4 ms·
Software That Predicts a Neighborhood’s Wealth from Space
- amelius 9y agoNext: a software that predicts a person's wealth by looking at them.
- dogma1138 9y agohttp://goldigger.io http://goldigger.io
- m_ke 9y agoI'm sure facebook already does that.
- amelius 9y agoThat would be discrimination. Or is that "ok" nowadays?
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoWhat things are Facebook doing based on their guessed-classification of your wealth?
- amelius 9y agoI guess at least showing me ads. It would be similar to an owner of a brick store directing me to the expensive or less expensive products, depending on my looks, instead of asking "what price category do you have in mind?"
- FLUX-YOU 9y agoThat's not discrimination, you don't have a right to be shown ads targeting the wealthy by using Facebook.
- basseq 9y agoThe crux of your comment is "offense" at the implication (correct or otherwise) that your looks reflect the price category you had in mind, because you can see the alternatives. (What about a shop owner directing you to a gender-specific department based on your looks? What about a shop owner directing you to the jeans section because you're wearing jeans?) You can see the expensive products you're not being offered. Online, you don't see the alternatives. So you're less likely to get offended. But here's the rub. You just don't buy. In a brick-and-mortar situation (if you can get over the offense), you might say, "Actually, I'm looking for a diamond-encrusted Rolex and have the bank account to prove it--nevermind my ripped Slayer t-shirt." And the store could pivot and sell you that Rolex. Online (and this is the difference between sales and advertising), you're not looking for what's being offered (say, a Seiko), so you don't click. You don't even enter the store. They didn't lose a customer: they lost a lead because of bad targeting. And remember that advertising is binary: you you want to buy this [Y|N]? Advertisers would love you to answer questions about your price points and interests, but you won't tell them directly (you won't), so they use what you have told them indirectly about yourself to guess. Online advertising does care about fairness or "segmentation" (read: discrimination). They don't care that you didn't get shown the "expensive products" (that you probably wouldn't buy anyway), and if you happened to have been a potential customer, losing you as a specific lead is just noise if the targeting is 95% right otherwise. Law of large numbers: who cares about you? Now, I want to tweak my targeting, and if it turns out guys in ripped Slayer t-shirts are great candidates for sales of my diamond-encrusted Rolexes, then I update my targeting, and everyone is happy. (Except for the guy who really wants to be offered a Rolex because it would make him feel good... even though he'd never actually buy one.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- learc83 9y agoSince household wealth is highly correlated with race. If they are doing anything that could end up costing people from a protected class money, it could open them up to discrimination claims.
- opportune 9y agoWhat? Is rolex advertising at tennis matches instead of bus stops also discrimination? Because that's essentially exactly what facebook is doing, except online
- learc83 9y agoThe household wealth gap between races is much bigger than the income gap in the US. You could probably get statistically significant results by just basing it on skin tone.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pcunite 9y agoPreoccupation with how wealthy others are is not a good use of your time. Different types of objects and shapes seem to be highly correlated with different income levels. For example, lower income areas tend to have baseball diamonds, parking lots, and large similarly shaped buildings (such as housing projects). In middle income areas we see more single family homes and apartment buildings. Higher income areas tend to have greener spaces, tall shiny buildings, and single family homes with lush backyards. I live within 2 miles of a baseball diamond. What do you think of me now?
- Double_a_92 9y agoDepends on how green the grass is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- blackbagboys 9y agoOf course it's a good use of time. Knowing where the wealth is, and who controls it, is a prerequisite for forcing it to be shared more equitably.
- microcolonel 9y agoCan't tell if you're being facetious or not, but "forcing" the wealth to be "shared more equitably" is a surefire way to generate capital flight. That's alright if your goal is to turn the United States into a giant Venezuela with nukes.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoDo you believe rich people will leave the United States if we taxed them more heavily?
- mmirate 9y agoSuch a thing is only logical for them, yes.
- myth_drannon 9y agoThere is a startup in Montreal that estimates how much solar roof installation will cost based on house photos from space.
- Double_a_92 9y agoWasn't that Google though?
- carlosdp 9y agoYea project Sunroof: https://www.google.com/get/sunroof https://www.google.com/get/sunroof
- didgeoridoo 9y agoThe helipad issue seems pretty intuitive. Personal helipads are so rare that the system probably hasn't seen enough to "learn" that this is a sign of extreme wealth. Virtually all the helipads the system has seen are probably on the roofs of hospitals and inside airports, neither of which is particularly associated with "high income".
- camiller 9y agoI have a different take. If I'm affluent I don't want helicopters landing around my house, too much noise harshing my mellow. So I use my affluence to influence the government to not allow the permits necessary.
- opportune 9y agoEver heard of the Hamptons? It's not about your own personal taste, wealthy people actually do have helipads.
- camiller 9y agoProbably less of an issue for neighbors when the estates are expansive, but dropping a helipad on (as the article suggests) trump tower or amongst the brownstones of NY is probably going to meet some resistance. I did spend a few min panning around the Hamptons in Google maps and didn't see any helipads. Not saying they don't exist, just not ubiquitous even amount the wealthy.
- panic 9y agoWhat is this software supposed to be used for? On their site (http://penny.digitalglobe.com http://penny.digitalglobe.com) they only say they're "hoping to spark a conversation". If it's a critical conversation they're hoping to spark, I wish they would follow projects like White Collar Risk Zones (https://whitecollar.thenewinquiry.com https://whitecollar.thenewinquiry.com) and go further into absurdity to make it clear what they're saying. As it is, it's too easy for someone confused about what "AI" can do to take this seriously as a tool for urban planning.
- edejong 9y agoUser changes small element of '100% confident' data-set followed by a regression to the mean. This sounds like an over-fitted model to me.
- sfifs 9y agohighly likely an overfitted model if such a small change can drive such large variation
- pavement 9y agoNews Flash: computer judges books by their cover, yields opinions regarding stereotypes developed by using statistical methods and correlation as an indicator of likely causation. Up Next: How to use fMRI images of fish brains to determine sentience.