9 ms·
How Not to Fix Soccer
- lenni 16y agoQuestion for the Americans: Is soccer really on the brink of becoming a popular sport in your country? I read that ESPN is investing lots of money into the world cup coverage and reddit is full of related submissions.
- chronomex 16y agoIt certainly seems to be. Five years ago I didn't hear much of anything from my peers about professional soccer. (But then, five years ago I was 17 ...)
- lionhearted 16y ago> Question for the Americans: Is soccer really on the brink of becoming a popular sport in your country? No, but it's slowly trending upwards. Without looking it up, the top American spectator sports are American football, baseball, basketball, NASCAR racing, hockey, golf, and tennis. The problem is that the best American athletes look to one of top three American sports - if you look at top NBA and NFL players, many of them seem well-suited to futbol, but it's not where the money/popularity/culture is at in the USA yet. As long as the fast and strong American athletes are looking to become running backs, wide receivers, and point guards instead of midfielders and strikers, the game won't reach the height of popularity. But it'll slowly grow in popularity if the U.S. keeps making decent showings internationally. Being a top 5 American sport by 2030 wouldn't surprise me. After that, it'd really only take one charismatic, transcendental American player for the sport to really break through - if there was an American Pele, Maradona, George Best type player, it'd go a long ways, just like Tiger Woods did for golf, Joe Namath did for American football, Michael Jordan did for basketball, etc, etc. So I could see the game trending up in the rankings, and then it's all about if it gets the one dominant, charismatic force that people fall in love with who kids want to follow in the player's footsteps.
- Maro 16y agoNBA players and soccer? You must be joking. Unless you want 11 Peter Crouches running around the field...
- adw 16y agoSteve Nash (admittedly: Canadian). His dad was a professional footballer.
- _delirium 16y agoIf the USA qualified for a world cup with a team of NBA players, at the very least, the TV ratings would be good...
- lionhearted 16y agoI'm thinking someone like Chris Paul or Rajon Rondo - same height and similar physical build to Cristiano Ronaldo, very fast and tough players with a good idea for spacing and good intuition and decisionmaking. Who knows how they'd take to the game, but I wouldn't be surprised if either could play futbol at the highest level.
- philwelch 16y agoMost top NBA and NFL players are fucking huge, because those sports reward gigantism. Soccer doesn't, with the slight exception of the goalkeeper, because even when the height or size of a Peter Crouch or Per Mertesacker gives you an advantage, being able to run circles around Per Mertesacker or get your defense behind Peter Crouch somewhat mitigates it.
- zalew 16y agofollow-up question - did David Beckham become a real star and popularized football in the US?
- profgubler 16y agoI think his wife became more popular here than he did, because of her show. You can't transplant greatness to get Americans interested in a sport. They must be american, and Americans who constantly beat up on Europeans like Lance Armstrong is always good for American ratings, even if overall Americas interest in cycling is only superficial. But, Lance did make it a lot bigger.
- rubidium 16y agono, not really. A foreigner has a hard time popularizing a sport.
- DaveChild 16y agoHey, things change. It wasn't all that long ago that rugby was big in the USA.
- philwelch 16y agoIt's always been a popular sport in America for amateur players, kids, and women (our women's team is the best in the world). Men's soccer on a professional level is trending upwards, though. In college towns and the like you'll see a handful of people wearing Man U shirts or something. MLS is expanding, and in some cities it catches on rather quickly (Seattle, for instance). It's still hampered by the fact that we have pretty third-rate players by international standards. The American leagues for gridiron, basketball, and baseball are de facto world championships because the best players in those sports always play here, but in soccer the best club could be English or Spanish or German or Italian, and Americans have a problem with that. I would say it's a top 4 sport already (displacing hockey) but the top 3 is hard to break into. I suspect it'll displace baseball next.
- fortybillion 16y ago> it's a top 4 sport already (displacing hockey) Not a chance. The NHL is enjoying some of its highest ratings ever.
- philwelch 16y agoRegionally. They don't have national coverage at all, but I guess soccer doesn't either.
- starkfist 16y agoIn NYC, World Cup mania is bigger than I've ever seen for any other sporting event, ever. Everyone is watching the games on their computer during work. This seems to be acceptable behavior because all the managers and CEOs are doing it too. Every bar in the city with TVs is open early for the early games. The "dive bar" by my apartment installed two flat panel TVs just for the Cup and they never had TVs before. I'm not really a soccer fan but I would say if the sport wasn't popular in the USA before, it is now, and will probably become more popular in the future.
- JacobAldridge 16y agoWhat a brilliant example of scalability in a real world sense.
- ubernostrum 16y agoNot really. This concept of "scalability", while alluring at first glance, falls flat on multiple counts. First and foremost, it verges on a straw man; Felten argues against unspecified "Americans" with largely-unspecified views, when in fact criticism has been quite specific and has come from practically every part of the globe. The things people are asking to have "fixed" are not the lack of an official clock or any of his other examples; the things people are asking to have fixed seem mostly to be abysmally inconsistent officiating standards. Which, in an article praising the uniformity of the game at nearly all levels, is a glaring oversight. Second, Felten's concept of "scalability" is deeply flawed; we might as well argue for the World Cup final to be played on a parking lot with piled-up sticks for goals -- after all, your neighborhood game doesn't have those big fancy stadiums, does it? Privileging some aspects of the game by allowing them to be radically different at higher levels of play, while arbitrarily requiring other aspects to be uniform at all levels, is frankly irrational. Worst of all, he touches on baseball as a game which "scales", but fails to note that while the basic rules of the game are the same at practically every level, the implementation varies considerably and the game is better for that. For example, a local sandlot game doesn't need six professional umpires, instant replay and a strike-zone-tracking pitch-plotting camera system, but a major-league championship game does. This allows each game to have the level of officiating it actually needs, rather than forcing impossible burdens on the local game or false austerity on the professional game.
- hugothefrog 16y agoI was trying to think of a good reason why FIFA continues to refuse to introduce any form of video replay/video referee, and the reason Ed outlines are just what I concluded. The game is supposed to be exactly the same when played at World Cup level as it is when played at Saturday morning club level, and even below that - the streets of Brazil, etc. Fifa has got its eye on the global market for playing football, which is what (possibly) makes it the world's most popular sport. It doesn't have its eye on the global market for watching football.
- zalew 16y agoHe forgets about one thing - pro football is not managed by a single referee because it'd be impossible, he has 2 side referees to help. Also, in amateur (edit: for fun, not non-pro leagues) football you usually play without offsides or almost without them; while in pro there is a ridiculous situation where a rule meant to prevent static play (standing in front of the goal waiting for a pass) is often ripping the game of dynamic (halted actions because the side referee saw that one player's foot was 10cm pass the line of defence). Football is scaled down mostly because you don't need expensive infrastructure to play and train - 2 sticks in the ground or draw lines on a fence and you're ready to kick - no equipment (baseball, hockey) besides the ball itself, no need to build anything (basketball, hockey). I think that's a far more important factor in football popularity than the rules set.
- trin_ 16y agowhere? maybe for 7-10 year old kids but even low games that have only 1 referee will be played with offside (at least thats my experience playing until the age of 16) i think the DFB (german football association) requires 3 referees starting from the 7th or 8th league. and below that they just dont have the manpower.
- zalew 16y agoyou're right, by amateur I meant the first level of engaging with sport, not amateur leagues. sorry for the confusion. made an edit.
- zazi 16y agoI play soccer and it seems like it doesnt need to be fixed. It is a beautiful game in all its glorious simplicity. or in hn style - soccer may be the the ultimate example of a MVP or 'minimal viable professional game' that you can play with a ball and two teams =)
- ubernostrum 16y agoBased on the events of the past year, the officiating most certainly does need to be fixed.
- zazi 16y agoyes i see where you are coming from, some officials have been making bad calls. but some would argue that the refereeing is part of the game and instituting video replays etc might unnecessarily complicate matters and ruin the flow of the game. i play soccer in an amatuer league every weekend and although the referees generally are not of a high standard, I still enjoy it. its part of the game.
- ubernostrum 16y agoDisparate levels of play do not require arbitrariness in officiating. I don't do soccer at any level, but in my spare time I do work and hold a certification as a tournament judge for Magic (the card game: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering). The DCI -- sanctioning body for organized Magic -- has formal standards for officiating which work at and scale from the smallest local game shop tournaments all the way up to massive events with large cash prizes and a pro tour. And one of the biggest goals is to ensure consistency: enforcement shouldn't and can't vary from judge to judge, because that would fundamentally damage the integrity of the entire tournament system. Given that as background, the lack of consistency I see in World Cup officiating literally makes me shudder. And the worst part is that the usual straw men brought up in response -- massive delays due to replay, etc., etc., -- are, well, just straw men. A few simple, non-game-disrupting, changes (a highly-relevant example: let a team captain or a coach ask an official to state the foul for which a penalty has been issued, something which, so far as I'm aware, practically every other organized sport in the world does) could vastly improve both the actual and perceived consistency and fairness of soccer, but FIFA doesn't seem to care enough to do anything.
- sev 16y agoI agree with the article, and the scaling down reasons for not changing the rules for the most part. However, when players are being paid millions, and countries reputations are on the line, there is no scaled down version of that anyhow. And therefore... There is only one thing I would change: if a violation is noted by one of the refs (such as an offsides), and a goal is scored during that same time the violation flag went up...let the coach have the ability to call for a review of the violation call.
- ErrantX 16y agoPlease no! One of the best parts of Football (IMO) is that the ref rules; it introduces that element of risk that can lead to the excruciating moments that define the sport. "we was robbed". Besides; in the example you cite in the vast majority of cases it will be ruled as a no-goal (I've seen it happen quite a few times this world cup).
- lenni 16y agoI agree. Referee decisions are a neverending source of outrage and drama and exactly the reason people love football. It makes it a human thing. The cynic would say that it provides emotionally crippled men with an outlet for showing their emotions.
- robryan 16y agoCan't remember which match it was I was watching but 2 minutes into a 3 minute additional time at the end of the match someone had a cut on their head or similar, at least a minute of play was lost but the ref added about 20 seconds additional time. Seems really unprofessional not knowing much much time is actually going to be played, especially at such an important tournament. Seems to be abused to, after the 90 minutes there seems to be a lot of pointless substitutes where the player walks off nice and slow to eat up time.
- Maro 16y agoI am familiar with the FIFA's reasoning, and I just don't think it holds up. The best example is the NBA: advanced technical rules at NBA games aren't stopping anyone from playing basketball on the courts or at the High School level. Also, the rules are different anyways. At the FIFA level, games are played on large fields for 2x45 minutes, there are 4 refs, etc. AFAIR HS level games were 2x30 minutes and we were lucky to have 1 ref, and so on. So the rules are already different at different levels, and people can deal with it. Would it really kill soccer if we had video replay? Match outcomes are routinely altered by erroneous ref. decisions, decisions which the whole world except the ref. knows are erroneous because we see the 1000FPS close up 30 seconds later. It's become so nonsensical that at the recent Brazil game, the brazilian players after a bad ref. decision to send off Kaka with a red card were begging the ref. to look up on the stadion screen to see the replay which clearly showed nothing happened, but he couldn't be bothered. I think everybody would be able to accept that at High School level games there's no video replay, and the ref. makes mistakes, while rejoicing that World Cup level games are not influenced by bad decisions avoidable just by having a 5th ref. look at the replays. This would also move the game towards actual fair play in the sense that players wouldn't be constantly diving, lying about who touched the ball last, lying about what happened, lying to convince the ref.
- zazi 16y ago> The best example is the NBA: advanced technical rules at NBA games aren't stopping anyone from playing basketball on the courts or at the High School level. alternatively, basketball has so many rules that it prevents first timers from truly picking up the game at all... ie. a non-intuitive game > Would it really kill soccer if we had video replay? Has the lack of video replays killed soccer? Why stop at video replays at all? why not have a group of referees sitting in the comfort of an airconditioned room with muliple camera angles available to them making decisions about the game which are displayed on the screen? would this kill the game? it is debatable. But would this significantly change the game? yes.... would I want to play in such a game? maybe not..
- Maro 16y agoPlayers constantly lying/cheating certainly has a negative effect on how the game is perceived. I know it has an effect on me. Also, it has a noticably negative effect at the kids playing at the amateur level. At one of the World Cup games the commentator noted that he teaches his young kid that diving/cheating is part of soccer and it's important to be good at it. Sports are supposed to be a part of life where cheating and lying is discouraged and outlawed.
- pierrefar 16y agoThree counter-points: 1. FIFA makes a ton of money from the World Cup. The sponsorship and protection efforts of the sponsorship are ridiculously elaborate. 2. Even FIFA doesn't scale the game linearly. In the World Cup there are always 3 refs on the field, even though really only 1 is needed. Further, there are many different types of football balls (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_%28ball%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Football_%28ball%29 ), so again, the game played on the streets or school leagues is not necessarily exactly the same as the World Cup. 3. FIFA constantly innovates in the making of the actual ball. Every WC we get a new ball that has different characteristics. This year's ball is the most consistent in distance and trajectory in tests (i.e. hit it the same way and you'll get the same volley). With all that said, I don't think "maintaining consistency" is the reason FIFA refuses to introduce replay refs. I think it's more about politics: they have always supported the number 1 ref as the final arbiter of play and introducing a replay ref would undermine this long-held traditional philosophy.
- ErrantX 16y agoIn the World Cup there are always 3 refs on the field, even though really only 1 is needed. I don't get that; the extra "refs" simply reduce the chance of an error being made. It is possible to play pretty effectively without them. Actually there is still only one ref - none of the others can make a decision, only advise the referee and provide an alternative viewpoint if he misses an event.
- pierrefar 16y agoWhich is exactly how a video ref would work: advise the main referee to reduce mistakes. And the current world cup certainly could use that given the horrible rate of horrible calls.
- ErrantX 16y agoyes, but it is going too far. Waving a flag, or perhaps the occasional short conversation does not delay a match very much. There is a net gain. I can't see much of a net gain in video refs simply due to the unnecessary delay. One of the delights of football is that 15-20 seconds after a goal they are kicking off again. (the calls in this world cup have been pretty good; I've watched, literally, every game so far and there have been a couple of shockers - which obviously we notice - but generally it has been good)
- avar 16y agoWhat football (I'm European) needs is much larger penalties for feigning injuries and taking dives. There's a good reason you see players rolling around on the pitch like bruised 4 year old girls, it's beneficial in the long run to the player feigning injury. You're more likely to win a beneficial free kick from it than two yellow cards in a row, so the practice continues. Some national football associations (e.g. Italy) start training kids to do this at a young age. It would probably stop overnight if a player seen taking a dive were to directly receive a red card, or a three game ban.
- pierrefar 16y agoMy favourite stat is from the 2006 Germany World Cup: http://www.fifa.com/worldcup/archive/germany2006/statistics/teams/topfoulssuffered.html http://www.fifa.com/worldcup/archive/germany2006/statistics/... Calculate the fouls suffered per game played. Italy is number 1.
- pbhjpbhj 16y ago>players rolling around on the pitch like bruised 4 year old girls I've never seen a 4yo girl (or boy) act like such a pillock; they cry when they're hurt and then normally get on with it. I think you do a disservice to 4 year olds.
- GFischer 16y agoIndeed.. that's one big point. Maybe there could be a special review of the game for awarding those cards after the matches... (during the post-mortem) Someone mentioned the English Premier League as an example of having a heavy stance on fouls and dives.
- edanm 16y agoOne of the reasons Poker is so popular is that even a terrible player can beat a pro by chance, some of the time. I've always suspected the same is true of Football. Any attempt to "fix" the game by making refereeing better makes the game more fair. While that might seem like a good thing, I don't think anyone is qualified to decide whether that will make the game more or less popular. And considering it's the world's most popular sport, tinkering with the games in unpredictable ways is stupid.
- yardie 16y agoI have only ever seen this true in movies. A newbie doesn't know how to count cards, feel out bluffs, or develop a strategy. Given enough money and time they'll feel their way around the unspoken rules. But no one I know rolls up to a table pulls a royal flush and walks out away the winner.
- edanm 16y agoNot true. Lots of people with very little skill have beaten superior players. They can't last against them for long, but they can get lucky. This is a known phenomenon around the poker world, and greatly works to pro's advantage (you would never wager money against a professional in other fields, since there is no way you could win. In poker, though, because bad players win once in a while, they can delude themselves into not realizing how bad they are).
- yardie 16y agoPeople win the lottery everyday, it doesn't change the fact that the odds are stacked incredibly high against you.
- adw 16y agoBroadly speaking, European sports evolved before the spectator-sports industry and, as a result, are primarily for playing; American sports evolved afterwards and have been shaped (to a greater extent) by needing to be good to watch.
- edanm 16y agoQuick check on Wikipedia shows Baseball was gaining popularity around 1860, and Basketball around 1900. Football was introduced around 1860. What am I missing?
- adw 16y agoThat's the formal codification of football - Association Football, Rugby Football (both League and Union). The games themselves have been around for hundreds of years. Really, though, it's a cultural thing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_rugby_league http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_rugby_league is pretty typical.
- mkramlich 16y agoYou're missing his first two words: broadly speaking.
- lutorm 16y agoThen why are American sports so outrageously boring to watch?
- philwelch 16y agoAmerican football is an enigma to foreigners in the same way that cricket is an enigma to Americans. It's just horribly complicated and weird and there's no way to get a handle on it if you weren't raised with it IMO. (Historically, gridiron is just another rugby variant, except with added down-and-distance rules, forward passes, and blocking. I like the Canadian rules a little better than the American rules, but the best players and teams are American so that's what most people watch.) Basketball and baseball, however, are tremendously popular around the world.
- bukkake 16y agoThe argument outlined in the article is absurd. Soccer is and has been by far the most popular sport participation wise in the USA for decades. I played and refereed it competitively for close to two decades until I started having problems with my knees. Most Americans are very well versed in soccer and have either played it themselves or have at least watched their kids play it. Most Americans have no problems with soccer as a recreational sport. However, from our perspective, there are major problems with it as it currently exists as a spectator sport. All American spectator sports are extremely fine tuned affairs. Every American sport's officiating body does a complete post-mortem of every single call in every single game and annotates them extensively. This information is used to educate individual referees and to supply information to rules committees for possible future fine tuning of the rules. At the minimum, the rules committees issue an objective and annotated series of"points of emphasis" each year for officials so they can call the game in a fairer manner. In every American sport, unsportsmanlike conduct is dealt with in the harshest manner possible. It is not uncommon for an unsportsmanlike foul to be undetected during the game but later caught by the reviewing body during the post-mortem analysis. You will often see $10,000, $50,000, or $100,000 fines to the players and even suspensions if the infraction is deemed worthy enough. As I see it, there are several particularly glaring problems with international soccer: 1. There is no post-mortem review process that has teeth. If the Ivory coast player that was involved in that incredibly unsportsmanlike dive was retroactively red-carded (i.e. suspended) and the team's country fined, then it would provide a disincentive for this kind of behavior. 2. Officiating standards are laughable. There is an unacceptably large amount of variation between referees regarding what is and is not legal play. This makes it very difficult for teams to plan matchups and it condemns every game to a lengthy "feeling-out process" where, by trial and error, the sides determine the refereeing standards. This is not to say that there is no room for subjectivity; what I'm saying is that you have effective anarchy right now and it's a turnoff for American viewers. 3. Post-mortem review should also revert suspect yellows and reds. What good does it do for the game to have Kaka out for the Brazil / Portugal match? Nothing. In fact, it actively harms the game. 4. Offsides should always be "tie goes to the offense". There is no compelling reason to blow extremely close plays dead because the offensive player just might have been offsides by 6 inches. FIFA should issue a "point of emphasis" stating that "ties go to the offense". 5. There needs to be more than one referee. The article makes bogus points about "scaling down". You already have linesmen and a 4th ref that does nothing but hold up a substitution sign and do paperwork. There should be at least one and preferably two more referees so that the on-field officials have multiple views. One referee should be a head referee (as is already done), and the others subject to overrule. 6. Referees should train as groups and speak a common language. This is even more important for an international world championship event. This is just common sense. 7. Referees should be required to make distinguishing hand signals for each call. This would greatly aid the players, the fans, and the commentators in determining exactly what the ruling was. 8. For minor fouls in the box on set pieces, there should be discretionary power to the referee to retake or reverse the direction of the kick instead of either calling a game altering PK or doing nothing (and thus providing an incentive for questionable behavior in the box). There's simply insufficient granularity there. Minor defensive holding should generate a warning and another kick from the same spot for another scoring chance (but at a much lower scoring percentage than PK). 10. If a player leaves the field of play for an injury, or is down for more than 1 minute, the player should not be able to return for 5 minutes. This would provide a disincentive for players to fake injury.
- patrickk 16y agoWho says soccer has to scale down well? And who says this is a good rationale to base the rules on? The whole point of playing a game as a child, IMO, is to learn the basic skills of the game as well as possible and to have fun. Do you think the street kids of Brazil and Argentina, some of whom grow up to be some of the finest natural footballers in the world, worry about the pair of t-shirts they use as goalposts isn't FIFA regulated, or the battered football they use isn't either? The whole point of playing the game at amateur level when you are older is to play the game you have loved since you were a child. Do you think every amateur game even has 2 linesmen to aid the ref? This is a totally different proposition to watching the World Cup, Champions League, English Premiership, La Liga or the Serie A. Millions of fans tune in and watch these high-level games, and billions of euros are generated by the sport. When Thierry Henry cheats by blatantly handling the ball, incorrectly getting France into the World Cup, when Kaka, one of the greats of the modern game, gets sent off by some diving, cheating pr*ck, when the ref disallows a perfectly legit goal for the USA, millions of fans are turned off by this crap. Diving is another huge area which is wrecking soccer too. Video refereeing and being able to appeal obviously incorrect decisions like most other modern sports is badly needed to bring the game into the 21st century. The argument about video refereeing slowing the game down doesn't stand up either. At least trial the system for a few months in major competitions where the necessary equipment already is in place - if it doesn't work after that, then I've got egg on my face. People who argue the reverse are mired in the past, and don't have the balls and vision to at least experiment with something that could bring on a new level of professionalism, and fairness to the sport instead of rewarding cheaters and divers.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- throwaway321 16y agoI'm not a particularly big fan of football, but even so it's glaringly obvious to me when I read articles by certain people (let's just say it's those who call it soccer) that they.. just don't get it. This isn't just random bloggers, I've read articles in big papers like the NY Times, and as much as they want and try to, they don't really understand it. It's not "inside" them like it is for me (involuntarily) and billions of others.
- megablast 16y agoSo you don't care about the blatant cheating that can completely change the course of a game? Well, lots of people do not like cheating, do not like deliberate diving. For me, this completely ruins the game of soccer, and I will never take it seriously as a sport. I don't tune in to see which side can game the system the best.
- lutorm 16y agoWould you be happier if the rules said "the player who most convincingly acts will win the call"? Then it wouldn't be cheating, but part of the game... I don't think it's nearly as bad as the American incarnation of hockey, where fistfights are tolerated with a slap on the wrist. Talk about encouraging unsportsmanlike behavior. If you tried that in soccer, you'd at the very least get a red card, if not more.
- starkfist 16y agoFistfights aren't just tolerated in hockey, they are half the reason anyone watches the game...
- daleharvey 16y agothis is fairly obviously wrong? children dont play to a clock in their backyard, they very very rarely play offside and they certainly dont give any yellow or red cards. I agree part of the beauty of the game is that you can play the same game in the park with friends, but most of the arguments were against details of the same game, not changing it (stopping clock, replays etc).
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoThey should play the proper game without a referee and then bar anyone afterwards who lied or cheated from ever playing again.
- ugh 16y agoI think something is off this World Cup. Quite a few referees seem to be overly pedantic. Not every small jostle should stop the game, not every foul warrants a yellow card. Whistle and card happy referees seem to me to be the overarching problem, not dives, clocks or missing video replay. That, to me, seems to be a problem of referee training and briefing. FIFA apparently wants the referees to be as pedantic as they are. That should be addressed first and foremost, not exotic rule changes. I’m all for extensively and carefully testing everything that was proposed – exact time keeping, two referees on the field, video replay, no more offside, you name it – and I really think FIFA should get more aggressive about it, but they should also be very careful about not changing the game. That has to be a long and careful process, not some ad-hoc decision.
- hcho 16y agoThe reason FIFA does not want video reffing is not keeping the spirit of the footbal or what so ever. FIFA (and UEFA for that matter) for that matter is a highly political organization which handles a lot of money with a somewhat obscure agenda. Fairness is a little bit less important when compared to leaving out big money nations(or clubs) from a tournement. Error-prone refereeing is a vital tool for keeping as many big money nations in the tournements. Had there been video refereeing it would be harder to provide the extra push to the teams that need it. Sounds too much like a conspiracy theory? Then tell me why it's almost always the smaller teams at the wrong end of the stick.
- zppx 16y agoSouth Korea in 2002 is a good counterexample to this rule, if you look at club tournaments you'll see that larger teams also are constantly affected by errors.
- philwelch 16y agoUSA is a smaller team than Slovenia? Brazil is a smaller team than Ivory Coast? Your conspiracy theory, actually, is much better suited to the NBA, which has always seemed fixed in favor of large-market teams.
- mirkules 16y agoI think the game could engulf America, if the Television networks are willing to air two 45+ minute halves without showing a single commercial. Note that every popular American sport has enough stoppage time during each break to show at least 4-5 highly-targeted ads. In my opinion, this is why the networks aren't really pushing soccer. On-pitch ads (i.e. sideline or sideboard ads) wouldn't really cut it because every network needs to have regional advertisements, and lots of them. Just my $0.02.
- GFischer 16y agoRegional networks' needs could be served by digitally replacing in-game ads with customized ads for the region, or adding small ads at the bottom of the screen (that's the usual way) This is already done in some countries for football (soccer). The thing is, it's probably harder and a more difficult sell than just airing the same old commercials during a break. It helps that football(soccer) is wildly popular so advertisers are willing to jump that hurdle in exchange for guaranteed audience in the football-mad countries.
- mirkules 16y agoGood point. It would require a different format of advertising than what America is used to, and that could be hard to sell. Interesting chicken-and-egg problem, it would really take a combination of a brave network and brave advertisers to change the whole thing -- and so, the future looks bleak...
- lazyant 16y agoThis is a good argument; that everybody can play because you just need a referee and not a lot of extra judging help or technical stuff. This is a good explanation of why soccer is so popular. The other one is that unless other sports you just need some sort of ball to start playing. Actually we played 5 to a side (smaller field) football/soccer in college without referee and without the offside rule (which would make it hard to call). The only point of friction between teams were the faults (only obvious ones were called) so it could get a little rough but other than that the situations are mostly obvious and you can do without a ref in friendly games. For critical decisions in a World Cup soccer could use video replay though, especially since the scoring is usually so low (average is about 1.5 goals per game so far I think) that a goal changes everything. Perhaps it could be used after the games just to punish "divers".
- bialecki 16y agoGet rid of ties and soccer is 10x better. Nothing more frustrating than watching a game for 90 minutes that ends in a tie. This is one of the big reasons playoff hockey is much better than during the regular season -- ever watched a game go into 5 OTs?
- philwelch 16y agoThis is a pretty common American cultural expectation, but it would really hurt soccer to have matches go into extra time unnecessarily. The fatigue and injury rate is already too high--look at how many great players are sitting out this World Cup, for instance.
- bialecki 16y agoSo injuries are the reason they don't play golden goal? If so, that's ridiculous. All sports deal with injuries and sometimes that means star players don't play. What really bothers me is when teams "play for the tie" in certain situations and that's a viable option. Sports are not about playing not to lose, they're about playing to win. That's why the old Brazil teams and the current Argentina team are so fun to watch -- they're not worried about losing, they're playing to win. That's why the last US game was so entertaining -- they had to go for it in the second half so at least salvage a tie. Soccer should encourage more play like that.
- philwelch 16y agoThey don't play golden goal because in practice, golden goal leads to more defensive play. The current overtime procedure of extra time + penalties is the best of many mediocre options, and I suspect future innovations will lead to better procedures. When you look at the reality of match congestion in top level clubs, you have situations where you may have to play 3-4 matches a week at times, when 1-2 matches a week is the most a player can reasonably recover from. As a result of that, clubs already have to prioritize which competitions they care about--a club simultaneously competes for a league, more than one domestic cup, and maybe even an international cup or two, so "less important" competitions like the English League Cup and even, in recent years, the English FA Cup aren't taken seriously by some top clubs. You start adding extra time to a significant proportion of a club's league matches and you exacerbate that problem and lower the quality of play.
- johnyzee 16y agoHere's a simple solution. The referee has the option to, if in doubt, consult someone with a video replay to determine a situation. He already has, and uses, the option to consult the line men, so it is not obvious to me why he shouldn't be able to consult someone who can watch a replay. Another thing that for the life of me I cannot understand hasn't been implemented: A chip in the ball to determine off sides and whether the ball has crossed the goal or side lines.
- anamax 16y agoThe way to stop "dives" is take every "he hit me" claim seriously by mandating a free substitution whenever a player makes that claim. Yes, the player can return with another free substitution after s\he's been checked out by an independent MD.
- mkramlich 16y agoBeing a namespace/terminology nut, one of the things that bothers me the most is that they still haven't solved the name collision/ambiguity between 'soccer' and 'football'.