8 ms·
China's new submarine engine
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI'm curious, which country did they steal it from?
- sctb 9y agoCome on, you know we don't need this here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- basicplus2 9y ago"Oops! Something went wrong. Please scroll down to find your content..." Nowhere to be found
- teapot01 9y agoWorking link here: http://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/1580226/shanghai-san-francisco-100-minutes-chinese-supersonic-submarine http://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/1580226/shanghai-san-... Note also, misleading title. Supercavitation technology has been around for a long time, the Chinese have solved some of the technical issues regarding scaling up to full size Submarine and steering. Still no solution to range and many of the related issues. Also unlikely to be put into service any time soon.
- mannykannot 9y agoThis appears to be about an entirely different technology. The original article appears to be about the use of rim-driven electrical ducted propellers.
- barrkel 9y agoThat is a completely different article.
- wyldfire 9y agoWhat of the turbulence just from the sub passing through the water? Can we distinguish it from the background noise?
- smileysteve 9y agoWithout active sonar? Not at a reasonable distance. Active Sonar can detect the water void/material difference with reasonable accuracy. U.S. sub streamlining and cavitation avoidance makes them nearly undetectable under running, much less full stop, and that's with a large prop rotating.
- clouddrover 9y agoIt's doubtful our sonar would even pick it up. And if it did, it would sound like whales humping, or some kind of seismic anomaly. Anything but a submarine.
- oceanswave 9y agoA fourth million dollar computer tells you you're chasing an earthquake but you don't believe it and you come up with this on your own?
- Merad 9y agoI recall reading something (I honestly don't recall where, so it's possible it was fiction) that discussed how Ohio class SSBNs are so quiet that theoretically, at least, they can be tracked by following the void that they leave in the natural background noise. Of course, the problem is that even if you can track it, you have to find it first. It's a big ocean.
- gscott 9y agoChina has figured out a way to better track foreign submarines. Just force them to not be submerged. https://qz.com/915110/china-wants-foreign-submarines-to-stop-traveling-below-the-surface-in-the-south-china-sea-and-other-waters-it-claims/ https://qz.com/915110/china-wants-foreign-submarines-to-stop...
- wyldfire 9y agoWhat of the turbulence just from the sub passing through the water? Can we distinguish it from the background noise?
- mberger 9y agoIf I understand this right, aren't they putting the motor around the prop? While it cuts down on noise, doesn't it increase, or at least give it a distinct, magnetic signature?
- hwillis 9y agoThe magnetic field of an electric motor only does any useful work when it is inside the motor. There is no stray flux that would be usefully detectable. Also, magnetic fields don't self propagate, really. That means they fall off extremely quickly with distance unlike electromagnetic waves.
- mannykannot 9y agoMaybe especially in seawater?
- phkahler 9y agoIf they use the "air gap" to separate the dry side from the wet side (stator from rotor) one may be able to mess it up by dropping a cloud of iron containing abrasive particles. They'd be drawn into the gap and grind away. Depending how it's constructed of course.
- coredog64 9y agoMagnetometers are already used to detect submarines [0]. Maybe it isn't so much about the flux from the motor being detectable, but it's additional interference with the Earth's magnetic field. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_anomaly_detector https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_anomaly_detector
- simonh 9y agoThey're used to detect the hull, which is why Titanium is valuable for use in military submarine hulls as its non-magnetic. Fun fact, much of the Titanium used in US submarine hulls was sourced from - er - the USSR. The needed the foreign exchange more than it was worth denying the Titanium to the US.
- phkahler 9y agoThe comparison to the Red October is unfounded, this totally has a propeller.
- simonh 9y agoIn the book the drive is not described as propeller-less, only in the movie.
- vilhelm_s 9y agoOn the other hand, the system described in the book is not shaft-less, so it still doesn't correspond to this new Chinese technology! > "They called it a tunnel drive. You know how out West they have lots of hydroelectric power plants? Mostly dams. The water spills onto wheels that turn generators. Now there's a few new ones that kind of turn that around. They tap into underground rivers, and the water turns impellers, and they turn the generators instead of a modified mill wheel. An impeller is like a propeller, except the water drives it instead of the other way around. There's some minor technical differences, too, but nothing major. Okay so far? "With this design, you turn that around. You suck water in the bow and your impellers eject it out the stern, and that moves the ship." Tyler paused, frowning. "As I recall you have to have more than one per tunnel. They looked at this back in the early sixties and got to the model stage before dropping it. One of the things they discovered is that one impeller doesn't work as well as several. Some sort of back pressure thing. It was a new principle, something unexpected that cropped up. They ended up using four, I think, and it was supposed to look something like the compressor sets in a jet engine."
- simonh 9y agoThe drive in the Red October itself is never described in any detail though. That description is of a US experimental system that American engineer was familiar with, not the actual Russian system. Other than the fact it sucks in water and ejects it out the back, we know nothing else, and that fits the Chinese system fine. So nitpicking like this is simply not justified.
- 9y ago
- mannykannot 9y agoI wanted to know more about the rim-driven thruster technology, and a quick search revealed that it is being deployed in a number of areas where hub-driven electrical thrusters would otherwise have been used. One manufacturer's blurb[1] states that they use no seals, so I am curious as to what sort of bearing is used - could the rotor be magnetically suspended within the stator, at least while turning? It also states that their device is symmetrical and so is equally efficient in either direction. My understanding is that, for optimal efficiency, a ducted propulsor should be narrower at the exit, but I guess there is no particular difficulty in making a rim-driven thruster of this form if its primary use is one-directional. [1] http://www.tsltechnology.com/marine/thrusters.htm http://www.tsltechnology.com/marine/thrusters.htm
- Animats 9y agoThat's a nice application for brushless motors with variable-frequency AC drive. The motor is so simple - it's just windings and the propeller ring. No seals, no gears, and no bearings that carry heavy loads. All of those things give trouble underwater. The drive electronics is more complex, but drives for variable-frequency AC motors are well-debugged now. Every drone has several of them, and electric cars have big ones. Some pictures of existing units: [1] They're mostly used as steerable thrusters for boats that need to be highly maneuverable, such as ferries. They're becoming very popular for ROVs, because they're much lower maintenance than existing thrusters used at depth. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Te_xejpriFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Te_xejpriFM
- cocoablazing 9y agoIf the impeller is capable of developing sufficient force to move a submarine at operational speeds, it will require serious axial thrust bearings. The impeller pushes against the housing with the same force that a conventional shaft develops against a shaft-mounted axial thrust bearing would for the same speed and vessel geometry.
- kpil 9y agoWhat do you have to use in this case? A large needle bearing along the motor ring? How much noise does that make? Is it possible to have a water-bearing with injected high-pressure water in a small area, or will that use as much power as the propulsion?
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoLarge axial thrust => tapered roller bearing, usually.
- cocoablazing 9y agoLarge vessels use much more complex and specialized axial thrust bearings for propulsion shaft loads. What works for an ROV won't necessarily do the job at the required scale.
- caycep 9y agoI don't know how accurate they are, but a lot of the military analyst/journalist blogosphere (i.e. Tyler Rogoway, War is Boring, etc) have been pointing out that that US Navy, with its nuclear blinders on, risks having its sub and carrier fleets badly disrupted by a swarm of newer, cheaper AIPs. While there are limitations in range and payload etc etc etc, the swedes were able to inflict disproportionate damage in war-games in their AIP sub. There are other thoughts on the current administration and their ability to see their way out of a Thucydides trap with a rising nation who also happens to be our largest trading partner...and the ability of the Pentagon to maintain primacy with the destruction of American STEM advantages...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- adventured 9y agoThe US doesn't need to maintain primacy, it has thousands of nuclear warheads. It needs to slash ~$250 billion off of its defense budget and invest that into infrastructure and healthcare over the next ten years instead. The US should pull back from trying to hold on to its status as the sole military superpower and focus that tax revenue on its own people. We gain absolutely nothing from trying to outpace the entire planet in regards to military dominance. Asia can deal with China (or not), Europe can deal with Russia (or not), the US should play a secondary role to whatever extent it can afford to (which is to say, it can't afford to do much and shouldn't be trying to). None of that is going to happen, of course. The US will ride the military superpower party to the end of the line, where it's financially forced to cut back. That won't take more than a decade or two to conclude at this point (given the soon-to-be routine $1+ trillion deficits due to inbound entitlement costs). The US will properly cede its European military position to European nations and it'll cede its Asia military position to Asian nations.
- microcolonel 9y ago> The US doesn't need to maintain primacy, it has thousands of nuclear warheads. A military whose first line of defence is nuclear weapons is not a functioning military. I don't think you want what you say you want. We all wish the military were cheaper, but that doesn't mean it should be at any cost.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 9y agoFwiw, the rim-driven pump-jet the article is talking about is not the same thing as the caterpillar drive [1] from Hunt For Red October, to which the article compares it. That said, this could be a similarly effective improvement to the submarine's acoustic signature and stealthiness. [1]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetohydrodynamic_drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetohydrodynamic_drive
- phkahler 9y agoThe problem with MHD is that it's inefficient and gets even less so when used to pump sea water. It would be less impractical if there were a lot more salt in the ocean.
- jonalmeida 9y agoSilly question, what other applications would work for rim-driven turbines work? The naive side of me wants to see how it would work on a plane.
- ihaveahadron 9y agochina has a faster underwater missile than any other country. seems pretty safe to assume china is at least as powerful as any other country. to be honest tho and to not beat around the bush china seems like the superior country to america. or any country on earth for that matter. stupid ass america cant even stop their TOP SECRET information from being stolen from a country that is THOURSANDS of miles away and separated by an OCEAN. pathetic. they can't even natively read our language or ANY language that uses romanized letters. seriously what the fucking fuck.