13 ms·
This is also really a zoning story. L.A. used to be zoned for 10 million people in the late 60s and decreased that tremendously in the early 70s: https://la.cur
by jseliger 9y ago
This is also really a zoning story. L.A. used to be zoned for 10 million people in the late 60s and decreased that tremendously in the early 70s: https://la.curbed.com/2015/4/8/9972362/everything-wrong-with-los-angeles-housing-in-one-graph https://la.curbed.com/2015/4/8/9972362/everything-wrong-with....
Today we have improved technology along almost every dimension yet the city is zoned for less than half as many people.
We are paying zoning's steep price: https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2002/10/v25n3-7.pdf https://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/r... (that's a link to a PDF).
- DiNovi 9y agosurprises me, since LA has so much sprawl
- handedness 9y agoI believe Curb's argument is that the sprawl was to some degree caused by the zoning, as it made high-density housing difficult to build. A lot of it, though, is just down to geography.
- klipt 9y agoFunny, I often hear people blame SF's high prices on geography ("it's a peninsula, there's no more room to build"). Seems LA wouldn't be geographically constrained in the same way.
- amyjess 9y agoMountains. Go switch Google Maps into satellite view and check out LA [0]; the whole metro area is a handful of valleys that are almost all filled up, and everything that isn't developed is a mountain. The only place in Los Angeles County where there's room to grow is in the Antelope Valley around Palmdale, and that's separated from everything else in the county by mountains so you probably won't want to live there and commute to any other part of the metro area. [0] https://goo.gl/maps/ePy7yztU7KL2 https://goo.gl/maps/ePy7yztU7KL2
- davidw 9y ago"Filled up" is not really true though. There's plenty of space to build up and in.
- selectodude 9y agoEverything is filled up with grass and single family homes. The amount of in-fill that LA could do is staggering.
- virmundi 9y agoBoth are more constrained by man than nature. SF could build up and up and up. It's not zoned for that. Practical limit is 10 stories where housing is. Could be changed, the argument is that SF would not be SF any more. It always makes me tear up when I hear that, tiny violin and all.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- posguy 9y agoYeah, zoning is the real story here. Rent control, increasing the cost of most new housing so there is some affordable housing, and similar measures will just worsen the problem of a small housing supply. If we remove modern zoning law that restricts the bulk of the city to be low density slum, LA can easily house double its population. A relevant article on affordable housing: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/5/8/immutable-laws-of-affordable-housing https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/5/8/immutable-laws-...
- zanny 9y agoYou don't just drop zoning laws and expect the problem to fix itself. The bad zoning lead to road planning for the densities that are there (and even then, the densities are beyond what was expected and thus infrastructure is taxed). Fixing LA at this point requires not only bulldozing the sprawl and building higher density but also requires expanded road, sewer, electric, and public transit networks to accommodate. And in this political climate that will simply never happen. Nobody wants to invest in infrastructure anywhere there is already established buildings. They just want to build new, not refurbish old, because its cheaper to do the former, even if it is macroscopically unsustainable and fails to solve the problem.
- posguy 9y agoThen you end up with a bunch of really expensive infrastructure in low density neighborhoods, which is really really bad. Cities can't afford to maintain said infrastructure, and you end up like Lafayette, Louisiana[1], or any of the older suburbs in the US. Dezoning and allowing urban areas to densify is the only reasonable way forward. Sure, you won't have every road be a 6 or 8 lane monstrosity like Atlanta, but that is not a bad thing. By densifying our cities, mass transit becomes much more efficient and cost effective, and reduces/eliminates the need and outsized cost of owning a car. 1 - https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason-your-city-has-no-money https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/1/9/the-real-reason...
- cylinder 9y agoYou need large continuous blocks to build high density developments. When you've got all these small single family lots, it becomes really difficult for a developer to acquire them all without some hold outs saying no or demanding crazy prices. It might be time to use eminent domain more
- jdavis703 9y agoYou can double the density by just building townhouses and small apartment buildings in many of these places. A small developer can buy up a couple of adjacent lots, add double the capacity and still make a tidy profit. No imminent domain is needed here.
- sbov 9y agoIs there something that keeps row houses from being built instead of townhouses?
- bickfordb 9y agoModern residential zoning codes often prohibits building within 5 feet of the property line (aka setback) or more.
- bogomipz 9y ago42% of the housing stock in Los Angeles is already apartment buildings[1]. These and commercial real-estate(strip malls) make up the majority of "the sprawl" in Los Angeles. Where does the land for your proposed solution of "just building townhouses and small apartment buildings" actually come from? Where are all these adjacent lots for sale? LA is no stranger to "small apartment buildings", this started back in the 1950's. In fact one of its architectural signatures is the "dingbat", its hard to drive anywhere in the city and not see these[2]. https://architizer.com/blog/dingbat-book-kickstarter/ https://architizer.com/blog/dingbat-book-kickstarter/ [1] http://www.nmhc.org/Content.aspx?id=4708 http://www.nmhc.org/Content.aspx?id=4708
- 9y ago
- bogomipz 9y agoBut the city council for years regularly approved zoning changes for more dense development. They did so right up until this March when measure S passed: http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-planning-commission-zoning-changes-20170210-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-planning-commiss...
- swrobel 9y agoMeasure S did NOT pass https://la.curbed.com/2017/3/7/14850898/live-election-results-2017-measure-s-la https://la.curbed.com/2017/3/7/14850898/live-election-result...
- jly 9y agoI would look also at the seriously distorted property and land taxation system in California as an additional contributor along with zoning. A few decades of Prop 13 have done an amazing amount of damage to the housing markets all over the state, by disincentivizing the sale of property. This has contributed heavily to reducing the supply of housing and distorting the market, among other problems. If California made some modifications to it's taxation policy - perhaps lowering income and sales taxes while leveling the playing field on land taxation - home owners could come out paying a similar total tax bill while adding needed fluidity to the market.
- PretzelFisch 9y agowhat do you mean "leveling the playing field" if you buy a house your property tax increase is limited to a fixed %. how is that not level.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIt's leveling it between existing owners and purchasers. As it stands, it's essentially subsidizing commuting. If you bought a house at $100k that's now worth $1M, and your job moves an hour away, you'd be giving up the property tax lock-in by moving to cut down your commute. Rent stabilization/control measures have a very similar problem.
- Y7ZCQtNo39 9y agoYou could always rent the home so someone else could occupy it. Presumably you would've paid off the $100k home by now, and then you could get a second mortgage on a new property, or rent and break even (given the income from renting the first property).
- CydeWeys 9y agoWhy should people owning investment properties be given huge tax breaks that wouldn't apply to someone buying the same home in the present day in order to live in it? Basing property taxes on the current value of the property makes sense, and is how it is done essentially everywhere else in the world. Basing property taxes on what the property cost the last time it was sold, even if that was decades ago and is some tiny fraction of the current value, is very unusual, and has all sorts of negative repercussions.
- jayd16 9y agoUntil we fix the public transit situation we're over-provisioned, not under.
- tmh79 9y agodisagree, we need to fix both problems, waiting for one to be solved to address the other means nothing will change
- oppositelock 9y agoThis isn't just zoning, it's so much more. 1) California's Prop13 discourages redevelopment. 2) Federal Reserve policies encourage housing speculation. 3) California is filled with NIMBY's who have an arsenal of tools to stop development, usually some kind of overbroad environmental review process. 4) City councils tend to approve higher-end luxury development because it brings in more taxes. 5) Developers tend to build higher end units because of bigger per/unit profits. Usually, cheaper housing is older housing, but not in CA where there's a shortage.
- hkmurakami 9y agoRegarding (2), the mortgage tax deduction and the primary residence capital gains reduction (and/or the cap gains carryover into next property) all contribute to the speculative behavior.
- shawnee_ 9y agoThere is a solution. Since this would probably have to be implemented at a city or county level (that is where permitting, zoning and property taxes happen), my current theory is that it would be something like: (1) Get rid of rent control; it doesn't work because it focuses on the price side. Instead... (2) Tax all businesses and individuals collecting long-term residential rents at a flat rate of, like, 65 cents for every dollar of rent collected. (3) Deposit the 0.65 revenue into a totally transparent, 100 percent "open accounting" fund that awards building projects to competing builders. The builders must build "for sale" units, some high-density urban, some "family size"... the key is to truly increase the supply of housing that allows people to build equity (as the article points out, people who rent simply cannot build equity and that has been the problem all along). (4) Businesses and individuals who can't afford the 0.65 tax on rents they collect are probably already too leveraged with other people's money anyway; let them go under and convert that "for rent" complex into a "for sale" one. Whoever buys it will be subjected to the 0.65 tax, too, if they decide "making money on rentals" is the kind of business they want to do. I suspect this "being too heavily leveraged with other people's money" is a root-cause issue for why rents keep rising astronomically and people's wages are not keeping up. Why not build a system that lets renters leverage their own earnings?
- radicalOH 9y agoI don't really understand how this would work out. A 65% tax on renters would really drive them away wouldn't it? If you were to collect enough to create the "construction fund", cheap buildings would be built, but who would buy them? If a bunch of buildings were built and rent prices dropped, wouldn't that further block people from purchasing buildings from rent too?
- mangofoobar 9y agoA 65% tax would bankrupt many landlords and they themselves would become homeless. You clearly have no investment properties of your own since you are absolutely clueless.
- closeparen 9y agoWho would buy a home while the market was being flooded with the intent to make homes cheaper? I wouldn't want to lock in my price until I thought prices were going to stop falling.
- branchless 9y agoWe have this issue in major cities all over the world. Are they all zoning issues or is the end of the gold standard, allowing banks to create unlimited credit part of the problem?
- m_mueller 9y agoJapan's example would suggest it's zoning. Tokyo is IMO very affordable for a metropolis (i.e. lots of people in middle income jobs can have a small but decent apartment here). And small apartments are less of an issue than you think, if a city has the right amenities. Room for children to play? There's tons of public play centers and playgrounds. A Garage? Don't need it, walk instead 5min to a superb transport network. Big kitchen? There's 50 restaurants within a 15min walk. Big relaxing bath? Go to a nearby public bath house and feel like an Ancient Roman. Need space for guests? Fold away your Futon, put up the heated Kotatsu-Table and have another room to use. More fun? Shibuya is 25min away. All yours for ~950 USD/month for a 35m2 or so apartment.
- branchless 9y agoJapan had a credit driven bubble. I strongly recommend watching this by Werner: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p5Ac7ap_MAY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=p5Ac7ap_MAY
- m_mueller 9y agoWell.. so had the US less than 10 years ago?
- CalRobert 9y agoIn addition to zoning, see parking minimums. https://www.portlandoregon.gov/bps/article/420062 https://www.portlandoregon.gov/bps/article/420062 discusses this in more detail, but in short, we make sure there are places for cars to sleep before letting anyone make a place for a human to sleep. As a result, most of LA's core is asphalt.