8 ms·
You guys are talking about Uber dying, but I cannot fathom how this is possible from just the user's perspective. Uber seems to be everywhere, people take Ubers
by baby 9y ago
You guys are talking about Uber dying, but I cannot fathom how this is possible from just the user's perspective. Uber seems to be everywhere, people take Ubers or driver for Ubers every day. How could a company this big fail?
Stop growing maybe, but going bankrupt and shutting down?
- Retric 9y agoIt's easy to grow when you sell dollars for 70c each. But, when you suddenly need to sell them for 1.01+$ nobody wants to buy. Uber's problem is taxi companies have lower overhead because among other thing their drivers sometimes get hailed by people at street level. Which means their either taxi prices are lower and people stop using Uber or they pay drivers more and drivers mostly stop working for Uber.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoUber is profitable in certain cities, e.g. New York City [1]. They could turn cash-flow positive if they just gave up useless market share. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/ubers-revenue-profit-and-loss-2015-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/ubers-revenue-profit-and-loss...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- evgen 9y agoTheir valuation is based upon the assumption that they can maintain market share and raise profitability in those other markets. We all know this isn't going to happen though, so eventually someone is going to eat the valuation hit but the game of musical chairs to decide that question is still being played.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoI don't think their valuation makes sense. I'm more replying to the gist of this thread, which seems to be saying they're dead because they aren't profitable. They could be if they needed to prioritise that. > someone is going to eat the valuation hit Liquidation preferences mean earlier investors (and employees holding Common Stock) take the hit of a down round.
- bogomipz 9y agoI thought liquidation preference mostly served VCs which could be earlier "earlier" investors no?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoDisclaimer: this is not investment advice. Do not make investment decisions based off my Internet comments. Let's say Company X has 9,000 shares of common stock outstanding. It raises $1 million at a $10 million post-money valuation with a 1x non-participating liquidation preference. Its cap table is thus 1,000 shares of Series A preferred stock on top of 9,000 shares of common. It then raises $10 million at a $50 million valuation with similar preference terms. Its cap table is now 2,500 shares of Series B preferred stock on top of 1,000 shares of Series A preferred stock on top of 9,000 shares of common. Let's contemplate a $100 million exit. Everyone converts to common at $100 million / 12,500 shares, or $8,000 per share. Series A bought at $1,000 and thus sees an 8x return; Series B bought at $4,000 and thus sees 2x. Let's contemplate a $50 million exit. Everyone converts at $50 million / 12,500 shares, or $4,000 per share. Series A gets 4x; B comes out flat. Let's contemplate a $25 million exit. Series B does not convert. Instead, it demands its 1x liquidation preference and gets $10 million. This leaves $15 million on the table, or $1,500 per share. Series A converts and sees its 1.5x return; B comes out flat. Let's contemplate a $15 million exit. Series B does not convert and gets its $10 million. This leaves $5 million on the table, or $500 per share. Series A does not convert and demands its $1 million. Series A and B come out flat; common gets $4 million / 9,000 shares, or about $444. Let's contemplate a $10 million exit. Series B gets its $10 million and comes out flat; everyone else gets screwed. Let's contemplate a Theranos exit. Everyone gets screwed. Turtleneck doesn't go to jail. TL; DR Later stages are least volatile. They get screwed last, but also see upside last. Lower rungs' returns pay for this safety.
- mysterydip 9y agoIsn't part of the reason end users use Uber is for its ubiquity? If it was only available in a handful of cities that I won't be visiting, I wouldn't bother with it.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean, running a livery service in NYC is a fine business and there's no reason you couldn't make money at it. But it is certainly not the scale of ambition Uber was pitching.
- addicted 9y agoIs the profitability in NYC before or after we discovered they were cheating their drivers out of money? And there aren't too many NYCs in the world.
- thrillgore 9y agoIf Uber was successful only in NYC, London, and Tokyo, someone would make the business work in every other city on earth.
- jerf 9y ago"Uber is profitable in certain cities, e.g. New York City [1]. They could turn cash-flow positive if they just gave up useless market share." I would assume that would also depend on how much of their fixed costs they can shed in conjunction with that. Uber may not die quickly but it could still die slowly if they lose the ability to move forward because they had to cut too much of their R&D and sales infrastructure to get to that positive number. Plus such a massive layoff would be a big red flag to customers too. By Uber's nature, a particular ride isn't a long-term commitment, but I think people would start looking for a stronger-looking horse even so. One of those differences between homo economus, who every time they need a ride rationally examines all their options regardless of the future and realizes that as long as Uber can complete this ride the internal state of Uber doesn't matter, and homo sapiens, who will take into account the fact that Uber doesn't seem to be doing well even if doesn't rationally matter at this particular point.
- jacquesm 9y agoYes, but that would tell the investors to forget about any pay day justifying the valuation.
- davidf18 9y agoIn NYC, the Yellow cabs have a huge, huge overhead because of Taxi Medallions that used to cost $1.2 million each which effectively added $125 or so for a 12 hour shift. The value of the medallions are now < $700K, but I don't know if the $125 overhead is still in force. Uber is far more expensive in NYC than other cities such as Chicago. Now that Uber has allowed tipping and since there is a rating system, everyone must now tip otherwise risk getting low ratings which effectively makes NYC rides even more expensive than they had been. Most people don't own cars in Manhattan so that they either have to take mass transit or use Uber/Lyft/Taxi. There are many elderly on fixed incomes that have trouble ambulating (moving around) where lower cost taxi service is important. In NYC at least, Uber doesn't need all of that corporate overhead and perhaps they should spin it off into some low-overhead operation.
- pishpash 9y agoTipping with rating basically equates to a shakedown. You have to now guess at the subjective price that the driver "feels" is deserved instead of what was agreed upon.
- smelterdemon 9y agoIt's not like it was impossible to tip before. Now you just don't need to carry cash.
- s73ver 9y agoOn Lyft, the driver doesn't know that you tipped or how much. I fail to see why this would be any different.
- taneq 9y agoI don't use Uber myself, but doesn't the driver not find out what tip you gave them until after they've rated you?
- lucaspm98 9y agoIt has been assumed that the rating system will be blind, meaning the drivers will not be able to see tips before leaving their rating. There is still the social pressure to leave a tip, but it likely will not be quite as rude as not tipping a traditional cab driver.
- ransom1538 9y agoOf course they can be profitable. Uber doesn't have overhead. There are no Uber factories or millions of rotting vehicles in a warehouse. At the core it is a iOS/Android app (4 guys could maintain this), a call center (India), and a law firm (outsource it). They would have to cut their staff, remove the ping pong tables and get real but profitability is there. They are on a land grab.
- islanderfun 9y ago> iOS/Android app (4 guys could maintain this) Those 4 can handle everything backend related too?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kevinmchugh 9y agoit's also a massive recruiting and advertising campaign, since they have no product without hiring huge numbers of drivers
- valuearb 9y agoThat's the point. Their technology costs are pennies per ride, revenues dollars per ride. They are only spewing cash trying to grow faster by buying more drivers in more countries. They could hire organically for much less.
- dagw 9y agoThey could hire organically for much less. Uber only works if there are enough drivers so that I can always get a ride. If I get told that I have to wait 30 minutes for a ride more than a tiny handful of times I'm uninstalling the app. Growing organically in region would be very tough since it would take too long to get enough drivers in place that users could rely on the service and conversely drivers would be unwilling to sign up because not enough users where bothering to use the service.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y ago> Uber's problem is taxi companies have lower overhead because among other thing their drivers sometimes get hailed by people at street level. There is always demand for Uber/Lyft just because there isn't a taxi cab nearby 24/7. How is that difficult to understand?
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, Uber, Lyft, or some other livery service.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> There is always demand for Uber/Lyft just because there isn't a taxi cab nearby 24/7. There's certainly a market for app/phone jailable cabs because there isn't one within street hail range at all times, but regular cabs have been phone hailable forever (it's the only way to get one outside of a few major urban cores) and are increasingly app hailable. Aside from regulatory supply restrictions (flouting which may not be sustainable) there's no real basis for a market for alt-taxis as anything but interchangeable competitors supplying the same substitutable commodity as regular taxis.
- epistasis 9y ago>regular cabs have been phone hailable forever For me, this wasn't particularly true, especially in San Francisco. The dispatch was unreliable and slow. Other areas, sure! Now that the idea of phone-trackable dispatch has become commonplace, regular taxi companies are starting to do this too.
- 2_listerine_pls 9y ago> but regular cabs have been phone hailable forever With Uber you also get know the fare upfront, the time of arrival, no need to tell them your address, there is a driver reputation filter, passenger insurance and it's safer than normal cabs in many countries. Not the same thing as a phone call.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoI travel a lot for work. Uber works in a lot of places where mass transit sucks and taxi service is nonexistent. Even if they cost more I have no idea how I'm going to get around when I travel. The other options are so disgusting I'm not going back to that. I would use them even if prices went up 30%.
- lathiat 9y agome too
- Retric 9y agoTo be profitable the prices would need to go up for more than 30% on average, because 30% only get's them to break even if you assume zero changes in ridership. There are a few costs like background checks that may go down when they stop expanding, but fewer than you might think.
- rhino369 9y agoAnd I used uber or lyft to ride back and forth to work every single day because it's so cheap. ~9 bucks compared to a 3 dollar metro ride (and I typically save 20 minutes). If it's 15 dollars I'd ride less often and I'd probably try to hail a cab first. Uber demand is definitely elastic.
- rubicon33 9y agoOh it's definitely elastic. I used to take Uber everywhere, until they (apparently) removed the restriction on driver's to use nice/current cars. Once drivers starting showing up in 10 year old beat down cars, my riding plummeted.
- erikpukinskis 9y ago> taxi companies have lower overhead because among other thing their drivers sometimes get hailed by people at street level I don't understand why that would decrease overhead? I also don't understand why the other aspects of overhead (dispatcher, offices, taxi lots) don't add up to more than Uber (whose only cost is servers and support)
- bunkat 9y agoUber doesn't make enough from fares to be profitable, they use investors' money to heavily subsidize them. Once the investor money runs out, Uber won't be able to pay drivers unless they jack up prices considerably. Once they are no longer price competitive, customers will move to other services. Turns out the car service business isn't very sticky at all (even the drivers work for multiple companies...). Drivers start to leave and the downward spiral begins. They just couldn't get to self driving vehicles fast enough - which may be why they were trying to borrow technology from Google.
- timje1 9y agoHa, nice use of "borrow".
- auggierose 9y agoCome on, self driving cars was never a solution for Uber in the medium term. Cabs are in the midst of normal traffic, not even highway or anything. No way this will work good enough within the next 15 years
- ProblemFactory 9y ago"Uber is a play on self-driving cars" is a misleading but often repeated story. When Uber started and raised its first investment rounds, self-driving cars were too far away to be part of a business plan. I doubt the latest investors take that view either - spending billions per year until self-driving cars happen is a way too expensive way to build up a fickle user base who will switch the moment a competitor offers 10% lower rates. And when self-driving cars do arrive, there is no reason to believe that Uber will have exclusive access to them. Google and other software companies will be licensing the technology to anyone who pays for it, car manufacturers will be selling cars to anyone who pays for it. It may kill taxi driver as a career, but there is no defensible advantage to Uber compared to Lyft, Hailo, Taxify, and so on.
- Cacti 9y agoYeah. The whole driverless car thing with Uber is such a load of crap. It wasn't even in the plan until they started hemoraging money and had to come up with some excuse to keep investors on board. And by that point they were late to the game. Uber as a play on driverless cars is a smokescreen to distract people from the fact they have little advantage over other companies and can't for the life of them turn a profit.
- georgespencer 9y agoIf the unit economics don't stack up, then the bigger it is, the faster it'll go out of business without external investment. Pervasiveness doesn't mean it's profitable, it means it's popular. If I had a network of people giving away $1 for $0.90 it'd be super popular. As it is, Uber doesn't need to do too much to hit break even. Some central costs cut, and a slight rise on price.
- rsj_hn 9y agoI agree, but investors don't want to break even. The fundamental tension here is high operating margins -- 60% not being uncommon operating margins for a software company -- are incompatible with a highly competitive industry. But it's those fat margins that justify massive R&D investment. Although software companies have enormous operating margins, they generally are not more profitable, because of huge fixed investment. That creates a bit of a puzzle for industries with very thin operating margins that want to make significant investments in R&D. Generally they don't do it. That is why innovation at the Grocery store or in Long Haul trucking is so slow. From an engineering point of view, they are ripe for disruption, until you bring in an accountant to tell you that the disruption doesn't pencil out. Uber, like everything else, said to hell with it we're going ahead anyway. So how can they make things pencil out? One option is to raise unit revenue in the future, which in an industry that's currently competitive means driving out the competition. IMO Uber was originally targeting this. But it turns out -- and really anyone could have told you -- that what Uber is doing isn't technically difficult. The heavy lifting is smartphones, GPS and Maps, whose availability made Uber/Lyft possible. Uber doesn't own any of the key technologies that make Uber possible, nor do they have a track record of being able to tackle really hard technology problems. They've had huge problems scaling and when Uber started using its own maps, it was a disaster. Bad maps is the #1 problem with Uber. Lots of new competitors have sprung up already that give basically an equivalent user experience, so Uber is not going to get real pricing power. The next option would be "Lower unit costs in the future", But so far, that means spinning tales about self-driving cars, which is way beyond their technical ability as well as decades out even for those that have the chops to pull it off. IMO this only works because the latter round investors are naive about technology and the current investment climate is conducive to reaching for yield. So while it's perfectly possible for Uber to continue existing as a concern, I don't think it's possible to satisfy their investors, and this means, unfortunately, that Uber may not make it. Many companies engage in a lot of self-destructive acts to meet unrealistic profit or growth goals set by investors, but in this case, Uber has only themselves to blame for setting these expectations. This is a shame, because I prefer Uber to Lyft and think they've created enormous value for both riders and drivers.
- Super_Jambo 9y agoThe reason it's so big is they're burning VC cash to subsidize rides. So yea when billionaires are paying your taxi fair to try and drive the local taxi firms out of business naturally they're everywhere. But when that cash runs out the necessary price hike could just as easily drive them out of business. It's not like the drivers have any great loyalty. We really need pro-competition legislation to stop this sort of predatory capitalism.
- VMG 9y ago> We really need pro-competition legislation to stop this sort of predatory capitalism. That's a non-sequitur
- bogomipz 9y ago>"We really need pro-competition legislation to stop this sort of predatory capitalism." This conclusion refers to the idea of VCs(billionaires) subsidizing rides in order to remove the entrenched player(taxis.) How is that a non-sequitur?
- mediocrejoker 9y agoIt sounds like the parent poster is saying that "pro-competition legislation" would prevent a new company (funded by VCs) from competing with an entrenched industry (taxis). I think the confusion stems from saying pro-competition legislation will prevent competition.
- VMG 9y agoWhat's bad about VC billionaires giving cheap rides to other people?
- bogomipz 9y agoIt wasn't my comment. I was just commenting on it not being a non-sequitur.
- 9y ago
- adventured 9y agoIt's a relished fantasy that Uber is dying or is going to die, because so many people in tech circles hate Uber and Kalanick. It's not actually dying and it's not going to die. Routinely skeptics here will point out that Uber is selling a $1 service for $0.75 (or a similar invented sum). Said skeptics then intentionally, comically ignore that Lyft is and has been doing the exact same thing and has radically less capital & valuation to play that game with. The name of the game is: last company standing; that's going to be Uber because they can afford to be and Lyft can't. It's that simple.
- dagw 9y agoLyft seems to be a fundamentally different company in two ways that gives them an advantage over Uber. First of all they are much happier to partner with local players and don't feel a need to 'own' the entire world in the way Uber does. Secondly Lyft seems happy being a ride dispatching service and don't see it as a temporary stepping stone towards much grander transportation ambitions. The downside of this approach is that Lyft doesn't have anywhere near the upside potential that Uber has. If Uber pulls off all of its ambitions it will be larger than Lyft could ever dream of being. The upside for Lyft's more humble goals is that it's chance of reaching them are much larger. Unless Uber is willing to change its DNA and scale back its ambition, give up on its long term goals, and stay just a basic ride dispatching service then your analysis is incomplete. However perhaps this scaling back is what the CEO change is fundamentally about.
- skinnymuch 9y agoRegardless of what you're saying, Lyft lost $600M on $700M in revenue in 2016. Those numbers are awful. And worse than Uber. Lyft isn't in any better shape than Uber in terms of needing more funding almost every year to sustain the company.
- dagw 9y agoTrue. However I personally don't think either company can do too much about revenues at this point and it's all about controlling costs. From an outsider point of view it seems that Lyft is in a better position, culturally if nothing else, to do this. At least when compared to a Kalanick run Uber. It will be very interesting to see what priorities the next CEO will have.
- jordache 9y agoThere is nothing that differentiates Uber from lyft, or another ride hail company. Drivers could easily switch between the companies. Driverless tech will be the differentiation. Whoever gets there first, even in limited urban centers will win the taxi industry
- api 9y ago> Whoever gets there first, even in limited urban centers will win the taxi industry Why "win"? There's no moat. I suppose there will be patents, but those expire or can be worked around. More likely is that whoever gets there first will make all the mistakes that others can learn from. Every major car company has a self-drive effort now. Apparently Tesla, GM, Ford, and BMW are pretty far along. Lyft has a few partnerships here. It's only a matter of time before most cars drive themselves to some degree.
- jordache 9y agoyeah expiring patents, and effective partnerships, give enough cushion for one company to get far ahead enough to dominate the business. self driving hardware+software is much more complex than just writing some software... a non player can't trivially get into the game just because someone else have higher advancement
- rhino369 9y agoCompetitors won't have to develop this stuff on their own. They just need to buy a self driving car that has an API. Trying to vertical integrate the self driving software is a moonshot.
- jordache 9y agoguarantee you that for the initial years, self driving car will take the form of proprietary units, used for specific purpose, in isolated locations. Akin to self driving rail transportation. No mass produced self driving appliances that any dumb human can use improperly. The industry won't take that chance of a poor impression and destroy public's confidence all together. In urban/high density locations, a ride hail company leveraging driverless vehicles can make a killing.
- _asummers 9y agoAnecdotally, I've personally taken Lyft almost exclusively lately. Among my peers, I've noticed similar trends. I've even heard shifting in language -- rather than say "call an Uber", I've heard "call a Lyft"., Plural of anecdote is obviously not data, but those are my data points.
- ada1981 9y agoWe've made the shift in NYC to Lyft or JUNO. Not even sure if I installed Uber last month when I got a new iPhone.
- badwolf 9y agoSame. Juno in NYC, RideAustin in Austin, and Lyft everywhere else if there's not another local(ish) tnc
- skinnymuch 9y agoThis conversation was had in a thread a week or two ago. The consensus was that the Lyft or other alternative anecdotes are far and few between. Like saying call a Lyft has to be rare and probably just in certain small circle. Most people are on Uber. The thread link is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14456973 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14456973
- trevyn 9y agoMy data points are that I've been taking Uber exclusively, because Lyft can't seem to figure out how to operate outside of the US. :-)
- ams6110 9y ago> going bankrupt and shutting down? Well, if you're spending more than your revenue, that is the eventual outcome if money stream from investors dries up. Uber doesn't really have many physical assets that could be liquidated. Their value is entirely based on profitability. Which is currently negative.
- intoverflow2 9y agoThe drivers don't suddenly cease to exist when Uber shuts down.