8 ms·
What bothers me more than people designing inaccessable sites is their excuse of "well, why put extra money and effort into catering to such a small segment of
by falcolas 9y ago
What bothers me more than people designing inaccessable sites is their excuse of "well, why put extra money and effort into catering to such a small segment of the population?"
Videos released without captions are OK, because "they're free!" Websites without Aria tags are OK, because "screen readers just need to get better." Low contrast fonts are OK, because "my design won't work with different font colors."
Everyone who doesn't die in their prime of life will eventually be disabled in some fashion; but so few people really seem to realize this (or care).
EDIT: Good question - do I practice what I preach? Yes, I do. I'm in an SRE position, and a few of our developers are hard of hearing, so I caption the training videos I make, without asking if they need them. No blind folks, but I make sure to use reasonable styles and page layouts to support fading eyesight. I don't set up Aria tags myself, because I don't have any users who need them at the moment.
None of my external or OS contributions are to UI related projects, so nothing of note there.
- Kenji 9y agoAccessibility costs a lot of money and it's a perfectly valid observation that one can skimp on it for profit. You may call it immoral, I call it mathematics.
- MBCook 9y agoExcept that makes things easier for everyone else too. For example I often can't watch videos at work. If that's the only way to get information about your product or fix to an issues you might as well be speaking Martian in that video I can't use it.
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoThe engines behind Alexa and Google Assistant have decent enough accuracy, I'm not sure why there couldn't be a product to run the audio through those to get subtitles. When there's not a single audio source for the main speaker, that becomes a problem, but that's the fault of the people recording it for not getting a clean audio source. However, in practice, this is rarely going to be the case for something like a product video because the studio will have recorded it correctly in isolated sound rooms. We're automatically reverting to "a human should do it" with adding aria tags, video subtitles, and screen readers. That is the problem because developers often have many other things to worry about -- database, security, scalability, maintenance, documentation. Accessibility gets put right beside those and it's no wonder developers don't prioritize it.
- MBCook 9y agoIt doesn't work well enough. We're no where NEAR it working well enough. People invent new words (product names, technologies), the text isn't synced to the video, there is background noise, the speech-to-text engine doesn't have the context of the video to guess which homophone is correct. Technology is not the magic bullet to fix everything. We're no where near that place. In the mean time, I still can't use your site. And neither can people with any number of other issues (medical, environmental, simple bandwidth, etc). Don't pawn it off on tech, people need to take responsibility for this kind of stuff.
- cbhl 9y agoMore importantly, accessibility is hard and complicated. There aren't good tools for collaboratively captioning videos ala a Google Doc. ARIA is a massively complicated spec that is much harder than <font color="red"> tags. There are simple and easy tools for making inaccessible content (Flash was a big one). It is much, much harder to make accessible content, and it shouldn't be that way.
- tmd83 9y agoFinancial perspective is an issue but this also. Its complicated and its not directly related to your core work/competency. One uses a lot of frameworks/tools to build on top of what if they are accessible and you can't build the thing completely on your own? Its quite to get started to be sure which one is just some regulatory checklist and which ones actually matter. I have trying to be knowledgeable on this but compared to normal web development informations are both sparse and harder to grok. And its also much harder to test/validate than just checking if my script/css is working/looking right. I have done very little screenreader tests but it somethings they are terribly good at working through and some things break too easily. It might make perfect sense for an accessibility expert but can be very non-intuitive for a regular developer.
- falcolas 9y agoPerfect compliance with Sccessibility can be hard and complicated; but have another look at the original article. The things being asked for are not hard or complicated. Making no effort just because a perfect effort would be hard comes across as a cop out. Would we accept this so easily if we were discussing testing?
- cbhl 9y agoIf you can push back on $BOSS, certainly. But, frankly, it's way too easy to make inaccessible content. It should be impossible to make inaccessible content. We could have browsers and/or compilers that just break the whole page if it isn't accessible.
- vacri 9y agoI dunno, satisfying both "not low contrast" and "not bright colour schemes" together, along with a good design in general, requires a moderate amount of knowledge. I'm not arguing that it shouldn't be done, but the idea that it's effortless is simply not true.
- Spivak 9y agoIf this is truly the case then website accessibility will end up going the way of physical disability accommodations -- legally required.
- tyingq 9y agoIt has in some cases. In the US, The DOT requires it for airline websites.
- panglott 9y agoUltimately you're mostly talking about the cost of digital typography.
- II2II 9y agoThe cost of accessibility depends upon many factors. If your design starts with accessibility in mind, the costs can be minimal. Keep in mind that the use of small and low contrast elements is a design decision. If the decision is made to use large and high contrast elements from the start, there should be no difference in the development costs. Making it possible to scale pages for pages where things are laid out spatially is far more difficult and incurs much more testing, yet costs can be reduced if the decision is made from the outset. Even the more difficult factors, such as captioning images and videos, can be eased if planning is done ahead. The problem with arguing that it's 'mathematics' is that there are many variables involved in the equation. If the variables use values for poor planning and design decisions, the result is going to be a much higher cost. If the variables use values for solid planning and design decisions, the difference is going to be much lower. Of course it also depends upon the media being used, so it is very difficult to use that equation to make generalizations for all cases.
- Arcsech 9y ago"Accessibility costs money" is a popular thing to say, but I'm not convinced that needs to be true. Okay, fine, captioning/transcribing videos I'll give you, but many of the other issues on this page can be addressed for a web page just by not breaking the defaults. By default, links are underlined. For text content, many major browsers (Firefox and mobile Safari for sure) include a "reader mode" or similar where the user can adjust their own contrast - as long as you don't break your HTML and prevent the reader mode from working. Web pages are black and while by default, so anything with lots of bright colors is something you have to do intentionally. Animations are also something you have to add intentionally. It really seems like just by not breaking the defaults (I.e., no work at all) your web page should do a decent (not perfect) job of being accessible. But we're so obsessed with making things shiny and swooshy that we've lost sight of that.
- SilasX 9y ago>"Accessibility costs money" is a popular thing to say, but I'm not convinced that needs to be true. Okay, fine, captioning/transcribing videos I'll give you, Even that one is overstated. Sure, taking some existing video, and treating it as the only representation of the content, and then trying to transcribe it -- that's expensive. But virtually every such video (esp. lectures) intended for conveying information is going to correspond to some text equivalent, and they can just post that in a place that's easy to find. Not only is it cheap, many users who can hear will prefer that version. I think it's just a widespread attitude problem (for lack of a more refined diagnosis). It's not just big institutions, but discussion forums where some users will stubbornly link a video as their only citation, and won't even take the time to summarize the key point they think it's substantiating.
- PeterisP 9y agoCan you elaborate why do you assume that such videos are likely to have a text equivalent? You bring up lectures as example - I certainly don't have transcripts of lectures I've given, and neither do most professors/lecturers/whatever that I know; a few of them have most of their talk content in their slides but that's a horrible practice that distracts from effective lecture or presentation; in general all the non-audio material is intended to be a supplement to the talk and either are not meaningful without it (e.g. illustrations) or are not representative of the talk (e.g. a textbook chapter that's mostly about the same topic, but different). The recorded audio (if it'd be recorded) would literally be the only copy of the content of that lecture in existence. The same applies for many other genres of video content. Most videos aren't scripted, and thus no script exists; heck, even videos that are clearly well prepared, staged and filmed with multiple takes (e.g. many of "youtube creators") generally don't have a script beforehand, the textual content is improvised on the spot and doesn't exist in written form unless it gets transcribed. Interviews and podcasts are other good examples - as you say, many users who can hear would prefer to read it, I certainly would, but the obvious reality is that the textual version of those things does not exist unless it gets made, and making it takes much more time than recording the interview or podcast in the first place.
- reaperducer 9y agoThere's a word for people like you: Sociopath.
- sctb 9y agoNo matter what we're replying to, personal attacks like this aren't OK on Hacker News.
- jxramos 9y agoJust thought it would be worth pointing out some other costs we don't typically consider here besides development costs is litigation costs... The most troubling wave of ADA litigation is just beginning to crest. The ADA’s next frontier—and next target of litigation—is the most innovative segment of the domestic economy: e-commerce. The latest trend in ADA litigation is suing commercial websites that aren’t sufficiently accessible to the disabled—because, for instance, they lack assistive technologies for the blind or hearing-impaired. Even though the ADA was enacted before websites became ubiquitous, many courts have interpreted the term “public accommodation” in Title III to encompass the Internet, and will entertain suits applying to it. In 2008, Target paid $6 million to settle a class-action suit brought by the National Federation of the Blind charging that the retailer’s website was allegedly insufficiently accessible to blind customers. Target also paid nearly $4 million in costs and attorneys’ fees to the plaintiffs. Why would Target pay $10 million to settle a case when the law is unsettled and its culpability far from certain? Class-action lawsuits are particularly expensive to defend, and because the potential liability is aggregated to reflect the entire class (all blind consumers, in this example), the financial exposure for a firm if it loses in court presents an unacceptable risk to most corporate defendants. https://www.city-journal.org/html/ada-litigation-monster-15128.html https://www.city-journal.org/html/ada-litigation-monster-151...
- zie 9y agoThis also happened with Netflix over captioning: https://www.nad.org/2011/06/16/nad-files-disability-civil-rights-lawsuit-against-netflix/ https://www.nad.org/2011/06/16/nad-files-disability-civil-ri... Netflix now does the right thing and captions everything.
- sokoloff 9y agoWas there a tradeoff involved there? Is there content that is not in the Netflix catalog today because of the costs of closed-captioning the rest of the catalog? If that is the case, are Netflix's customers better or worse off, individually and collectively? Is society better or worse off? (I don't have a clear answer, and I'm not sure there's an objectively clear answer, but I do think that there are tradeoffs in these discussions that are sometimes hidden/ignored.)
- microcolonel 9y agoHow many times have you selflessly made your product accessible? It's easy to point fingers and judge people, but it is genuinely difficult to serve people with every conceivable disability. Do you optimize the prose on your websites for people with IQs under 75? How exhaustive is exhaustive enough? I've spent considerable effort on making things accessible in my life, and I'm sure it can cost you your entire product when you're just starting out. Edit: I think the limitations apply to products which are marketed to the general public. If you know your existing users are struggling with an accessibility bug, then you know what you have to do.
- falcolas 9y agoWriting documentation for the equivalent of 8th graders is pretty common for any writing, so I made a habit of doing that a long time ago. It's like coding - if you're too clever, it's hard to understand and read later. How hard is it to really use reasonable font sizes and contrast ratios? How hard is it to add a few more tags to your site? How hard is it to caption videos as you're making them (most time you're working from a script anyways). If you're not starting these good practices from the beginning, yes, it will be harder to do all at once later. But if you start doing it from the beginning, it is pretty easy to do. Just like testing. Just like coding standards. Just like design patterns.
- greglindahl 9y agoIt's easy to accuse people of pointing fingers and judging people, too, and genuinely difficult to make high-quality, thought-provoking Hacker News postings. (Your comment would have been much better had you left out the rude accusations.)
- mjevans 9y agoReleasing content in to the commons for free //should be// an exception; however if someone else wants to add to that by providing captions in a standard format there should be a way of combining that to achieve a further enriched commons.
- Justsignedup 9y agoThe truth is there is a cost associated with all of this. Example my current job I brought up issues of font scaling, screen readers, etc. They care to make it good enough BUT not enough to invest significant time, because we need MVP. People won't accommodate the minority unless they are one, unless they have to, or unless they really really care and can convince their boss. This is an unfortunate truth of humanity or business. Personally I very much care. But I don't get to call the shots.
- eagsalazar2 9y agoI was going to make this comment on the parent comment but you really tee'ed it up for me perfectly. Not doing basic accessibility on the web is just mental laziness, plain and simple. I have to strongly disagree the the implied point in your post that it requires investment of any significant time. You can get 90% of the way to "good" just by picking appropriate font sizes and colors, doing halfway sane IA, and probably most important just using semantic markup. Adding text info to images, aria tags, etc are very minimal efforts if you simply have it in mind as you work. None of those things require any extra time except that people need to care enough to read some documentation and watch a couple youtube videos which is a one-time up front investment of 1hr or so (not saying you are an expert after 1hr but you can definitely do "ok" with 1hr of research and learn as you go from there). a11y gets more complicated when you start doing heavy js with custom realtime interactions but even then you can get 70% of the way there with very little effort and it is a bit of a red herring because how many people are really working on fancy modern SPAs in their day jobs?
- hinkley 9y agoThere's an argument to be made that the aria data can be leveraged by your test automation as well. Code that a screen reader can't decipher is pretty hard for test frameworks to figure out, too.
- matwood 9y ago> I have to strongly disagree the the implied point in your post that it requires investment of any significant time. Totally agree. Basics like alt tags on images, wcag contrast friendly colors and semantic tags to let screen readers know this is a repeated menu, this is content, etc... take very little additional time and help so many people. Even in SPAs these items are basic.
- SippinLean 9y agoIn my experience companies don't want to pay for it up front. So they end up paying much more later (after the lawsuit).
- WalterBright 9y agoOn the other hand, catering to ignored niches is a good business plan. If you can own a small segment, you can make more money than uselessly going after the center of where your entrenched competitors are. Once the niche is conquered, this can be used to go after the less nichy segments. See "The Innovator's Dilemma" by Christensen
- falcolas 9y agoThe problem is that this niche is not stereotypically a very well paying niche. The intersection of high earners and disabled people is quite small (and the intersection between lowest 20% of income earners and disabled is quite large)n So, there's not really a lot of money (if any) to be made by focusing solely on this niche. That's why the ADA and various government laws came into existence - nobody was catering to the niche since it wasn't lucrative enough.
- WalterBright 9y agoI made good money in the compiler business by catering to niches that were completely ignored by the other vendors, large and small. I'm also happy to get any accessibility problems in dlang.org and digitalmars.com fixed, if anyone wants to notify me of any problems.
- isleyaardvark 9y agoThat may be good for one individual business, but not good for the segment of the population that's disabled. For example: restaurants. Take a world where restaurants have to comply with ADA regulations versus a world where it's expected that someone coming up with a business plan for a restaurant that caters to the disabled. It's the difference between a world where the disabled can go to restaurants or where they can got to a restaurant.
- avar 9y agoI live in a central European city full of restaurants that would be sued out of existence if they were in the states for ADA violations. The ADA also means that a lot of hole in the wall establishments you see in Europe simply can't exist in the states. Society is poorer for it.
- ddebernardy 9y agoThat's hardly the biggest problem IMO. What bewilders me most is the number of engineers and designers who can't empathize with how their users might interact with the unspeakably bad UX they're putting together.
- analog31 9y agoSometimes I have a hunch that inaccessibility is what costs money. A basic informative HTML web page is cheap to write and host. The deluge of swirling graphics, icons, and microscopic pull-downs, are what cost money to create.
- wmeredith 9y agoI have been building software UI's for a decade and I absolutely agree.
- CaptSpify 9y agoI really don't get it. Basic web-pages are simpler, easier, faster, smaller, and provide data in a more manageable format. Sure, there's some things that work better as an SPA, but those are extremely rare.
- vacri 9y agoBasic web pages are less appealing to the mainstream, so they capture fewer eyeballs there. Example: https://www.debian.org/ https://www.debian.org/ is a simple website, designed for broad accessibility, but it doesn't look 'slick'. If you were looking to choose an OS, this website wouldn't make you go 'wow'.
- CaptSpify 9y agoYou are correct, but that's kind of my point. To me, a website is a tool to get something done. I don't want a website that "wows" me. If you really want to wow me, then you are likely trying to sell me something that I probably don't want. Accessibility is about letting people get shit done, not marketing to them.
- vacri 9y agoIf basic webpages 'sold', then marketers would use them. Webpages that 'wow' work, that's why people use them. It's not based on gut feelings either - there's lots of research in the area, for example A/B testing. People say they don't want shitty news either, but the news that is most popular is pretty low quality, sensationalist tripe.
- gnicholas 9y agoYour point about profitability assessment is an excellent one. I recently spoke to the CEO of a company that makes ebook reader software. This CEO has issued multiple open letters about accessibility, claiming that his company cares a lot about making its products accessible. But in a conversation with him about a new text accessibility tool, he said that if he can't "pass on the cost to his customers", he is unlikely to offer it to his customers. This shows a complete misunderstanding of what accessibility is. If his company could make more money by including a new feature, then integrating it wouldn't be "accessibility" – it would be "usability" or "good design". Accessibility is (almost), by definition, the stuff you do to make your product usable even though the time you are spending does not pass a typical cost-benefit test. And the point of ADA lawsuits is to make sure that the cost-benefit does line up, if legal fees and judgments are included.
- jessaustin 9y ago...screen readers just need to get better. TFA doesn't relate any tweets about screen readers, and identifies many easier tasks as being more important than screen reader compliance. It would be nice if web authors had a tool for that compliance that wasn't expensive and obscure like the readers themselves. (If they weren't obscure, we'd just file some PRs and be done with this.)
- steveax 9y agoNVDA [1] and VoiceOver (iOS and MacOS) are free. [1]: https://www.nvaccess.org https://www.nvaccess.org
- fapjacks 9y agoWhere do you draw the line? Berkeley recently [0] had to pull tens of thousands of free education videos, because California law required that they be captioned, and they couldn't possibly caption tens of thousands of videos. So they just pulled them. I'm on board with an E for effort, but I find what I've described unacceptable. [0] https://reason.com/blog/2017/03/07/berkeley-deletes-200000-free-online-vide https://reason.com/blog/2017/03/07/berkeley-deletes-200000-f...
- vizeroth 9y agoI think people underestimate the difficulty of getting this done in a University environment, but I also think people are too quick to side with Berkeley in this particular case. One of the points made by the DoJ was that Berkeley makes resources available to faculty and staff to do the captioning, so, in theory, the captioning could have been done as the videos were made (at least those which were made in the last couple of years), and it should have been done as they were posted (again, at least those posted in the last couple of years). So, the problem is getting the faculty and staff at Berkeley (and nearly everywhere else) to take the requirement seriously. Many of the people working to make content accessible are not in a position of authority over the people creating the content. In some cases it's a battle to educate the people who are in authority regarding the legal requirements and the consequences of ignoring those requirements. As much as I wish that content didn't have to be pulled because of accessibility issues, sometimes there is no other way forward. It is worth noting that the Berkeley case was federal law. California law does make the requirement for state Universities to comply with the ADA more explicit, but the US DoJ isn't in the habit of investigating violations of state law. The DoJ's letter to the University cites the ADA and various portions of the US Code: https://news.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/2016-08-30-UC-Berkeley-LOF.pdf https://news.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/2016-08...
- Chris2048 9y ago> it should have been done as they were posted This was not something they where required to do?The implication here is if you add requirements to free content, institutions just won't bother - the material was only released due to the low bar to do so in the first place. > sometimes there is no other way forward There is if you change the law, which is what I think parent was implying