8 ms·
Iron deficiency anemia (IDA) has been associated with strokes in young people. IDA doesn't necessarily have pronounced symptoms and a diagnosis with a blood sam
by weinzierl 9y ago
Iron deficiency anemia (IDA) has been associated with strokes in young people. IDA doesn't necessarily have pronounced symptoms and a diagnosis with a blood sample is simple and cheap. It is often considered a "female disorder" but it's only slightly more common in females than males.
tldr: Have your blood checked.
[1] https://www.hindawi.com/journals/crinm/2012/487080/ https://www.hindawi.com/journals/crinm/2012/487080/
EDIT: As most follow up comments seem to center around diet as a cause, I wanted to point out that there are several other causes.
- simonsarris 9y agoVarious deficiencies are definitely a problem in my friend population, where many of them are vegans. The vegan diet is a diet of deficiencies, and since none of them are particularly careful about what they eat, I worry that it is making them all worse off. Iron and B12 may be the most obvious, but also D3, calcium, zing, animal based nutrients like creatine, and I'm sure others. Unfortunately, this becomes a touchy subject with them very quickly, and most of them believe "being vegan is healthier," but are uninterested in engaging with or supporting this claim.
- danenania 9y agoI'm not vegan, but the counterargument I've heard is that an unbalanced omnivore diet can also lead to deficiencies/nutrition problems, and that actually the average vegan diet is more balanced overall than the average omnivore diet, so it's unfair to single out vegans when eating a healthy and varied diet is a challenge for everyone. In other words, you should probably be just as worried about your non-vegan friends who eat too much meat, not enough leafy greens, not enough vitamins, etc.
- ThomPete 9y agoHow can a vegan diet be more balanced? It lacks diversity which as far as I understand is the primary foundation for good healthy diet. Many different things in not too much quantity.
- pmichaud 9y agoStrictly speaking vegan is obviously a more limited subset of omnivore. But in a practical sense, it would surprise me if vegans didn't have more variety in their diet. I was vegetarian for almost a decade, basically my 20s, and what became clear immediately was that I had to figure out different stuff to eat. Default food wouldn't work anymore, so I have to branch out a lot and find foods that I would've never thought about before. I think my experience is relatively common. That having been said, it IS easier to have a deficient diet, if you're not paying attention. "Carbitarian" is what some people call veg-ns who just hork down pasta, bread, and whatever other unhealthy nonfood is technically animal-free. So I think it's possible that veg-ns have a more diverse diet on average, and that they also are statistically more likely to have deficiencies (something like a bimodal distribution). Obviously, these are empirical questions.
- Moto7451 9y agoI think you mean to say that veganism is a subset of vegetarianism? Omnivores by definition eat animal products. I'm typically vegetarian to suit my own wacky body chemistry and slow metabolism (tldr; lowered/normalized my blood pressure, cholesterol, lost weight etc by diet changes and exercise) and would like to underline the point you're making about finding dietary substitutes. Protein consumption was the hardest thing for me to adjust back into nominal ranges. It's pretty easy to overconsume carbs (carbitarianism) on the way to getting the 50-100g of protein needed for a typical semi-active to active day.
- nradov 9y agoHas your slow metabolism been confirmed by lab tests? Many people seem to think they have a slow metabolism but very few actually do.
- Moto7451 9y agoI suppose I don't fit the scientific definition of a slow metabolism. I clock in at around 1800 calories per day, which is within a nominal range. That said, I cannot eat the way the rest of those around me can without gaining huge amounts of weight. I've lost 100lbs and it took a lot of time to figure out that I just can't eat the same as my friends do and maintain a healthy weight.
- scythe 9y agoIt's actually pretty rare to eat too much meat. Meat is expensive, despite subsidies. Unless you deliberately go out of your way to eat lots of meat, you won't be eating that much. Furthermore, the combination of meats, vitamin D-added milk, and enriched cereals, the latter two courtesy of the FDA who have centuries of history fighting malnutrition, and who for example introduced hominy grits to the South to combat pellagra, tends to hit everybody's basic nutrition requirements with the exceptions of dietary fiber, vitamin C, and potassium. While good health is still dependent on eating a variety of vegetables, it's important to give the US food system its due -- it produced pretty good results before the modern Age of Excessive Sweeteners.
- abrowne 9y ago> the FDA who have centuries of history fighting malnutrition Founded in 1906.
- darkmarmot 9y agoWell, 1.11 centuries. It's plural!
- pilsetnieks 9y agoHe mentioned that they're not very careful about what they eat. Regardless of the diet, you have to pay attention to what you're consuming, otherwise you're going to have problems.
- zosophorous 9y agoPerhaps that is true for a vegan diet where you only eat standard American food, but a whole foods plant-based diet has been shown time after time to lower risks for all sorts of diseases, from heart disease to cancer to parkingsons and MS. Iron and calcium are in plants, D is in fact added to milk, and can be added to a plant based diet via a pill as well if you don't synthesize enough. You are an animal; your body creates enough creatine (creatine production is in fact downregulated when you consume meat). B12 can also be added via a pill, and it is already added to many foods like cereal. When you look deeper into the facts, you will see that the Standard American Diet faces far more deficiencies, the most obvious being fiber.
- markeroon 9y agoThis is true, but the bioavailability of non-heme iron is 14-18% of heme iron https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Iron-HealthProfessional/ https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Iron-HealthProfessional/ It makes sense to just eat a balanced diet.
- petre 9y agoAlso zinc and copper is found in animal sources. The only non-animal source for vitamin D is UV exposed mushrooms.
- screye 9y agoThis is surprising to me, as in India a large part of the population is vegetarian. We don't seem to be susceptible to the same problems. The move away from Milk products & Eggs seems to open a huge nutrient gap that the vegan population hasn't adequately identified how to fill.
- akg_67 9y agoActually, there are higher incident of B12 deficiency in Indian vegetarians as found by a study done in late 90s (sorry I don't have specific reference). Indians dont have a practice of regular/ preventive doctor visits, annual checkup and diagnostic testing. They only go to doctor when there are significant medical issues. So these issues are not found until they morph into bigger problems. I have a quite a few younger cousins who died in their 30's. Not a single one ever was tested for cholesterol despite poor eating habits and obesity. Recently I noticed a few startups in India focusing on diagnostic testing. But their user base seems to still be elderly than young people.
- nradov 9y agoThere is little evidence that annual checkups actually produce better health outcomes for people without serious chronic medical conditions.
- simonsarris 9y agoSome vegetarians in developing countries do not have a B12 problem (which also causes anemia) because their food and water are more dirty, and there (B12) bacteria producing. For those vegans at least, their best bet is to accidentally eat enough food contaminated with bacteria or feces to consume decent quantities of B12. Source: The Dietitian's Guide to Vegetarian Diets, 3rd edition, 2011. See page 192. https://books.google.com/books?id=eJ10HoYQ2woC&pg=PA183#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=eJ10HoYQ2woC&pg=PA183#v=on...
- zionic 9y agoThis comment was both disgusting and enlightening. Wow, who would have thought some people derive nutritional value from feces-laden water?!
- alanbernstein 9y agoMost, really? Have you spoken to "most" vegans?
- Retra 9y agoThat's not how statistical inference works.
- gonyea 9y agoI'm not sure Rural and Vegan intersect much. Doubtful this Is the source issue. I'd wager a sedentary lifestyle and stimulants are a major culprit.
- dgacmu 9y ago> The vegan diet is a diet of deficiencies, and since none of them are particularly careful about what they eat First off, B12 is important, but most vegan milk-substitute things have 25% or 50% of the US RDA of B12 per serving. Not all - a lot of almond milk isn't supplemented with B12 (to which i grumble). They're often also iron-supplemented. Here, for example, is the nutrition label for Silk Organic Unsweetened Soy Milk: https://silk.com/sites/default/files/products/nutrition/SK_2443_nleas_OrganicSoyUnsw.png https://silk.com/sites/default/files/products/nutrition/SK_2... Note the vitamin D and calcium in there as well. The FDA is generally clever about the requirements they put on things -- the potential for such deficiencies is well-known, and so is addressed at a few places. Creatine isn't a necessary nutrient - our kidneys and livers synthesize it. Finally, I, at least get a lot of "zing" in my diet by being creative about what we cook. (Sorry, couldn't resist) Zinc, however, you should pay attention to, but eating a diversity of beans and nuts (and tofu) covers it quite well. Seriously, though: It's not hard to have the bases covered. If you're really concerned and not just concern-trolling, sit down with your friends and a copy of Cron-o-Meter, which is one of the most comprehensive meal nutrition profilers around. It's what I used when figuring out the overall layout for our family's meals, and it did lead me to a few cheats -- like favoring molasses as a sweetener, throwing flaxseed in place of part of the flour in a bunch of recipes, etc., to make sure we were hitting all the targets. Useful software.
- taneq 9y agoBeans, nuts and tofu may be 'good' vegetable sources of zinc but they're still awful compared with meat. You'd have to eat 2.5 cups of baked beans every single day to maintain recommended daily intake. (Not concern-trolling, just a vegetarian who was disgruntled to discover how easy it is to become zinc deficient, after specifically asking a GP if I needed to take any supplements, and was told no. I take a 25mg daily supplement now.) Source: https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Zinc-HealthProfessional/ https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Zinc-HealthProfessional/
- ChristianBundy 9y ago> The vegan diet is a diet of deficiencies This is, unfortunately for you, completely fabricated. I'd recommend at least checking Google Scholar before making silly claims on HN. If you'd like to make a claim, cite your source. If you'd like to circlejerk the "vegan is bad, meat is good" fiction, downvote instead.
- lsc 9y agoEh, op is right and wrong. You certainly can get everything you need and be very healthy as a vegan, but... if you eat about what a normal person eats except without the meat and cheese? you are, as they say, gonna have a bad time. As a child, I insisted on being a vegitarian - as long as my parents cooked for me (and were careful to see to it that I had a balanced diet, compete proteins, lots of nutritional yeast, etc... They had spent time as vegetarians themselves, so knew how to do that.) I was quite healthy. After I moved out? I did very poorly, because I wasn't willing or able to put in the effort to see to it that I had balanced nutrition. That's the thing; as a meat eater? There are a lot of ways for me to get complete nutrition (and yes, it comes with a lot of other things that I don't need, but at least I get what I do need.) - so even someone who puts minimal effort into eating a balanced diet is not going to suffer from deficiencies very often, if they eat meat in the traditional manner. (Quite the opposite, really.) If you put the same effort in but avoid all meat and animal products? at least in the place and time where I live? You are probably going to make yourself sick. In a culture where most people eat meat, you need to put in a lot more effort and research in order to avoid deficiencies as a vegetarian. You could argue that this is a truism and that the same could be said for a meat-eater in a culture that just ate vegetables. Most cultures have evolved a traditional set of foods that won't leave you with severe deficiencies of anything, and so if you cut out certain classes of food from that tradition, you need to pay more attention to what you are consuming in order to see to it that you get enough of the nutrients you need.
- cylinder 9y agoDon't forget Vitamin K2.
- velox_io 9y agoThe reason more females have it is because of blood loss from periods (Iron is needed to make up Red-blood cells). I had IDA for over a year. My doctor tried to fix/ mask it with iron supplements, turns out was a coeliac. Which explains why I was constantly felt lethargic/ hung-over. Pro tip: Don't trust everything your doctor says (new Dr suspected it and ordered tests straight away).
- mistermann 9y agoI will second this, many doctors are willfully ignorant and can't even conceive of the notion that a doctor is capable of being uninformed or wrong. I've been having some unexplained medical issues lately and asked for some specialized blood tests and was refused (this being Canada, you go to the doctor with your hat in your hand, begging that they actually take your problems seriously, and if they don't want to help you, you're out of luck.)
- danaliv 9y ago> blood loss from periods ...is a whopping 10-35 mL per period—hardly enough to cause a nutrient deficiency.
- lostlogin 9y agoThe flip side is hemochromotosis, women doesn't necessarily become symptomic while pre menopausal. The blood loss masks/treats it until menopause.
- velox_io 9y ago"In women of reproductive age, periods are the most common cause of iron deficiency anaemia." http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Anaemia-iron-deficiency-/Pages/Causes.aspx http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Anaemia-iron-deficiency-/Pages/...
- agumonkey 9y agotiny warning: if you take iron supplement, you'll shit black (or a very dark shade of gray). Do not panic.
- mistersquid 9y agoSame is true for Pepto Bismol. Someone I knew took some extra strength Pepto Bismol to treat an upset stomach and diarrhea. Her stool ended up turning black, which I advised is a sign of intestinal bleeding. She went to the emergency room and learned that bismuth, the active ingredient in Pepto Bismol, can temporarily turn stool black. [0] [0] https://www.pepto-bismol.com/en-us/faq/black-stool-black-tongue https://www.pepto-bismol.com/en-us/faq/black-stool-black-ton...
- koolba 9y agoWhat do you ask for to have your blood checked? Would whatever tests they do as part of a routine blood tests in a physical include it or is it something separate you'd have to ask for?
- just4themoney 9y agoFirst off, for the record, routine physicals/wellness exams are not evidence based. That being said, theres nothing about routine physicals/wellness exams that are standard. Every doctor/clinician has a different idea of what a routine physical is and many (most?) ignore official guidelines. I've had routine physicals from many different doctors (I've moved a lot) and ever single one of them do something different. One didn't actually touch me other than blood pressure (which was done by a medical assistant) but ordered a ton of "routine" blood work and talked to me a real lot. One listened to my heart, lungs, looked at my eyes, nose, throat, and felt every single one of my organs (that she could) but didn't order any blood work at all. Some call to see me every year some don't call until a few years later. Then there's this nonsense - https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/32293/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/32293/ So absolutely nobody knows what your doctor orders, you'll have to ask them. (Which you should do anyways). Routine screening of individuals without symptoms or other indications can also harm, so caution is warranted: https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/a-skeptical-look-at-screening-tests/ https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/a-skeptical-look-at-screeni... "I would like to be screened for anemia" is what you would say to your doctor.
- dwich 9y agoThe key words would be to ask for an "iron panel". In most US states you can also order one yourself without a doctor's visit, but without much option of having insurance cover it.
- weinzierl 9y agoWhere I live there is a standard blood test, which consists of at least 11 different values. It's a routine thing which is done at at your yearly check-up, but also to check for infections, for example. It is probably similar to a complete blood count (CBC)[1]. I'm not an expert, but from what I understand iron deficiency anemia (IDA) would show in several of these standard blood test values. Not only would Hemoglobin levels be low but also the size of red blood cells be influenced. For a more specific diagnosis of IDA you could ask for ferritin levels, which are not part of the CBC. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_blood_count https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complete_blood_count
- kqr2 9y agoCooking in an iron skillet is an easy way to supplement your diet with iron. http://goaskalice.columbia.edu/answered-questions/does-cooking-cast-iron-pots-and-pans-add-iron-our-food http://goaskalice.columbia.edu/answered-questions/does-cooki...
- askvictor 9y agoCurious, I remember a study a few years ago suggesting a lot of makes in western countries had excessive iron as a result of eating lots of meat and not bleeding.
- nradov 9y agoExcess heme iron from consuming meat is also associated with heart attacks. So too much iron isn't good either. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/04/140423170903.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/04/140423170903.h...
- Danihan 9y agoI _really_ doubt it's an iron deficiency considering how much iron is spammed into every particle of fortified grain within the US, and how much grain the average person consumes overall. If anything, I'd guess that it's too much iron. http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/stroke-risk-linked-to-iron-overload-gene-1.686352 http://www.cbc.ca/news/technology/stroke-risk-linked-to-iron...