7 ms·
Websites offering pirated papers are shaking up science
- dreen 9y agoSend them bitcoin if you wish to support them: SciHub: 1K4t2vSBSS2xFjZ6PofYnbgZewjeqbG1TM LibGen: 1Gz3SZniRo8isQzgPiuovr11n3s75zecg2
- simlevesque 9y ago> 1K4t2vSBSS2xFjZ6PofYnbgZewjeqbG1TM I don't know where you got that, but it's not the actual bitcoin address of SciHub. http://www.sci-hub.cc/donate http://www.sci-hub.cc/donate edit: It's the one on their home page: http://sci-hub.cc/ http://sci-hub.cc/
- dreen 9y agoLooks like they have two? On the front page, when you scroll down "support the project" they display the one I pasted.
- dmytrish 9y agoWith all my respect to your desire to support SciHub, it'd be better to link to a verified page with their bitcoin credentials.
- ishtu 9y agoPlease don't share links that require paid account to read/view.
- rocqua 9y agoI disagree. This is and remains news, and deserves discussion. It sucks but banning this stuff is even worse.
- ungzd 9y agoHN for last few months is like mainstream TV — links to all these bloombergs, economists, mainstream world news, politics, social justice, all that dirt. It transformed into yet another top news aggregator. Who needs HN now if you can just turn on old nasty TV box and receive the same crappy information?
- erikb 9y agoThe information deserves discussion. What he criticizes is choosing a paid-access-only information provider to share this information here. It's probably possible to find the same info somewhere for free and that source should get shared.
- stillhere 9y agoAt least use http://archive.is/ http://archive.is/
- snakeanus 9y agoPlease avoid archive.is if possible, it makes accessing the articles extremely annoying if you are using tor or a proxy. How about archive.org instead?
- nraynaud 9y agoto be fair, this article is very shallow anyways.
- kronos29296 9y agoSo it's not full article?
- rocqua 9y agoIt probably is for you, I get a "you only get 3 free articles per month" paywall.
- kronos29296 9y agoTry Tor or a proxy I guess. Maybe the website hasn't blocked those. But the article doesn't really talk about much. It's like an introduction to Scihub.
- ungzd 9y agoPeople not paying for news are shaking up journalism and democracy!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tomhoward 9y agoFrom the FAQ's [0]: Are paywalls ok? It's ok to post stories from sites with paywalls that have workarounds. In comments, it's ok to ask how to read an article and to help other users do so. But please don't post complaints about paywalls. Those are off topic. As for a workaround, I can't offer any tips on this one because it opened for me without any restriction whatsoever. But the most common workaround for porous paywalls like The Economist is to open the HN web link in an incognito window and click through from Google search. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- simon_acca 9y agocomplaining against paywalls is against the FAQ: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html
- ezequiel-garzon 9y agoI can't access the article, but in any event I wonder: doesn't it feel like this is actually being allowed? We're talking about hosted content, not torrents. Of course, many (including me) feel that this sharing of information can only advance society, but I'm surprised to sense that the establishment agrees.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoI believe there have been takedowns of SciHub... it's why they host in multiple countries and maintain multiple domain names.
- reacweb 9y agoThe society as a whole has to accept small violations of laws. Otherwise, it would be very difficult to improve laws. IMHO, it is a temporary tolerance because the correct final stance is not obvious.
- api 9y agoI don't universally support this kind of thing but in this case I do. Nearly all of this research is directly or indirectly taxpayer funded. All taxpayer funded research should be freely available to us since we paid for it. That and these gatekeepers are just bridge trolls that add zero value. It made sense back when journals were physically printed but today the distribution cost is zero.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoThat most of this research taxpayer funded is indeed a good argument. Beyond that, people criticized other disrupted industries for continuing to provide poor customer service -- seemingly unable to fight back after decades of treating customers as captive audiences, and taking them for granted. Well if you think the music industry was bad at that, the academic publishing industry is way worse. These guys typically provide no significant value add, yet they want large economic rewards. Meanwhile, journal after journal has been shown incompetent to keep garbage papers -- even papers generated by Markov chains -- out. My impression is that they also discriminate heavily against individual researchers, many of whom cannot afford exorbitant per-per paper fees, while large (typically subsidized) institutions get much better deals when they are able to afford bulk access.
- rocqua 9y ago> many of whom cannot afford exorbitant per-per paper fees Whilst the publishers are certainly not pulling their weight, I don't think the biggest offenders have per-paper fees. The biggest offender is probably Elsevier, and as far as I know they make their money from selling subscriptions to research institutions and universities.
- threepipeproblm 9y agoI don't have any real data on this... my comment was based on my own experience of not being able to afford per-paper fees and certainly not being able to afford subscriptions, whilst observing that the academic institutions seem to have no trouble maintaining access. No idea what the per paper fees would actually work out to for universities (say, the ones actually downloaded/accessed). As someone who reads a fair number of papers, I definitely feel like the publishers' days are numbered, and not just because of Sci-Hub and LibGen. More and more often now, I can find papers that I want, legally, on the first try. Even more encouraging, I find that when I can't find a paper I often just have to wait a few months and try again to find an open Internet source. Case in point: a few months ago I wanted this paper -- http://bit.ly/2tE4O4K http://bit.ly/2tE4O4K -- but all the CiteSeerX links were broken and apparently had been for a long while. About two months later it's back. This is just one example, but I find this increasingly works with many papers. There is also ResearchGate, which is a social network to get papers from an authors, which is legal if they are alive. But their sign-up process is also much harder for independent researchers. You have to "prove you are a researcher," as though attempting to get access to research papers weren't prima facie evidence of that. In CS the worst paywaller is consistently the ACM.
- dagenleg 9y agoI think the big publishers are not behaving rationally here, trying to fight a library based in Russia via American courts. A much cheaper and effective alternative would be to simply bribe some Russian officials. If the bribe is big enough the websites will be gone in a week, owners arrested.
- conanbatt 9y agoI'm pretty sure that is criminal.
- owebmaster 9y agoAnd probably would not work. If this is a common expedient, at least with Snowden it didn't work.
- matz1 9y agoOf course you would do it secretly.
- conanbatt 9y agoStill, i would never recommend a big institucion to engage in criminal activities for its own benefit :)
- exhilaration 9y agoI'm sure they'd love to but if the publishers are US-based, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) makes it a crime to bribe officials of foreign governments. The law is somewhat actively enforced: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/us-firms-say-costly-foreign-bribe-law-lacks-clarity/2011/07/05/gIQAB50jTI_story.html?utm_term=.dfd599aca054 https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/us-firms-say...
- dpatru 9y agoThis is probably a very bad idea: https://www.justice.gov/criminal-fraud/foreign-corrupt-practices-act https://www.justice.gov/criminal-fraud/foreign-corrupt-pract....
- sleepless 9y agoUniversity research is funded by the state in germany. Research results should thus live in the public domain. I have no pity for those artificial paywall companies, benefiting from research funded with tax money. This model needs to change - fast. And the change should be supported by legislation.
- mvitorino 9y agoThis. A lot of long term research worldwide is publicly funded and the status quo of the scientific journals (that once had their place in a world with high communication barriers and costs) needs to be seriously shaken up. That plus the huge business around scientific conferences with most speakers having to pay to be able to present their findings. But I guess the whole model in the scientific community might need rethinking. Most people are only worried publishing because that is the only measure that matters at the moment...
- denzil_correa 9y ago> Research results should thus live in the public domain. Yes but not by paying humongous Open Access fees to publishers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- themind 9y agoEconomist paywalls are easily circumvented: a) Delete the element covering the content b) Disable or delete cookies
- kiasta 9y agoMost of the time, yes. Some sites like to be sneaky though and disable scrolling and other weird annoyances. A simple DOM event to check for certain elements existing would circumvent removing of the element. I would remove all events associated with said element (if they exist) first to prevent weirdness. Hell even developing a greasemonkey/tampermonkey script for that particular website would be easy enough, so you don't have to do that every time.
- Nacraile 9y agoEconomist also lets you a few articles per week for free. If you find yourself bumping against their paywall with any regularity, perhaps you should actually pay for the content? Or, would you like to live on an internet where the only content that can pay for itself is clickbait?
- kuschku 9y agoEconomist only lets US citizen read a few articles per week for free. I get on the first visit with a clean browser already that message.
- fazkan 9y agoI dont get it, how is it shaking up science. The heading is illogical. The article starts with how the film industry is being affected by piracy. Then it says that a court has granted a publishing platform damages from sci hub. Then in the next few paragraphs it lists the countries with the most users of the sci hub websites. Then it ends with how the creator of sci hub will be awarded a Disobedience award by MIT, which she likely wont attend... I was expecting a detailed analysis of how something like sci hub affects research and science, not the middleman companies that earns from the research.
- simias 9y ago>An analysis of Sci-Hub’s server logs, published in Science in 2016, found its biggest users were people in Iran, India and China. Such middle-income countries do not qualify for the subsidies big publishers provide to users in the poorest nations, but their universities nevertheless may not be able to afford subscriptions. That alone could potentially have far reaching consequences. I agree that the article is a bit light on details though.
- kefka 9y agoYeah, that may be true.. But Scihub is an onion site. That means there's not much in the way of "who", but in the way of last hop before hitting the onionsite. And I would daresay that one should probably not trust logs when going through Tor.
- pen2l 9y ago> >An analysis of Sci-Hub’s server logs, published in Science in 2016, found its biggest users were people in Iran, India and China. Such middle-income countries do not qualify for the subsidies big publishers provide to users in the poorest nations, but their universities nevertheless may not be able to afford subscriptions. How did Science get Scihub's server logs? Did scihub give them to Science? It's annoying that the economist is not linking to this supposed Science 2016 publication. If they did, I would have known how to access and read that publication (because I know this one website which would let me read it).
- nickysielicki 9y ago> An analysis of Sci-Hub’s server logs, published in Science in 2016, found its biggest users were people in Iran, India and China. Such middle-income countries do not qualify for the subsidies big publishers provide to users in the poorest nations, but their universities nevertheless may not be able to afford subscriptions. Not every downloader was cash-strapped, though. Americans were the fifth-biggest users. Let's be frank here, the people pirating these papers are capable of understanding them (to some extent or another), and being educated to the point of understanding new-ish papers necessarily implies that a relatively large amount of money is being spent on their education. This isn't entirely/primarily about money. If the main users of this site are using it to get around sanctions placed against their country, the site becomes far less sympathetic in my eyes.
- tonyarkles 9y ago> If the main users of this site are using it to get around sanctions placed against their country, the site becomes far less sympathetic in my eyes. I struggle with this. An opposing perspective is that there's a bunch of students who are trying to do their research and push science forward, but a country (or group of) half-way around the world has decided that they'd rather the student not have access to the world's body of research. I can see merits in both angles...
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Thomas Jefferson, the third president of the United States, described knowl-edge in the following way: “he who receives an idea from me,receives instruc-tion himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me”. In doing so, Jefferson anticipated the modern concept of a public good. Today we recognize that knowledge is not only a public good but also a global or international public good.We have also come to recognize that knowledge is central to successful development. The international community,through institutions like the World Bank, has a collective responsibility for the creation and dissemination of one global public good—knowledge for development." Joseph Stiglitz, "Knowledge as a Public Good" http://s1.downloadmienphi.net/file/downloadfile6/151/1384343.pdf http://s1.downloadmienphi.net/file/downloadfile6/151/1384343... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stiglitz
- watermanio 9y agoThere was a good article on the vast money charged by these journals in the Guardian last week. Although the publishers business does seem pretty robust, there are at least winds of change from universities and governments who fund this research that are finally saying enough is enough... https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-business-scientific-publishing-bad-for-science https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-b...
- jasonhoyt 9y agoIf anyone is interested in a former researcher turned Open Access publisher's observations on the issues: https://twitter.com/jasonHoyt/status/879624241817296896 https://twitter.com/jasonHoyt/status/879624241817296896
- HarryHirsch 9y agoHopefully something charges this time. Last time (i.e. around 2010) the publicity campaign failed. Back then university librarians managed to create some awareness about the extortionate price of journal subscriptions, but that's all they did, prices didn't decrease. The trouble is, there are certain core journals that are really needed and many crap journals. Subscriptions come in packages, i.e. a library can't choose to keep Cell and get rid of Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry, they can only cancel Elsevier altogether. That's why the campaign failed last time, there wasn't a critical mass ready to unsubscribe from everything to convince the publishers to get their act together. Maybe this time, with Scihub, things improve. I predict that Elsevier & friends are going to use their influence on Congress to implement internet filtering at universities to keep Scihub out. It worked for the music/film industry.
- paulftw 9y agoDid someone pull the strings at Economist to publish this editorial in order to respond/damage control the Guardian piece? (obviously it's just my speculation but coincidence is also only one of the plausible explanations)
- SeanDav 9y agoNot many people would mind a company making a small profit from tax-funded research, if they are offering a value-added service, but the scale of Elsevier profits is ludicrous. It is one of the most profitable large companies on the planet. Clearly Elsevier are profiting from their near monopoly in this area and something really needs to be done about them. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-business-scientific-publishing-bad-for-science https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/jun/27/profitable-b...
- skywhopper 9y agoElsevier and others represent a massive and punishing private tax on the basic operation of science and academia. It's a scam but it's so ingrained in academic culture that very few groups of scholars seem willing or able to break away from it. They basically steal copyright from the authors of these papers, they don't compensate the authors or the peer reviewers, but they collect outrageous prices from libraries and individuals for access to already-publically-subsidized research. It's utterly depressing that they continue to exist.
- Jugurtha 9y ago> they don't compensate the authors or the peer reviewers, I suffered reading peer reviewed articles on Elsevier or IEEE with unremarkable results at best, irreproducible results at worst. The title goes "Novel Way of Breaking a Glass", an abstract that describes the methodology as "dropping a file cabinet on it", and the talent (yes, talent) to come to the conclusion that "file cabinets could prove useful in breaking trees or pierce underground bunkers in the future". Are you kidding me, Dr Bozo et al? I've had to wade through hundreds of insipid articles which made my feeling of being stupid more bearable but diminished my respect for many things shrouded with a veneer that come at $35 a pop.
- Robotbeat 9y agoSuper misleading Economist headline and subheading: "Websites offering pirated papers are shaking up science: Musicians and moviemakers are not the only ones to suffer from internet piracy" If you come to this topic from an essentially blank slate, the headline and subheading would make you think that /science/ and /scientists/ are suffering from piracy (in analogy to the claim that musicians and moviemakers are). Except very likely the opposite is true: this piracy offers much greater exposure to scientific literature and enables access to otherwise-inaccessible scientific knowledge for scientists in poorer nations. Unlike musicians and moviemakers, scientists make ZERO money from publication royalties of journal articles but they (or their institutions) have to /pay/ for access to these journals. The only ones making money are the publishers.
- elif 9y agoWell, in deference to the dramatic title, there are also negative consequences and not only those positive ones. For instance: It seems logical that the average quality of science goes down when peer-reviewing is optional. Likewise, corrections and redactions are not guaranteed to take place. The real game change will be if/when pirate publishers force traditional publishers to drop their profit models, and the best of both worlds can be achieved.
- sitkack 9y ago> average quality of science goes down when peer-reviewing is optional where was this claim made?
- kbutler 9y agoYou also need to show that current peer review is happening and is effective at identifying bad science, and that corrections and redactions are currently guaranteed to take place. Both of those are questionable.
- shock 9y ago> Elsevier argues that there is more to publishing than simply shovelling papers online and that work such as editing and arranging for reviews has to be paid for. It's funny how arranging for reviews has to be paid for, but the work of reviewing doesn't.
- jjoonathan 9y agoNot just reviews. Elsevier doesn't fund any of the scientific work, but it didn't stop the article from comparing them to record companies and film studios in the very first sentence.
- ocschwar 9y agoThat really infuriates me. In the fields where I worked, I've had to read dozens of papers by teams from Turkey, China, the Slavic countries, and other places. People whose command of their field was far ahead of their command of English. People who submitted to Elsevier. And whose papers received no amount of copy-editing whatsoever. It was so bad, you could tell the authors' nationality by their grammar errors. Slavs would drop the definite and indefinite articles. Turks would refer to people as "it." Chinese authors would mix plural and singular inappropriately. If they just spent a minimum on copy editing, I would pay the fees on every paper I needed. But they didn't even have the decency to do that.
- libeclipse 9y agoThe irony of this article being behind a paywall.
- hd4 9y agoPastebin (or one of the many variants) should be put to use with anything like this.