8 ms·
A reality check for virtual headsets
- davnicwil 9y agoI was at Facebook's F8 conference this year and to say they are pushing hard on VR is an understatement. Personally, I find VR and its potential applications very intriguing and I welcome this, but it all still feels.. I don't know.. very much top down and too early. I'm not sure if it's consumers driving demand for this, or the industry desperately looking for the 'next' platform 10 years on from the iPhone. In contrast, it feels like the whole mobile app paradigm was a more emergent trend that rose from the hardware getting better and it being an 'obvious' thing to do with software on that hardware. Like, smartphones weren't designed specifically with apps in mind, but they emerged as a phenomenon naturally, in response to demand. But maybe that's just hindsight talking, maybe it too was ultimately pushed from the top down by companies building apps and promoting them. Hard to say I guess. If any company can push VR into the mainstream, or at least accelerate the process, Facebook has to be one of the best positioned, and I hope it works. I just wonder if the hardware doesn't need to get dramatically (5 years) better before it becomes obvious that ordinary people will want to incorporate it into their daiy routine (and then, possibly more in AR form than VR form) - indeed, to be fair, at F8 a very similar message was delivered in some talks.
- aracari 9y ago> to say they are pushing hard on VR is an understatement. Well they do own Oculus, so they have a vested interest in making sure VR succeeds, whether it is a demand or not.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pishpash 9y agoThe issue is at the content side. 360 videos may give it a good push. That's user created content so it doesn't rely on studios like the 3D TV.
- was_boring 9y ago360 videos are a rather poor experience (currently). You cannot tell narrative content on them because you cannot control the view like you can with movies or shows. So what you are limited to is static scenery type of experiences.
- icebraining 9y agoTheater has survived for thousands of years without being able to control the view like you can with movies or shows. In terms of VR, I think the shark demo of PSVR already shows more than static scenery type of experiences can made.
- bonesss 9y agoTheater is almost exclusively carried out with pre-determined views: the audiences seating arrangements. Motion on stage is used to guide attention and frame the narrative. The form of presentation impacts blocking and scene-changes. Theater in the round would result in different staging than a traditional auditorium, for example. A 360 degree movie is essentially the inverse of the theater experience. Instead of fixed locations pointing towards the action, the viewer is in the center of the world with potential for action all around.
- icebraining 9y agoTheater is much more than the stereotypical dark square room. Round arenas, street performances, they're pretty common. And even immersive plays are being done in many places nowadays. People will pay attention to what's happening, there's no need to worry too much about someone simply ignoring the action. Besides, even casual YouTubers do positional sound nowadays, which can be used to "lead" the spectator.
- jpindar 9y agoDo you play modern computer games? There are "live" narrative sections in many games now. Cut scenes don't freeze the player anymore. You can turn around and stare at the scenery if you want to. In some cases the story keeps happening when you aren't watching, in some the action pauses at strategic moments and waits for you.
- prostoalex 9y agoThe chicken-and-egg problem with VR is numbers and quality content. So far the sales numbers of VR headsets to consumers did not convince major developers to make a major push. As a result, 95% of Steam VR titles are versions "My First Unity VR Project". You'd think that device manufacturers would then subsidize content development to differentiate, but that didn't seem to pan out either http://variety.com/2017/digital/news/oculus-story-studio-shutting-down-1202409809/ http://variety.com/2017/digital/news/oculus-story-studio-shu...
- deweller 9y agoVR was just overhyped early. It will catch on. Keep in mind that these are all 1st generation products. When an immersive VR system comes with a wireless headset, costs less than $500 and doesn't require 30 square feet of space, then it will begin to take off. Remember the first iPod? We are going to be in this early adopter phase until the technology matures. VR is not 3D TV. People who use immersive VR actually like it. 3D TV was annoying to most people after the novelty wore off.
- pishpash 9y agoLet me know when headsets look like accessories, like the iPod did. Otherwise it's more apt to compare to Glass.
- Animats 9y agoThat was a PR masterpiece - making iDweebs, those silly earbud things with wires, cool.
- tpeo 9y agoThese aren't 1st generation products. There has already been a VR craze, back in the 1990s.
- whicks 9y agoThe VR devices that are out today are incomparable with the devices of the "VR craze" of the 1990s.
- tpeo 9y agoWell, I didn't say they were comparable. I just sort of pointed out they existed. Current generation video game consoles are also incomparable to Pong. But hey, that's the difference between 1st and 8th generation consoles.
- calafrax 9y agoThey are much better but they are still basically the same designs as the late 90's. A lot of things have improved but most of the problems are things that were recognized before and still aren't perfect. They still need to get smaller, lighter, higher resolution, faster refresh rate, 4-8X GPU power, and wireless, but in another decade they should be awesome.
- JauntTrooper 9y agoI still remember when the original Nintendo came out in 1988. It was $149 for the system, the light gun + Mario Brothers and Duck Hunt. ($320 in today's dollars). I don't think the NES would have succeeded as much as it did were it not for the Mario Brothers + Duck Hunt bundle. The light gun turned out to be a gimmick, but at the time it felt like such a huge technological leap over Atari, and Duck Hunt was the way to show it off. VR needs a Duck Hunt + Mario Brothers. I think Nintendo gets this. Wii had Wii Sports, the Nintendo Switch has Zelda: Breath of the Wild. They're more than just games, they're brands that through their ubiquity generate cultural capital for the platform.
- deweller 9y agoI think part of the magic with the NES was that you could plug it into your TV and it would just work. I can only use a Vive if I have a high powered gaming computer in a place conducive to gaming.
- 52-6F-62 9y agoBingo! You highlighted two major barriers of entry for the larger market: 1. Initial Cost 2. Technological knowledge required (to inform the purchase and to set it up) Another point adding to the cost is that VR games of any quality [or by larger studios with resources for quality development] are new games, and as such usually run around 60 to 100 dollars each. And they don't just come on a disk you pop in and play. Sidenote: Playstation VR, which is substantially easier to set up -- the headset is more expensive than the console at this stage. If you get the starter bundle it's almost 3x the cost of the console. To many people, it's outrageous. And the argument would likely follow, "there just aren't that many good games for VR" or "I just bought a new 4k tv, why would I buy that _now_". (At least this is what I've heard so far)
- arielweisberg 9y agoI haven't seen a single 100$ game. Maybe this is a Playstation specific thing? VR games tend to go for less than 60$ right now. Initially people tried to pass them off at 60$, but no one was having it. If you wait for the several times yearly sales you pay less even less than 40-50$ Playstation VR seems like a terrible deal at this point with the Rift price drops and deals. Most of the cost of a VR capable PC with a Rift with vastly inferior experience.
- tekism 9y agoMr Williams, a 32-year-old former marine, was playing “Sprint Vector”, a VR running game: players swing hand-held controllers to simulate motion. Though he has been standing in one place, his brain believes he has just run for several miles. I wonder if anyone has tried using this tech to somehow trick the body into activating what happens when one actually goes running? Can I get a workout by just watching myself run in this VR world???
- phinnaeus 9y ago"You said it wasn't real" "The mind makes it real"
- glangdale 9y agoThere are some weird results in exercise science related to this. For example, if you perform exercises only on one side, unilateral strength on the other side improves (something that seems like a pointless novelty until you consider training while injured). There's a huge amount of strength that relates to 'neural' factors. Conversely, apparently elevated heart rate due to gaming does not improve aerobic fitness. So I'm thinking that, broadly, there will be no such thing as a free lunch here (as per usual).
- recursive 9y agoI highly doubt it. At least not more of a workout than you get from just bouncing in one place, which is more than a lot of people get.
- agar 9y agoThe hardware companies investing in VR understand that this is the beginning of a new market, and success will take a long time (e.g., see Zuckerberg's statements during investor calls). They also recognize that initial efforts like today's headsets are required V1's to begin the technical evolution that will result in a mass-market product. To look at today's initial products and call the industry dead, or disappointing, is like looking at an MVP app release and deciding that an entire market does not exist because the initial solution is not perfect. This type of contrarianism is seductive, and often results in many clicks for the media and the reinforcement of curmudgeonly opinions by those with unrealistic expectations for short-term change (and often who underestimate long-term impacts). But it's important to evaluate today's VR with the same eyes as when looking at an MVP: does it meet its goals? Does it provide value? Does it show potential if developed further? Is there a product-market fit? The answer to all of the above is a resounding "yes." Try it if you haven't. VR and AR have the potential to be truly revolutionary technologies. Yes, there is some distance to the goal, but it's eminently achievable - if the tech is not killed off by mis-set expectations, tribalism, paranoia, pessimism, and negativity.
- tptacek 9y agoThe problem with this rebuttal is there's no argument you can't apply it to. Try making it falsifiable. The first Rift Dev Kits landed in 2013. At what point can we look at uptake of these products and conclude that they're not catching on? I have no trouble with the argument that 2017 is too early. But what year won't be too early? 2020? As for investors, it's important to remember that when you're swinging at a pitch, it's no more productive to swing too early than to swing too late. They're both strikes.
- DenisM 9y agoWhat about pocketable computers? They have been envisioned decades before they became possible and then usable. It wouldn't have served any purpose to have designated an expiry data on the whole idea back in seventies. VR may take 4 year or 40 years to mature, or it may never take off at all, it's not something we can judge either way.
- hoodoof 9y agoVR needs good software and the reality is that it is just not there yet. If it does not come by the end of this year there will be a problem. I think it will happen though for the one reason that Bethesda is delivering Doom, Fallout 4 and Skyrim for Sony PS4 VR for this Christmas. That will give Sony a big reason to keep yelling about PS4 VR and will restore the faith of people like me who bought a VR headset early that is now just sitting there waiting for good software to use it with. The next challenge facing vR beyond that point is whether the three titles mentioned above deliver on the promise of VR - if they do not then VR is finished, at least for this round of enthusiasm about the idea.
- TuringTest 9y agoDoom, Fallout and Skyrim seem like precisely the wrong games to target for VR, unless they remake them completely to use instant teleportation instead of walking. FPS in VR only works from a static standing point, otherwise the VR sickness kicks in really fast.
- Animats 9y agoI've been saying for some time that VR is the next 3D TV. I've tried VR systems from Jaron Lanier's original rig with two SGI workstations in the 1980s to the HTC Vibe. Technically, there's been plenty of progress. The lag problem has been fixed. The resolution is better. The headgear is still clunky. There's still no killer app. You can play FPS games. Works fine, for people who like shooters. You can run roller coaster sims. Works fine, gets boring fast. You can visit Second Life. Kind of cool, if you like SL. You can visit High Fidelity, which is a higher-res Second Life where nothing is going on. Boring. (Worse, the High Fidelity CEO is now talking about "sovereign identity on the blockchain". If one branch of hype isn't working, pivot to another.) VR conferencing? Working in High Fidelity and Second Life now. HF even has gaze tracking and facial gesture capture. In the early days of VR, there was hope that VR would provide a more natural interface to CAD programs. Autodesk put effort into VR to try to make that work. Turned out that trying to do precision work in VR is not only difficult, but really tiring. It's all been built, and nobody came. Best Buy is removing the Oculus Rift demo stations from stores due to lack of interest.
- theptip 9y agoAre you considering AR as a separate concern, or do you consider that one doomed to mediocrity as well? Personally I think that features like virtual workspaces (e.g. multi-monitor displays / overlays) and HUDs (e.g. vehicle navigation) are going to be game-changing outside of the entertainment industry, when the headset tech gets to where it needs to be; this will probably be better implemented as an AR overlay (a la Hololens) than full VR.
- joshlemer 9y agoI agree, I can't wait until we're all in VR desktop environments, which will I think open up really interesting new ways of personal computing and working. Take for example software development. It has huge potential to improve how efficiently we can work together remotely. It is often difficult to communicate very well with remote team members, and to develop a rapport with them. But imagine if you could be pair programming right beside them, in a VR setting, pointing to some code in a floating IDE or something, and explaining to them how it works. Or you could pull up a virtual "white board" and start drawing maybe. It could also go a long way to making work more comfortable. With your computer being just a VR headset, it would be easy to work in a laid back recliner, standing in your office, or even lying down.
- SwellJoe 9y agoIt's always fun to watch media before a thing explodes in popularity and becomes part of everyday life; during that period when the thing still sucks, but a lot of smart people are working on it because they see some incredible potential. I'm not sure that VR will be one of those things, but I'm pretty confident of it. I recently got a VR headset, one of the cheapo kind that you stick your phone in, just to try it out. It's pretty much amazing. I mean, it's stupid, all the games and apps are stupid, all the videos are stupid, interaction is clumsy, almost everything I try to use shifts steadily to the left until I can't see anything anymore without turning my head, and eventually turning my whole body around to keep up with the shift, and all around it just barely works at all. But, it's still amazing. That tells me something really big is going to happen; the Internet started out the same way. It was stupid. You could watch a video, if it was 1/10th the screen size, buffered for several minutes, and you didn't need it to look very good. Regular old television was a million times better. I feel like we're at that same point right now with VR. It all sucks right now (probably because I have a cheapo VR headset that uses my phone and my phone isn't well-supported by the VR players, but it was cheap), but we're only a year or so into the "anyone can afford it" phase. Think how many years it took for the tech to use the full potential of the Internet took to make it into the majority of homes. I think we're still way too early to tell how VR is gonna play out, but when I use it, I feel a bit of that old "OMG, this is gonna be huge in ways I can't predict" feeling the Internet gave me the first time I logged on.
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoI mean, it's stupid, all the games and apps are stupid, all the videos are stupid, interaction is clumsy, almost everything I try to use shifts steadily to the left until I can't see anything anymore without turning my head, and eventually turning my whole body around to keep up with the shift, and all around it just barely works at all. But, it's still amazing. This sums it up perfectly.
- anton69 9y agoI don't see this mentioned too often in the critique of vr, but I wonder if the isolation of putting on a headset is another barrier for adoption. While the isolation could be an advantage on something like an airplane or even an open office, I just don't feel like disconnecting that much from reality when in the comfort of my own home.
- flavio81 9y agoKiller app + low price + user friendliness = mass-market success. VR still doesn't have the three variables. But it's getting really close!
- kazinator 9y agoI tried a VR demo a few months ago. It was fantastic! This stuff has come a long way. It tracks every slightest movement of your head and controllers. The graphics and sound will immerse you in a world you will believe is real. Very nice gaming is possible, as well as recreation. People could visit fantastic virtual worlds just to be somewhere else and feel good; a kind of therapy, if you will. I don't understand what these insipid nay-saying wankers are blabbing about.
- icebraining 9y agoI don't know. I tried the PSVR, found it very cool (significantly better and more immersible than I thought), yet I wouldn't buy one. A good demo doesn't make for a good product.
- TuringTest 9y agoThe HTC Vive feels much better than the PSVR. The room-scale tracking and "grappling" hand controls really add to the experience. IMHO walking around is the real thing in VR; games not directly designed with this in mind are not exploiting the unique possibilities of the medium.
- freekh 9y agoWhat I imagined VR will give, once the headsets and input devices have been iterated on, is a way to have a true workspace environment on the move.
- yoz-y 9y agoI wonder how far would screen/projection technology had to go. I'd love to have an AR headset that would allow me to summon a huge screen in front of me, however I want that screen to have the same DPI as my computer.
- rjvs 9y agoVR might take a while to become a viable mainstream entertainment medium but there are sizeable niches that can sustain businesses as development catches up with the hype. Location-based entertainment, hardcore home VR games and enterprise products all seem to be reasonably solid markets, even if they don't scale up to the dizzying heights some expect them to reach. We have a design meeting and visualisation tool for engineers and desginers to discuss projects with their management, clients and other domain experts. This has significant benefit for our customers and it will not go away anytime soon. Perhaps the hype cycle will cause the current HMD manufacturers to exit the market and VR will retreat to these niches but it's definitely not going away.
- onetokeoverthe 9y agoDoes anyone have links to Mckinsey/KPMG* type studies (in pdf format) which forecast VR adoption and segment usage by type? *Or anyone "authoritative".
- cortexio 9y agoWOW! WTF! An actual article that shows a view based on reality and data. It's been a while since i've read one of those. I got so used to reading shitty sponsored content on HN. gj whomever the author is.
- reacweb 9y ago15 years ago, the foreseen path was adoption of 3D TV then replacement of TV by headsets. 3D TV does not exist anymore and people are watching movies on their phone. IMHO, the future is the replacement of the screen of smartphones by glasses with AR. The phone will be in my pocket with my hand and the glasses will be near my eye, ear and mouth.
- Hasknewbie 9y agoI'm on the "will flop like 3D TV" bandwagon, but for another reason than just the lack of killer app and high price. I think a lot of faithful are just trying to wish away a significant barrier to entry: motion sickness. I know lowering the lag reduces this issue, but it does not completely solve it. I have a friend who has an interest in VR so he tried the various models being demoed in shopping malls when he could find them in the US and the EU. Always the same problem: motion sickness. So he would ask the people managing the demo kits and would usually get the same answer, a bit more than 50% of the people who try have that same problem. Then a few months ago I came across an article that was essentially raising the same point (can't source it, sorry. The number they gave was closer to 40%). So basically it seems about half of the target audience asked to shell out a small fortune will have "puking on the carpet" as their most memorable VR moment... Not really a recipe for success.
- ryandamm 9y agoThat's not a separate point from "lack of a killer app" -- most motion sickness is a result of bad content, that violates rules of good perceptual design.
- DiThi 9y agoI'm guessing your friend tried the PSVR or Oculus Rift with heavy use of a controller while seated. Having tracked hands, moving around (instead of turning with a controller) and using teleport (or just room scale 1:1 movement) reduces the percent of dizzy people to zero. If you use slow artificial locomotion with comfort features (e.g. FoV reduction), that number is about 5%.
- Hasknewbie 9y agoI am aware that these prevent nausea or dizziness from happening, but what does it say about the viability of the medium if all of its content must have that kind of constraints? VR allows experiencing so-called 'presence', except in practice said presence must not match anything else than that of your actual body at that moment. We end up quite far removed from the "freely explore virtual worlds" that VR is marketing.
- sbmassey 9y agoI read, when they were pushing 3D TV, that some 10-15% of the population don't have 3D perception for one reason or another, and therefore don't get the immersive experience. Personally, being in that category, I don't get much from these headsets beyond feeling that there is an image in front of my eye that moves with my head, which is more annoying than anything. The AR thing sounds potentially useful though.