10 ms·
Amazon engineer will let strangers manage his $50,000 stock portfolio 'forever'
- arikr 9y ago> Its 0.4 percent return slightly outperformed the 0.2 percent rise in the S&P 500 since its launch on May 30. Amusing excerpt. Highly relevant, of course.
- dsacco 9y agoOne of my favorite things about this story is the way it discretely slides an association between "Amazon engineer" and "has $50k to let go of 'forever' on a social experiment" across the table to the audience. That's the real message that's going to be received by a large amount of the population reading this story as it makes the rounds on outlets like CNBC.
- merkaloid 9y agoHe's probably not just any engineer because if you actually check the stream it looks like it is viral marketing for "robinhood.com"
- willtheperson 9y agoThis is probably it. I personally signed up for Robinhood based on this project. I'm already interested in stock trading though so it wasn't that big of a commitment from me but they do have a nice App and signup process compared to other financial trading outfits I've used.
- MichaelGG 9y agoYeah, Robinhood is mentioned quite a bit on his site, including a sign up referral link. Seems like their referral program gives you $10 for each signup. Also he says if it hits $25K, then the game is over. So it's only $25K at real risk, not $50K. (True, the stocks could fall further before he liquidates.)
- hbosch 9y agoAlso: anyone have an idea as to what regulations he is citing when he says if it drops below 50% he has to close the account? Is that a Robinhood thing, or an equities trading thing? As far as I know, there is no regulation limiting how much a person can lose on the market... Makes me wonder if perhaps his account balance is $25k personal, and $25k matched by Robinhood for the stunt.
- adt2bt 9y agoHe'll just cut the stream<->robinhood connection, there's nothing from robinhood on down that will save his $25k.
- stockstream 9y agoActually, there kind of is. It will stop you from placing trades if you daytrade with less than that. Your account will be suspended. https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/217072366-Pattern-Day-Trading https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/217072366-Pa...
- dragonwriter 9y agoStopping you from trading on the account doesn't protect the value in the account (and makes it harder for you to take action that would protect it, too!)
- abofh 9y agoTypically you're forbidden from increasing your equity loan on a margin call - closes are completely fine (So you can buy shorts, or sell longs, but the inverse is against the rules). I've never used robinhood, but I've been declared a PDT before.
- vxNsr 9y agoI think you need $25k to be a day trader on Robinhood. So if it drops below that he can't trade the same way he would unless he adds more cash which I guess he isn't prepared to do.
- wyldfire 9y agoFor folks playing at home and wondering "What is Robinhood?" From [1] > Robinhood is a stock brokerage that allows customers to buy and sell U.S. listed stocks and ETFs with $0 commission. ... we are able to maintain a lean bottom-line and pass the savings along to you, the customer ... Robinhood is an SEC registered broker-dealer and member of FINRA & SIPC. [1] https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/202844869-About-Robinhood https://support.robinhood.com/hc/en-us/articles/202844869-Ab...
- spoonie 9y agoDon't waste your money and time trading individual stocks. Invest for your future with dollar-cost-averaging and buying ALL the stocks (AKA a diversified index-tracking fund with very low fees (less than 0.1%/year)).
- dawnerd 9y agoI think so too. When it first launched I signed up for robinhood and tossed just 100 bucks to see how it worked. App needs a lot of work to be useful so I doubt I'll throw any more money at it. On the plus side, I am up ~4%
- stockstream 9y agoStockStream was launched independent of Robinhood. I really like their platform, so am glad to include links to their site.
- mabbo 9y agoHe totally is just some random guy. I know this, because I worked with him for a few years in Amazon Fulfillment. Just found out today that it was him that made this project (haven't talked to him in a while).
- abandonliberty 9y agouser: mabbo created: 1527 days ago karma: 6074 Active, long-standing account. If you're a sockpuppet you're a damned good one. :) Out of curiosity, how significant is 50K to this guy?
- Pica_soO 9y agoToy money, i guess. Its suprising who is a millionair and who isnt. In a car factory where my brother works, one of the workers, financing a house with his money and then houses with money from the house, became a millionaire without anyone in the above layer noticing. So if he gets chewed out by one of his fore-masters or executives, they are - not knowing- chewing out somebody who could quit any time.
- Taek 9y agoAll it takes is 10-20 years of saving 30+% of your income. Most people balk at that savings rate, but anything white collar pays enough to have that sort of savings if you are willing to life a more modest lifestyle than your socioeconomic peers. 10 years later the interest you earn on it will be more than the 30% you are putting in.
- Pica_soO 9y agoIt helps if you have entertainment/activitys that are solitary, cheap and infinite. Games, books, whatever occupy you without draining resources.
- user5994461 9y agoThat was automatic for most people not so long ago, at the time house were bought on 10-20 years mortgages.
- encoderer 9y ago$50k in RSUs annually is a decent target for a mid-level engineer (non-management). With overlap of grants after the first year and price appreciation of the stock, you can imagine how this can grow. That said, I think Amazon has some unfriendly vesting terms compared to the SFBA-based companies I'm more familiar with.
- cbhl 9y agoIs this person a Twitch engineer? That's kind of a subset of Amazon engineer...
- alttab 9y agoBased on information, I'd argue Michael Roberts isn't his real name so we will never know.
- stockstream 9y agoNope. It actually is my real name.
- wellsjohnston 9y agoOh snap.
- rsync 9y agoDid you also win the putnam ?
- alttab 9y agoAwesome, which org?
- alttab 9y agoAh - you just don't work at Amazon anymore.
- ryandrake 9y agoThat was my first question too. What "engineer" has $50K sitting around to practically throw away? Then I remember, when it comes to tech reporting, "engineer" could mean anything on the spectrum between "7th code monkey from the left" to "CTO".
- nandemo 9y agoI think y'all are overestimating the risk. He isn't throwing it away. He's mentioned here that it's max 1 trade of 1 share every 5min. The initial portfolio is very diversified, so barring a concerted attack this experiment's returns likely won't be much different from a random actively managed mutual fund -- with the advantage of having no management fees and no trading fees either. And he can stop the experiment any time.
- hartator 9y agoEverytime you buy and sell a stock even if the stock didn't move and no fee, you loose at least 0.01 usd per share because of the spread. Ie. Apple trades 123.45 to buy and 123.44 to sell.
- nandemo 9y agoRight (not sure why you're downvoted). I don't think the spread will have a large effect though, for such infrequent trading.
- dsacco 9y agoI think you misunderstood my point. I'm not at all surprised that he has $50k to do this with as an engineer (I could do the same). Engineers, as a class of people who work at companies like Amazon, are very well paid. I was more commenting that many other people outside the industry are going to become familiar with this idea on a somewhat more visceral level now that it's at the point that CNBC is talking about it. As an aside, you might be surprised at how many of those "seventh code monkey from the left" are clearing over $200k per year at Amazon. The last time I spoke to people I know at Google/Facebook I was hearing total annual compensation packages of about $250k for senior level in NY and CA. If you don't have a family and aren't growing your spending habits to match your pocket you can easily have that much extra cash lying around (NB I hesitate to use words like "easily" because people tend to have an indignant reaction, but that doesn't really alter my point).
- morley 9y agoI'm really curious what his streaming software looks like. I've always been interested in how stream video gets composited and what tools are available, but I'm too lazy to look into it.
- bendauphinee 9y agoX-Split is the go-to solution for most streamers these days.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoWhy do so many people use XSplit over OBS? OBS is free and the featureset is (or was) more than a match.
- azeirah 9y agoXSplit markets actively, OBS not really, if at all.
- sorkin2 9y agoReally hasn't been in years. I've not even heard of anyone using it in over a year. But I mostly speak with people who stream video games.
- r1ch 9y agoOBS Studio is the most popular software right now for Twitch live streams. It's open source and under active development. https://obsproject.com/ https://obsproject.com/ (Disclaimer: I'm one of the developers)
- stockstream 9y agoYep, I use OBS. Its awesome, thanks for all your hard work on it!
- ohashi 9y agoThanks for working on OBS, it's awesome :)
- jimmcslim 9y agoWould an infinite number of monkeys making an infinite number of trades find proof of Fama's Efficient Market Hypothesis?
- passivepinetree 9y agoTwitch Plays Pokémon and other such games tended to be highly disorganized and take forever to accomplish basic tasks. I wonder if that'll be the case here, and if so, whether that means better or worse investing.
- matty22 9y agoI guess it might depend on what timeline you're looking at? Generally, a more hands off approach to investing is better in the long run, so over the long run perhaps highly disorganized and taking forever to accomplish basic tasks would make for better investing?
- gipp 9y agoVideo games require relatively long sequences of coordinated actions to accomplish anything, though. In trading, every action is fairly self-contained in a few important ways, e.g. the ordering of actions doesn't matter much.
- jmcgough 9y agoIt's a much smaller group of people in this case, so my guess is that the people who'll stick around are people who already do trading and are somewhat knowledgable. There have been other x plays streams with a small number of viewers that did pretty well at slowly beating their games. When you have thousands of people like TPP did, you attract trolls who spam "down9" ;)
- MichaelGG 9y agoPretty easy: "The game is divided into voting rounds, each lasting 5 minutes. Every 5 minutes the top buy or sell command will be executed and one share will be bought or sold. You may only vote once per round." https://www.twitch.tv/stockstream https://www.twitch.tv/stockstream Buying or selling a share is basically atomic, so there's no coordination needed apart from the overall portfolio. Looking at the portfolio, http://stockstream.live/portfolio.html http://stockstream.live/portfolio.html , most positions are just a few shares.
- havella 9y agoMaybe this is the beginning of "Twitch Trading". If ppl like seeing other ppl playing video games, trading stocks/futures could find an audience. The question is what would be the incentive for a competent trader/algo to let ppl see it's trades.
- brahmwg 9y agoAs far as I know eToro already allows users to copy other traders strategies. The incentive for the trader to allow others to copy their strategy is likely some % gain based on the number of copyers, so if you develop a successful trading strategy and allow others to profit off it, you also profit. Just a hunch.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hkmurakami 9y agoPossibly general solicitation of funds from retail investors. But I agree with you that if you're any good, you're not going to be asking retail for money, you're heading straight to UHNW individuals and whatnot.
- gricardo99 9y agowhat would be interesting though, but much more of a niche, would be if some successful quant traders did an in-depth review of some "alpha" or strategy they ran some time ago, which is no longer profitable. They could discuss their tools, analysis , trading metrics, performance, and some discussion of why the strategy stopped working. It would give a good window into the work-flow and skills required to do this successfully. Even if it's retrospective, going back a few years.
- rfrank 9y agoA friend of mine kinda does this, a lot of the content on his site is comparable to what you're describing. http://www.verticalsolutions.com/papers.html http://www.verticalsolutions.com/papers.html
- 9y ago
- sillysaurus3 9y agoFor realtime stats: http://stockstream.live/portfolio.html http://stockstream.live/portfolio.html Looks like they're down $577.18 so far. Jebaited
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI wonder how they got one share of ZNGA for $0
- ENTP 9y agoI dunno, but the infitity% return is awesome.
- stockstream 9y agoSome shares were gifted for free by Robinhood for referrals.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThanks for that tidbit. What was second place, two shares of Zynga? :-)
- jsmthrowaway 9y agoOne share of Snap, probably.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoPretty much defines a "blind trust" :-). I find the experiment pretty interesting, how many people will try to make him go to zero? How many will want to make the value higher? If you were leveraging a pump and dump house how does that work? And home much can you trade at once? (all would seem to be a silly amount, but it has to be enough to make reasonable trades) And how do you know it is actually real money? We used to do office stock pools where folks would start the month with "$100,000" and got two trades a day, one at noon and one when the market closed (easy to do on the west coast) at the end of the month the one with the most "money" would "win". It was fun and taught me a lot about market volatility (and that I would suck as a day trader :-)) but there was no actual requirement for money to actually trade hands. And even at $50,000 you're not buying or selling enough to move most stocks.
- stockstream 9y ago>And home much can you trade at once? As of current rules, you can only make one trade of one share every five minutes. I will likely change and tweak these rules over time.
- lr4444lr 9y agoThe question that really bakes my noodle is, what if the people who try to make him go to zero collectively make his value higher? ;-)
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoI've come across multiple papers investigating stock trading strategies, where they mentioned little or no effect for the actual strategy, but a significant positive effect for the opposite strategy.
- likelynew 9y agoIf people knows how to make it go down, then they can easily earn from that.
- arwhatever 9y agoIs he going to support the software integration piece of this, forever?
- stockstream 9y agoYes
- quickthrower 9y agoPresumably he is mortal. He needs to hand the chocolate factory down to a youngster at some point.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hammock 9y agoScreaming Eagles are an arena football team that allows the fans to call the plays. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/17/sports/football/indoor-football-league-screaming-eagles.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/17/sports/football/indoor-fo...
- kuldeep_kap 9y agoDoes anyone know how is this implemented? Is there some stock trading API? He also talks about some regulation at the end. Does the entity needs to be setup legally in a certain way?
- oh_sigh 9y agoYes...presumably many companies offer it, but it may not get top billing because it isn't exactly a widescale consumer product. Here's the one I use, which has great rates: https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=5041 https://www.interactivebrokers.com/en/index.php?f=5041
- kuldeep_kap 9y agothanks!
- stockstream 9y agoI found a bit of code on github to access the robinhood api. That bit was actually not too difficult to implement. The regulation bit not special, just a restriction on what trades are allowed.
- kuldeep_kap 9y agoha nice! I didnt know robinhood api was public. Any pointers? Did you set it up as some formal entity or just through your personal account? Any pointers to learn about the restrictions. I'd love to so some interesting apps myself. Update: I think i found it - https://github.com/sanko/Robinhood https://github.com/sanko/Robinhood . Thanks!
- CryoLogic 9y agoI wonder why the Amazon engineer part is relevant?
- grahamperich 9y agoit's not, it just gets the writer more clicks on his/her headline
- luvandp3ace 9y agoYou need a hook. Especially when robinhood is trying to generate some viral growth.
- quickthrower 9y agoSingle mom, 24 would have been better.
- grahamperich 9y agoOh, yeah I agree! I didn't mean to sound like I was knocking it. Good journalists know they need an enticing title
- stockstream 9y agoHey everyone! Glad to see you're all enjoying the project. I'd be glad to answer any questions you have. Let me know!
- matt_wulfeck 9y agoHow much money do you actually have?
- stockstream 9y agoHeh, well I definitely don't consider myself to be super wealthy. $50k is not a small amount for me, but not the end of the world if I lose half.
- artursapek 9y agoThe way your stream works I can't imagine you would lose that much, since the buys are in such small lots. There'd have to be a way for the users to make you go all in on a volatile stock to see those kinds of losses (or access to a sharper knife like options). Anyway, it's an interesting experiment. Very popular over at /r/wallstreetbets.
- 1337biz 9y agoWas looking through the comments to find a fellow yachting club member. Avast Matey!
- mabbo 9y agoWait, wait, don't I know you? You worked in AFT Picking, right?
- stockstream 9y agoAh yeah, hey, how's it going? I remember you from the YYZ office.
- martin_hnuid 9y agoDoes Robinhood offer an API?
- WalterBright 9y agoBrokerage fees on each transaction may quickly eat up his principle.
- pgodzin 9y agoRobinhood doesn't have transaction fees
- WalterBright 9y agoI see, you're right. But there's the spread between the bid and ask prices, which will grind away at your profits if you rapidly trade.
- quickthrower 9y agoDejavu! I had this exact same conversation on the last thread about this topic. Different account though.
- crimsonalucard 9y agoI bet he can beat 50% of all hedge fund managers.
- MetaMonk 9y agoTwitch plays NASDAQ
- Pica_soO 9y agoBuy in a fractal denial pattern area near the New Coastline. Global Warming. Rising Sea-levels. Human stupidity. Profit. Your grandchildren will be grateful. Or spoiled brats.
- rizwank 9y agoFractal Denial? This is a new term to me... and the #1 link for Fractal Denial on Google is your post :)
- Pica_soO 9y agoIts basically patent- trolling with ground. You buy enough to stop any construction process, dead in the water due to legal processes. Now you can extort from any company going there, wanting to build something the money for the little area you sell + the money it would cost to restart construction elsewhere - 1$ + the legal fees saved by not going to court. ProTip: You might want to share the wealth with local legislators later upon, to avoid having zoning-laws changed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gcb0 9y agois forever in quotes because it implies "until 4chan gets here"?
- petraeus 9y agoIts 50k of advertising for robinhood, which is peanuts
- pebo 9y agoI bet it'll just track the s&p 500