12 ms·
AMD Launches Ryzen PRO CPUs
- 0xbear 9y agoIntel CPUs had the various "management" features for over a decade. Does anyone actually use them though?
- yuhong 9y agoWhat is fun is the confusion between DASH and PSP.
- sambe 9y agoSo did AMD CPUs: "For years AMD’s processors for business PCs supported additional security technologies (collectively known as AMD Secure Processor and Platform Security Processor before that) enabled by the ARM TrustZone platform with the ARM Cortex-A5 core. AMD’s previous-gen PRO-series APUs included Secure Boot, Content Protection, per-Application security, fTPM 2.0, and support for Microsoft Device Guard, Windows Hello, fingerprint security, data protection and so on." I honestly don't know who uses them. I've not seen it in finance or health. Government?
- tremon 9y agoTrustZone is not a "management" feature in the sense that Intel AMT is; it is a security feature that can prevent/obscure certain hardware access (basically Ring 0 for peripherals), but does not allow for out-of-band machine access like AMT (although in-band machine access, with the firmware circumventing the user OS is a possibility).
- julian_1 9y agoTrustzone is ARM's hardware access control. But I suspect AMD's PSP which incorporates an on-die ARM core rather than just implement the Trustzone ip, is doing a lot more. Reportedly it can manage DMA actions itself independently of the amd64 core.
- bryanbuckley 9y agoSeems like a catch-22 of adoption. Not worth the effort to develop on unless it is ubiquitous enough? I'm sure there will be growing (security) pains as well. Also not sure exactly how AMD allows development for the PSP (specific vendor keys?).
- TwoBit 9y agoThey wouldn't be selling them unless somebody was buying them.
- beagle3 9y agoThey wouldn't be selling them if the customers had a choice. But the customers don't.
- qb45 9y agoYou have a choice. You need to specifically buy a Q-series chipset to get working AMT. I presume that's a sign some enterprises are buying it or Intel wouldn't bother with Q-series. Another story is that the difference between Q and non-Q may be nothing more than firmware and some ROM bits ;)
- beagle3 9y agoBut ME is everywhere.
- qb45 9y agoME is not a "management feature", it's a general purpose auxiliary CPU used to implement management features and also "consumer features" like DRM. Whether you like it or not, ME is not relevant to the fact that yes, the AMT was developed because some customers actually use it.
- beagle3 9y agoThat very well may be, but you are the only one talking about AMT, and I still can't get a CPU without an undocumented privileged CPU thrown in. If I had a choice, I would not get ME
- qb45 9y agoThe whole thread started with somebody asking whether Intel management features are of any use: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14668965 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14668965 To which you responded that Intel wouldn't be selling them if customers had a choice to which I responded that they absolutely would.
- amiga-workbench 9y agoOnly as a backdoor.
- mtgx 9y agoLet's be fair. It's not used only as a backdoor. There are a few enterprise use-cases for it, too. So, I would say it's mostly used as a backdoor.
- jeltz 9y agoBut does anyone actually use them for that? In the server space people do not and instead use management cards from the server manufacturer, but I have never worked with desktop IT in an enterprise setting. My guess is that enterprise workstations is the intended audience for the IME.
- mschuster91 9y agoI've seen IME (or its more featured server companion iLO) in both servers and workstations for out-of-band remote management. It's really nice from a corporate admin view - you can always make sure machines have latest updates installed, reinstall them when users mess stuff up... and you don't depend on the machine being powered on or a working OS!
- baq 9y agoof course, anyone who has to manage more than a dozen boxen for employees of his $CORP. enterprise computer management is a sanctioned backdoor just as employers are allowed to read your corporate email.
- geezerjay 9y agoExactly. Those boxes were bought and paid for by the corporation. They are the company's property, and they have the right to access them whenever they want. It's a shame that those backdoors then find their way into consumer products, but it's silly to assume that a corporation doesn't have the right to access their own equipment.
- PedroBatista 9y agoNo they don't.
- noir_lord 9y agoExcept legally they do and morally it's debatable. I have no expectation of privacy on a work machine as the company has to protect its IT systems and assets. However I do have in my case since it's a Linux desktop with encrypted disks to which I have the password alone in a company full of Windows machines with an outsourced IT department who couldn't support Linux if I asked.
- sliken 9y agoAnyone heard performance numbers on the encrypted memory? Any change in latency/bandwidth? Would this help protect against malicious thumbdrives stealing keys out of memory? Seems like encryption would disable all DMA.
- 0xbear 9y agoYou don't need encryption to disable USB DMA. IIRC Apple and Microsoft disable DMA in recent versions of their OS when you lock your computer. Don't know about Linux, would appreciate if someone shared the state of affairs there.
- qb45 9y agoWhat's USB DMA?
- 0xbear 9y agoDirect memory access by USB host controller. A good explanation can be found here: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/118854/attacks-via-physical-access-to-usb-dma https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/118854/attacks-...
- qb45 9y agoOK, I see. For the record, USB devices can't simply request the host controller to read or write whatever they want, as it was the case with FireWire and Thunderbolt, which is why people say that "USB doesn't have DMA". The controller will only do DMA to/from OS-specified USB buffers. This SE post says something about DMA in USB 3.1, but I couldn't quickly find any confirmation that something has changed in version 3.1 in that regard. I didn't follow this standard closely, though. However, 3.x controllers usually run firmware blobs of unknown quality and if a device manages to pwn this firmware then it may turn out to be able to access other memory. I think that's what the poster was worried about. I don't think it's possible to "disable USB DMA". At least in case of 1.x/2.0 controllers most of the communication between OS and controller happens through RAM data structures and nothing would work without DMA. The right solution is of course IOMMU.
- thejosh 9y agoStill waiting for the threadrippers, excited to see the benchmarks and if it will be worth buying. Will be using it for mainly developing elixir applications, which use all cores.
- trengrj 9y agoI wonder how Ryzen CPUs will fare in laptops especially around Linux compatibility.
- d33 9y agoCould you elaborate? TBH I don't know much about incompatibilities CPUs can cause in Linux world.
- zdkl 9y agoI'd be concerned about power usage and thermal dissipation, apart from that the Ryzen & co procs look awesome.
- dom0 9y agoZen has shown excellent efficiency figures for both the CPU itself and entire systems. That does not necessarily translate to good mobile systems, but is a good sign.
- kobeya 9y agoI think the implied question was more about system software compatibility. Power management tooling is often vendor specific.
- d33 9y agoThis might sound naive, but shouldn't this be implemented within ACPI/APM? Or does pretty much every CPU family need special code for that anyway?
- tutanchamun 9y agoWhy would you be concerned about power usage and thermal dissipation? Are you concerned the power saving features don't work as good as they could with Linux (like with Skylake? at first)? Otherwise the reviews of the AMD Ryzen CPUs put AMDs 8 core parts around Intels high end 4 core parts [0][1][2][3][4][5][6][7] in terms of power consumptions, which is promising looking at the announced 4 core mobile APUs with Vega graphics. Also nice for thermal dissipation: AMD uses solder for the heatspreader, which helps with thermal dissipation. My only concern would be the idle power consumption since the PCs are idle most of the time, which seems to be ~10 watt higher than Skylake/Kaby Lake due to more power hungry mainboards. But maybe that can be fixed in Notebooks? [0] especially the R7 1700 which seems to run at a sweet spot with 3 ghz base clock. [1] http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-7-1700-cpu-review,5009-8.html http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-7-1700-cpu-rev... [2] https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/ryzen-strictly-technical.2500572/ https://forums.anandtech.com/threads/ryzen-strictly-technica... > 850 points in Cinebench 15 at 30W is quite telling. Or not telling, but absolutely massive. Zeppelin can reach absolutely monstrous and unseen levels of efficiency, as long as it operates within its ideal frequency range. [3] http://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/8081/amd-ryzen-7-1700-1700x-cpu-review/index11.html http://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/8081/amd-ryzen-7-1700-1700x... [4] https://www.bit-tech.net/reviews/tech/amd-ryzen-7-1700-review/6/ https://www.bit-tech.net/reviews/tech/amd-ryzen-7-1700-revie... [5] http://hexus.net/tech/reviews/cpu/103270-amd-ryzen-7-1700-14nm-zen/?page=7 http://hexus.net/tech/reviews/cpu/103270-amd-ryzen-7-1700-14... [6] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=de&ie=UTF-8&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.computerbase.de%2F2017-03%2Famd-ryzen-1800x-1700x-1700-test%2F6%2F&edit-text= https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=y&prev... [7] https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=y&prev=_t&hl=de&ie=UTF-8&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.hardwareluxx.de%2Findex.php%2Fartikel%2Fhardware%2Fprozessoren%2F42250-amd-ryzen-7-1700-im-test-der-interessanteste-ryzen-7-prozessor.html%3Fstart%3D1&edit-text= https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=de&tl=en&js=y&prev...
- lsjdfkljdfwkwdf 9y agoWhy don't AMD focus on server market? How much money is still there for custom PC?
- daxorid 9y agoIt's absolutely astounding to me that anyone could claim, with a straight face, that the PSP "enhances security". The fact that one is not even offered the option of disabling the PSP (or the ME for that matter) tells us everything we need to know about the true purposes of these features.
- illumin8 9y agoIsn't it somewhat like a fuse in an electric circuit? Let's say, for example, that you had perfect overvoltage protection implemented in firmware, and could disconnect the mains quickly enough to prevent damage or a fire. But, the feature is implemented in firmware, which can be modified, so a malicious individual could disable this protection and expose you to risk of damage or fire. By implementing an unmodifiable security feature (like a physical fuse), you minimize the risk of a malicious individual bypassing the protection or security control.
- takeda 9y agoNo, it doesn't work this way. CPU has various modes that are typically switched when booting. It could allow to control it before the system boot without forgoing security. Unless... that "security" is from the users that own it.
- illumin8 9y agoThe security also needs to protect against an attacker that has physical access to the device. This is necessary to prevent things like extracting encryption keys.
- takeda 9y agoOne of things I was taught is that you can't really protect if there is a physical access. Yes, you can make it harder, but that's pretty much it. That's why anyone who is serious have multiple layers of security. Take for example Google data centers, you need access to enter the facility and access to whatever you supposed to work. There are security guards which will follow and stay with you while you are performing your work. The mechanisms in the CPUs are there to protect CPUs from their users. Let say again you are a Google and are planning to use this technology. Why would you trust a third party to decide (by signing) what can run and cannot run on the CPU. What if that 3rd party happens to be your competitor. The issue is that person/company who owns the CPU doesn't have full control over it, they can't load their own certificates and use them for signing. They need to trust 3rd party with it.
- jackmott 9y agoI have to chuckle that the features here are 1. We promise it will work now 2. We will reduce the user's power over their machine
- GoodAdmiral 9y agoDo you guys think these are worth the price premium for home server use? Are they really "better quality" (more margin/tighter silicon screening, etc) or is that part mostly a marketing gimmick?
- CaseInsensitive 9y agoCan the SMT part of a die be defective? I'm just wondering if it's by choice to have SMT-less chips or if it's to recycle chips that have SMT defective.