11 ms·
A shift in China to less toxic coatings for containers increases shipping costs
- Nition 9y agoThere's nothing in this article about why the containers need to be painted. Could the shipping companies just paint their logo on rather than painting the whole container and save a bunch of money?
- esturk 9y agoMy guess would be the paint prevents rust.
- tyingq 9y agoLike why they need to be painted at all? Bare steel and a long journey over salt water. They would rust out pretty quickly.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- metafunctor 9y agoA coating of some sort is probably necessary to limit rust and keep the containers is good shape longer.
- tesseract 9y agoMy understanding is that shipping containers are usually made of COR-TEN steel, which forms a protective layer when it does rust (similar to the protective oxide layers that form on aluminum and stainless steel). But considering the containers are exposed to sea salt spray pretty much continuously, it makes sense that the additional protection of a coat of paint is necessary.
- givemefive 9y agoeven if the containers are made with corten, it's not good for sea. The protective rust keeps getting washed off by the rain and the salt is too much for it to handle. Ends up rusting just as bad..
- CalChris 9y agoNo, that's not going to work. CLIMATES NOT TO USE COR-TEN®: COR-TEN® steel requires alternating wet and dry cycles to form a properly adhered protective layer. Areas that have salt laden air, high rainfall, humidity, or persistent fog are typically not the proper environment for COR-TEN®. http://www.corten.com/frequently-asked-questions.html http://www.corten.com/frequently-asked-questions.html
- Animats 9y agoAware of that one. The trail bridge at Pilarcitos Creek on the California Coastal Trail in Half Moon Bay was made of unpainted Cor-Ten steel. That will not last in the coastal zone, where it never dries out. The bridge collapsed when park staff drove a tractor across it.[1] No injuries, but the heavily used trail was out for most of two years. The new bridge is made of marine-grade aluminum. [1] http://www.hmbreview.com/news/groundbreaking-for-coastal-trail-bridge/article_5211eb44-6791-11e5-98ef-bb4dfb1108b4.html http://www.hmbreview.com/news/groundbreaking-for-coastal-tra...
- acomjean 9y agoEspecially in the ocean. A galvanizing zinc paint perhaps to stop rust? I think this is why cars now don't rust as much as they used too. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galvanization
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThat's not why cars don't rust as much. Coatings have just gotten better and simulations have gotten better so engineers can know in advance that all the salty water that runs down the vehicle will be channeled through a few spots that will rust out in short order then do it anyway. Galvanization was popular for a brief time while the industry was still trying to find replacements for lead in paint that didn't have crap performance. Cold galvanization is expensive and involves nasty chemicals. Hot galvanization is cheaper but not as cheap as paint and involves equally nasty chemicals and molten metals. Basically paint is cheap and good enough.
- tyingq 9y agoUnibody construction helps some as well. Less drilled holes, more plastic panels, better sealed seams, fewer dissimilar metals touching.
- GhotiFish 9y agoalso it seems its not the paint that's expensive, but the retooling, so it's a one time cost. really seems much ado about nothing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- virmundi 9y agoAmongst other points, the article says that a water based paint takes 5 times longer to dry than the oil. From a production stand point you have a bottleneck. You now need 5x capacity to dry the containers to stay even with the normal production. Since I doubt they have vertical drying racks, production should slow due to that alone.
- noir_lord 9y agoIt's a classical 'flow shop' scheduling problem. Either you increase the number of 'machines' (lines in this case) or you increase your drying area foot print to compensate. Once you do the latter you can produce at the same rate assuming all products produced are identical) since you the ones coming out the dry end do so at the same speed as the input end. Edit: This does assume production demand is constant, longer pipelines make responding to demand more difficult.
- jhoechtl 9y agoI am pretty certain paintings used for containers have little to none in common with paintings you get at the home improvement store but some observations I have made concerning water vs. oil based paintings: * Water based paintings dry much faster than oil based paintings * The durability is pretty much the same * The scratch resistance of oil based paintings, once fully dried, is light years better than that of water based paintings. In some aspects the green movement has brought us water based colors where you could water your home plants with but are inadequate for some (read: wide) range of application.
- lostlogin 9y ago
- WalterBright 9y agoThe German Me-262 wasn't painted on the inside because it wasn't expected to last long enough to corrode.
- lugg 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_Me_262 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_Me_262 WW2 fighter jet
- jwilk 9y agoNon-mobile link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_Me_262 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messerschmitt_Me_262
- simias 9y agoCompletely off topic but I don't understand why wikipedia doesn't simply select the desktop/mobile version of the website based on the user agent (with maybe the possibility to override the behaviour via a cookie if you really want to use the desktop version on mobile or vice-versa). The number of times I have to manually edit a wikipedia URL every day to remove the ".m" part is getting frustrating. I'm sure there's a browser extension for that but really, I blame wikipedia's poor ergonomics.
- FrozenVoid 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/frozenvoid/wiki/userscripts/wikipedia/wikimobile2desktop https://www.reddit.com/r/frozenvoid/wiki/userscripts/wikiped...
- venning 9y agoMy guess is that this is similar to StackOverflow switching to HTTPS [1]. Once you get to a certain size, something seemingly simple like turning on HTTPS or detecting desktops and redirecting comes with non-trivial problems. I can only imagine all the nuances that have to be addressed when you're serving the fifth largest site in the world [2]. [1] https://nickcraver.com/blog/2017/05/22/https-on-stack-overflow/ https://nickcraver.com/blog/2017/05/22/https-on-stack-overfl... [2] http://www.alexa.com/topsites http://www.alexa.com/topsites
- rangibaby 9y agoI guess, if you want a rusty container
- homelessinsf 9y ago>> "There's nothing in this article about why the containers need to be painted." You're right. There isn't. It's taken for granted that you are aware of the fate of unpainted steel in a salt air environment.
- sigi45 9y agoI read about so colled 'shunts'. Steelplates you put into the earth to protect your construction site for water. It is also partial used on a river side. Those things are not painted and google told me that you can calculate how much is oxidized in a year. I would really love to know how a shipping container is so much more fragile. Perhaps it is not that relevant but in masses it makes a relevant amount of money. Like steel container 20 years and with color 25 years and that makes it just better.
- e12e 9y ago> There's nothing in this article about why the containers need to be painted. Could the shipping companies just paint their logo on rather than painting the whole container and save a bunch of money? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNCb9fzYBEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNCb9fzYBEk
- csours 9y agoSide note: at places like automotive plants where solvent based paints are applied in the US, you are required to "burn" the air to reduce the VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds). If your VOC burner is off, you can't paint cars - the EPA levies a SERIOUS fine, like thousands of dollars a minute. Even with the VOC burner on, paint shops always smell funny.
- tesseract 9y agoI thought the auto industry had mostly already switched to waterborne paints in the past decade or so. (Maybe the changeover is still not complete?)
- csours 9y agoI worked on a changeover in about 2013. I can't speak to much besides that. I've been let to believe there are still some plants running solvent, but those might not be in the US.
- dazc 9y agoWaterborne paints can still contain high levels of VOCs
- csours 9y agoHigh compared to water, but not compared to solvent based paint.
- DannyBee 9y agoErr, 100% false. If you helped with the changeover, you should know this. VOC is not the same as HAPS. (Nor is VOC in any way related to how harmful the compounds are to people) Trivial example: Acetone is VOC exempt in the US. It's pretty trivial to make a 0 VOC solvent based coating using acetone. They tend not to because it's not horribly friendly to use, due to, among other things, how quickly acetone flashes off. In truth, water based or solvent based doesn't really change the VOC level that much these days, nor would it really matter to people. A lot of the auto paints are 2k urethanes. a 2k water based polyurethane is still gonna be isocyanate + something else. It doesn't really matter whether it's 0 VOC or not. You are going to use a supplied air respirator (minimum) because breathing isocyanate is a really bad idea. So the idea, often floated, that lowering the VOC helped people's occupational exposure, is usually unsupported by evidence, at least in the auto industry (i'm only familiar with wood and auto :P). The auto industry did not used to spray water based 2k urethanes. Now they do. Spraying and breathing a post-cat lacquer with n-butyl acetate in it + some acid, is infinitely better for you than spraying + breathing a water based 2k urethane with isocyanate in it. Are there cases it ended up better for people? Sure, of course. But most of that is completely and totally independent of VOC content. Because of course, most coatings manufacturers, surprise, optimized for legal VOC content, often at a cost to harmfulness to humans. Note that, of my professional wood coatings, my water based and solvent based still have exactly the same amount of VOC (2.75lbs). Are there some that don't? Sure. They are mostly crap, because nobody has come up with magic ways to dissolve or emulsify various polymers and catalysts :) So i can't get a water based post-cat conversion varnish that is anywhere near as good as a solvent based one. The chemistry to do it simply doesn't exist. I can get a water based 2k urethane that has as nice (or nicer) properties than that conversion varnish, but at a high possible cost to my health. I'll pass.
- Animats 9y agoWhat happened to the glut of Hanjin containers after the bankruptcy? Those things were piling up in ports around the world.[1] Back in February, creditors were trying to dispose of them. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/hanjin-creditors-fighting-over-who-can-sell-shipping-containers-1487887301 https://www.wsj.com/articles/hanjin-creditors-fighting-over-...
- georgeglue1 9y agoIs there vertical integration in the shipping + container industry? I imagine Hyundai, Maersk, etc. could buy or start some container manufacturers, but it sounded like in the article that they were just going to unhappily deal with it.
- bkor 9y agoMaersk used to produce their own refrigerated containers. I think this has stopped as Chinese manufactures are just way cheaper than doing this yourself. Maybe the highly specific 'super freezer' containers (stuff to transport fish at - 60 Celsius see http://www.maerskline.com/~/media/maersk-line/reefer-cargo/frozen/superfreezer.pdf http://www.maerskline.com/~/media/maersk-line/reefer-cargo/f...) are still created themselves, but doubt it. Regarding this article: either you lease more containers to handle a peak season, or you choose to just have a bigger container fleet. I question if it really makes sense to lease containers only during a peak season. If you already bought those containers last year then increased prices this year doesn't affect things as much as this article pretends: you still have your entire container fleet. Containers yet reused and written off over many years (e.g. 8+.. though just guessing), it is not a one-off activity!
- xbmcuser 9y agoIt feels weird when ever I read stuff where China is doing things to improve or protect the environment where as US is doing the opposite. Like we are living in a mirror world.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoAmerica will catch on eventually.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoI moved from china (Beijing) to the USA (LA) for the much cleaner air. Ya, parallel universe for sure, it's like comparing mordor to the shire, where the former is freaking out over its horrible pollution problem while the latter doesn't notice anything wrong.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y agoPeople in LA, and Californians in general do care about pollution. After all, it is one of the birthplaces of the modern environmental movement in the US. Despite its urban sprawl, LA has one of the lowest emissions per capita in the US, lower than nyc even. The pollution tends to accumulate due to it's geography, being that the city is in a basin instead of dispersing. Tear down the Santa Monica and San Gabriel mountains, and the air quality would be greatly improved.
- nerdponx 9y ago
- brianwawok 9y agoExcept it had no day to day change for 4 years. And he wont be here in 4 years.
- chronic61a 9y agoOf course Trump will be reelected. Just as the US president has alternated between Republican and Democrat for the past 50 years, each time a president is in office, they assume two full terms. Don't believe me? Well Trump got elected. And he'll will again. Bernie Sanders won't even win the Democratic primary in 2020. Hindsight is 20/20, don't you know?
- pc86 9y agoGeorge HW Bush. Jimmy Carter. LBJ. Hoover, if you don't mind going back nearly a century. And before you say "well that's just three examples!" there have only been 45 presidents in 250 years. Just about the only presidential thing you can get dozens of examples of is white men. I'm not sure how "Well Trump got elected" is any proof of your "parties alternate 2-term presidents" thesis. I doubt Sanders will run in 2020, but I don't pretend to know what will happen in the future.
- mikeash 9y agoYou should add Nixon to that list, since they said two full terms, and Nixon's example may well be followed again. Gerald Ford belongs on that list too. In fact, only four of the ten most recent former Presidents served two full terms. (JFK is something of a different category, of course.)
- melling 9y agoCarter and Bush both lost because the economy was in a recession during their final years. Bush might have won if the economy had pulled out quicker. LBJ did not run for reelection. If the economy is doing well, it is quite possible for Trump to be reelected.
- eganist 9y agoIt's like this account was made by a bot which just googles political terms and then astroturfs the opposing viewpoint. It's so irrelevant to the rest of the conversation. lol
- contingencies 9y agoAccording to a factory I discussed painting options with in Dongguan (near Shenzhen) recently, local environmental pollution regulations have made traditional approaches to anodized steel powder coating (my inquiry) effectively illegal. The processes are still 'available' through amorphous parties (no discussion of distance or environmental regulation legality). However, that's coming from a factory so take it with a grain of salt. My takeaway, if any, would be this is part of a broader shift toward stronger environmental protection efforts led by forward-thinking regional governments, not Beijing.
- jobu 9y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I thought Beijing sets the broad emissions/pollution targets and then leaves it up to the regional governments to decide how to make it happen. If the regional leadership does well they get rewarded, and if they fail they get replaced.
- devy 9y agoAll these labor intensive jobs that involve exposure to toxic chemicals should ALL BE replaced by industry robots, no?
- hmahncke 9y agoFTFY, Bloomberg: "A shift in China toward less toxic coatings for containers has shifted costs from health care costs for employees to shipping costs for customers"
- dang 9y agoOk, we inserted 'shipping' above.
- hmahncke 9y agoThanks! My comment was more directed at the Bloomberg article and authors, which institutionally see situations like this as a "cost increase" because they don't consider the existing environmental/ health consequences to workers as a "cost" (but of course it is). But I appreciate you taking my comment seriously.