14 ms·
What Is Space?
- ravenstine 9y agoI'm simultaneously glad that someone's writing articles about these things and dismayed that too many people will read this and believe they understand astrophysics without having philosophized about it on their own. Analogies like "space goo" are useful but can be a double-edged sword(seems the author recognizes this) that can mislead the public in much the same way that the holographic universe theory leads the public to think we might be in a simulation run by space bastards, which doesn't really explain anything about the very nature of existence.
- model_s 9y agoDo you mind elaborating? Or pointing me in the direction of material that explains the space goo issue. thx
- gizmo686 9y agoThe biggest issue I see with the goo metaphor, is that it seems to suggest some sort of stationary ether that we move through as we move through space. That is to say, the mathaphor suggests that it makes sense to differentiate between stationary objects and moving objects in an objective sense. However, the core insight of relativity is that there is no such distinction.
- worldsayshi 9y agoThis seems like a inevitable issue with any metaphor. It will always supply unwanted associations.
- lgas 9y agoYes, but its still worth being intentional about which ones you allow/support and which ones you don't.
- mschwaig 9y agoI'm reading the whole book right now and the chapter after the one from the article is about time and goes more into spacetime according to relativity. So far it seems to me that they sometimes provide an oversimplified analogy which they revise in a later chapter.
- cyphar 9y ago> So far it seems to me that they sometimes provide an oversimplified analogy which they revise in a later chapter. Welcome to every high-school, undergrad and postgrad physics course. That's just how most sciences are taught. Physics especially, because all analogies lead to misunderstandings because they are an attempt to simplify the mathematics underlying the physics[1]. Such analogies will always result in certain subtleties being lost on the student, but if the student is not familiar with the subject then the mathematics would also be lost on them. The reason why this method works is that physics operates on approximations, so an approximately accurate analogy is a step in the right direction for a more accurate mathematical model (which is still ultimately an approximation). [1]: https://xkcd.com/895/ https://xkcd.com/895/
- mabbo 9y agoI'm really loving the book (half way through it!). Part of me knows that a lot of this is being simplified down for me, but I also trust the authors to not steer the reader too far off course. I may not have all the math and physics understanding, but I get that dark matter is real. I didn't before. That's the kind of thing the book is about, imho.
- wrycoder 9y agoThere is currently no way to differentiate between Einsteinian relativity and Lorentzian relativity. The latter proposes an absolute reference frame. The CMB frame would be a reasonable choice for a stationary structure at the Planckian level that would host the energy bundles (quarks etc) that make up objective reality, cf. loop quantum gravity. A one-way measurement of the speed of light is needed to differentiate between the two theories, and that has not been accomplished. In fact, it may not be possible in principle to do so. Choice then becomes a matter of taste and philosophical/physical economy.
- lmm 9y agoLack of philosophizing is less of an issue than ignorance of the physics, even - especially - among philosophers. There ought to be a rule against speculating on the nature of reality in the context of quantum physics if you haven't completed the exercises in Nielsen and Chuang.
- zdkl 9y agoThere ought to be a rule against people making rules not founded in maths.
- wrycoder 9y agoYea, "piled higher and deeper", indeed. Unwarranted speculation and generalizations purely for the entertainment of those who enjoy a good mind boggle. You'd be wasting your time if you expected to gain any solid insight from the article. Space and time are what keep everything from happening at the same time in the same place. The infinitesimal bundles of energy that make up objective reality are vastly separated in spacetime. Why is that?
- losteric 9y agoIsn't the "rubber sheet" analogy better than "space goo"? The goo analogy makes it seem like "ripples" and "bends" are something space does, where as it's (from my understanding) actually the influence of gravitational fields/aggregations of mass.
- prodmerc 9y agoJesus fucking Christ, who fucking cares? It's space, there's some objects, humanity needs to colonize it. That's all there is if you want to take action. It's like a company that makes great and not-so-great-but-useful products stopping and wondering "why are we doing this? Why do we exist?" You won't exist forever, so just do it. Some people with enough free time and money can do the philosophies, the rest need to focus on action.
- accountyaccount 9y agoWhy do something if you don't understand why something?
- owebmaster 9y agoWhy do nothing if you don't understand why something?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- justinpombrio 9y agoI'm really curious what comment led to these replies.
- gizmo686 9y agoIf you go to your profile page, there is a "showdead" setting you can use to see dead comments.
- justinpombrio 9y agoDon't view the dead, it isn't a pretty sight.
- prodmerc 9y agoSome philosophical/theoretical thinking about space. Ain't nobody got time for that.
- Noxchi 9y agoHow fast are you really going? One of the things I've thought about is relatively. Consider a toddler strapped to his car seat in a luxurious BMW cocoon while his father speeds down the autobahn at 200km/h. He calmy drinks from his sippy cup. You're in a passenger jet above him going 700km/hr. You're going 500km/hr faster than him. But how fast are you really going? Consider that the Earth is spinning around the sun at a rate of 1 billion kilometers per year or about 100,000 km/hr. You're on Earth, so is your jet's true speed 100,700 km/hr? Relative to the sun, yes, but everything that orbits our sun is considered our solar system which itself is orbiting our galaxy at a rate of 800,000 km/hr. So if we add the 800k, 100k, and 700 km/hr your plane is moving, is it not fair to say you are traveling at almost a billion kilometers per hour? I'm sure you can infer the galaxy itself is hurling through space at an ungodly speed. I ask two questions: 1. When does this stop? What is the most supreme center in the universe? 2. Just as the child could roll down his window, and have instant access to the outside, is there a way we can do the same?
- platz 9y agothere are no absolute reference frames. only relative ones! however, at least there is a fixed relationship between reference frames they all must obey with regards to the speed of light.
- tombh 9y agoJust thinking out loud here. If the speed of light is absolute (it's not relative right? it doesn't change in any reference frame?), then could the speed of light be considered the base axis, or to continue the metaphor in the parent comment, that the speed of light is the 'outside the car'? Also, doesn't time 'stop' when you are at C, so that the whole idea of space (speed * time) sort of collapses?
- jacobolus 9y agoYou should spend some time doing calculations in the “hypercomplex plane”. That is, something like the complex plane, but where you’ve taken the real number line and added a a new value u such that u² = 1 instead of the value i such that i² = –1. Try to work out what perpendicular numbers look like in this space, what “circles” look like (hint: like hyperbolae), what the tangents to those circles look like, what kind of metrical relationships arbitrary triangles or other shapes have, and so on. If you play with this simple 2-dimensional number system for a while, you’ll come to understand the nature of special relativity much better. * * * The displacement between two points in spacetime can be either “spacelike” in which case there is some inertial reference frame in which the two points are simultaneous, or it can be “timelike” in which case there is some inertial reference frame where the two points are at separate times, unmoving in space, or the displacement vector can be “lightlike”, which is a boundary between the two – the two points are always in every inertial reference frame separated by some speed-of-light separation.
- basicplus2 9y agoMaybe space is the ether afterall
- copperx 9y agoIt could be infinity. We don’t really don’t know. But it could be. It has to be something, but it could be infinity, right? - DJT
- recursio 9y agoAt the macro level, Space could expand outward infinitely, or maybe if you travel further enough and you return to where you started. Or maybe there's the multiverse thats teaming with infinite universes? Most physicists will tell you that at the quantum level, the most fundamental level is at the Planck scale, and the "nothingness" of space is still teaming with particles popping in and out of existence. Some particles being hypothetical and have yet to be discovered.
- peter303 9y agoEther was invoked the structure of space was necessary for fields to propagate, e.g. light was a vibration of space. This is no longer necessary. And could not be detected in the M-M experiment. The Ionian Greeks proposed most of same models of space as modern physics, but lacked experiments to select the correct model. Some model propes emptiness and others an underlying substance of matter or energy.
- signa11 9y agofwiw, a tangential comment, jorge-cham, is also the progenitor of phd comics.
- narrator 9y agoOne thing about space that I didn't see mentioned in the article is that even in a complete vacuum billions of miles away from anywhere there is still inertia. If something spins around it will still experience centrifugal force, so this is an absolute property of space and the universe that isn't caused by interaction with another body.
- cyphar 9y agoThat's because rotation is a form of acceleration, and you can measure the acceleration (or if you prefer, the gravity) of a non-intertial (accelerating) reference frame. Galilean relativity only applies to inertial reference frames.
- Razengan 9y agoSome related questions that I don't know where, or how, to ask: - Is there a “quantum” of space? Where/how is location stored? - If electromagnetic repulsion is what makes matter “take space”, and if virtually all macroscopic phenomena are governed by electromagnetism and gravity, then could this reality be said to be “gravelectromagnetic”, and might there be other “dimensions” governed by other forces, like “cones” extending in differing “directions” from the subatomic scale? [0] - Could gravity be the result of space trying to deflate/return to the pre-Big Bang singularity, kind of like pulling magnets apart? i.e. is gravity the “opposite” of, or a reaction to, “space?” [0]: http://i.imgur.com/6meZmc2.png http://i.imgur.com/6meZmc2.png
- jacobolus 9y agoFrom what I understand nobody knows the answer to your first question, but there’s been speculation both ways. As for your second question, you might want to start with something like Feynman’s book QED.
- tombh 9y agoNothing to add, I just love where your questions send my mind, thank you.
- Razengan 9y agoYou may enjoy contemplating a sort of "epiphany" that I had during that usual pondering of imponderables: That the default or base state of existence may not be nothing, not "not even nothing", but rather Everything. ... Instead of viewing the origin of all reality/creation as things being added to a canvas of blackness/emptiness/voidness, rather consider that "Existence" may be a subtractive process: akin to holes being poked into a canvas of white, or bubbles in a boiling liquid. (I mean even before the Big Bang, or the classic "Who Created God"/Prime Mover/First Cause question – humans are given to assuming that the start of anything must be Zero or Nothingness, that the end of everything is Oblivion, and that may not be the case.) Our existence is a "filter", our perceptions being a very limited subset of everything that's around us, of select wavelengths and frequencies and etc. This entire universe could just be a transient bubble inside a flood of Everythingness. [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_vacuum#Existential_threat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_vacuum#Existential_threa...
- graycat 9y agoDo we know enough yet to have some good guesses about (1) the purpose of the universe, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14570170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14570170 (2) the end of the universe, (A) big expansion and cool down to nothing, (B) no more expansion and cool down to nothing, (C) contraction back to another big bang, (D) something else very different?
- cyphar 9y ago> (1) the purpose of the universe, This question is far more philisophical than anything. Personally I subscribe to Camus' Absurdism[1] -- that our yearning for meaning and purpose is ironic given how uncaring and lacking in meaning our universe is. > (2) the end of the universe There are several theories[2], but from my understanding we need to better understand "dark matter" and "dark energy" (scare quotes because those names are really silly, since we know effectively nothing about either). In particular, it appears that we live in a flat universe but the evolution of the universe becomes more complicated with the cosmological constant terms in the evolution equations (believed to correspond to dark energy). Effectively, the cosmological constant can be seen as an energy density that remains constant throughout the universe which means that the amount of dark energy increases as the universe expands. I believe we discussed the current theories in my second-year cosmology course, but I can't recall the conclusion (it wasn't taught very well). [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absurdism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absurdism [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe
- graycat 9y agoFor my first question, I was wondering if by now we had enough information to make a guess that is not just philosophical.
- cyphar 9y agoBut I don't understand how the question "what is the purpose of X" can be anything but philosophical. Science is primarily concerned with creating models of reality and testing the predictive power of those models. The "purpose" of something is not really a meaningful concept in that context. ... unless by "purpose" you mean cause? As in, what caused our universe to exist? That is also not really a meaningful question, because time began with our universe so it's not clear what the concept of "before our universe" actually would refer to. Physically, I believe the currently popular theory is that the progenitor for our universe was an anti-matter explosion caused by the spontaneous creation of a matter+anti-matter pair (which happens all the time in a perfect vacuum due to Heisenberg's uncertainty relation -- \Delta E \Delta t \ge \hbar/2). There are several unsolved problems with this theory, the biggest one being how does it explain that there is a clear imbalance between the amount of matter and anti-matter in our universe.
- lwansbrough 9y agoGreat read. What intrigues me - based on the description offered by the author - is that the leading theory seems to more or less try to side-step the existential problem of space. The author referred to this as "super space" -- but is it really? Or is it possible that in attempting to simplify the model - or worse - fit it to a prior assumption, we've actually taken a wrong turn in our understanding of the universe? I'm not trying to say that the theories surrounding our current understanding of the universe are wrong. But they do seem to conveniently leave out one of the most vexing aspects of the entire problem. Where did it all come from? What's beyond "super-space"? Or, what's its container?
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThis continues to be one of my favorite questions. In high school we were creating a vacuum in a bell jar to do the 'drop a feather and drop a weight' experiment and my physics teacher asked it. "So if we didn't have our apparatus in there, and we sucked it dry, what would be in there?" It makes a great interview question because it helps identify people who have a hard time holding an unknown concept in their head and working with it. I asked that of one of the folks I interviewed for Google when I was there and we spiraled off into a discussion of branes and multi-dimensional manifolds and quantum wave equations[1]. [1] Fun interview and they got the job :-)
- kobeya 9y agoI went into entrepreneurship because I hate these kinds of interviews. You think a good way to tell whether I'd be good at writing code is my opinion on philosophy outside my domain of expertise?
- hackits 9y agoI dislike the one where they ask you how would you handle a situation that is highly dependent on the organisation and the organisation goals and procedures. The only answer really I give is not to answer such silly questions.
- anonymoose111 9y agogoogle interviews try to gauge how smart you are, not how well you can program
- kobeya 9y agoI fail to see how someone who is not a domain expert on the nature of space-time asking someone else who is not a domain expert can result in a reliable determination of how smart either person is. To be clear, I don't think the correct answer of "I don't know, but I'll do a review of the literature and see what the scientific consensus is" is what the interviewer was hoping for, which is my contention.
- mjfl 9y agoTo all I recommend Tim Maudlin's Philosophy of Space and Time: https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-Physics-Princeton-Foundations-Contemporary/dp/0691165718/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1499137957&sr=8-1&keywords=tim+maudlin https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-Physics-Princeton-Foundati... It might not answer the question, but really helped me understand the nature of space time.
- Piccollo 9y agoSpace is what?
- graycat 9y agoOne of the ones that gets me and may be central to space is the central idea in the Young's double slit experiment, the Michelson-Morley interferometer, the Fabry-Perot interferometer, etc. Indeed, the night I was studying for my final in optics and radiography, I thought of this stuff and never really studied for the exam! So, just shine a light through a beam splitter. So, ballpark half of the light continues on essentially straight and the other half is deflected 90 degrees. Such a beam splitter is in the M-M experiment. For the double slit, it divides the beam. For a Fabry-Perot, it ends up making many such splits. Okay, as we heard from Feynman, we could send just one photon through any of those devices and still get the same interference effects. Feynman also explained that we'd get the same result sending one electron at a time instead of a photon. So, here, to heck with recombining the beams and getting it to interfere with itself. Instead, consider just the beam splitter. So, the photon (or electron, neutron, whatever) is a wave function, and after the beam splitter that wave function is in two parts traveling apart, in the case of the photon, if we add a mirror to have the two halves going in opposite directions, at the speed of light. But such splits of the wave function happen at every window pane, no doubt in every water droplet, etc., that is happen all the time. And such a wave function doesn't split just once but commonly many times. So, the one, poor photon as one simple wave function is soon in dozens of pieces all moving away from each other usually never to come together again. After a billion years, the pieces are still moving away from each other. Then, presto, bingo, one part of that wave function enters our telescope and hits our detector. Then all the dozens of pieces of that wave function, scattered across a billion light years, have to disappear, instantly, since with two telescopes we can never get two detections from the one photon. Well, that's tough to believe. So, maybe the universe is filled with tiny pieces of wave functions condemned to go on forever. Maybe that's the dark matter?
- vlasev 9y agoOr perhaps the wave functions "gains a dimension" in that it spreads evenly (or weighed) in all of space, thus making it that a photon is "almost everywhere" until detection.
- lmm 9y ago> And such a wave function doesn't split just once but commonly many times. So, the one, poor photon as one simple wave function is soon in dozens of pieces all moving away from each other usually never to come together again. After a billion years, the pieces are still moving away from each other. > Then, presto, bingo, one part of that wave function enters our telescope and hits our detector. Then all the dozens of pieces of that wave function, scattered across a billion light years, have to disappear, instantly, since with two telescopes we can never get two detections from the one photon. > Well, that's tough to believe. There are a dozen different possibilities for what the photon has done - a dozen different universes, if you like. As long as the photon never interacts with anything else, this bundle of a dozen universes can act much the same as a single universe. Certainly if you're just looking at a telescope, all dozen versions of that telescope are behaving the same, so they behave like a single unified instance. When the photon hits the telescope in one universe, the perspective shifts: the telescope is now "inside" the 12-way split, either the photon went one way and the telescope recorded it or the photon went another way and the telescope didn't. And when we look into the telescope, we again shift from looking at the superposition from outside to being part of the superposition on the inside. Our language isn't great for talking about this, because it's not a binary is/isn't thing - entanglement is a continuous phenomenon. If you imagine just two photons each in one of two states, then it's easy enough to imagine: photon A is in a superposition of states 0 and 1, photon B is in an independent superposition of states 0 and 1 - each photon has two possible "local universes", but because they're distant and noncommunicating, to each one the other looks like it's in a superposition. And it's easy enough to imagine: photon A is in a superposition of states 0 and 1, photon B is in a superposition of states 0 and 1, but they're entangled such that we know the sum is 1 - here there are two possible "global universes", and we see a superposition between them, but ecah particle knows the other is in the same universe - if A is an 0 then it knows B is a 1 and vice versa. The part that's hardest to imagine is that it's also possible to be somewhere in between these two states: A and B can be partially entangled such that e.g. there's a 75% chance that the sum is 1. > So, maybe the universe is filled with tiny pieces of wave functions condemned to go on forever. Maybe that's the dark matter? No. The evolution of quantum systems is unitary and conserves energy.
- dredmorbius 9y agoJohn Baez, UC Riverside physics professor, on elements of various fundamental units, limits, and constants: https://plus.google.com/+johncbaez999/posts/RBwcd1jTDxM https://plus.google.com/+johncbaez999/posts/RBwcd1jTDxM
- Jaruzel 9y ago"Space is big. Really big. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it's a long way down the road to the chemist, but that's just peanuts to space." - Douglas Adams
- knouth 9y ago"At some point in the future, we’re going to look back and say how did we do it without space?" - Donald Trump
- parandroid 9y agoThe way the first paragraph was written instantly reminded me of Douglas Adams and his works. Glad to see another one. :)
- piotroxp 9y agoThey just forgot to mention the theory of everything,right
- piotroxp 9y agoAlso, ive posted this here sevral times, check out and google electromagnetic field patterns
- terryf 9y ago"But if you use a rigid ruler, all of its atoms would hold on to one another tightly (with electromagnetic forces), and the ruler would stay the same length, allowing you to notice that more space was created." This is the part that I don't really understand - how does the electromagnetic force "know" the true distance? Basically, there is an equation that determines the strength of the field that depends on the distance from the centre of the particle, or rather the "particle" creates a ripple in the field. The ripple still has a length though. So, the question then becomes - somehow the fact that the field has a bigger differential between two spots in space, keeps from more "space" appearing between those two spots. Yet where the field is zero (or whatever the lowest energy value is) more space can be created within the field. So, it seems that there is a "space field" and a number of other fields, that interact with each other and can influence the properties of each other. This kind of makes sense, essentially if the "space field" can have values attached to it, that in effect would determine "distance" from our perspective, then the interactions with other fields can influence the change in distances. IANAP, so if you are, would this be a correct line of thinking?
- yk 9y agoThe electromagnetic force does not know the true distance, here the ruler is more of a theoretical construct. Perhaps it helps, if you think about it as moving the underlying coordinates vs moving the particle. (There is no difference between the two pictures in the theory only the relation between coordinates and atoms appear. Sort of, at least.) So, if you apply a force to an atom, that means that the second derivative of its position changes. On the other hand, if we imagine for a moment that the atom is stationary and the coordinates change, then the second derivative of its position will change and it will therefore feel a force, gravity.
- mathgenius 9y agoIf you are really serious about this question then you would also consider what mathematicians have to say about "space". Unfortunately, this is pretty much the whole of mathematics, but I think special attention should be given to the duality between geometry and algebra. This stuff goes back to Descarte. For example, you can consider the points equidistant from a specific point, which gives a circle. Or you can consider the algebraic expression X^2+Y^2=1. Both of these viewpoints are in a sense, two sides of the same coin. What is that coin? Deep answers can be found when you start doing funky things like change your definition of numbers, to say, a finite field. Even just having two numbers 0 and 1 is quite interesting to consider. What is the corresponding geometry? Or, more confusing still, let's drop the requirement that xy = yx (commutativity). Now what are the non-commutative geometries on the other side of the coin? Considering the wide variety of these apparently fanciful ideas that have made their way into theoretical physics fills me with wonder. I wonder if the authors of the article mention any of this stuff in their book.
- westoncb 9y agoControversial, I know—but I wonder how deep that connection actually is... 'the points equidistant from a specific point' and 'X^2+Y^2=1' are both descriptions that we know how to parse and and evaluate into the same thing. Don't get me wrong, I do think it's a super interesting property of the systems of description we formulate that it's possible to talk about the same things with different abstractions (which happens a lot in math: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duality_(mathematics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duality_(mathematics)), even with very high degrees of precision—but I have a hard time seeing how this could be a property of space rather than of human conceptual structure/language.
- posterboy 9y agoThe last bit can be said about anything. It might be relevant if the notion is intrinsically motivated by an instinctive search for closed forms. "Space" being emptiness would be isomorphic (dual) to many experiences of limits. In contrast, mystifying the unknown might inspire curiosity at best, reserving free space in the back of the mind, or philosophic arguments at infinitum at worst. The article is somewhere in the middle with its talk around gravitational waves and einsteinian curvature of space, without directly mentioning them.
- FeepingCreature 9y agoMy reaction to the illustrations: http://i.imgur.com/wF3HSDM.png http://i.imgur.com/wF3HSDM.png
- gramstrong 9y agoWell, this is ironic.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- burnbabyburn 9y ago"baby don't hurt me, don't hurt me, no more"
- 205guy 9y agoUsually, I enjoy articles that explain difficult concepts in math and physics, and I like to think about these concepts. But this article just rubs me the wrong way. It throws out some scientific jargon in the first paragraph that could be accurate, but instead they belittle it. Then they try to describe how some people would describe "space" but then argue as if everybody thought that way. I don't and felt talked down to. Worse, they argue as if "space" could have a simple, singular meaning, when obviously it can be defined on many levels, or at least looked at from many levels. Then I got to the part that says: This is the part where your brain goes, “Whaaaaat ... ?” No, my brain is not so easily confused that it expresses itself in slack-jawed mono-syllables. I get it that the article is trying to simplify some explanation, but I think it's trying too hard and failing. It makes too many assumptions about what the reader thinks and then bases its arguments on these wrong assumptions. I much preferred the discussion and links here on HN. Fwiw, I see space as the coordinate system of our universe but with no origin because it's all inertial frames of reference. It is usually thought of as a fixed 3-d Cartesian system plus time, but as I went through life and learned about relativity and Big Bang theory and universe expansion, I understand it as a much more dynamic and complex system.
- 205guy 9y agoI'm trying to read through the article now, and disappointed in every paragraph. Even the illustration that are trying to be cute are blatantly inaccurate. For example the one labeled "Space Expansion" shows a grid on the floor. In the case of expansion, the number of grid lines would be the same not more, and the point is that we definitely wouldn't feel the expansion. And then the explanation of rigid rulers and soft taffy rulers seems wrong. Both would expand because the underlying nature of matter expands along with the universe. In other words, all atoms and their distances are affected equally because the forces that determine those distances also change. It has nothing to do with soft or rigid property of an object, which is at the macro level of our perception of matter. I really expected better of Nautilus, I thought they had a more rigorous standard.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> all atoms and their distances are affected equally because the forces that determine those distances also change. Is that true? If the expansion of space didn't affect anything, wouldn't we not see any of the redshift?
- jhallenworld 9y agoThere have been some recent experiments and proposals looking for discreteness of space: http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2015/12/what-fermilabs-holometer-experiment.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2015/12/what-fermilabs-holo... https://www.space.com/29629-quantum-foam-bubbly-universe-search.html https://www.space.com/29629-quantum-foam-bubbly-universe-sea...