.
- trhway 9y agoscale it up a bit and drop a bunch of them in Middle East to weed out terrorists.
- cmurf 9y agoSeems like insects and rabbits are a bigger problem for the typical backyard gardener than weeds. So if the robot has insect and rabbit shooing modes, maybe...
- tertillpower 9y agoI like this robot. It's cute