11 ms·
Colorado doesn’t need to replicate Silicon Valley
- MadManE 9y agoThey don't need to, but Colorado, and Boulder in particular, is trying like hell to do it anyway.
- mojowo11 9y agoSt. Louis here. The startup scene here are also trying to copy the Silicon Valley model, instead of trying to be something unique and different. It is frustrating.
- sledge 9y agoIt's nice to see a company that doesn't have Valley Envy.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoIn the 60s or 70s, IBM made all their plastics, worldwide, for their machines near Boulder, where SparkFun is based. As a result of that, when IBM moved production elsewhere, much of the talent stayed in the area - now there are a lot of high quality smaller companies with injection molding and other plastics experience etc. in the area. Another area in business where the high rents and "you need a VC" mentality would have worked against real world success. CO attracts high quality people - although the housing prices skyrocketing is going to affect whether the younger people who are less financially established, will come in the same numbers as before.
- rpcope1 9y ago> although the housing prices skyrocketing is going to affect whether the younger people who are less financially established, will come in the same numbers as before. It's been mindblowing how much housing has gone up over the Front Range even in the last ten years (median price of a single family home in Boulder is now over $1M whereas ten years ago I think it might have been a third of that). Much of the affordable housing for northern Colorado means being all the way up in Larimer or Weld county if you're interested in a single family home. I think this is only going to get way worse, with a number of companies like Google and Amazon significantly growing their footprint around Boulder and Denver.
- blackguardx 9y agoWeld county is affordable because it there aren't a lot of jobs there. As people move further and further out for cheaper housing, traffic gets worse and worse. The Front Range is basically like Nebraska: You can basically build in any direction without geographic limits. It that happens, the traffic will be worse than LA as people zig zag across the Front Range to commute to their jobs in different suburbs. As a Boulder resident (renter), I think Front Range cities need to have a pro-growth mindset to allow people to live closer to their jobs. We shouldn't repeat the same mistakes as LA and Silicon Valley.
- davidw 9y ago> As a Boulder resident (renter), I think Front Range cities need to have a pro-growth mindset to allow people to live closer to their jobs. We shouldn't repeat the same mistakes as LA and Silicon Valley. Bingo! My near-miss with Boulder is what got me interested in how cities (don't) work in the US and the people interested in fixing them. It's a pretty interesting movement, with people all over the ideological spectrum, from environmentalists to libertarians. Since it's local, I think it's possible to make more of a difference than with national politics. Here are some good ones: * http://www.sfyimby.org/ http://www.sfyimby.org/ & https://www.yimbydenver.com/ https://www.yimbydenver.com/ * http://www.strongtowns.org/ http://www.strongtowns.org/ * http://marketurbanism.com/ http://marketurbanism.com/
- jdcarter 9y ago> although the housing prices skyrocketing is going to affect whether the younger people who are less financially established, will come in the same numbers as before. But at least you can just go East here. The towns surrounding Boulder--Superior, Louisville, Lafayette, Longmont, etc.--are great places to live, costs are far lower than in Boulder proper, and your commute is still only 15-30 minutes. I live in Lafayette and commute into Boulder; it takes 20 minutes and it's mostly on 2-lane roads going past farmland. And as an added bonus, when I'm missing a part for one of my electronics projects, I can always stop by SparkFun. :)
- davidw 9y agoIt strikes me as something of an "own goal" that the "green belt" in Boulder has had the effect of putting a lot of people in that area out of reach of public transportation or bicycling as viable transportation options, requiring more cars and parking and traffic and pollution. Instead of growing out a little bit (god forbid they build 'up' or 'in'), people just drive even further out.
- blackguardx 9y agoThe green belt worked in Boulder's early days before many people commuted in. Unfortunately, Boulder's anti-growth mindset these last few decades has priced people out, forcing them to "jump the gap" in the green belt. I think the green belt is a really good thing for Boulder to prevent sprawl (and traffic), but it needs to be coupled with a pro-growth mindset. There are shifting attitudes in Boulder as NIMBYs get more competition from younger people like myself. I hope it isn't too late because at this point, Boulder is in danger of turning into Aspen or Santa Barbara.
- davidw 9y agoI get the reason for it and it makes sense to me - but the unintended consequences are causing problems. Oregon has a similar thing, the 'Urban Growth Boundary', but those expand over time so that cities can expand.
- 9y ago
- w00tw001 9y agoIBM is definitely not the only reason there is so much talent. Don't forget about the numerous government research centers.
- r34yll2k 9y agoSparkfun has not had to compete talent just yet. Wait until the competition for talent in Colorado reaches SV level. Sparkfun will have to stop relying on "I want to work at a cool/fun/relaxed place badly" and start paying market rates for talent. Take a look at their crazy application process. It's built around how badly labor wants to work there. This strategy doesn't work in SV anymore.. Good candidates want to get paid, not have "fun times" at work. Sparkfun's talent strategy is built on concepts that are well over 15 years old.
- Apocryphon 9y agoIf it's 100% employee owned, does that mean SparkFun is a co-op?
- dsp1234 9y agoA cooperative[0] is usually operated and run for the mutual benefit of it's members. So for example, a credit union co-op provides services by members, and for members. Since Sparkfun provides the majority of it's services to non-members, it's unlikely that it would fit the bill of a co-op. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cooperative
- unclesaamm 9y agoThis isn't true -- there are worker cooperatives, where workers own the means of production and sell the goods to others: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_cooperative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worker_cooperative Which isn't to say that Sparkfun is a coop -- I don't think it is, just a bootstrapped company where the equity has stayed within the hands of founders/employees.
- rubiquity 9y agoSilicon Foo is a meme for non-technical types used to communicate some sort of software renaissance by a city. It makes them picture the AmaGooFaceSofts of the world opening up offices to rescue their economy. Or maybe they picture the next UberLyftAirbnb will happen in Fooville. Of course it makes us want to vomit because we take it literally and know that isn't what's going to happen. The Bay Area[0] is the Emperor of building software (business and consumer) and it will always be that way. The Bay Area's primary business is the building of software and thus software is created there for software companies as well. At the rest of the Silicon Hopefuls, just getting a handful of legit tech companies that want to build software specific to that city's primary economies (oil, real estate, defense contracting, lumber, etc.) would do A LOT of good. Disclaimer: I don't live in the Bay Area. I live in Silicon Foo where talented software builders either run away or work remote for Bay Area companies. 0 - Citizens of other very large cities: please don't have your egos bruised. Your cities matter, too. Ok, you know I'm really just talking to New Yorkers who have a hard time not being the best at everything.
- acchow 9y agoNot pertaining to OP's article, but when reading fluff pieces about some "next silicon valley", it's always strange seeing them use the opening of a Google or Amazon satellite office as some kind of validation of their claim. Do they really not understand what the valley is about?
- wamatt 9y agoExactly. Just like Detroit will always be the global epicenter of the automotive industry /s. A lot can change in 50 years.
- dwyerm 9y agoRelated: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/02/05/382664837/map-the-most-common-job-in-every-state http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2015/02/05/382664837/map-t... Maybe this is just a lot of lying with graphics, but it has always bothered me that Colorado has been a tech center on and off for decades, while California is nothing but truck drivers and secretaries. Yet it seems like Colorado is the last place people look for tech talent.
- jdcarter 9y agoI work at another Boulder company just down the road from SparkFun, also founded by a CU student in his dorm room, which has been successful without VC investment. Boulder is an odd hybrid of new tech companies and more traditionally bootstrapped companies like SparkFun. There's plenty of VC-funded startups in Boulder, too. The main pedestrian mall downtown, Pearl Street, is flanked by tech companies on the 2nd/3rd floors, above the retail shops. It feels quite similar to University Ave in Palo Alto, back when I lived there in the 90's. Perhaps the biggest difference is that where Silicon Valley is geographically locked-in and there's no cheap office space to be had, in Boulder you can go East a little bit and the price of office space drops dramatically. Taking SparkFun as an example, it's not on Pearl Street, it's several miles outside of town in an industrial park. As such, Boulder gets to be both a micro-size Silicon Valley and a more normal commercial environment as well. It's also just a great place to live, housing costs are reasonable (relative to California anyway), there's tons to do, and it's a good place to raise a family.
- davidw 9y ago> Boulder, CO I don't know, that place has actually tracked SV in a lot of ways, from a good university, to a concentration of smart people, to some good VC's, to being a nice place, to ... rampant NIMBYism that has driven housing prices up to nearly 700K (Zillow).
- pdeuchler 9y agoAs a Boulderite I take offense to that last part... the average house here is actually over a million dollars thank you very much
- atcole 9y agoThank you. I'm glad someone corrected this man's outrageous claim that we would let anyone in for less than 9 bags.
- pdeuchler 9y agoTell me about it... I'm sick and tired of the trope that Boulder is just white people from the coasts when it's actually wealthy people from the coasts, and Wisconsin.
- ianai 9y agoYou know what's funny? Six or seven hours south is Santa Fe/Albuquerque NM. Both have nearby national laboratories, colleges, and (some) technical businesses. They're also generally affordable. Pretty much anywhere in NM would just kill for more business and has some technical workforce. I'm also sure it'd be relatively easy to convince people to move there.
- jharger 9y agoNot only is it a nice and inexpensive place to live, but the traffic situation is cake. A very bad day is a 45 minute commute. (ABQ resident here)
- w00bl3ywook 9y agoSparkfun has not had to compete talent just yet. Wait until the competition for talent in Colorado reaches SV level. Sparkfun will have to stop relying on "I want to work at a cool/fun/relaxed place badly" and start paying market rates for talent. Take a look at their crazy application process. It's built around how badly labor wants to work there. This strategy doesn't work in SV anymore.. Good candidates want to get paid, not have "fun times" at work. Sparkfun's talent strategy is built on concepts that are well over 15 years old.
- pdeuchler 9y agoI agree with this comment as it applies to the general tech ecosystem here, but Sparkfun might actually be exempt from this because it is legitimately a very cool place to just be around... But that said yeah, it is very apparent that too many companies here are coasting on the general area's appeal. We're just starting to hit the point where that won't cut it anymore, and I think a lot of companies that have gotten by on quality talent at cut rate prices due to the lack of competition and the inherent desirability of the area are in for a serious rude awakening. Salaries are already starting to rapidly increase (more than they already were) in Boulder just with the announcement of companies like Google moving large offices here and it's been very disconcerting to see companies resort to the same tactics used by Bay Area companies to circumvent paying people (company commuter busses so you can live in more affordable areas, $500 ski passes instead of $5k raises, free food, etc etc). This area can't really even bank on the usual scam of promising big exists since those are much more rare in these parts. Watching the economics of the whole situation has been very interesting, especially when you see that they're only going to make many of the social problems we're dealing with much much worse.
- jdcarter 9y agoThere are a shocking number of older tech companies around Boulder (say 10+ years old) that haven't gotten the memo about the market value of engineers. They've somehow gotten away with paying engineers $80k/yr, and now they can't even hire a new grad for that. I've certainly had several hiring discussions that were going great until we hit salary. I make good money but nowhere near crazy money, yet these hiring managers weren't even in the same ballpark.
- w00bl3ywook 9y agoSparkfun has not had to compete talent just yet. Wait until the competition for talent in Colorado reaches SV level. Sparkfun will have to stop relying on "I want to work at a cool/fun/relaxed place badly" and start paying market rates for talent. Take a look at their crazy application process. It's built around how badly labor wants to work there. This strategy doesn't work in SV anymore.. Good candidates want to get paid, not have "fun times" at work. Sparkfun's talent strategy is built on concepts that are well over 15 years old.
- robbyking 9y agoThe headline posted here is misleading; the actual article says "Colorado Doesn’t Need to Replicate Silicon Valley to Have a Prosperous Startup Industry"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- miles_matthias 9y agoWhen I graduated with my CS degree, I knew I wanted to be a part of startups, so I decided to move to either SF or Boulder. And I'm so, so, so glad I picked Boulder. My company operates in several cities and it's great to have options like SF, NY, DC, etc. where there's a ton of activity and a ton of $$$, but most of the time, we just don't need it. Most of the time we want a place to actually enjoy our work. We frequent Boulder & Austin since we have investors in both locations.
- bkjelden 9y agoThe Front Range isn't really part of the 'Heartland', unless your definition is naively "all things not close to an ocean".
- 65827 9y agoYeah midwesterners can fuck right off, Colorado wants nothing to do with that. Heartland is like Ohio or something right?
- pcarolan 9y agoI agree and like this article but the midwest needs to adopt a few things the valley did right. 1) Hand out more equity to early employees and create a flywheel of entrepreneurs who build and finance other businesses. 2) Get rid of the non-compete culture. Standard form in Chicago is 18 months. This is unenforceable in Cali. 3) Put value on youth. We still live under a manufacturing seniority mindset. One woman once told me "I can't wait to turn 30 so I can be taken seriously". The midwest has all the talent and ingenuity it needs. It has a unique perspective and is relatively inexpensive to live in, but the rules need to be revised to favor competitiveness.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoI think the social conservativeness of the Midwest is also a huge negative for many.
- pcarolan 9y agoChicago is an oasis for that. Check it out if you haven't.
- dalfonso 9y agoAt the end of the day, it's about access to capital. My wild hypothesis is if some angel investor said, "I'm going to invest 10 billion dollars in funding startups but you have to relocate to Colorado/midwest/anywhere for the first 5 years", then in the next 5 years that city will definitely "have a prosperous startup industry". Yes, you can be successful bootstrapping but it seems so much easier once you have funds to use for hiring/marketing/scaling/etc. (Note: I've never raised any amount of capital before.) In addition the "we've raised money" badge also signals legitimacy to potential employees, customers, partners.
- bluGill 9y agoIn any good sized city there are venture capitalists and angles willing to fund SOMETHING. A number of them do not care where you are physically located (unless physical location is important) and will fund you wherever you are. There is a lot more money in the valley for some reason, but there is still plenty in any great large city if you have a great idea. It is the okay ideas that they cannot fund in other places (note some seemingly bad ideas take off you will see more of that in the valley if this is worth it or not is an open question)
- kevinr 9y agoFriendly amendment: it's about access to capital relative to local costs. Arguably OP's point is that he had access to enough capital relative to his local costs in Colorado to afford to bootstrap, whereas he'd have needed VC to hit the same ratio in the Valley. Turned out well for him, and has worked for others like him. "I'm going to invest 10 billion in startups but you have to relocate" is basically what Tony Hsieh did in Las Vegas, and it... based on how rocky that got, I think it's about more than just access to capital.
- got2surf 9y agoIt begs the question of why we (generally) feel like tech startups need to think/behave differently than traditional businesses. "Startups" in the sense of new businesses have been around for centuries (arguably longer). But recently, the popular image of most tech companies is raising large amounts of money to grow/scale really quickly. If anything, shouldn't the fact that engineers understand how to leverage technology lead to higher profitability and lower need for capital than all the brick-and-mortar businesses that came before us? Like the SparkFun founder says, as an engineer, I started a company that I knew how to build and implement on my own.
- codingdave 9y agoIt is mostly a question of terminology. Around here, "startup" is defined as hyper-growth, because YC chose to define it that way and HN came from YC. In other places, it can have a more flexible definition. So while most of the audience here will absolutely agree that you don't need VCs or insane growth to start a business, on HN, that would be coined as a "lifestyle" company, not a "startup". (And in my mind, more power to anyone who goes that route.)
- got2surf 9y agoGood point on the terminology. My main (and relatively early) experience has been that there are good lessons to be learned from both sides (like sustainable growth and profit models on the "non-startup" end, and rapid innovation/marketing on the "startup" end)
- Balgair 9y agoBoo! No, don't move to Colorado! It's terrible here! Too much snow! White people all the way to Nebraska! The views are over-rated! Skiing is too expensive! Beer is all just hop-juice or Coors! Terrible food! Nothing but Papa Jonh's and stoners! Stay Away!
- ThomPete 9y agoWhat's wrong with white people?
- yathern 9y agoI think they're just being sarcastic and saying as many things as possible to scare people away from their beloved state, by throwing out a bunch of stereotypes about it.
- deusofnull 9y agoI think they might have been sarcastic there, but I wouldn't want to live in a neighborhood where white people were the supermajority. I grew up outside NYC and live in New Haven now and I get totally freaked out by rural areas where you don't see a black person for weeks. Just feels off.
- amyjess 9y agoI'd say it goes hand in hand with the bit about "terrible food". OK, "terrible" is hyperbolic, but I'm specifically avoiding places that are as white as snow because of food. I'm looking at moving, and one hard requirement for me is that the suburb I'm moving to have an Asian population of at least 15%, specifically for food-related reasons. I live in the northern suburbs of Dallas, which have fairly high Asian populations. I want a large amount of Thai, Vietnamese, Japanese, Korean, regional Chinese, Indian, etc. food wherever I live, and if a place is 90% white, I'm not going to get that. I'd also like a Hispanic population above 15% too because I love me some tacos, but I'm willing to forego that as long as a nearby suburb is >15% Hispanic. I've narrowed down my search to the suburbs of Los Angeles and Las Vegas; specifically, Torrance (or Irvine) and Spring Valley, respectively, and ethnic makeup is one of my most important criteria.
- jstueve 9y agoAs a QA Engineer (living in Broomfield, 9 miles east), the number of cold calls I am getting from recruiters for tech positions in Boulder is averaging 4/week. This number has been steadily rising the past 3 years. Boulder may not be SV, but as Nate says, it doesn't have to be. It is it's own beast and it is, by my eyes, succeeding.
- 65827 9y agoYeah the startup scene is pretty rag tag and unprofessional in a lot of ways, but in other ways it far exceeds any capabilities you'll find in California or anywhere else for that matter. Boulder doesn't really need a model, they are sort of pushing a bunch of envelopes uphill all on their own.
- Johnny555 9y ago"In those beginning stages, I never would have been able to pay for warehouse space in the Bay Area while waiting for investors to commit" You'd be crazy to start a warehouse in Silicon Valley -- run your development and operations there, but when you're ready to move out of your garage into a real warehouse, put the warehouse (and product assembly) in Tracy or someplace like that that's an hour's drive away and much more affordable.
- Mz 9y agoI don't think you need to replicate Silicon Valley. Why would you want to? It has serious problems that are not going to be easily addressed. Also, it isn't a given that money has to continue to concentrate in a few places. This is not some force of nature we are watching. It is human activity. Sure, human activity gets influenced by factors outside of our control. It is easier to "go with the flow" of various things than to swim upstream. But we have a lot more ability to choose to do something else if we don't like how this is going than most creatures have. I don't like how articles (like the Wired article that inspired this post) just seem to presume all we can do is document the trend and make our peace with accepting it. That is crazy. If people think this is a terrible, corrosive trend, then why not write articles that give push back to the trend (like this one does) instead of just documenting it like a runaway train we cannot stop? VCs can go invest money wherever they want. Rich people have far more mobility than others. They don't have to limit themselves to a handful of places. Nor are other people simply doomed to curry favor with them. Most of their so-called money isn't actually in the form of money per se. They own stocks or real estate or whatever. Money has to circulate like blood in order to stay alive. They need things to invest in. It isn't in their best interest to let it sit in a vault rotting. It is absolutely not a given that these trends have to continue in this same direction. Humans can say "Oh, we don't like where our behavior is taking us. Let's consider other options." It isn't a Greek Tragedy where the more you try to resist your fate, the more doomed you are to entrench it as the only option.
- czbond 9y agoRelated: I run an engineering team in Dallas, TX and moved to Colorado recently. Where would you look for high quality, heavily growing firms in the area? I'm only interested in running large teams - otherwise I get bored. Eg: CTO or Managing Director style roles.....
- rollingpebbles 9y agoEspecially not the Man Jose gender imbalance.