17 ms·
A lot of fuss, but if you look at the presentation slide in the middle of the page (https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-PyyPpTv1p7g/WU7hMEBnm4I/AAAAAAAAEZ0/IZSBv4d5G1kV2
by znpy 9y ago
A lot of fuss, but if you look at the presentation slide in the middle of the page (https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-PyyPpTv1p7g/WU7hMEBnm4I/AAAAAAAAEZ0/IZSBv4d5G1kV2rCkpA-DziMB_4o2ri0RQCLcBGAs/s640/MITNAT-Slide.png https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-PyyPpTv1p7g/WU7hMEBnm4I/AAAAAAAAE... for reference) it is clear that MIT is not stifling anything or shutting anyone's mouth.
MIT is just moving to IPv6.
Actually... MIT forcing an entire generation of future engineers to deal with IPv6... That will literally push innovation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hawkling 9y agoMoving IPv4 to NAT and moving to IPv6 seems orthogonal.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jccooper 9y agoNot if you're selling your IPv4.
- sargun 9y agoWhy do you say that? They're converging with the way the rest of the world* does things. *Consumer, and Enterprises in the US
- p1mrx 9y agoIPv6 is the standard way to preserve end-to-end connectivity when IPv4 NAT breaks it. You're free to see these as orthogonal problems, but if enough people think as you do (moving IPv4 to NAT without first deploying IPv6), then the Internet as we know it is dead.
- cma 9y agoOn the other hand, selling its IP4 blocks may do more to slow down the move to IPv6.
- hawkling 9y agoIndeed! If anyone needs to feel the squeeze for IPv4 to make a move to IPv6, it is AWS... which MIT is conveniently selling the IPv4 addresses to!
- srcmap 9y agoSometime, I felt force all IOTs devices, typical laptops, Phones, behind NAT is actually safer for internet as whole. Security via network segmentation. IMO, NAT gateway is good place to lock down and put in network security appliance to track/block all the unwanted connections.
- kazen44 9y agoexcept NAT does neither network segmentation or lock down the network. Those things are done by a router and firewall. Implementing proper security of IoT devices can be solved by A) writing more secure software for IoT devices and B) having a proper firewall solution with sane defaults. Using NAT as a tool to masquerade your IP addres is not secure. see NAT hole punching for example [1] NAT is terrible from a network engineering perspective, it was mostly a patchwork to deal with the rapid expansion of the internet and the shortage of IPv4 space. IPv6 brings a lot of cool technology to the table in, like MTU path discovery[2], header extensions[3] and proper anycast[4]. It also makes dealing with subnets and network segments a lot more sane and scalable. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hole_punching_(networking) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hole_punching_(networking) [2] https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc1981 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc1981 [3] https://www.cisco.com/en/US/technologies/tk648/tk872/technologies_white_paper0900aecd8054d37d.html https://www.cisco.com/en/US/technologies/tk648/tk872/technol... [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anycast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anycast
- CamperBob2 9y ago
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 9y ago> Actually... MIT forcing an entire generation of future engineers to deal with IPv6 Then why are they doing NAT? Edit: Although moving to NAT might push innovation too, or at least some clever hacks. Speaking of that, if you want use a relay to do NAT traversal then is TCP over ARQ (on UDP) as bad as TCP over TCP?
- ajross 9y agoThey're doing NAT for IPv4. The IPv6 network space listed in the slide is publicly routable and almost certainly untranslated. It's possible it's firewalled though.
- kevin_b_er 9y ago> Then why are they doing NAT? Because they sold their IPv4 addresses.
- hawkling 9y agoIndeed! The only reason they're doing this is clearly that they want to sell even more IPv4 addresses. Because even with the current /9, it's more than enough to go around the campus.
- pdonis 9y ago> MIT is just moving to IPv6. The "just" is incorrect. There are four bullets on the slide: DHCP, IPV6, private IPV4/NAT, and firewall. From the diagram it looks to me like even if you move to IPV6 (which, as others have noted, MIT has not yet rolled out, so at this point you can't), you will still be behind the firewall, so setting up a service visible to the Internet will still be more difficult than it used to be.
- Animats 9y agoMIT doesn't have IPv6 everywhere yet? That's lame.
- ocschwar 9y agoMIT just sold off half of its class A subnet. MIT was always going to be the last place on earth to go total IPv6
- rspeer 9y agoThe post isn't objecting to the firewall, though. I totally understand the need for a campus-wide firewall. The MIT network is a juicy target for botnets, and individual students are not good enough at running security on their own computers. The old approach to IP assignment was that you needed to get your IP approved and made routable by IS&T anyway, and if they detected botnet activity on your computer, they'd manually intervene and make it unroutable again. That sounds like a lot of work. If computers end up with firewalled but publicly routable IPv6 addresses, that sounds perfect.
- dheera 9y agoNo. IPv6 is great in concept but the world just isn't ready for it yet. Even our Google Wifi access points don't support IPv6 in their latest firmware, so I have no way of using IPv6 even though Comcast supports it. AWS IPv6 support has been sketchy until only this year. Many parts of the world are happily dancing with their IPv4 NAT and their sysadmins have no incentives to support IPv6 whatsoever. Forcing people to use anything is never a good way to promote innovation. I went to MIT for my undergrad and doctoral studies. One of the main reasons I chose MIT over other schools was the ease of availability of static IP addresses, unlimited symmetric gigabit bandwidth, no port restrictions, and other things. I even mentioned this in my undergrad application essay. I built a lot of things with it and learned a lot in my time there. I probably learned more outside of classes than in classes, and I think that's one of the distinguishing aspects of MIT culture.
- deprave 9y agoGoogle is known to be against new and safe technologies. Google Finance still uses Flash, and Android has the worst IPv6 support despite it being based on Linux. What's your point?
- eightysixfour 9y agoI am almost positive I saw IPv6 in the release notes for the latest Google Wifi app update, am I crazy?
- compuguy 9y agoYou are correct: http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/06/22/google-wifi-onhub-update-adds-ipv6-support-new-features-apk-download/ http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/06/22/google-wifi-onhub-up...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dheera 9y agoThanks! I enabled IPv6 on my Google Wifi router. I see a Global inet6 addr in my ifconfig. IPv6 websites work. I can ping6 my machine from the outside. I can ssh -6 into my machine from other machines on the LAN. But unfortunately I still cannot ssh -6 into my machine from an outside computer. It probably is firewalling all incoming IPv6 connections (?). The Google Wifi app has no settings about this. Googling and stackoverflowing for 10 minutes didn't find a solution. That's when I give up. Sorry Google and the IPv6 community but I have more important things I need to be working on than dealing with this BS that never works the first time. Back to IPv4 and port forwards, which is working fine for me right now, and will let me get back to my work. :-/
- anderskaseorg 9y agoYes, yes, it’s been three months since the provost triumphantly announced that IPv6 will finally be coming to the campus network, and communication about IPv6 on campus goes back much longer than that, but we have yet to see it in a single building (beyond the buildings where students have set up their own tunnels, and who knows if those will even work with the new network). Meanwhile, the NAT was deployed in twelve buildings with same-day notice and no prior communication, leaving some student groups with unreachable servers. If this had anything to do with pushing innovation, don’t you think the priorities and communication pattern would have been a bit different?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]