14 ms·
On Starting a Software Business
- Kiro 9y ago> legal fees What is this referring to exactly? Administration fees for starting a company?
- trevyn 9y agoSounds like LLC formation fees, yeah.
- chrisvalleybay 9y agoIt might also include fees for accounting work etc. which could possibly be considered a legal fee
- jwildeboer 9y agoLegal help in drafting contracts with customers, license agreements for the product etc.
- skybrian 9y agoI'm wondering about how they draw the line between "give first, take later" and "don't do work unless you're getting paid for it."
- cies 9y agoHow I understood it: > "give first, take later" This was when they were looking for leads. > "don't do work unless you're getting paid for it." That was in the context of the product they were selling. A choice not to work on the product when there is not a customer paying you to do so. I can imagine they chose to operate like this because it is very easy to sink many hours into perfecting a product that does not have paying customers. I believe they will step away from this rule later when they have so many customers that they want to develop ahead of payments.
- thomk 9y agoIf you get free advice to someone, that is the giving part. It also is an area you know so you can speak with authority on the subject. The minute you are actively helping them (you are touching a computer or phone) that's when you should be getting paid. I would also cut off the advice giving at a certain point and bring up money.
- bluedino 9y agoI'd like to hear more specific experiences on switching from working for free to $CONSULTING_RATE for the same client I helped a local business group with their website, their previous host shut down and all they had was an archive on CD, they had some quotes for 10-20 hours to get it back up and running (and then everyone wanted to charge them hosting/domain registration). I did the work for free. A couple hours importing databases and site files, configuring WP/Joomla (I forgot which), some testing... My hope was that I'd get a few leads from the 50-60 companies in the business group. I was contacted by a few but once they found out I wouldn't do the work for free...
- Silhouette 9y agoThis is an example of a more general problem with undercharging (or doing spec work) in any creative industry. If you don't charge what you're worth, perhaps because you're trying to be helpful or offering "mate's rates", then you may get one happy client but you'll also get underpaid. Then that client will happily recommend your (excellent value!) services to their friends and colleagues who are also looking for (excellent value!) services and will be happy to similarly underpay you. And so it goes on. In my experience, there are really only two levels of pricing that work. You can work literally for free, or for some token payment so someone is an official client of your business. This is sometimes helpful very early in a business to start some sort of portfolio and establish a bit of credibility, but otherwise I think it should be reserved for genuine charity work where it's clear that it's a gift and not your normal working practice. Everything else should be charged at decent professional rates immediately, both so you don't undersell yourself and to dissuade potential clients who can't or won't pay decent professional rates and all the other similar potential clients in their network.
- user5994461 9y ago>>> dissuade potential clients who can't or won't pay decent professional rates and all the other similar potential clients in their network. Agree. Keeping cheap and non paying clients AWAY should be a top priority for any business. In consulting, that's achieved by ALWAYS charging and being clear about your rate.
- shubhamjain 9y agoThere is a bit of detail missing that I would like to understand. How to just 'talk' and give help? Do you approach people/businesses and ask if they are having any problems? Or, your aim is to just get the conversation ball rolling, hoping that it leads to the problem part without deliberation?
- chii 9y agoi have a friend who is a construction contractor, and one of the tasks they needed to do is inspection of a property, and take pictures of problematic areas with notes. Currently, this is a manual process, paper driven with digital photos, and after wards, somebody back in the office would transcribe the hand written notes into an excel spreadsheet along with pics. This process could be made easier with an automated app on the phone. I had thought about making such an app, but haven't yet. I guess when you talk to someone, you naturally gravitate towards issues they have.
- floogtheunfound 9y agoIt exists; was at a Founders pitch day for new Seattle startups recently and the winner was a company using drones and sensors along with chat features. I’m pretty sure it was called something like “Unearthed” or something. I’m not sure if they got inspired by a similar interaction with acquaintances or not but it seems reasonable
- tacostakohashi 9y agoThat app is called Evernote / OneNote / Google Keep - incrementally improving their process using off the shelf software is likely to be more practical than a custom app. Where is your contractor friend based? I am looking for a contractor, or some contacts, for a job now.
- Silhouette 9y agoimproving their process using off the shelf software is likely to be more practical than a custom app That really depends on context. Very often something starts out sounding like "document with text and pictures" or "database with some tables in it and some forms for UI", making it an easy job with generic business software. However, often when you look at the details the actual requirements are more complicated and require some level of domain-specific functionality. There are many applications that are aimed at a certain industry and provide some core function that seems quite generic but then some other more industry-specific functions on top. That certainly includes tracking, displaying and annotating specifications and inspection results in the construction industry, where there are multiple players in the market already.
- westoque 9y agoInteresting about the 50-50 split. If you talk to most people in the valley, they would probably tell you this is the worst thing you can do. That is, if you're looking from the perspective of a VC.
- dahart 9y agoYCombinator advises equal splits. https://blog.ycombinator.com/splitting-equity-among-founders/ https://blog.ycombinator.com/splitting-equity-among-founders... I've also read a bunch of articles that suggest unequal splits, and the reasons they cite seem to boil down to the idea that the split should reflect the proportional risk taken, and not much else. There are times when founders truly take the same amount of risk, and an even split is justified under the common VC thinking. In my limited experience pitching to VCs, as someone in an even-split startup, I believe VCs do prefer to have a primary person responsible who is in the CEO seat and has authority to make unilateral decisions. I can imagine an uneven split makes it clear when that's the case. I'm certain many of them have seen cases where even split partnerships were made more difficult and ended up being unfair largely because of the even split. I'm also sure that there are cases where it's harder for them to communicate and negotiate with multiple founders rather than one. Those reasons don't matter if you're not taking funding, so even split in a contracting partnership (even split effort), turned profitable product startup that doesn't deal with VCs makes a lot of sense.
- katzgrau 9y agoI've done both equal and non-equal, but I've yet to have or observe a business where both the risk, contribution, and effort put in by the founders is actually equal. Sometimes it's just a conversation founders want to avoid having because it's uncomfortable, but that in itself is a bit of a red flag.
- dahart 9y agoI have no doubt you're right that it's frequently a red flag, and that founders often go equal to avoid ranking themselves. I've also watched and been part of lots of partnerships where the expectation before hand was equal contribution, and the reality after the fact was lopsided. I feel fairly lucky that my most recent experience truly was equal risk and equal effort; my even split experience has been truly reflective of what's happened, and truly fair for both of us. The big mistake I have made is giving people besides my co-founder too much equity. Nobody else who's contributed to my company so far other than my co-founder have lived up to what they said they'd do, and we gave out too much equity in advance of them doing it. Considering that, and considering both the issue you brought up and the reasons YCombinator gives for pushing toward equality rather than away from it, I think the main thing founders need to do is have a mechanism for not committing equity in advance of the effort. It's important for founders to be on a vesting schedule so that when one stops contributing or contributes less for a long period of time, you can shut it off. And it's important to communicate that things are going off the rails, and then actually take the action to shut it off. That's really basic and somewhat stating the obvious, but if you are diligent about cutting off people who don't contribute, then there's no reason to shy away from equal split plans in advance. My experience has been that people I've partnered with for equity aren't avoiding contribution maliciously, they simply and honestly didn't realize in advance that they don't have the time & energy they thought they did.
- gt2 9y agoIs this for the company Binomial, mentioned on the author's home page?
- RMacy 9y agoYes
- mobitar 9y agoRelated piece: Starting a Business as a Developer in 2017 https://journal.standardnotes.org/starting-a-business-as-a-developer-in-2017-4f4a2a0b1922 https://journal.standardnotes.org/starting-a-business-as-a-d...
- sniper007 9y agotest
- walkingolof 9y ago- "We can make a decent salary out of this" - 36 months - 48 months I started and 10 years later made a successfully exit from my company, we never raised any money, the above figure is what it took us to go from financing our development our self (by having two jobs), to having enough customers to break even. I think everyone should, bootstrap one company to get a feel for how it is, will make you a better entrepreneur.
- simonswords82 9y agoExactly the same setup as you, although I've not sold my company as I'm a happy owner (https://www.atlascode.com https://www.atlascode.com). I launched Atlas in 2007, just one year prior to the economic crisis that followed. Nothing ensures that you keep an eye on every bill that is paid and focus ruthlessly on efficiency gains more than a global financial catastrophe. Getting through that taught me I was capable of running an already tough business under pretty much any circumstances, and gave me an incredible confidence boost. Not that I'd recommend it, definitely some of the toughest years of my working career.
- zerr 9y agoDoes the website help with getting new clients? I mean completely foreign clientele, outside your reference circle.
- quadcore 9y agoI have a question regarding startup growth so I apologise in advance if its irrelevant here (haven't read the article to be honest). 1) I get that to get the first users, you have to go out and recruit them. That's the advertisement part. So yeah, I get how you get users by advertising. 2) I get that when you have a million customers, they become the advertisement and they are the ones who are bringing you new customers. Your product "ad surface" is way bigger than simple banners through them. Now what I have a hard time to understand is how 300 users procures the same effect as 2) (or even 3000). I get that they gonna get you 30 more customers by talking about your product to their "friends" who, if everything goes fine, at their turn gonna bring you 3 more customers who gonna bring you 1 more customers, for a grand total of 34 more customers. And that's the end of it. That wont grow much bigger. So basically, you would have to go back to 1) to get new users. What am I missing? Does a user have to bring you n more new customers, n > 1? How many customers do you need via advertising so that the compound growth effect kicks in? edit: I can see actually 2 types of compound growth effects: a) a user explicitly recruit another user (ex: "hey my friend, come play to this game"), b) a non user "see" other people using the product and he tells himself that might be a good idea to try it. Anyway, so basically, what I see is that, early on, you can rely only on a) so, in average, your customers have to get you n more new customers, n > 1, by explicitly recruiting them for you. Which, if Im correct here, would give an idea how badass the product must be.
- rmah 9y agoThe short answer is: it depends. The long answer... New customers come from two primary sources: 1) marketing and 2) referrals. Marketing is things like events (trade shows, media hits, advertising, reviews, etc). None of those things happen without outreach on your part. Referrals are when (as you described) existing customers tell other people and a few of them try your product. This will not be constant, right after a customer buys your product/service, they may be excited and tell some friends. Best to model referrals over time with cohort analysis. At the same time, you will lose existing customers. Like referrals, this is best modeled as cohort analysis. After a customer signs up, after 1 month, x% will leave, next month, a different %, next month yet another %. Typically the churn rate declines for a given customer cohort over time (though there may be bumps along the way). So, you have customer inflow and outflow. It would be nice if there was a simple formula, but the marketing efficiency, the referral rates and churn rates will all be constantly changing. So, there is no way to know in advance if or when compound growth kicks in until you have solid data. It will vary by market, company and product.
- draw_down 9y agoI was fortunate to see the author speak at a conference not too long ago, I really enjoyed it. Like her, I have had several bad experiences at tech companies and would just like to not ever work in one again. So I am very envious of her story and it's really cool to see how it has worked out for her and partner. (Unlike her, I don't really have contacts and I don't think I would be very good at the sales side of being a contractor.) Anyway, very inspiring stuff!
- dkersten 9y agoYeah, I agree! I like the people I'm working with, am paid well, have a good work environment and have interesting work to do, but for some reason I'm not happy and feel on the verge of burnout (if it hadn't happened already). I've done startups in the not too distant past and while they were a lot more stressful (and paid very little - we had some funding and had revenues but we never broke even), I was definitely happier working in my own thing. My problem is similar to yours. My personal network is good for changing jobs, but I have no idea how to make it work for consulting work or a startup and I'm really terrible at networking and find it difficult to talk to people (or at least, I find it difficult to strike up conversations - after that I'm not too bad). I also feel like my skills aren't very useful broadly speaking. Maybe it's imposter syndrome because I am good at my day to day work (which can be quite complex). I enjoyed the article though. It gives me hope that perhaps I can push myself and improve to the point where I can make something work. The thought of going out selling is a scary one to me though.
- jbchoo 9y agoCould totally relate to author's personal experience because this is what my biz partner and I are going through right now. Great article by the author.
- EGreg 9y agoObserve what people are doing inefficiently that you can fix. Test whether they'd buy it with google adwords or facebook ads and conversion rate to filling out the form and putting in credit card. Refund everyone. Imagine how it would be viral and test your hypothesis as well. So your customer acquisitin cost goes down exponentially!
- siliconc0w 9y agoConsulting doesn't scale, software does. One pragmatic strategy to find product/customers: 1) Pick an industry 2) Ask someone in that industry what they use spreadsheets for 3) Build something better There is a lot of 'cybernetic' processes that are a mix of humans with domain knowledge and machines with spreadsheets for schemaless storage and querying. Generally the move is to encode the domain knowledge into code and standardize the storage (i.e excel -> RDMS) to make it more useful.
- chubot 9y agoI've heard this before, but part of the appeal of the spreadsheet is that Patty from accounting or Joe from HR can modify it without having to ask any IT staff, including you. So I don't think it's a foolproof scheme, unless your solution is also programmable/customizable, which is a lot of work.
- siliconc0w 9y agoYeah it's not foolproof just a way to start. Here is one random example that comes to mind. "Risk Management" is something every company needs to do or pretend to do. So someone gets stuck with this responsibility and they create a spreadsheet that looks like: Department | Risk | Likelihood | Impact So this is a fairly mediocre solution but it kinda works and "risk management" for "Small Company Co" becomes "Bob's thing". Of course there is very likely software that already does this but in my experience it's usually what the hipster programmers call "enterprise garbage". You know what i'm talking about - buzzwordy site with stock photos, long annoying sales cycles, no online demo or sign up, some java server you have to deploy, and some extjs/jquery interface that is ugly and each click takes 5-10 seconds. You aren't competing with these guys, you're going after the long tail of small companies they are ignoring. Your move is to register some fun name - "Riskly", "Riskque", "Risksalot", etc. Next, hire a graphic designer to put together a fun colorful site, hire a college kid to make a fun video with royalty free upbeat music and narration showcasing your app, and build a simple CRUD app with maybe some built in risks for certain industries and some cool simulations/reports. So go spend a few years of your life and see if you can't 'Disrupt/Fix Risk Management'. Or go work for a large company for eight years, take all your earnings, go to Vegas, and let it all ride on a 10:1 bet. It works out about the same.
- scandox 9y agoThis is a person who obviously has a lot of talent and a lot of specialised knowledge. I doubt most people can get properly paid consulting work or get to product stage as fast as she clearly could.
- tertius 9y agoI'd like to see some responses to this from some gurus. I have the same problem. I have a bunch of generalized skill but I feel not enough to make large $ with consulting. I don't attribute this to impostor syndrome.
- theparanoid 9y agoSpecialize. It doesn't have to be an esoteric domain. Something like Go server apps or Docker is enough.
- ClassyJacket 9y agoWith an industry that moves so ridiculously fast, how do you know what'll be in use in the few years it'll take to become good at something? I feel like if I'd learned web development five years ago I wouldn't know anything about it today.
- cheez 9y agoYou answered your own question: keep learning. There isn't enough time for mastery of any particular technology, but mastery of the flow of technical change.
- samsonradu 9y ago> I feel like if I'd learned web development five years ago I wouldn't know anything about it today. This is a wrong assumption. Web development just gives the feeling of moving fast, it's not really the case. The foundation of web development is roughly the same as 5y ago. Most things from the http protocol, web servers, data storage, authentication, websockets etc. still works the same. Give or take a few UX and state-management tools and we're not that far into the future. Also due to the huge investments in the web during the past decade(s) things should get slower because of legacy issues. Think fe. how long it's taking browser vendors to dump Flash or to adopt WebRTC.
- k__ 9y agoSo basically she got much skills and happened to meet someone who was a well known player in the game industry. Most people have neither or just the first one.
- jwildeboer 9y agoSo basically she worked hard on her skills and invested a lot of time and effort to talk to a lot of people to meet the persons that allowed her to grow her business. Most people don't do that and complain. ;-)
- k__ 9y agoFor me the point here was, that the meeting of that person the most crucial step and also pure luck. Writing about "Starting a Software Business" which boils down to "just know the right people" is a bit demotivating :\
- pyrrhic 9y agoDid you miss the part where they intentionally spoke to lots and lots of people?
- k__ 9y agoI read it that the "talk to lots of people" part was independent of her knowing Rich in the first place.
- davidbanham 9y agoShe made her own luck by making a concerted effort to meet lots of people who may be relevant to her business.
- valuearb 9y agoSo basically anyone can do it. Work hard, meet people.
- ivanbakel 9y agoOT, but referring to the article: why are so many websites allergic to serving basic HTML these days? You get a lovely white page with a Javascript blocker if you try to open this article. What's particularly offensive about this one is that all the raw data is loaded in correctly anyways - the JS appears to just fiddle with making it look right, and there's no default style for if that doesn't happen.
- dcwca 9y agoIt also doesn't look right if you turn off CSS styling.
- btown 9y agoI feel like this comment is the equivalent of posting a meme on Reddit.
- whateveracct 9y agoThe article loaded fine on my old iPhone 5s. I leave JS enabled tho because I don't believe in the Fake Idea that the web should work for me without it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jmnicolas 9y agoAm I the only one getting a blank page on Firefox, Chromium and Opera included the google cache and archive.org versions ?
- goingbananas 9y agoI stopped reading after the "lol". I tend to do not get advice from lols lmaos & company...
- nathan_f77 9y agoThat might be a decent quality filter if you're reading comments on YouTube or Disqus, but you shouldn't apply it to articles on the front page of Hacker News.