11 ms·
Infarm wants to put a farm in every grocery store
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoI can see this playing well with the doomsday bunker crowd. And even before we get to that point, a distributed agricultural system would help lessen our reliance on large-scale industrial farming operations which we are frankly not using at a sustainable (1,000+ years) rate.
- jfim 9y agoKeep in mind it doesn't get rid of the centralized petroleum-based fertilization, so you're still dependent on large-scale industrial petrochem for fertilizer production.
- strictnein 9y agoJust tap into the store's bathrooms and presto! free fertilizer.
- mobilefriendly 9y agoThat's true but with this controlled environment the amount needed could be highly targeted...think drip irrigation.
- chris_t 9y agoWhat is it about current agricultural practices that makes them unsustainable? I know there is a reliance on fossil fuels, but that seems like it could be overcome in the long term (1000 years) without needing to move to a decentralized system.
- vkou 9y agoTopsoil loss [1] and aquifer depletion. This happens with decentralized farms, too. The problem is not in the kind of farm, but with the techniques used. Tractor tillage increases yields, but is hell on topsoil. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/only-60-years-of-farming-left-if-soil-degradation-continues/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/only-60-years-of-...
- chris_t 9y agoInteresting, thank you. Aquifer depletion seems like a modest problem on a 1k year scale, there's plenty of water around generally. But I hadn't heard of topsoil depletion before; I wonder how difficult it will be to produce it artifically? It sounds like something that will soon be in demand.
- vkou 9y agoThere's plenty of water, but aquifers are tend to be tapped in areas with insufficient rainfall/access to rivers. If you're drawing on the aquifer faster then it replenishes, it'll eventually run out. Sure, it'll replenish itself - eventually - but the land you were cultivating will be unusable for decades. In the meantime, all of your nice topsoil will turn to dust, and blow away.
- schiffern 9y ago>I wonder how difficult it will be to produce it artifically? It's easier to conserve the soil that's already there than to make new soil. That said, there are techniques to increase the production rate of soil. Sheet mulching can create 4 inches of topsoil out of waste organic matter in 2-5 years (compared to thousands of years for natural processes). Generally it's better to make soil "in place" because moving it breaks up important soil structures, leading to oxidization and nutrient loss. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheet_mulching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheet_mulching http://tobyhemenway.com/resources/how-to-the-ultimate-bomb-proof-sheet-mulch/ http://tobyhemenway.com/resources/how-to-the-ultimate-bomb-p...
- yongjik 9y agoMaybe I lack imagination, but I have a hard time visualizing a doomsday prepper walking down an isle at Trader Joe's, looking for a pot of fresh organic basil. "Damn nuclear apocalypse, it's been weeks since I had fresh basil! How can I feed my militia if I can't even bake a pizza?"
- shortstuffsushi 9y agoThey're still people that enjoy flavor, and a basil plant is pretty "easy" in terms of adding flavor to any food.
- EGreg 9y agoI support decentralizing many things. Energy generation Cellphones Social media As farming can now be done in 3D, this may become a good idea. My main concern is city pollutants getting caught in the plants.
- rosser 9y agoI think these racks were intended to be used indoors, in climate-controlled environments. I'd imagine at least token air quality management wouldn't be too difficult or expensive to add, and that's all you'd need to beat, e.g., an urban backyard garden...
- mtalantikite 9y agoI spent a lot of time thinking about and researching vertical farming a few months back, even going as far as to start prototyping out a system, and while I love the vision for the future, I'm wondering how this ends up being profitable for those doing it. As LED prices continue to fall it starts making more sense, but can you really compete with the Sun and industrial agriculture on price? How many of these units would you need to install to meet demand at my grocery store up the street here in Brooklyn? I think we forget that a huge amount of automation already exists in the agricultural supply chain. I'd love to see it work since you can reduce water and pesticide requirements, which is great for the environment. I'm just skeptical that you can be more than a basil and microgreens service for yuppies.
- ilaksh 9y agoSeems like it should be possible to let the sunlight into part of the store.
- kingbirdy 9y agoIt also reduces transportation costs, and cuts out the farmer's profit margin, and any other middlemen between them and the grocer
- mtalantikite 9y agoThat's certainly true, but then you have to add back in the cost for LEDs, land space, and labor for harvesting. A retailer is going to be required by local laws to pay at least minimum wage, which is often higher in urban centers than out near farms. Also, unfortunately quite a lot of farm labor is exploited and only paid per pound harvested and not even paid minimum wage. There are lots of horrifying stories about the treatment of migrant laborers, which we all should be more aware of and demand more protections for. I totally support the vision and want to see this work, but I'm really not convinced it makes economic sense (I'd be happy to be proven wrong though).
- kingbirdy 9y agoIt seems like the harvesting is done mostly by customers, or at the least by existing grocery employees, and land space would just replace the existing produce section - light and water and licensing the tech seem to be the main costs
- ilaksh 9y agoRight idea, but basil leaves is not a farm. I think for this type of thing to really change things, they need to concentrate on calories and nutrition. Things like peanuts and potatoes. I also think there is some room for permaculture. Such as replacing ornamental city landscaping with productive food forests.
- mrspin 9y agoThey do more than basil, it was just the example I used in the opening, also other greens and even some fruit.
- maxerickson 9y agoWhat's your definition of "work" there? They need to make stuff that grows fast and has a relatively high price. Potatoes and peanuts don't particularly match either of those criteria.
- apendleton 9y agoRight, and also stuff that doesn't keep well anyway. Seasonality or needing to ship quickly to avoid spoilage aren't problems for potatoes either; if well-climate-controlled they keep for months.
- Animats 9y agoThis probably works only for items where there's a huge markup. It's like those little indoor trays of growing grass seen at some hipster sandwich shops. The article suggests they want to grow basil. This was tried in LA in 2015.[1] Not sure what happened to "Green City Farms", but their last Twitter activity was in 2015 and their web site says "Error establishing a database connection". [1] https://www.fastcompany.com/3044958/this-hollywood-restaurant-grows-your-food-next-to-your-table https://www.fastcompany.com/3044958/this-hollywood-restauran...
- devoply 9y ago$20 for a spring of basil plant grown in your local grocers, though sounds very expensive, there is probably almost definitely a demographic for that. And it does not go stale, you can keep it there indefinitely. What is likely to happen though is that it gets commercially farmed and then is brought to the store after it has reached a certain size. Totally destroying its purpose but there is a market for this sort of thing.
- mobilefriendly 9y agoMy wife buys live, potted basil plants all the time from a mainstream US grocery store. I don't think she pays more than $5 or $6.
- joshvm 9y agoThat is staggeringly expensive. In the UK you can buy a pot of basil for about $2 in most of the big supermarkets. Often it's more economical to buy a large plant than it is to buy a small bag of cut basil...
- syphilis2 9y agoAn automated indoor herb garden would be neat, but what does the cost curve look like compared to shipping traditional potted herbs? I was offput by the article mentioning flying basil thousands of miles, but maybe that's my bias since stores in the US usually carry potted basil plants. Taking care of the hydroponic stack might be as simple as changing a cartridge now and then, but how much does that cartridge cost and where does it have to be flown in from? Clearly stores and investors are buying into this, so I must be missing some information. Or I'm overly skeptical because I dislike the idea. But how much do these store grown herbs cost?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThe next decade of incremental farming improvements is mostly going to be built on the back of grow-op technologies and techniques going mainstream. Some of them will be more successful than others.
- kefka 9y agoWell.. I could see a path forward, but it would be quite a bit of CNC like automation. Primarily, I can see a hydroponics setup being used with a Farmbot.io style automation. With this, a bot would zip up and down powered rails, and use Wifi to communicate with the base station. Buckets would be provided for the toolhead to pull plants done growing. Ideally, this could be used to grow herbs, lettuces, and the like on huge racks. Of course, in the jurisdictions that allow it, could be modified for cannabis as well. The long and short, is that machine vision can be utilized to determine the fitness of a plant and its finished growing season. Add tilapia to this and you have a near closed-loop biological system. And then you can also sell fresh live tilapia. To give an example, 25 sq ft of this system provides enough food for a human indefinitely. This also localizes food production thus strengthening national food security. And this one is what wins a lot of conservative types who want to see a gain rather than "feed the fuzzies" kind of reasoning.
- bsder 9y ago> Of course, in the jurisdictions that allow it, could be modified for cannabis as well. I suspect this is the actual reasoning and target product. Unfortunately, you can't get funding for that legally in most jurisdictions.
- kefka 9y agoWell, yeah. Shrooms and Weed are the two I could think of that would easily support hydroponic grow systems. Ideally, I could see them taking off in the Southwest, given intensity of the sun and win power. The only thing that would really cost is water, and that should be closed-loop as much as possible. I'd wonder if some of the new metal-organo-frameworks could efficiently get water from the air as they were reported to do. But republicans are still moralizing christians that wish to force their ideals upon others. Because if anything's been shown, cannabis is one hell of a tax generator and mucho underutilized commerce. But aside this illegal usage in most jurisdictions, this could suffice growing in bad environments or to people with way too much money to spend. There could be a different segment; people who want guaranteed food supply. And locally, this could make food safety a guarantee. I could also see this as a non-profit as well, with low income and homeless getting free access.
- peterjlee 9y agoThis may work for a few Whole Foods customers who pay $5 for a bottle of herb infused water but I wonder if the cost is going to be reasonable enough for most people. Real estate cost alone may trump every other cost savings. Even if that "farm" can produce 10x more per square foot from vertical farming, the real estate cost of a grocery store in a city is a lot more expensive than a farmland in the middle of no where.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoMaybe it would be available to Amazon Prime or even an add on paid service to prime. Also they would target areas similar to their two hour delivery.
- TheIronYuppie 9y agoBut what if the store could produce its own plants at 1/10th the cost of purchasing them elsewhere (just light and water)? It's not like they don't already have floor space taken up with plants today - they just buy them from elsewhere.
- aetherson 9y agoThey "only" cost "light and water" elsewhere, too (actually, obviously, far more than just light and water). Do you think that 90% of the wholesale cost of produce is transportation costs? If so, why do you think that?
- peterjlee 9y agoThe plants taking up space in the grocery store have a pretty fast turnaround time while these basils will take few weeks to grow. Though I guess they could have these "farms" in some cheap warehouse then move it to the grocery store only when they're ready. Ok, this seems a bit more viable now.
- apendleton 9y agoThese are hydroponic systems, so it'll be distilled water, power for high-intensity grow lights (where stuff grown outdoors, at least in-season, gets this from the sun), nutrient solution (in an outdoor context, some of this would be "free"-ish, from soil, and some would be from fertilizer), plus lifetime-amortized costs of the grow setup: pumps, filters, etc. And all of that besides the water you'd have to ship anyway from wherever it's manufactured. Granted, if we're talking lettuce, it's like 95% water by weight anyway, and a decent percentage of what's left is carbon that's fixed from the air, so there's probably a shipping savings, but I still don't think this whole setup would be particularly cheap.
- russdill 9y agoAlright, there are 37,716 grocery stores in the US and 321.4 million residents. That's about 8500 people per grocery store. According to this: https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1aozn1/how_much_land_does_it_take_to_support_one_human/ https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1aozn1/how_much... The minimum amount of farmland per person assuming a vegetarian diet is about 0.17 acres. This comes out to a land area of a little more than 2 square miles per grocery store. Your average grocery store is 46,000 square feet. So if you did stacked farming on the area of the grocery store, you'd only need a about 1400 levels. Give 2 foot per stack, and your grocery store is only about a half mile high.
- TheIronYuppie 9y agoI don't disagree that something about the equation has to change. I think that "thing" is the 0.17 acres. According to this webpage[1], the productivity of a vertical farm is 11x greater than a horizontal farm. But, that said, I don't think a complete replacement is necessary for this to be significantly beneficial even on a subset of grown plants. [1] http://stateofindoorfarming.agrilyst.com/ http://stateofindoorfarming.agrilyst.com/
- inetknght 9y agoTo replace the entire food chain, sure.
- ratsz 9y agoSeems like this could be beneficial for areas with religious-based dietary restrictions.
- carlob 9y agoI've seen supermarkets sell live basil plants for the past 20 years (probably even earlier but I wasn't paying attention) in multiple countries. Maybe they just picked the wrong example to start the article?
- microcolonel 9y ago> internet-controlled irrigation and nutrition system Why? What happens when the network drops out on your basil cabinet? Is there any reason not to just put the logic inside the thing? Other than that, I can see this functioning pretty well for large suburban grocery joints if it's limited to herbs. In fact, I seem to remember seeing something approximating this at a Canadian grocery store, I don't remember where.
- web007 9y agoThis looks like a variation of FreightFarms https://www.freightfarms.com/ https://www.freightfarms.com/ - they've been doing this for 2 or 3 years now.
- rojobuffalo 9y agoIt will be cool to see advancement in this area and any potential cross-over with tech research for Martian and space agriculture.
- santiagobasulto 9y agoIt can't get more hipster than this
- sapote 9y agoThis is a terrible idea. Growing plants sustainably requires soil and sun. And good tasting produce requires both. Two minutes thought about it from a whole-systems perspective, and maybe a bit of common sense, would have told them that this was a terrible idea. A few reasons to get things started: * Pests go nuts in indoor farming operations like this. You have to spray to stay on top of them. There's no natural ecosystem present, so natural predators don't take care of your pest problems. Also, plant metabolism changes to adapt to pest problems, and such systems are typically "precision" agriculture oriented, where the plants' needs are reduced to a small set of easy to distribute soluble elements. * Soil composition and biology influences produce flavor. There's a reason vineyards care a lot about soil. * Energy efficiency of such an operation is far below that of an outdoor farm -- just think about the number of energy conversions and the infrastructure needs (and its embodied energy) of this sort of operation. * The most local basil is one that you put in a flowerbed next to your kitchen window.
- spraak 9y agoIt's true. As much as we want to use technology to make our lives better, this isn't the way. There are much better ways to innovate that still involve real soil and sun.
- Tharkun 9y agoI mostly agree with what you're saying. Not sure whether vineyards are such a good example though. Isn't wine one of those things where even "experts" can't taste the good from the bad? That being said, some vegetables need to be kept away from sunlight (flemish endives come to mind). This could probably work quite well for those.
- Intermernet 9y ago> Isn't wine one of those things where even "experts" can't taste the good from the bad? Experts can't really reliably tell the good from the mediocre, but bad wine is pretty obvious to anyone, and certainly has a lot to do with soil type and quality.
- ciconia 9y ago
- theprop 9y agoThis is HUGE. What's much more interesting is not getting this into grocery stories but into homes. Delivery costs and spoilage represent something like 40% or so of produce costs, maybe more. So in theory it would be much more efficient if you could grow your own vegetables and fruits at home. Right now, only a few things like basil can be grown this way, but probably in time, we can via "breeding" have many other fruits and vegetables that can be grown on a smaller scale in the home. I personally like this because of trust...I don't want pesticides in my food and I don't trust organic farmers markets who probably just bought their produce at a local grocery store then mark it up double for me ;-D. So I'd much rather grow myself if it was easy enough to do.
- FrozenVoid 9y agoIts actually pretty neat if somewhat expensive. 1.It saves transporation/labor costs. 2.Allows to monitor/control plants 24/7 3.Immune to all weather conditions/theft/birds I imagine it would be available to individuals too: allowing people in cities to grow personal food indoors, without any gardens. The potential of this "digital agriculture" is huge, since it allows to control 'natural environment' variables.
- brad0 9y agoThis makes zero sense. Even if you choose very specific items that can be grown in a constrained environment it's going to cost too much to run. Grocery stores make next to no margin on their sales - by adopting this they will have to charge more than their competitors. Which means they won't get sales. --- EDIT On top of this, there is not the physical space to do this at the scale you need. Do you know how often shelves are restocked, especially in the UK where stores are tiny? How are you going to fit your equipment in such a constrained environment.